2022 Pocket Profile: St Kilda Saints

Published by Community Member on

It was a disappointing year for the Saints in 2021 overall, both on the footy field and in my SuperCoach team. However, I press on with optimism, as clearly I haven’t learned anything from my 26 years on Earth.

After some big recruiting years it wasn’t a surprise to see the Saints quiet heading into this season, mainly adding to the team through the draft (I’m ignoring the addition of Tom Campbell ($312K RUC/FWD) for my own mental wellbeing).

However, it wasn’t all doom and gloom in 2021, and I think there’s some gold for 2022.

LOCK

Jack Steele ($685,800K MID)

Jack Steele. Do I need to say more? Probably not, but Lekdog asked me to write this so I probably should.

Steele was the only Saint to average over 100 last season, and he did it with ease, playing 22 games with an average of 126. Yes, he’s pricey, but he was also the second highest scorer in the AFL whether you break it down by average or total points. 

Turning 26 heading into this season, Steele is just hitting his prime. He’s proven over the last two years that you can’t tag him – Alan Richardson has actually been the most successful person at slowing the impact of Steele so far in his career.

I wanted to get cute with this pick, but I just couldn’t. Pick Steele and watch the 2022 Brownlow Medallist with joy.

BREAKOUT 

Jade Gresham ($299K MID/FWD)

Honestly, this guy is the first player picked in my team and he should be in yours too. He was a lock when I thought he would be MID only, and I threw away the key when I saw DPP.

Jade Gresham was in my team at the start of last year and delivered early with scores of 82 (28 disposals) and 104 (29 disposals and a goal). Besides Steele, I think Gresh is the team’s best centre bounce midfielder, and he was showing this with great early season form. Sadly for Gresham and the Saints, he got injured in round 3, scoring just 20.

Gresham will be back to 100%, and should he get through pre-season healthy, looks set to once again be deployed in the St Kilda midfield.

In 2018, 2019 and 2020 Gresham averaged 79, 84 and 82 playing mostly in the forward line. This seems like his floor for this season, and his ceiling could be around the 95-100 mark given extra midfield minutes. Priced at under $300K, even if his average remains at 80, he’s still an easy pick. 

If he does get legitimate midfield minutes all season, he becomes a potential $299K forward keeper.

SMOKEY

Hunter Clark ($401,100 DEF/MID)

Hunter Clark has always shown flashes that he can be a game changer whenever he plays. In 2021, after a hot pre-season, Clark was a popular selection and looked like a good one too. He rattled off a 113 in round one and had five scores over 95 in the first 8 weeks (including two over 110).

Injured two weeks later, Clark never really looked right upon returning, and got injured again (twice) finishing the season with 24 in round 12, 23 in round 13 and 54 in round 20. 

If Clark has a solid pre-season, and gets some midfield run, he could be a high upside pick to slot in at D3. However, with high reward comes high risk. He has been put in a number of rolls throughout his career so far, and that can result in a yo-yo of scoring. With Jack Sinclair ($469,700 DEF) and Brad Hill ($394,900 DEF) seemingly set to play off half back, is there enough kicks for Clark as well?

ROOKIE

Nasiah Wanganeen-Milera ($162,300 DEF/MID)

Nasiah Wanganeen-Milera looks likely to be the only St Kilda player under $200K with a chance to get a meaningful amount of games. With Hill in the back line, a wing position is there for the taking, and Wanganeen-Milera ticks all the boxes St Kilda need – foot speed and classy ball use going inside 50.

NWM will likely never be a great SuperCoach scorer given what his likely role will be (outside only ball user), but he’s also talented enough, and a good enough ball user, that 14-18 disposals a game should be within reach. If he plays, I could see him providing a solid 70 average.

AVOID

Brad Crouch ($491,500 MID)

I really struggled to think of anyone to put here, because to tell someone they should avoid a player, they’d have to be thinking about picking them… and there isn’t many other Saints who will be getting picked. I ended up settling on Brad Crouch.

I think Brad Crouch had a decent first year at the Saints, and will have a better one in 2022 as he grows more comfortable in the club. With a 2019 average of 98.4, there may be some people thinking of picking Crouch, hoping he could increase that career best by 3 or 4 and be an M8 keeper.

He may well increase his average to 100 in 2022, but there just isn’t huge upside. Jack Steele is the number one midfield beast at the Saints, and Gresham’s health (plus hopefully Hunter Clark’s development) will limit the amount of clearances and centre bounce stats available to Crouch. I don’t see an avenue where he scores well enough to be a keeper, and at $492K you better be buying a keeper.

Thanks for the write up, Craig! You can follow him on Twitter here.


Subscribe
Notify of
guest
11 Comments
Oldest
Newest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Kat

Hunter Clark has been in and out of my team at D4 for a while now. Loved the way he started last year but not sure if I will take the chance or stick with Whitfield. The extra $100k could get me some of the higher priced rookies or a Gresham in the FWD line instead of a rookie. Decisions decisions

Craig

At this stage he’s not in my team but one good preseason game could change that. Definitely a risky one though.

Russty

Hi Kat, nice to see you, I think Clark is a hard no for me…at least until we know exactly what his role is, that he can execute that role and score consistently and…he needs to show some durability, he just misses too many games. If you’re looking for a cheap defender who could average well this year, Will Day might be your man.

Mike

Thanks Craig, I was wondering what your thoughts on Rowan Marshall to start as an R2, and the Saints playing style of sharing that role with Paddy. Given the changes to Supercoach around DPP adds throughout the season, can you see value in picking him up from the get-go with the possibility of being able to float him forward later in the season.

Cheers buddy

Craig

If Marshall started the season with FWD eligibility I’d have him as a lock. I know the rule changes make it likely he will be forward at some point, but I don’t think it’s worth the risk given the number of safe rucks.

However, if Paddy were to get injured / not play early in the season, I’d be making Rowan an option again.

S C tragic

Still wavering between Marshall and Oscar Mc. R1 Gawn. Maybe go with good old Grundy again. I do however have Gresham in the mid. Thats it for saints SO FAR.

Foodie

Gresham had 67% TOG in round 1 and 3 centre clearances that was equal team high with Seb Ross who had 79% TOG
In round 2 he had 75% TOG and 4 centre clearances that was team high with Ruck Hunter and Sinclair being equal 2nd with 2 centre clearances each.
Round 3 24% TOG and no centre clearances

There is no doubt that he was the best centre clearance player at saints in rounds 1 & 2 last year.
The concern is his durability he missed 19.75 games last year, in 2020 he missed 7 of the 18 games and, in 2019 he missed the final 3 games.

I am starting him because if he can stay together for 5 games he’ll score some points and make some money and with Neale at M6 I need to cut costs on other lines

TREV'S FANTASY

There are savings to be had for the first part Witts appeals as does Oscar and Answerth in defence is only 246k and will play Fagan has him in his best 22 Curnow is apparently flying There’s a few there

Foodie

Fagan doesn’t have Answerth in his best 22 what he said about Answerth was “He’s as fit as I’ve ever seen him… we’ve got no reason to think that with a little bit of lucky, he’ll play a full season this year and we’ll get to see a player who we’ve probably all forgotten about.”
That comment came immediately after Fagans comment that Answerth had been unable to play in NEAFL and it is more likely to mean that he’ll play 2nds before playing in the senior team than it is to suggest Fagan has him in the best 22. Answerth is an injury magnet and Fagan is an astute coach so he won’t be building a game plan that includes a guy who breaks easily until that guy proves that he doesn’t break easily.
He hasn’t participated in any of the match simulations yet this preseason

Russty

He ruptured his archilles tendon last year, and the year before it was a back fracture, not sure what the final 3 games of 2019 was due to. I think if he’s good to go, he’s a good pick cause he’s still young and has had time to re-evaluate his career and really get serious going forward, could be a Ziebel-esque story this year maybe?

PhantasyFantom

Was was Wanganeens average last year in the non-afl?