Is this the perfect SuperCoach team?

Published by Trigger Happy on

Happy new Supercoach peeps! 

Yep SC is open for 2020. 

BBL helped to partially fill the void but is a poor second cousin compared to the real thing. 

Not sure how many of you have been playing along at home but the Phantom has completed a review of every team over summer and has listed each player accordingly in a Supercoach form guide in order of significance for 2020. 

So I thought it would be a bit of fun to see what a team would look like if you took each selection made by the Phantom for each team in order of SC significance.  

Refer below for the top 3 for each team.  

So here we go. 

I have called the team the Phantom Menace

If we pick up the phantom’s first selection for each team this is what it looks like. The only exception is I have not put in Todd Goldstein as Brodie Grundy and Max Gawn are on field so it would be waste to have Todd sitting at R3 on the bench. So I moved down to the next selection for North which is Aiden Bonar. 

I know a couple of guys are under an injury cloud but in this exercise they form part of the team purely based on supercoach significance for 2020. As you can see the top pick from each team uses $8.2M of the $10M salary cap. But powerful ruck and midfield and value picks in the forward line and defence with the ruck and forward line already filled on field. 

Not a bad looking team huh? 

Good way to get around the byes with is a selction from the 18 teams? 

Now it gets a little tricky as we only have $1.8M to play with and have 12 spots to fill. 

So I have added any cheaper options with the Phantoms second pick for each team as to add Cripps or Danger in the midfield for example would blow the salary cap. 

So out of second selections there are 3 spots in defence so in comes Dylan Roberson and Stephen Hill. 1 spot left on ground in the midfield which is filled by Matt Rowell and Miles Bergan takes the first bench spot in the forward line. 

This now leave one spot in defence and the benches with just over $1M remaining. 

So now we apply the same principle as above based on the Phantom’s 3rd pick for each team. Selecting players who can fit in the remaining salary cap. 

The final spot on field is filled by Hayden Young with Will Gould filling one of the spots on the bench. Hibberd and Cockatoo fill two of the midfield bench spots with cockatoo creating a DPP with the forward line and Pickett fills the final spot on the forward bench. 

This leaves 3 bench spots but only $330k remaining salary cap. As rookies are at least $118k this doesn’t leave enough cash to realistically fill the remaining spots. 

So I have swapped Pickett to Max King to fill the rest of the team. These rookies may change depending on selection for Round 1. 

So behold the finished product with a lazy $4,900 left! 

So after all that you have a pretty impressive looking team there Mr Phantom! 

I may even run with this one myself to see how it pans out over the season though Titch is looking unlikely to play round 1.  

What do you reckon community should I run with the team above? 

Give us a shout out in the comments 😊 

Gone to my happy place be back in a few …. 

Notify of

Newest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments

Is Chayce Jones really an option? Kelly and Roberton wouldn't be popular.Roberton just needs one heart episode to be out for the year.


Phantom rates him. He was a first rd pick and a gun jnr in the mids. Been training with the midfield as adelaide a bit one paced. Clean with his hands and disposal. If starts in midfield great value, touted as potential break out.

Maybe ask BVC his take on the kid.

I hope kelly and robbo aren't popular be gr8 pods!

Robbo bit of wait and see but if plays proven point scorer.
#2 at the saints according to the phantom. πŸ˜‰


I think he could be Mr breakout.


Swap out Titch for Dunkley, the Dogs 2nd pick and you go an exceptional team


Was amazed how the team started to form based on the form guide!

Yeah reckon Titch will be under done so dunks, Cripps or Danger are options.


Good areas, Trig. Interesting exercise. We all have our thoughts on players but structure wise there’s plenty we can take away from this.


Cheers Kev.

I thought would blow the salary cap as thought the phantom would select all the excy players in the form guide.

But with rooks like mead, Rankine, Pickett as #1 in the form guide for their team allowed me to pick 18 with cash to spare.

Team picked itself only had 3 picks at the end which were at my discretion on the bench.

Really like it and will probably be my rd 1 team if some of the rooks perform in Marsh series. <img draggable="false" role="img" class="emoji" alt="😁" src=""&gt;

The Ranger

Love ya work Trigga,
Ballsy team to start with.


Cheers mate.

Virtually formed itself.

Thanks Mr Phantom. πŸ™Š

Shake n bake

To all that sent me invitations to join their league, I’ll definitely get on to it hopefully in the coming days as im up north. I’ll also hope the teams included in up there cazaly will save a spot as l will also get that up and running next week.


Love that league




Yes Shaker, yes πŸ‘

Shake n bake

Only got home tonight John I’ll have a look tomorrow. To all the other invites l just jumped in πŸ€—

Shake n bake

hey Neil code for A Graders didn’t work??

Shake n bake

Worked now Neil πŸ‘Œ


Amazing how it all come together using the selections.πŸ˜‰

That's two votes for Dunks firming for a starting position. πŸ‘


This team is way too heavy in defence. Needs one fewer premo πŸ˜›

This is stellar stuff mate.


Doesn't lloyd count for 2? πŸ™Š


What are the prizes for supercoach this year?
AFL Fantasy has a new hilux valued at over 60K plus prizes for the top 100.
Apart from endless spam from every business associated with Herald Scum what are the SC prizes


Weekly Prizes: total up to $1,750 cash per week. Bonus Prizes (if any) as advertised prior to the relevant round. Overall prizes: First Place Competition Major Prize $50,000 cash. Second Prize: $5,000 cash. Third to Tenth Place Major Prizes: $1,000 cash.


Try finishing 11th overall, like I did one year.
Worst heartbreak imaginable


Ouch e wa wa!…that smarts a bit, bloody great result for the year though, you should be proud of that.


Great inspiration, thx!<img src="; width="1"/>


A very similar team to mine Trigga and i'm pretty set on what I've picked.. By the way did you get my emails for the rat pack and magnificent 7


I did now Gat.

Wasn't in inbox so had to go to all mail to find invite.

In mate. πŸ‘


Cheers mate.. The side you have put up is so similar to mine and I love the Hunter Clark move

Shake n bake

Hey Trigga did u get my code 145829? Love to have u back.


Yep joined today mate πŸ˜‰


Have you got any space for me Gator?


HI Finn jump in mate The Rat Pack.. code 594654….. Magnificent 7 code 136810… Jump in mate

Shake n bake

Hey Finnius your welcome to join up there cazaly? 145829 let me know.


Anyone got a couple of leagues?

Shake n bake

What’s the name of ur team BB?


This year at the moment I've gone with Jaegarnauts

Shake n bake

Up there cazaly BB 145829 jump in!

Shake n bake

I did have a look at RTradres this morning but was full I’m in 6 leagues now I’ll wait till a few more other leagues l was in last year drop first. Are you in my league John?

Shake n bake

Jump in John.


In thank you!


Jaegarnauts is the team name!

I just jumped on Rogue Traders, if you need to kick me, feel free to do so πŸ™‚




Hi BB was you in my 2 leagues last year … The Rat Pack and Magnificent 7


Yeah I was in both of those!


Jump in BB codes above


In thank you πŸ™‚

Mighty Chungus

Still a few spots available in Smoove Jimmy's League of the week:


BB are you recreating your "elite of the elite" league from last year? It was a cracker.
Go cats πŸ‘


I'll get onto that now Hedski!

Hopefully a good year ahead for the blue and white hoops. I'm optimistic. Excited to see Jack Steven, if he gets back to his best lookout.


Cheers mate I'm in, hopefully it was only a minor calf tweak he did the other day, should be a good addition when he's fit.

Shake n bake


Lee Mahony

I joined as 'Stack to Pickett' -name Lee

Shake n bake

Hey Holty did you get my league code 145829?


I didn’t but I just entered. Cheers mate


I finished 7200-th last year Holty so you'd better watch out for me..I'd be shaking in my Gumboots if I were you.


Hi Holty I think you was in my leagues last year… The Rat Pack.. code 594654….. Magnificent 7 code 136810… Jump in mate


Thanks Jd.

If I have taken one of the regulars spots feel free to boot me. πŸ™ˆ


Any spots left John – keen to join Rogue Traders or other solid leagues.


Thanks John! Looking forward to it.


Hugh Greenwood 463k Fwd/Mid – Thinking he may the extra step and end up being in the top 6 Fwds by season ends ? thoughts anyone ?
I currently have him at F3 with Smith F4 who could be Steven at some stage

Mighty Chungus

Jaa, him and zeib might be a sneaky chance.

Shake n bake

RIP mumba.


And his 13 year old daughter. Devastating news. RIP Black Mamba, your legacy will never die.


John mate, Why don't you just send out invites to who you want in your league ?, Thanks Trig I got your email / invite ,I'm in again


Hi DBB jump in to these leagues.. I'm sure you was in them last year The Rat Pack.. code 594654….. Magnificent 7 code 136810… Jump in mate


Ok JD I'ii jump in

Shake n bake

Let me know if a spot does open up in holy grail John.


Already in mate.


Some of the regulars should have received an email to join the Elite of the Elite league again this year. Not sure how well the emails get sent out and if they even make it to people, but fingers crossed!


I'm in πŸ‘


got the email BB


Not regular enough. πŸ™‰


TH I'd love you to jump in. I'm wary of posting codes in here with people tending to just jump right in.
I can email you a league invite if you'd like, or if you'd prefer I can post the league code in another league chat on supercoach we are currently in together? Just let me know a list of leagues you're in and we can go that route if you'd prefer πŸ™‚


Both of gators BB

Rat pack and Mag 7.



I'll post it in Rat Pack TH!

Lemme know your team name so I can boot anyone who tries to join.


Yeah I'd love to John!

Whichever one you'd like me to join I'll do that. I'll leave RT to free a spot for someone else right now!


Is there a spot still open NDD?


Are there any SC leagues? Ranked around 800 last year, so keen to try my mettle against the veterans!


Hey John,
I’ve also jumped in.
Champs. Nev


Hey all. Other than getting thrown into a public league, I need a league to join . This will be my second year in supercoach. Played fantasy for a few years . ( Different format is challage) Team B52's. Name Herb

Shake n bake

Is Max Gawn??!!


I think we just wait and see Shake… Crossing fingers it's not bad


Hi folks,
How does one become a member here?
Keen to join a SC league on here. Finished 1,721st last year.


Hi Ian, for making a profile you just need to sign up at intense debate (should prompt you either at the top of the comments section or the bottom)…I don't have any league codes at the moment but join our community group here:…




Not sure if this worked?

Try signing up here:

Chop Buster

Stop posting your codes in a public space ya spud


Here’s my pre Marsh squad. Let me know your thoughts.

DEF: Sicily, Houston, Docherty, Doedee, Young, Gould, Rivers, B.Smith
MID: Macrae, Neale, Cripps, Fyfe, T.Kelly, Rowell, McHenry, Pickett, Hutchesson, Mead, Budarick
RUC: Grundy, Gawn, Comben
FWD: Whitfield, Martin, D.Smith, Bonar, Hill, Rankine, Cameron, King

Will be interesting to see what the Marsh has in store for us!


My team is. Let me know what you think.

Daf Tom Stewart. S Docherty. Z Williams. S hurn. W day. B starcevich. Bench w gould. T Bianca.

Mids. L neale. M bontempellI. A trelor. Z marritt. J newnes. A bonar. M rowell. M Pickett. Ben h N mchenry. D robertson. T rivers.

Rucks. B Grundy. S Martian. Bench J sweet.

Fwds. L Whitefield. H Greenwood. J Steven. D Smith. M king. B Frampton. Bench D Cameron. C budarick.

Taking a punt on a few players hope it works out for me.

King Tools Setup

Nice post