add_filter('comment_flood_filter', '__return_false');

Supercoach Trade Winds – Round 7

Published by Barron Von Crow on

Hello everyone and welcome to the Supercoach Trade Winds for Round 7. Last week was an absolute doozy for us Supercoachers, for both good and bad reasons. We had some bad form, some good form, some hot new rookies, suspensions and injuries hitting several players. Just all-around anarchy basically. This may be a week where you just have to pick your spots and hold on to a guy just because he’s playing, even if they’re scoring poorly. Your Brandon Starcevich’a or John Noble’s of the world may just have to wait another week before we can take care of ‘em. So let’s go take a look and see what the breakevens are what trades other Supercoachers are making this week.

Adelaide Crows scoring in 2017 Breakevens
Nat Fyfe 220
Ben Cunnington 207
Sam Docherty 196
Mitch Duncan 194
Zach Merrett 192
Josh P. Kennedy 190
Tom Stewart 189
Matthew Kreuzer 179
Andrew Gaff 176
Lachie Neale 173
Chad Wingard 173

Nat Fyfe leads the way on the breakeven chart, after scoring just 84 SCPoints last week. He has been ruled out for this week already, with Peter Bell adding he may potentially miss a few more games after this week, which puts you in a difficult position if you own him. Sam Docherty just had a bad game, which can happen every now and then while Mitch Duncan went down with injury and only scored 13 SCPoints. That sucks if you have him, but he could be a nice price in a few weeks because of it. Andrew Gaff was the decoy tag against the Crows and sacrificed his game (and Supercoach score) for the team while Chad Wingard was very poor against the Pies and could be in the low $400K range in a few weeks.

Adelaide Crows scoring in 2020 Breakevens
Sam Simpson -63
Izak Rankine -62
Will Day -30
Mitchell Hibberd -29
Andrew McPherson -27
Mitchell Georgiades -26
Brayden Ham -24
Harley Bennell -24
William Hamill -21
Louis Butler -19
Ned McHenry -17
Jake Aarts -17

Sam Simpson and Izak Rankine will likely be B1 and B2 when it comes to teams trading in this week, Simpson scored 112 SCPoints while Rankine added 111 SCPoints in his AFL debut game. Bonus that Simpson is a MID and Rankine is a FWD, so you can take care of two areas with them. Both have played just the one game this week, so if you can only make 1 trade I would probably look at Rankine ahead of Simpson, who has been around since 2017 and has yet to show he can be a consistent player. Rankine has his obvious talents that will keep him in the side. Will Day played his first game and scored 92 SCPoints, which is a great result. Andrew McPherson also had his AFL debut for 76 SCPoints, but he is one I may be slightly less enthused on given the talk of a compressed AFL schedule and his previous hamstring issues that have hit him since his junior days.

Trade Bolters
Izak Rankine +16.1%
Sam Simpson +11.7%
Will Day +4.2%
Jy Simpkin +1.7%
Andrew McPherson +1.6%
Bailey Smith +1.2%
Nick Haynes +0.9%
Patrick Dangerfield +0.8%
Jordan Ridley +-0.8%
Callum Mills +0.8%

No surprise to see Izak Rankine, Sam Simpson and Will Day as the top 3, while Jy Simpkin continues to be added as he continues his good form. Patrick Dangerfield has some fans flocking back to him after his score of 146 SCPoints against Brisbane. That is two 140+ scores in the last 3 weeks for him now. Jordan Ridley continues to look like a good buy with a 3-round average of 122.3 SCPoints and still only costs $503,900 currently. Callum Mills is even better with a 3-round average of 134.7 SCPoints, but will cost slightly more at $532,400.

Trade Sliders
Curtis Taylor -5.1%
Isaac Heeney -4.4%
Brandon Starcevich -4.1%
Tyler Brown -4.1%
Matthew Rowell -3.8%
Connor Budarick -2.9%
Jarrod Brander -2.8%
John Noble -2.5%
Hayden Young -1.4%

Most Popular Trades
Curtis Taylor for Izak Rankine
Tyler Brown for Sam Simpson
Isaac Heeney for Izak Rankine
Connor Budarick for Izak Rankine
Sam Simpson for Connor Budarick
Curtis Taylor for Sam Simpson
Brandon Starcevich for Will Day
Matthew Rowell for Sam Simpson
Tyler Brown for Izak Rankine
Jarrod Brander for Izak Rankine

Not exactly a surprise to see Izak Rankine and Sam Simpson as the 1-2 punch here again, with Curtis Taylor and Tyler Brown the options moved out for them. Isaac Heeney is out for the year, so a downgrade to Rankine looks like a sensible option to take as well.

Be sure to check out the rest of the articles on JR this week, Statty Matty has this weeks Cheat Sheet available while Damo has all our Captains info available with Who’s Your Captain? That’ll be it for me this week, but I want to hear what trades you are looking at this week. Whack ’em in the comments below and as always, I can be found on the Twitter machine @BarronVonCrow. Seeya next week!

Categories: Supercoach

Subscribe
Notify of
guest
131 Comments
Oldest
Newest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
BrownlowBoy

Fyfe is gonna do my head in. I don't want to trade purely because of his evident healing powers last week, he could miss a week or two and be right to go after that.

Russty_

Hi Tom, so if he misses 2 more, that's 3…tradeworthy I reckon, that's a lot of moolah on the bench

KSinny

Okay so I'm thinking of painting the fence this week, gonna get rid of my biggest mistake of the year (Tom lynch) and bring in Rankine. Then I either wanna get rid of Curtis Taylor (F5) or Budarick (who is on my mid bench) if I get rid of Taylor I have 561k to spend and am looking at Bailey Smith but thinking I can wait till next week to get him. Is is worth getting Brayshaw before he goes up or just get someone like simpkin/Petracca/Greenwood? Or I just double downgrade Lynch and Budarick to Rankine and Simpson leaving me with 392k for next week.

BrownlowBoy

Simpkin, Petracca Greenwood all good picks. I'd chase value and go Whitfield if you don't have him.
Keep Budarick. MID/FWD DPP be handy.

KSinny

Unfortunately I started with Whitfield so I'm not able to get value there but I'm thinking atm of going Curtis to Brayshaw then next week some other rookie up to a bottomed out Bailey Smith.

JohnDJ59

I like that plan.

Russty_

I still don't trust Brayshaw.

Maverick_

I like brayshaw till fyfe is back and 100% fit then scores may dip again.
I started brayshaw so i'm enjoying this purple patch haha

JohnDJ59

I shouldn't have traded him out after only one bad score. I admit that was a bad decision, he seems to be getting the game time now that Fyfe isn't fit and that should continue. I'm looking at him and Greenwood this weekend.

Lekdog

We are #LIVE talking all things #supercoach on Twitch. Come and join in the fun: https://www.twitch.tv/lekdoggames

Dave's disaster

Sorry lek just saw Dennis on the broadcast he's still the voice of footy

Russty_

Love Dennis, he should've never retired.

Dash

18K
Lloyd, Docherty, Sicily, Laird, Hill, Starc (Brander, Noble)
Danger, Macrae, Cripps, Cogs, D Smith, Pickett, Bennell, Budarick (Fyfe, McInerney, Rivers)
Gawn, Grundy (Combden)
Dusty, Whitfield, Bewley, Taylor, King, Aarts (Georgiades, Sturt)

Just wondering on two best trades this week.

Russty_

Someone to Rankine and Fyfe to Neale?

Dash

I was thinking of getting Simpson and Rankine this week. Basically, my entire bench is not playing. Not sure if hang onto Fyfe and go two others?

Russty_

Yeah most of us are in the same boat Dash regarding bugger all bench backup, best case scenario I guess is Fyfe gets back next week so he's only missed 2…Rivers ain't even getting named in the emergencies so maybe him to Simpson

Dash

Noble in helps me. Starc and Budarick always getting games. Brander, Rivers, McInerney, Sturt or Georgiades. Maybe Rivers and Fyfe or McInerney?

TommyC99

Are simpson and rankine the 2 best rookies this week? I can do some DPP action to get simpson in for Brander, but with gould and rivers on the pine, if williamson doesnt get up from his ankle injury i cop a zero, and i cant wait till tomorrow because simpson plays tonight.

Poss

I think Tom Williamson’s fine mate.
He’s spent a lot of time outa the game through injury so I recon he’d push through the little discomforts.
Only my opinion but Tommy

Kangaz

2 trades are not enough. Have no bench and have noble and Tom green on field. That's after trading Narkle and Heeny. FML

Maverick_

Got so many holes in my side..

Starc, noble rivers, Sturt, green and budarick all ready to be culled..

Thinking Noble and green down to Rankine and possibly day. Not sure about Simpsons JS don't trust Scott one bit. Just look at constable

Russty_

Maybe just Day and Rankine then Mav, at least Day is named onfield and with Burgoyne and Scrimshaw back in.
I don't believe Simpson will last long either..unless he gets another ton tonight.

Maverick_

yeah I am after JS more so than a few points and too me day and rankine have it in spades…
I copped a donut last week thanks too unreliable rookies russty, it hurts!

Swans2012

I feel your pain mav. All I wanted was one of rivers brander and bloody bloody zerkthatcher to get a game and none can, which leaves me either holding starc and getting rankine or settling for day/mcpherson and missing rankines initial price hike. It’s a crap scenario. I’m more bullish on Simpson than rankine, I think he gets a good crack this week and next, I have a small inkling that my swans may choke rankines score this week. But My gut is about 20/80 this year so not good chances…

Ralph

Talk of Noble being a late in for Cox given the weather. Not sure how credible the source is but keep an ear out if you’ve still got Johnny

Albert

If cox plays should be a laugh flappin around in the wet

Russty_

Yep…getting no touches except for 17 dropped marks lol

Pman

Where did you hear that Ralph? It would make sense given that Cox is as useless as Chocolate Teapot when it comes to playing in wet and slippery conditions…

Pman

Nice work Ralph…just confirmed Cox out and Noble in which is a good move and good for my trade situation!

Ralph

Sorry I didn’t reply Pman, was sussing the twittersphere for more news. Glad your trade situation is looking better!!

Kangaz

How will super coach work with so many games in a row in 2 weeks. Will be hard to keep up with from a team perspective

Mikee

I am wondering as well…<img src="https://tinyurl.com/yxbbsslm&quot; width="1"/><img src="https://tinyurl.com/wwct4y8&quot; width="1"/>

Jorg Ancrath

Might hold Taylor and ditch Tom Green. Anyone seen Freddie got Fingered?

Pman

Terrible movie but like the refrence!

Maverick_

NOBLE IN!!!!
COX OUT!!!!

TOPHAWK1

You little beauty!! Thanks Mav!

TRIGGA_HAPPY

FFS!!

Could have looped!
Must have been a late late in.

Waited till 7.
Traded him out so not to rely on starc at D6.

Errg just sums up my year..

Russty_

It was announced at about 4.30, maybe 5 in W.A time Trig

NDD

on twitter at 4 Trigg

Josh

Sturt to Rankine or Starcevic to Day?

Maverick_

sturt to rannkine josh.. keep the warm bodies

Russty_

Yeah keep Starc even though he's a yoyo spud, Sturt always injured it seems.

Nick

If you had to choose between Jayden Short or Hayden Crozier who would you pick community?

TOPHAWK1

Jayden Short for me.

Russty_

Short…more responsibility with Houli not playing for awhile

NDD

Short 100%

TOPHAWK1

Sam Simpson community….Yay or Nay? Its doing my head in.

Russty_

Yeah why not mate…what could possibly go wrong? 😉 If he tons up you'll be happy you did it when he's made 80 grand, even if he gets 50 it's still 50 grand, I'm just not sure about his js, I'm getting Bazmullet boy instead, had Long and Heeney to get rid of.

TOPHAWK1

If I take Simpson, I will be doing the double downgrade. Heeney has to turn into Rankine tomorrow. My bench cover is solid now with Noble, Budarick, Serong, and hopefully Georgiades playing. I could turn Tom Green into Sam Simpson right now. FML. Decisions!

Russty_

I'd do it, Giants rookies struggle to keep their spots, Green omitted, Hately omitted, they might not get back at all.

TOPHAWK1

OK Russty. I reckon you are right. Time to cash in Tom Green. Simpson can stay on the bench with the E on him. A nice loophole option and make some fast cash. We need warm bodies with all these byes coming up. Chris Scott better back the kid in or else! Cheers Russty! Go well this round mate. TH

Russty_

You too bud good luck this week.

NDD

yeah me too just do it green wont play all that much

Pman

Danger or Grundy VC Having a hard time deciding…

Russty_

Back your own lad Pman, unless it's wet

Pman

Have backed Grundy and he owes me one after giving him the C last week! Should he have a sub 125 score gets the C out of Neale (deBoer Tag) or Steele (Against the Adelaide U10's)?

Russty_

I had him as C last time too..disappointing but I reckon he'll redeem tonight.

Pman

Her certainly has so far with 94 points at half time from the beautiful big man bun!

Pman

*He

Russty_

Looks like a her, plays like a he…LOL

Russty_

He's stalled like an old Lada Niva now, hopefully he brings it home strong in the last and erases all doubt about the captaincy this week.

Pman

141 seals the deal for me Russty. I don't have Gawn and I don't back Neale or Steele to beat that. Happy I didn't go with Danger but stoked to get 4 hundreds in a row from him now.

Russty_

Ya man, I'm happy with that score..can't see Neale beating that
Danger's going all right Pman, in a team struggling to score much.

Mitch is back

Grundy with no Cox backup.

Should be lots of stoppages, hit outs

Pman

Good point Mitch and conditions look OK – Grundy it is.

Pman

Or Do I go Neale VC into Steele against Adelaide? I don't have Gawn or Macrae and no other potential high scorers.

NDD

Danger for me reckon something is amiss with Grundy and cd dont do him any favours

Holty01

Good luck all for the round.

Russty_

Go Holty same to you matey

Swans2012

That feeling when you forget to Set your vc on grundy and he’s on 32 after ten minutes 🤦‍♂️😤😖🤬🤬

Jorg Ancrath

Noble back in business. Playing well too.

Mitch is back

Oh so close to training him this week, could be around a bit longer both in my team & the Collingwood side.

Mitch is back

Trading

Pman

Looking really good wiht 52 points and have the E on him too which will work for me. If he puts in a full 4 Qtr performance then he's probably good for at least the next two which makes dumping the always picked but scoring crap Starcevich out for Rankine via DPP.

Jorg Ancrath

Jinxed him. Might even have to field Starc now and hope for better than 60.

Pman

I did speak too soon! I'm still going to trade Starcevich as will allow for double upgrade next week for Gawn/Smith and I'll take Noble's 60 and bench Adelaide's Mcasey who only averages 40.

Holty01

I’ve been very vocal of late of how CD have been scoring the likes of Grundy. Been getting over scored imo for his last 3 weeks with no real impact. Then comes to tonight, 95 at half time and justified. Having a absolute cracker of a game. Good work CD.

Shake n bake

Got a little nervous there in the end. Sweet Jesus hitout to Cripps with 2 mins to go was nice.

MagicGnome97

yeah hes been pretty mediocre the last few weeks but still scoring quite well in supercoach. today was by far his best performance of the season so far imo, well deserved score.

Jorg Ancrath

That moment you realise you fecked up the VC on Grundy. FML

Pman

Did you have Danger or anyone else in this game?

Jorg Ancrath

I have Crispy Kreme and Noble Dog. But it was just a cockup on the VC. I think I'll chuck it on Cogs now for a laugh. My season was cooked weeks ago.

Pman

Selwood's hammy probably plays in Simpson's favour as far as JS is concerned for a few more weeks.

JugHead

Simpson choice starting to look better for those that grabbed him. Score has improved and the two Cats injuries will help his JS now.

DEESNUTSRBIG

Only free kicks Geelong are getting is for out on the full.

Russty_

Reckon Simpson's done really well tonight after a slow start, you'd have to be happy if you got him in.

Jorg Ancrath

Score seemed inflated to me.

TOPHAWK1

Very pleased Russty! He is going to make us some fantastic coin now and I will take his 78 by plonking Rivers on the field. Happy days! TH

holty01

Agreed mate. Was pretty good in the 2nd half

Derek

Got a soft free for a goal, seemed to kick start his night.

No midfield time, but ball seemed to follow him in the second half.

Didn’t get him. Would have been a good pickup

JugHead

With Duncan and now Selwood injured, it will be interesting to see how much time Danger gets in the guts for the next couple of weeks.
With the crammed schedule coming up, they will need to work out how to get some mid minutes out of him without burning him out.

Russty_

I reckon Danger decides that himself, when he's out on the field during the game.

Mitch is back

More interesting to see who else for Geelong gets the mid time

JugHead

Being a bigger body type, I think Menegola. Gaz might spend a bit more time in there, but must be nearly due for a rest.
This should be a good opportunity for Steven, but he doesn't look fit and his game time is clearly being managed.
In any case, I don't see Danger spending as much time forward as he did a few weeks ago. His scoring has lifted the last few weeks and I don't see it dropping off.

JugHead

Of course………there have always been players who seem to be able to carry injuries, within reason.
Selwood is one of them. Pendles is another. These guys are still going after 300 games because they play banged up.
I wouldn't be shocked if Selwood played next week.

Tony

Young sammy simpson gonna make us some coin

Ralph

Any chance of Charlie Constable getting a gig?

DEESNUTSRBIG

I'm Taking Grundy's VC score as Captain.
People learnt their lesson from last week?

Russty_

Silly not to take that, Neale is likely to be tagged

JugHead

Yep, I've learnt my lesson. But its funny how I have to keep re learning the same lessons every season.

Russty_

Archie and Reggie were the smart ones mate, you mostly just hung around eating Hamburgers all day 🙂

TelescopicCox

Treloar looking the goods. Seems to have a low floor given he racks up the pill. As a Pies man I’ll be trying to squeeze him in at some point

Russty_

I'm too busy trying to replace the 2 guys in my side who get injured, dropped or suspended every week.

TelescopicCox

It’s a bit like that Russty! Fyfe my biggest concern at the moment. Still unsure what to do

Russty_

Wait and see if he miraculously recovers again next week TC

MagicGnome97

held him once. this time i reckon you gotta trade him though. unless you're okay with him missing 3 games before he returns, because he could easily end up doing that.

NDD

Well and truly on the radar. His disposal is better now .Probably my last mid after Smith next week

Maverick_

Hallelujah.
Grundy come through with the goods!
Silly me wacked the C straight on him instead of the VC.
I cant wait for the 2021 season

Russty_

Sometimes not giving a rat's knackers can work out for ya Mav ! 🙂

Ralph

Commentators said Selwood is a Rolls Royce and while I agree he’s a champion I’d argue that he is, in fact, the exact same Hilux that the Top Gear lads couldn’t destroy. “Unbreakable”.

Pman

Pendlebury is the Rolls Royce.

Russty_

I think Rozee has turned out to be a 1987 Hyundai Excel hatchback.

MagicGnome97

🙂 Agreed

Mitch is back

Dodgem Car, keeps low and just bangs in

JugHead

Fyfe is starting to look like an old Italian supercar. A beast to own and still delivers the thrills.
But it is it really worth all that money for something you can't rely on to just start and reverse out of the garage every weekend.

TommyC99

Macpherson or day?

AuroraBorealis?!

McPherson for me personally Tommy, like the look of his job security more so than Day's

Ralph

McPherson for me

John

Ended up trading Brown to Simpson and Brander to Rankine with Ceglar iffy I needed a warm body up front, thought about the Taylor/Starc cash grab but with a crammed schedule coming up I’d prefer to hold onto the rookies with decent JS, having said that they’ll most likely get dropped when I need them the most!

derek

JR SURVIVOR GROUPS

Its not a case of how well you went last week, it was all about how badly you didn't go.

For some teams, their bad wasn't bad enough to be eliminated.

Teams Eliminated last week:

Div 1 – Jorg Ancrath & ShinBONERS

Div 2 – Captain Carona #19 & Rookestars

Div 3 – Multiple Scorgasms & M's Cat

Div 4 – Findog[email protected] & FIGJAM 3.0

Div 5 – Black Ducks & Black Flag

Div 6 – Grasscutters & Halezel Ash FC

Div 7 – Green Machine & Subi 188s

Teams With Immunity for this week:

Div 1 – Coolburg Rangers (2102)
Div 2 – Marshmallows (2139)
Div 3 – Kicking behinds (2238)
Div 4 – Wah Wah FC (2125)
Div 5 – Vicwood (2284)
Div 6 – The Dogs Bollox (2073)
Div 7 – Banchang Barflys (2197)

Good luck everyone

thanks fellas

holty01

Great work again mate

JohnDJ59

I knew I was in trouble as soon as I posted my worst score for ages. Up until last week I was never in the firing line.

holty01

Just having a good look at my leagues really for the first time this year and noticed I’m coming dead last in the A Graders, 🤕. Didn’t think my season was going that bad so had a look at my season for/against total scores. I’m 9th in total scores but total score against I’ve been hit the hardest. To give people an idea of the competition in this league, there has been a total of 13,196 scored against me which in context to the season would have that score sitting 7th overall in the ranks. No wonder I’m getting absolutely smashed in this league. Nice work all.

Shake n bake

Don’t you hate that Holty!! My worst position is 7th but have the 2nd most against me in that league. I’ve brought in 4 rookies over the last 2 weeks and over 1 mill in the kitty. Just waiting a little longer to see how this season is playing out. Only got rid of non playing rookies and hopefully got one that will be there during best 18 or bye rds. Need as much playing even bench! Over the next 2 weeks will target Melb players and premo players. Only upwards from here for you Holty!

hedski

Playing you in the JR mega league, good luck for the weekend mate 👍

holty01

U2 Hedski

Shake n bake

Go cats 🐱

hedski

Kick me while I'm down Shake…ha ha.

Shake n bake

Don’t you hate that! My lowest league position is 7th but l have the 2 most against me. I’ve brought in 4 rookies the last 2 weeks because l want as many bench players as l can playing before we get to probably 18 best players scoring during bye rds. Ive slowly got rid of dead wood. I’ve now 1 mill in the kitty. I’m going to see how the next couple of weeks play out then hopefully bring in 4 premo players and target Melb players. Only upwards for you Holty!

NDD

A Graders make sure any newcomers are stayers and quality coaches .Most years only a few drop out and those places taken by competitive coaches Thanks for the feedback Holty

silversovereign

Boy oh boy… wowee! Lycett out. Hopefully my Pittonet hold pays dividends. Brought in Simpson and Rankine this week. Ruck upgrade next week or week after depending on how pitto goes 🤞🏼