add_filter('comment_flood_filter', '__return_false');

THE CHEAT SHEET Round 18

Published by Damo on

There comes a time in every year when players start to get hurt, the players start to get injured. Players start to miss games. The world collapses and everything goes dark.

Okay maybe not that bad, but it’s getting to the point where only the strong will survive. Not only the strong teams, but the strong minds too. Those who still have 5 or 6 trades, and also have a team full of champions.

In case you didn’t know, James Sicily has done something to his wrist. Michael Hibberd has strained his quad/hamstring/leg. Nic Naitanui has done his ACL again (I’m still consoling Kev – It’s going to be okay, Kev.) and Robbie Gray went to sleep in Perth and we still don’t *really* know if he’ll wake up in time for this weekend’s game against the Giants.

Callum Sinclair is back! This time recommended as a Nic Naitanui replacement? His weekend’s game wasn’t great, but he’s still the fourth ranked ruckmen for the year, and he’s still a great pick.

Is it time to go and get Rory Sloane? Does Tom Bellchambers run home tempt you? What is Michael Hurley building to? All these are very good questions. Do you want to find out and bring them in? Some players are safer than others but if you take a risk, and you get the reward it could see you rise above the pack.

Ladies and Gentlemen, the cheat sheet!

Categories: Cheat sheet

Subscribe
Notify of
guest
94 Comments
Oldest
Newest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Lazza

Hey Damo.. good stuff .. I’d take Brayshaw in a flash ahead of bandy Shaw..

r_calve

who wouldn't, the kid's a gun

r_calve

on more forward spot up for grabs with 7 trades left, pull the trigger on lids, big risk but big rewards if it works out and I got enough trades to cover him if it fails

what do you guys think?

NoLanguage

I wouldn't but if you've got brass balls do it. Blokes made of glass though!

BrownlowBoy

Best defender for 460k?

r_calve

my top five under 460k are:
1. luke ryan
2. tmac
3. nick vlastuin
4. mcgovern
5. princess rance/savage

Maverick_

No witherden?? Only 420k. Very stiff to not make it in ya 5

r_calve

has a decent option but there are too many guys in Brisbane backline that can steal his points such as rich and Hodge, I can almost guarantee that if one of those guys doesn't play he will score better, but he is still very nice for 420k.

hedski

Please don't demean Alex by calling him Princess Rance.
His name is Fancy Pants Rance.
My order would be.
Ryan
Fancy
Tmac
Sav
Gov
Vlaustin
πŸ‘

r_calve

fancy pants rance it is then!

Tyruddanaut

Oh, you mean France, sorry it took me so long

Valens_FC

Stats say T Mac but I don’t mind our man Tuhoy given the run home. 4 at Kardinia Park including nice fixtures for league prelims and grand finals. McGovern draw not bad either and in good form.

NoLanguage

Ryan for mine

Ahmad rubas

3 options to trade out hibberd lobb and Sicily
5 options to trade in lloyd McDonald Oliver buddy gray
What's the best combination I'm currently leaning towards lobb to Oliver as that was my original trade before injuries and hibberd to McDonald as Lloyd can still fall in price. What are your thoughts?

Daz

Can't go past Lloyd and Oliver to score the most from that list. I finally can bring Lloyd in this week, got sick of watching Sydney without him.

Ahmad rubas

after taking a closer look the 3 main negative pods I need to close are grundy Lloyd and macrae. Grundy is a luxury trade considering I have goldy at R2 but Lloyd and macrae arent luxury. The main problem with macrae is his high breakeven so it would be smart to to wait a week on both these players considering I'm not facing a donut. The only problem is hibberd and Sicily are injured so won't drop in price meanwhile lobb has a BE of 91. Should I pull the trigger on the trades or just hope that lobb breakeven meanwhile Lloyd and macrae tumble in price

Hawks

I see neither Kennedy or Gray have been ruled out for this week.

Do we really expect them to play?

r_calve

jpk is pretty much a Mack truck so he should be fine but gray might be late out so put the E on someone before the game

DavidC

"His importance to coach John Longmire's side means the likelihood of the three-time club champion running out against the Suns is remote, especially with crucial games against Essendon, Collingwood, Melbourne, Greater Western Sydney and Hawthorn to come in the run home to the finals."

High chance he is a late out.

theRealPod

Doubt it. Selection committee have no respect for SC, bloody disgrace.

BrownlowBoy

Dangerfield also somewhat doubtful.

Is unwell apparently.

hedski

Lack of leather poisoning BB.

Lazza

Has a bug … will be in bed for a couple of days… not allowed at the club…

BrownlowBoy

Any chance he could somehow kiss Max Gawn?

theRealPod

Na he chucked a sickie so he could go fishing.

Donthesash

Who would you pick up out of Macrae and Beams

Tyruddanaut

If it’s your last upgrade, Macrae, if not, Beams

Tyruddanaut

Looking at my potential 2018 team:
Weitering, Marchbank, Plowman, Thomas, Rowe, Simpson

Murphy, Dow, SPS, Fisher, E. Curnow, Kennedy, LOB, Garlett

Kreuzer, De Koning

Pickett, Wright, Curnow, McKay, Polson, Kerr

Docherty is too expensive

Nifty

No spot for Gaff..

Andrew

I think he was just picking Carlton players… Who would want to leave a top 8 side to a wooden spooner?
He will only go to a club in the top 10.

HarryH76

Only way Gaff would get to Carlton is if they pulled the old Visy/Judd deal. But I think the AFL changed the rules after that so doubt they can give him an attractive enough offer

Hawks

I like it some real POD's, but think you may struggle with coverage through the byes….

Florence Maxwell

Probably a bit late to pick a 2018 team

Stupid Coach

Thanks for another great cheat sheet Damo. I have 5 trades left and 30k. My only concern is Sicily and Gray if he is a late withdrawal. I have Josh Battle and Keefe (if named) to cover Gray and Lynch to cover Sicily. Do I hold trades for this week and use the bench or should I trade Sicily to T Mac or a defender under $530k or trade him to a forward (currently have D Smith, Buddy, Heeney, McLean, Westhoff and Gray). Thanks Community.

Marcus

No point holding Sicily, especially with 5 trades up your sleeve
Depending on how your defence is looking could be easy swing to a crisp or brayshaw type

Lazza

SC Finals will be over before Sicily returns Stupid ..

Luke Purcell

Also, dont discount that having trades if you are in finals for $$. Sicily is not playing for sure but if you have bench cover till finals maybe hold fire and get the guy on a hot run. Its only 1-2 weeks and maybe 50 points per week.

John

5 Trades and $269k, do I trade Sicily to Mundy and then upgrade Logan Austin to Jake Lloyd? Or do I wait a week or 2 on Lloyd?

DavidC

Yeh, do it. Hold your last 3 trades for emergencies.

KingWinter7

My defence looks like this: Laird, Yeo, Simpson, Sicily, Hurley, Hibberd (Rice, Redman)
With only 2 trades left and 96k in the bank should I be trading both Sicily and Hibberd or just Sicily

Question is I could trade Sicily to Lloyd but that would leave me with only 10k to use my last trade with which wouldn't cut it as ideally I'd be trading Hibberd

If I traded Sicily to Hurn I'd be leaving myself with 100k in the bank which is far more useful but not having Lloyd hurts

The rest of my team is full premo with Billings as F7/M9 cover

Cheers

r_calve

go lloyd

Derek

Get Lloyd

AFC1886

Crisp, Hurley, Hurn, or Brayshaw who do we expect to score the most from here?

Finnius

I'm going Crisp. Most consistent and the most durable.

Connor

5 trades left
Straight-swap Sicily to Hurley / Ryan, or swing him FWD and grab Westhoff??
Otherwise can downgrade a rookie and grab Lloyd…

Derek

Hold your trades, you will need them when teams out of contention start resting their players and sending them for early pre-season opperations.

It you can use just one trade

Jock

Need a forward, can afford anyone. Current forwards heeney, mclean, gray, hoff, smith and sicily. Thinking franklin or mundy… Thoughts community? Cheers

Finnius

I like the Chad.

Jock

Already have gray and hoff dont really want chad too

Krama

Please rank these defenders from best to worst options to bring in for Sicily at D6.
McDonald, Brayshaw, L.Ryan, L.Whitfield.
I have a feeling with only 2 trades left saving 35k with McDonald or 46k with Ryan instead of Brayshaw could come in handy when a prem MID or FWD goes down. Or should I just go with L.Whitfield 492k who i think will be the best scorer and only have 2k left in the piggy?

DavidC

Whit's is a mid only so assuming a bit of dpp in play there.

Richard

How come no one is talking about crisp as a defensive option? Averages higher then Ryan and has seen increased midfield time since Treloar gone out.

Audrey Horne

Have you read any of the other comments? Loads of people talking about Crisp.

BlueSteele

Literally everyone has mentioned Crisp

NoLanguage

Best defensive downgrade?

Will be my last one to keep $200k for injuries. Thinking Richards to his teammate Lynch??

Audrey Horne

Lynch is now $180k, already had his first price change.

DavidC

Get the irish Swans man. Looks like he has good JS at the moment and a good fantasy game so a good E option.

Bobby

Hibberd to Crisp Or Whitefisld? Whose likely to have the higher scoring from here on. Cheers community.

theRealPod

Out of those two definitely Crispy

Da_Boysh

4 trades, 3 after i move Sicflog on

Should I get Lloyd and have $0 in the bank, or go for L.Ryan and have $150k in the bank

Derek

If you can get to Lloyd with one trade I would do that.

redherringfc

Ryan had a few poor games, followed by a good one last week. I’ve got to hold him but I don’t think he’s going to finish the season off strongly.

Go for Lloyd.

Derek

I didn’t see the WCE game on weekend, how did McGoven play? Scored 132 but not sure he was on much at half time. Was it just because it was Collingwood and they always give opposition defenders plenty of points

Can’t help but notice his score improves with JJK and Darling back.

Only $422k and a great draw

HarryH76

I considered McGovern but spent the extra money on Crisp.

I've had McGovern previous years and the problem with him is inconsistency. His big scores generally come from intercept or contested marks but he has some games where the opposition play smart and don't allow him that luxury. Hence he'll get a 130 one week and a 60 the next.

I would have strongly considered him on a limited budget but luckily I can afford Crisp and at this time of the year got to go as strong as you can.

r_calve

the gov was BOG on sunday and looks gold, will be even better when barass comes back

HarryH76

Someone during the week floated the idea of Buddy as VC this week. Not a bad shout considering the opponent. I can't go Gawn into Titch as my last loophole option is T Smith so probably need Gawn C, with VC prospects limited. With only 4 games to choose from, my options are probably either Dusty, Billings (ha!), Crisp (left field), Buddy, or D Smith. Surely Buddy tops that lot? Or can we trust Dusty has come back into form? Not sure I can at this stage.

DavidC

Dusty or Buddy into Gawn for me.

Derek

i'm thanking my old mate Olango. with JSmith, Heron, Brodie and Battle all getting a start this week, i have my whole bench playing. so much for looping.

I'm locking the C on Max. going with Henney or Dusty as VC, i got no-one else in the early games to have as VC (i need to make sure i put Grundy on Bench so i can C Olango if needed)

redherringfc

Who to get to replace Kreuzer?

I’ve got the money for Grundy, but saving $70k and getting Martin has its appeal. Goldy looks back in form, but I’m not convinced he’ll outscore the other 2.

Next best look like Sauce, Sinclair and Nankervis, but they aren’t in the same ball park.

Any advice would be appreciated.

redherringfc

My next question.

Is there any merit in holding Sicily for a week so I can pick up Heeney cheaper (assuming he misses his be of 157)?

I’d have to field Ahern, but I could then loophole Franklin as vc.

Maverick_

Do it mate. I’m holding Sicily to hopefully grab Greene after 1 more look and at a cheaper price.
Ahern will most likely give you an 80. Pretty respectable score

Derek

get Heeney now. he is playing Suns at SCG without (probably) JPK. he is a VC option this week.

redherringfc

Thanks Derek. That’s the way I’m leaning.

Any advice on a ruck? Grundy or Martin (saves about 70k)?

r_calve

stef martin looks very nice now that his midfield is in form, hell probably have the same output as grundy so go for him

Stacky23

got 5 trades left, 170k and nic nat and sicily out
Thinking nic nat to martin and then is it worth moving fritsch to the field until finals and trading sicily to macrae next week, i can then use 2 of my final 3 trades to go giro and one of ahern/austin to get my final fwd
im guaranteed a spot in top 4

Maverick_

My side & my injured players with an asterisk.

DEF. laird, yeo, simpson, hurley, Webster**, hibberd**, (naughton taylor)

MID: danger, TMitch, oliver, beams, cognilio, Martin, Curnow, Martin (ahern Phillips Powell)

Ruck: Gawn nicnat** (olango)

Fwd: heeney McLean Sicily** DSmith Gray westhoff (battle TSmith)

Nicnat has to go either Martin or goldy.
2nd trade I’m unsure on yet.
I wouldn’t mind waiting a week on sic though to have a look at lids & Greene. Solid pods.
Any help is appreciated

r_calve

im goin lids to but trade nic nat for big bellchambers and sic for deledio

WTFoxtrot_58

If someone had told me at the start of the year
'You'll have Dusty as your M8 going into the finals'
My thoughts would have been

Thankyou Supercoach Gods

What a difference hindsight makes!!

edospeedos

Hey guys, only going for league.
Should I go
Safe: Sinclair & smith for sicily & nicnat
High Risk: Martin/Goldstein & West coast kennedy (playing dogs/freo run home..) for Sicily & nic nat

r_calve

how much cash have you got to play with cos u should go for stef martin but probably someone like caddy instead of jjk

edospeedos

Max 420k on the fwd if I trade martin in

r_calve

for under 420 either billings, mclugage or ed langdon

murray

I am thinking of holding Sicily this week and waiting for Mccrae to drop in price, need him to drop 30K to pick him up next week.

What would Mccrae have to score in R18 to drop 30K given his BE of 175 this week, If he dropped the 30K what would his new BE be for R19. Hoping someone can provide/do the maths for me
thanks

r_calve

if he gets about 125 he'll probs drop to about 550k but don't quote me it's just an estimate but you should be alright
if he gets around 125 his new breakeven will probs be like around 110

Murray

Thanks R

Dogsdik

Laird, savage, hurley, lloyd, tmac, yeo(jsmith/cumming
jpk,danger,parker,dusty,jkelly,oliver,cripps,titch(ahem/barry/brown)
Max,grungy(cammo)
Heeney,hoff,dsmith,walters,mclean, Sicily(battle/keeffe)
Greene, Gray or Buddy for Sicily?

r_calve

buddy

Jock

Mundy or buddy???

Mograt

In which order do you guys think provides the best replacement for Sicily in the forward line. Noting I have 7 trades 40 k in bank, playing for league, and have full promo except for mihocec in the back line which I will address next week.

1. Wingard @ $490k – consistent, playing on ball but $50k extra
2. Mundy @ $445k – playing more on ball since Fyfe out
3. Buddy @ $439k – such good value with high ceiling but frustratingly pumps out low scores when you least need it by leaves me $100k for other things.

Much appreciate opinions and comments. Cheers community.

r_calve

I'm going for the chad

FearTheBeard

I'm stumped guys.

Low on trades.

Macrae in for Sicily and play Ahern as a FORWARD ON FIELD?

OR

Westhoff on field and Ahern as bench cover?

r_calve

the hoff

FearTheBeard

thanks calve.