add_filter('comment_flood_filter', '__return_false');

THE CHEAT SHEET Round 10

Published by Damo on

The cheat sheet speaks for itself but you will notice that Jake Lloyd has returned this week but with a green cape on, after playing as Fremantle’s marking forward on Saturday night.

*pauses for laughs*

Aaaanyway, here’s the cheat sheet!

As always, my thanks to Fantasy Insider for keeping this website going!

Categories: Supercoach

Subscribe
Notify of
guest
120 Comments
Oldest
Newest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Russty_

Hi Damo, agree about Andrews, could be the new best pod at Brissy, and he's affecting Witherden's scoring.
Tough week for a lot of coaches with many outs, tossing up yet whether to go Nicnat or Grundy if the Nank is out this week.
Howe is definitely confirmed as part of the Supercoach climate lol.

Crowboy94

I went for Crisp over Andrew's.

Russty_

Pretty similar really, in price, output and risk.

StatsFrog

Suprisingly he's the 2nd fastest Lion and covers more distance than all lions except Zorko

Ahmad rubas

laird sicily hurley hibberd doedee cole (murray cumming)
danger titch fyfe cripps kelly coniglio kelly higgins (spargo dow coffield)
gawn goldstein (olango)
heeney smith petracca billings lobb fritsch (langdon crowden)
21 trades 120k
original plan was kelly and murray out for dusty and phillips via coffield dpp but now i have a donut in defence and coffield doesnt save the donut as he is managed as well.
would kelly and murray out for phillips and yeo be the best trades to make this week?

Hawks

Yeo could be a late out, after his injury last week. I think they will give him a chance recover, but don't be surprised

Ahmad rubas

yeah thats one thing im scared about. if yeo is guaranteed to play i think he is the best defender i dont own. problem is im changing my original plan to avoid a donut and it would be annoying if i still cop a donut with yeo as a late out

Redpill5

Yeo is a possible out. Phillips is a good trade for Kelly, he had a low score last week but had 19 touches. Plenty of options down back, Howe, Simmo, Webster, crisp. Turf Murray

Ahmad rubas

need a round 12 bye defender ideally for structure but howe and webster do look like great POD options

Cyriledagain

Yep, Yeo is a risk not to play with knee injury from last week.

Ahmad rubas

if he is named tomorrow should play shouldnt he? he played through it last week and doubt he would fly to melbourne just to sit out

Cyriledagain

Just listening to sports radio this morning here and apparently he did nothing apart from standing around bouncing ball . He thought Yeo was very doubtful.

Ahmad rubas

Oh that doesn't sound good. Thanks for the info

Russty_

You can't bank on it Ahmad, Jack Higgins flew to Perth last week and was omitted last minute, they don't care about a $700 airfare.

Ahmad rubas

Yeah good point I think I'm just trying to find reasons to justify yeo in haha

Swans2012

Not so much the airfare rust, more they wouldn't make him sit with his knee bent for the plane trip if they didn't expect him to play, if he flys he plays imo.

Hawks

What effect does Mills being out for the year have on Jake Lloyds scoring

fcabel

I wonder this too. Bump

Sc_Wow

No one would know, we haven’t seen it so the only responses you’d get are people guessing

Jimmy

wow these threads are full of guesses you idiot

Skate or die

That’s very uncommunity like Jimmy! I think you need a basic lesson in the jock Reynolds community eddicate mate..

Jimmy

well they are guesses. never said they aren't good opinions

Swans2012

I think he was just saying to wow that an opinion would be better than saying "it'd be a guess" which we already know. People ask questions to get people's opinions which most of the time are just educated guesses.

Swans2012

For mine I think they play different roles and it won't be too much of a problem, lloyds main problem will be opposition coaches cracking down on him….

Mike

Hey guys, thoughts on T.Kelly and Murray to Dangerfield and Ridley? I would have 17 trades and 122k left over after these trades, to potentially upgrade my forward line next week. Any other suggestions for trades are appreciated!

DEF: Laird Yeo Sicily Doedee Mirra Ridley (Hurley Murphy)
MID: Fyfe Dangerfield Cripps Titch Dusty Parker Bontempelli (Holman Spargo Mutch)
RUCK: Gawn Nank (Olango)
FWD: McLean Heeney Smith Petracca Fritsch Guelfi (Langdon Keeffe)

Redpill5

Probably not many other options for you this week, so go for it.

Jared

jack crisp as a smokey?

Redpill5

Yup traded him for Murray this week

Flaccid Jaff

I like it. He's gonna be moved around the park so will be inconsistent. Greenwood back in the side will affect him. But he'll do well on average i reckon with some big scores. Good pod

theRealPod

Na maybe next year

Flaccid Jaff

Yeo, howe, ryan or tuohy in order?

Defying_Madness

yeo, ryan, howe, tuohy

Hawks

Yeo, Howe, Ryan & Tuohy

Cyriledagain

Any suggestions appreciated community.
Was going to hold Finlayson and Murray to byes but their non selection is forcing a change.
Really liked the look of Ridley so either Finlayson/Murray to Ridley and to T Mcdonald/Simpson?
I would have 19 trades and around 100k left over after these trades, to potentially upgrade my forward line next week. Any other suggestions for trades are appreciated!
Billings and Hibberd have really hurt me this year.
DEF: Laird Hibberd Sicily Doedee Finlayson Murray Ridley (Richards Murphy)
MID: Fyfe Dangerfield Cripps Titch Dusty Coniglio T Kelly Petracca(Holman Barry Coffield)
RUCK: Gawn Natanui (Olango)
FWD: McLean Heeney Smith Christensen Billings Fritsch (Spargo Keeffe)
Any other thoughts appreciated.

Hawks

I would select Simpson over McDonald.

Simpson will continue to average well, where McDonald have been played forward in easy match-ups in the past few weeks.

neil demons delight

Mcdonald is permanent forward now Doesn't even train with the backs anymore

Redpill5

McDonald is a possible out and it sounds like the injury that kept him out for the first 5 weeks isn’t healed properly. Reckon he’s a trap anyway.

neil demons delight

interesting they selected Pederson who is in rare VFL form 11 snags in 2 games same position as Macca and a ruckman wouldn't surprise if they rest him with those hard red surfaces in Alice

Hawks

I need a defensive rookie, what are everyone's thoughts on Rice v Ridley?

I saw Rice play and thought he was composed for a youngster, Ridley obviously had a good day in a match where Essendon flogged Geelong.

Lazza

Bomber capt gave Ridley a huge wrap on SEN during the week. I reckon he has a few weeks in him…

Russty_

If T-Mac is out with Footrot Flats, could mean Hogan gets back to his best again…don't need another mediocre 63 out of him.

neil demons delight

Reckon he plays Russty but not for me. Lloyd or Martin just too good

KSinny

Lloyd, Howe or Webster at D5?

Haze

Surely Lloyd. But any of the 3 would be solid. Maybe decide based on bye structures.

Haze

Help Community! Going to cop a defense donut regardless but trying to minimise the damage.
Help needed to decide between:
Option 1 – keep Kelly and trade Murray & Naughton to bring in Lloyd and Ryan, and have no bank left
Or
Option 2 – Trade Kelly and Murray, to bring in Sicily and Ridley (via Coffield swing to mid) and keep $300k in bank for another upgrade next week.
Advice?

Sandyf62

Option one, you gotta do what you can to minimise the damage plus Lloyd and Ryan look solid options, I'm bringing both in myself.

Haze

Cheers. Agree, keeping Kelly and hoping he doesn't lose too much price seems to make sense as really need a win this week. Although toying with the hybrid option of bringing in Lloyd and Ridley for Murray and naughton. And picking up Ryan after the byes as he has the same bye as Lloyd. So many options!

JohnDJ59

Hey Haze, option one for me as well, on the Ridley idea, you could wait a week and make sure he gets picked for his third game.

oliverfisher

Who do we think is most likely to get picked again at some point, Murray or Finlayson? I'm looking to offload at least one this week, but i'm hoping one of them comes back soon to give some coverage during the bye rounds.

CalebCripps922

Murray should be back i'd reckon

Sc_Wow

Not sure really, Collingwood have an easier run so if they’re winning games they might not change teams.
Someone could get injured from either team and force their inclusion. There isn’t much difference between who is more likely

TBrab

Appreciate any suggestions on trade ideas for this week. Thinking maybe Hurley & Coffield to Sicily and Ridley??

Def: Laird, Hurley, Savage, Doedee, Murray, Coffield (Mirra, Mihocek)
Mid: Macrae, Fyfe, Cripps, Mitchell, Pendlebury, Martin, Coniglio, Kelly (Holman, Dow, Wilson)
Ruc: Gawn, Nankervis (D. Cameron)
Fwd: Mclean, Robinson, Walters, Petracca, Fritsh, Higgins (Spargo, Switkowski)

17 Trades and $35k in the bank

neil demons delight

Great job Damo Surprised not to see Dusty there somewhere. We wont get him much cheaper

SCDamien

I really thought about it, and totally agree that he should've been featured somewhere. His BE is 131 though, so even if he does beat it this week, he'll still be really cheap for next week.

His R14 bye is something that causes me headaches though, because lots of people are already stacked with players who are off in the same week.

neil demons delight

A truckload of work in this article and it is appreciated .Kudos to you Damo NDD

Demons 5th 4 2018

The Melbourne Football Club
The Dees big problem is we only have 16 players that are a week in week out walk up start and another 6 spots for 12 players. A great and stable side normally has 20 regulars and 2 spots between about 6 players. The talent and depth is looking strong but there has been rumblings coming out for a while about Vince, Lewis and Garlett from the younger players.
Expect a couple of younger blokes to be traded out and a star player brought in via trade or free agency for next season (plenty of money under the cap too)
Melbourne can beat anyone when they play quick (play on, kick the ball long) but as soon as they go back to chipping the ball and working it slowly they will turn the ball over and lose – they simply don't have the field kicking skills of a Sydney, Adelaide, Hawthorn to play that style.
The Dees handball (only 35 more kicks than handballs) too bloody much for my liking – the opposite is West Coast (102 more kicks than handballs per game) who have made this their main focus for the season and coaches may finally take notice.

neil demons delight

You are quite correct about Vince Lewis and Garlett but I think you will find some of these newer players Fritsch Hannan Spargo and Smith have the ability to become regulars,maybe not this year but next. Whilst we are hopeful this year next year is our goal.. The player you are talking about is a premiership mid . . In my view these 3 will be moved on . Getting young Bradke was a clear bonus for the dees cheers and go dees

Demons 5th 4 2018

Another 30 games into this team and we could be just about flag favorites. Fritsch is a regular already, he is solid. A 12-15th best player in the team type but not going to be a top 10. You are right about being 1 gun mid short. Melbourne have about 6 younger role type players that could go either way, 20-30 more games will tell – talent level is exciting.

Savage Cats

Will move Finlayson to the MIDS bench or Sicily to the FWD line.
Cant take the risk on a DEF rookie after 1 game as already have Duman not playing at D8 (plenty of rookie DEF next week to choose from)
Lloyd is in Murray is out. Badly wanted to upgrade a premo MID @M8 but that has to wait.

jeff

trade in howe, yeo or webster for finlayson?

yeo is doubtful, but if he'll be fine from next week, then looking long term, I'll probably trade him in.

SC_Kev7

Agree. If Yeo is confirmed to play go him. If not, prefer Howe as he’s proven

Stupid Coach

Really enjoy the Cheat Sheet Damo. I have 17 trades and only 37k. Team is as follows:
B: Laird, Yeo, Savage, Ryan,Hurley, Deedee, Keefe, Dunman.
M: Danger, Cripps, Titch, Dusty, Parker, Cog, T Kelly, Spargo, Holman, Barry, Crowden
R: Gawn, Nank, Olongo
F: Buddy, Smith, Sicily, Petracca, Gowers, ZGL, Henry, Guelfi

Can swap Sicily and Keefe meaning that Henry or Guelfi takes the last forward spot and do no trades.
Leaves me with no bench coverage in the midfield or defence. Alternatively, I could trade Crowden to Phillips or Dunam to Ridley/Rice to generate cash for upgrades next week.

I really appreciate any advice/feedback community.

redherringfc

Definitely Crowden to Phillips. Crowden is maxed out and not scoring well. Phillips is on the bubble and will probably keep getting games.

Sc_Wow

You’ll be in trouble if Yeo is a late out

BadgerHoney7

i think a lot of people will be in trouble if yeo is a late out, even if u do have lachie murphy, he doesn't look like hes playing

Rivo

Donut coming if Yeo is a late out. Can’t be avoided.

I have Finlayson, Duman, Murray & Naughton all out.

Only Murray named as an emergency, so trade plan is:

Naughton & Finlayson to Ridley & Lloyd. Would have to field Ridley.

Do we think there’s a sneaky chance Murray might be a late in?

Sc_Wow

The risk of holding your rookies too long. Don’t think there is any chance of Murray being a late in, Collingwood play tomorrow so he wouldn’t of been ommitred if someone was questionable

DavidC

Should have traded Naughton earlier, this is what happens if you leave no cover on a line.

Rivo

Yeah it was a risk with the rooks, just rough luck with 3 def rooks all out this week. DPP swing could have helped but Keefe out also.

Rivo

Yep, just a little odd that Murray still an E which has happened earlier this season. Expect there may be a few exposed in the defence this weekend.

Corey

Who to Downgrade Naughton to?

Harrison

Ridley

Darcy Franks

Is it worth getting like Andrews over Ryan because of bye's

CalebCripps922

What Trades should i go with this week?
Murray- Phillips
Christensen- Buddy
or
Murray- Philips
Coniglio- Macrae

I've decided on trading Cogs to Macrae but just not sure if now or after his bye. Any Help Appreciated community.

ATeam12345

No way would I get in Macrae at that price. 1st option is best.

DavidC

Macrae gets tagged this week by Levi.

Jimmy

Murray or finlayson to tuohey?
We know he’s a vital part of cats defence and scored 120 on the w/e n is under 400k..

Harrison

Murray

Noah

Is Finlayson and Naughton to Ridley and Howe a good trade.

Ja191

yes

BadgerHoney7

yeh, have u already got yeo??

Noah

yea

Ricardo

With the predicted crackdown on Macrae for the rest of the year, I reckon the Bont is a good option. Just my opinion

theRealPod

Yeah I agree Ricardo, he's no Danger or Gaz. He will cop the heat like never before so will be interesting to see how he handles it.

Redpill5

I don’t have macrae so I hope you are right but the crows put Gibson on him and he still racked up 36 touches and 177 points.

DavidSA

So Yeo named on field but is 50/50 more so because it's interstate
Cole and Murphy on extended list and I think has no chance with Hartigan, Gibson, Otten and Milera ahead of him.
Murray, Finlayson, Cumming dropped and Duman not getting a gig probably ever again with Freo players back now.

Rice is a must have next week.

Sam_01

Boys I have a burning question
Should I bring in buddy now given his lovely upcoming run Brisbane saints and Carlton or should I get Tom mitchel
If I go on buddy the only problem is I’ll have to wait till Walters has his bye to grab him or I’ll be stuffed
I guess the question comes down to points
Or bringing in a value premium what’s the better call here
Either way Murray and Tim kelly will have to go this week

Da_Boysh

Mitchell first Buddy after bye, we need to make sure he is ok

Derek

He is on injury watch now.

Plus Andrews will keep him quiet this week

Theoriginalforce

Thoughts on lachie Neale Capt? Fyfe possibly getting tagged and lachie loving playing against norf.

Sam_01

Couldn’t risk either with Jacobs on the prowl

Derek

Walters back will take points away from Neale

The Ranger

Sicily or Yeo?
Gotta take one of them.

Help

Any suggestions? got 17 trades and $193k.

DEF: Laird Yeo slicly Simpson, Doedee, Murray ( naughton, Murphy)

MID: Fyfe Cripps Titch Martin Cogs Crouch T.Kelly Holman (brodie coffield Barry)

RUCK: Gawn Nic nat (Cameron)

FWD: McLean Smith Heeney keefe Fritsch Spargo (Ahern Crowden)

Ricardo

Murray and Kelly have done their jobs. Get rid of them both

Help

any suggestions for who to bring in

Sandyf62

I love the intro

Stupid Coach

I have traded Crowden to Phillips which leaves me with 16 trades. I am tempted to trade T Kelly due to his high BE to either Zerrett or Zorko or should I hold him given until his bye and pull the trigger then.

Also, thoughts on VC – Danger, Cripps or Titch.

Dave

1. Jacobs -> Grundy & Naughton -> ridley/rice (will be coping a zero in the backline still)
2. Murray -> Lloyd & Naughton -> ridley/rice

With jacobs projected to lose another $30k would going to grundy cover the donut ill be coping or just too bad that ive got the big red head? Also, rice over ridley due to job security?

Playing for rank btw

Dave

or instead of naughton i can go T.Kelly -> ridley/rice via DPP before he loses some $, thoughts?

heads up

Panic room round 10 thread is open

r_calve

anyone reckon i should go Murray to crisp as a POD

JIMMY

Nah

Russty_

Harris Andrews is better I reckon.

JIMMY

Gaff or Martin this Week and next week Westhoff or R Gray