add_filter('comment_flood_filter', '__return_false');

PODCAST: THE ROUND THREE RAGE TRADING

Published by Patch on

NOW’S THE TIME, COMMUNITY!

Now is the time to go wild on your Supercoach side. Round three is upon us, a round with price changes, where you can have your wanton way with your underperforming premiums and failed midpricers.

It is The Purge, where all rules are off and all trades are on the table.

Lekdog and Patch, despite a noticable inability to do “quick maffs” on the fly, run through what you need to do this week to ensure your side doesn’t absolutely fall apart.

We spend a lot of time on the rookies you need to nail, as well as discuss players like Hibberd, Rockliff and Dahlhaus you need to flick and the players you need to bring in – if you can.

Strap yourself in and keep your hands and feed inside the cart of all time as we take you on a whirlwind tour of your Supercoach side.

What are your trades this week, community? Who’s facing the wrath of your trigger finger?


Subscribe
Notify of
guest
839 Comments
Oldest
Newest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Super

Stef martin do i trade to grundy

NoLanguage

Hold Stef he's a mountain will come good

liamphillips35

He's not going to be the last ruckman to struggle against Gawn

r_calve

nah stef is a tad inconsestent but isnt playing on gawn every week

Carleton

Do not trade to Grundy. Yes, Grundy had a great game, but that was because Mason Cox was suspended. Cox will be back next game and will halt Brodie's scoring.

Russty_

Maybe not..lol

Rabbits16

11hrs too late to say yes trade grundy in?

nickgonzalez771

I went in with the mindset of being ultra-conservative with trades this season but now I find myself with a very juicy trade possibility which will see Lambert and Naughton shown the door for a more promising rookie in Murphy and getting in Dusty before his price goes north. These are top priorities and I'm still left with 30K so I'm not too doubtful about them but what are your thoughts?

NoLanguage

If you can get Dusty for Lambert do it. I'm pondering the other trade myself, may be a waste of a trade depending on how long you think Murphy will stay in the side

neil demons delight

doing the same go for it

b_sh3p

I am keeping Lambert, I have faith he'll be a keeper long term but can see the temptation.

nickgonzalez771

Definitely, there's no harm in it. I wanted to stick, but the offer was too much to not take in my own opinion. I sincerely hope he turns that workrate into a better SC output.

THE SALTSHAKER

murphy had 6d (32sc) and 10d (80sc) that looks like a bit of plump in that score. He is cheap but a slow burn. Naughton should hold his spot, has played WAFL seniors will adjust. Jong and a few others be under more pressure with Wallis returning.

Get Dusty over Lambert though

VFL

71k salary cap.
C.Rayner (202k) out

Z.Fisher (263k) in.
OR Waterman (123k), Langdon (117k), Gowers (117k) Fogarty (117k), Barry (117k).
And Pocket the cash.
(I have all the other decent rookies FWD and MID)

Derek

Only two types of players, keepers and cash cows. Which one is Fisher?

Sc_Wow

Watch everyone try get fisher in after this podcast

Daniel Z

I haven't listened to the podcast yet, but I feel like a lot of people are jumping on him and Bonner. While they might keep up their scoring and make the required cash generation, I think there is too big a risk they have a bad game or two and they (a) get dropped; and / or (b) stop making money.

I think in the early rounds everyone has this fear of missing out on this year's big players / rookies; combined with not having hit the trade button in months, it can lead to snap decisions that end up hurting long-term.

Tyruddanaut

Fisher has a great spot in our best 22

Tyruddanaut

A combination

fcabel

Like fisher

Luke

Zac Fisher lol

Fabian

I'd go with christensen (267k). He's got a breakeven of -10

Patch

Prefer a rookie over Fisher when push comes to shove. Geelong's Fogerty for mine

BrownlowBoy

Suggestions for trades this week?

Sitting on 30 trades with 107k in the bank.

Laird, Hibberd, Sicily, Doedee, Murray, Finlayson, Naughton, Murphy
Dangerfield, Mitchell, Kelly, Oliver, Fyfe, Brayshaw, Kelly, Holman, Banfield, Barry, Garlett
Gawn, Nank, Olango
Heeney, Billings, Walters, Smith, Taberner, Fritisch, Langdon, Ryan

Suggested trades or any feedback is much appreciated.

NoLanguage

Good side. I'd be inclined to leave it alone and save trades unless you go Naughton to Bonner but I think he's overhyped.

b_sh3p

With Bonner, pittard has to come back in soon which may affect his scoring so I agree.

Sam_01

Naughton is also garbage and has to be flicked

BrownlowBoy

Naughton will earn cash. Just slowly.

Tyruddanaut

Too slowly and will only earn around 50k in total

joe444

Bonner has a breakeven of -41 and is expected to go up in value by over $50k next week.

He may not be in their long-term best 22 post-bye, but I wouldn't call that overrated from a Supercoach perspective.

Patch

Personallt will send him packing by his bye. Elevated cash cow for mine.

Patch

What are your thoughts on Hibberd, BB? Personally would turn him into Heath Shaw or Kade 'The Sleeves' Simpson with that side (which is excellent btw)

BrownlowBoy

Thanks Patch, yes Hibberd is a concern. I did ask about him below on the second page I think. He isn't scoring as well as I would have liked. Could turn him into Simmo.

I also heard that Devon Smith had scans this week? Not sure what for.

NoLanguage

Would love to hear your thoughts on trades or no trades this week guys!

B – Laird, Hibberd, Savage, Doedee, Finlayson, Murray (Naughton, O'Connor)
M – Dusty, Mitchell, Fyfe, Parker, Cripps, Coniglio, Kelly, Holman (LDU, Banfield, Barry)
R – Martin, Gawn (Cameron)
F – Heeney, Walters, Smith, Sicily, Christensen, Fritsch (Venables, Langdon)

Scored 2359 – 30 trades with $20k in the bank. Questions I'm pondering are:

1) Naughton to Murphy and bank $60k?
2) Venables to Ryan?
3) Back in who I've got and save trades?

Any feedback or suggestions hugely appreciated.

Davo

I would leave your side as it is. Back it in and save trades.

Derek

you are looking good

very bold to start Parker, Cripps and Coniglio

b_sh3p

Agree with others to hold you've got a great side. Many trading Hibberd for Simpson but I'm keeping him and unlike last year where I wanted to make 10 trades I'm keeping the faith and doing none this week…. For now! LOL. Venables to Ryan seems too sideways for me but can see the temptation

NoLanguage

Thanks guys. Gut feel was to hold, trades are gonna come in very handy when the inevitable carnage hits.

Daniel Z

I heard Langdon out for a month, so maybe go him to Ryan instead.

NoLanguage

Yep. No brainer

Josh

Got a few issues so not too sure what to prioritise:

Laird, hibberd, savage, doedee, murray, finlayson (naughton, keefe)
Mitchell, crouch, Merrett, Fyfe, Cripps, Parker, kelly, Holman (brayshaw, Barry, banfield)
Kreuzer, Gawn (olango)
Heeney, billings, Maclean, Bell, fritsch, Giles-langdon (Garlett, ryan)

Hibberd, naughton, crouch, Kreuzer and bell are probably the main ones I’m looking to move on, but not too sure what to do

Daniel

Do you have any cash in the bank? If not, dump Bell (you have the forward rookies, so you'll have to sideways (Christensen or Fisher) or upgrade). If you want to upgrade, go Crouch-Coniglio or Kreuzer-Nank (or something similar) and then bring in one of DSmith, Petracca, or CCurnow for F4. Definitely wait to see if Crouch or Kreuzer get up for this week though.

I wouldn't worry about Hibberd (yet) as 2 90's-100's will end his slide.
Naughton can wait – he's not that far off, as long as he keeps getting games (he'll just be a slower burner on your bench).

Josh

78 k in the bank
If crouch and/or Kreuzer are out injured, would it be worth holding either if it will only be a few weeks?

Stirlsy

Crouch said to be 4 weeks Kruz might be another 1 or 2

Daniel Z

That is not good news… is that from the clubs' websites?

At 4 weeks, Crouch should go, Oliver would be almost straight-swap, or could upgrade to Dusty (or d/g to Coniglio if you don't have him).

Kreuz is a tighter call but a groin injury with a big man is troubling as it could hamper him once he is back. What are people's thoughts on replacements? Nank?

NoLanguage

Not Crouch, too much cash sitting on the pine for a month. Maybe a straight swap to Sloane or downgrade him to Coniglio

Paul

Kreuzer will play this week. Will smash Grundy too.

b_sh3p

Agree that Hibberd is too sideways, I have him and he's sure to come good

fcabel

Kreuz, Crouch & Bell. I’d be looking at downgrading Kreuz and upgrading Crouch to Dusty or Danger. Look at Bell next week

SCDemon

Gday Community,

Need some advice

Laird, Hibberd, Bonner, Finlayson, Murray, Doedee (Naughton, Keeffe)
Martin, Mitchell, Kelly, Oliver, Fyfe, Brayshaw, Kelly, Holman (Banfield, Barry Garlett)
Gawn, Naitanui (English)
Heeney, Walters, Petracca, Sicily, Cox, Ryan (Giles-Langdon, Fritsch)

I have seemingly nailed all the 'must-have' rooks', and I am left with a whopping $447k ion the Warchest.
Only made the 1 trade (Ryder to Nic Nat).
My question is how do I best use my bankroll.
Assuming English will suffice as Ruck Cover (is JS ok???), I am weighing up 2 options.

1) downgrade Cox to non playing RUC / FWD to swing with English & upgrade any mid rookie to Dangerfield.

2) downgrade Cox to non playing RUC / FWD & use the $650k ish to pick off 2 cheaper options (Zerrett / Parker types in coming weeks)

I feel the points yield will be greater with option 2, however I want Danger in my side come seasons end. Option 2 needless to say prevents this from happening anytime in the foreseeable future.
Alternatively, open to other suggestions.
(Not sideways trading including Hibberd!)

Thoughts, PLEASE Community?

Cheers

TheScacman

Hard not to see danger in the top 3 players across Supercoach come seasons end, scored a 130 on one leg while playing a fair bit in the forward line. Bring the man in

Derek

if he has the same umpires every week, he will score 130's without any legs.

fcabel

First option. Lock it

TIGESB2B

Dangers BE is 181 this week.

Patch

Demon, I reckon Danger will be cheap enough in four weeks to pick off at 650k if you've got some bank. I'm pro-option two with a cheap Zerrett and then Danger a few extra weeks down the track myself.

Daniel Z

Doubtful you'll see Danger at 650k in four weeks. To drop that much, he'd have to average around 105 for four weeks. Can't see that happening unless he gets injured. More likely you'll be looking at him around 700k.

Jim

O’Mera for Coniglio?

Corey

Yes!

fcabel

Definitely

Jim

Thanks

Fabian

I just made the exact same trade

Northerner

Last year if you had projections on, it would show expected price changes on your players instead of their current price. Anyone know why they've changed it or is there somewhere else it shows up? Thanks

Looking to hold trades as have all the rookies, but one will gnaw at me at week: Lobb to Christensen. Leaning toward getting one more sample size as Lobb's BE is not high and Christensen' price will be held down a little by his first round 60odd. The extra $130k is looking attractive to assist in getting Danger. Thoughts welcome.

Daniel Z

If Lobb and Christensen score at their current averages (78 and 84, respectively), Lobb's price will not change but Christensen goes up around 30k (it jumps by the same amount the week after as well). So if you wait a week, that 130k becomes (probably) 100k.

Northerner

Cheers. That was what I was thinking. And I don't need the cash for a few rounds yet. I think the $30k extra is worth the additional info on both and an extra week of knowing whether you need to cover for injuries or not.

Northerner

BTW. I found the cash detail. It's on the analyser tab under cash cows. Gives you BE and projected price change. I have a projected $975k increase. Only Lobb and Fyfe to drop and both have achievable BEs. Hypothetically, if I traded Lobb for Christensen it'd be over a million!

Plenty of cash around. Let's hope that

Northerner

….rookies emerge for downgrades and we haven't used them all up early.

fcabel

Hold

Rick Grimes

Is Coniglio essential? Gonna make a sweet load of cash and scoring like a premo.

gator59

He's not essential Rick, But if it's cash your after then it could be a good option
Not knowing your structure who are you trading to make this work for you

INPieman

Not essential Rick. Your not picking him as a cash cow at 450. Only if you think he's a top 10 mid. Which he might be

SW Roosters XXX

Pieman has nailed it..
Cogs is not a cash cow – if you are bringing him in for that purpose you are basically committing two trades to him one to get him in and then one to get rid of him….

Appeal of Cogs is – could he potentially be a Top 10 mid? I think he can be very close to the mark. If that is the case getting a premo mid for $450,000 has a lot of appeal and could speed up the process of getting to full premo…….

Derek

If he slots into M6 get him.

fcabel

Get him in

NoLanguage

Get the man in. He's playing like a madman and will be GWS #2 mid behind Kelly IMO. Could easily be a top 10 mid by season's end

Valens_FC

Always scores well when he’s fit. He’s cheap because he gets injured a lot. That’s the risk…. and will hurt more if you traded for him vs started him.

StevoRivo

Naughton & Lambert to Bonner & Gray? Or do I persevere? Also Holding Hibberd at D2 for now. But trades are gold, they are not injured, and I can leave Naughton on bench and hope Lambert comes good?

Crowboy94

Get rid of Lambert. He is struggling a lot

CalebCripps922

I would try and Hold Naughton and Lambert but it is tempting to trade.

StevoRivo

Maybe a hold but Bonner & Gray are tempting!

David C

They both have the crap bye.

fcabel

Like it

Jim_bob321

Hello community,
Should i be making 2 trades… Naughton to Bonner and Brayshaw to Kelly
OR
Just be making the one trade and getting Kelly
Thanks community

Crowboy94

Just trade for Kelly. Leave Naughton on the bench.

INPieman

If you don't have Tim Kelly you trade your family, body parts or whatever to get him in & on field. Best rookie since Barlow

neil demons delight

Forgetting Oliver PIES. finally got the team I should have started with Traded Lambert for Martin . Was reluctant and gave Gator's idea of Petracca a lot of thought and the 14 bye. Now every trade will have to be done with Round 14 in play

Jordan

Thoughts on Tim tarranto (mid/fwd 365k) scores 104, 115.
Thinking of going Rayner to him

Sc_Wow

Think he’s a keeper? Or else you’re using 2 trades on him

TheScacman

I'd go Rayner to Christiansen if you're going to make a trade like that, will save you 100K, and christiansen will be around the mid-high 300K range in about 3 weeks time, which makes him perfect for a downgrade or an upgrade

fcabel

If you think you can keep him it’s a great trade

Crowboy94

Should Lambert be traded? Seems to be struggling a lot.

INPieman

You should never have had him in the first place. If you don't think he's going to be a top 8 Fwd then get rid of him now, I would

Crowboy94

I'm thinking of trading him to Mclean. Seems to be playing a lot of midfield.

Sc_Wow

Shhhh pieman don’t tell them all

INPieman

Deleted now. If they were lucky enough to read it in the 20 minutes it was up then lucky for the viewer

Daniel Z

Now I'm curious just because you deleted it.

TheScacman

Very happy i went with McLean at F3, even though he came at the expense of Curnow, he's well and truly performed for me Pieman

b_sh3p

I am keeping Lambert. He's been racking up the k's in the midfield so he's fit, just needs to find the ball. Time will tell but holding him and Hibberd to ride out the storm

Kyle

What are your thoughts on Merrett and Zorko boys? Considering bringing Oliver and Cripps for both of them since they’ll drop in price a lot. Cheers

Sc_Wow

Why does it matter if they drop in price? If you never sell them their price is irrelevant

TheScacman

If you can bring in that cash before they lose value, it becomes valuable in terms of upgrading other players. Given Cripps is scoring like a midfield Premo at a reduced price, that 70K you get by bringing him in for Zorko means that it can go elsewhere on the field

Sc_Wow

I think that trade is worth more than 70k. You’ve got to back your premos in. Sideways trading all year will leave you with no trades left by the byes. If you’re rookies are set you should have no issue making cash.

Starky

I’m really keen on the communities advice.
At the beginning of the season I decided that I would trade Dangerfield down to Josh Kelly and keep the money to bring him back when he showed his fitness. To be honest, I didn’t think it would be this quick but I’m content to lose a trade.
As a result I’ll trade back up this week and then trade Lever down to Bonner. Would anybody keep Lever in my position?
Bonner at the moment looks like he’ll score more points this season and would be a good stepping stone.
I have used 0 trades and have all the scoring rookies

neil demons delight

Danger wont go up yet and then not much To be honest as great a pick up as he was for the dees he is pretty much irrelevant for S C

neil demons delight

THATS LEVER being irrelevant

INPieman

If you didn't start Danger, you wait. Despite his 130 he has a BE of 181. And that's because the algorithm used on starting price of previous years AV times 5.5 drops in round 3. I think it drop to 5.1. So unless a player significantly out performs last years Av they will fall in price. It's inevitable

Wedge

Say if danger was to score another 130 in Rd 3 what would his b/e become the following week? Trying to decide if it's worth waiting for his price drop.

Daniel Z

Pieman's right, the premiums almost always drop (a bit) in price as the rookies start to take more of the overall pie (sorry, I couldn't resist). If Danger puts up two more 130's, he will drop around $20k; continuing with that scoring until round 6 sees him level off just under $700k.

Starky

Thanks guys

BoltonsBlues

If you consider Naughton your only problem and can get Bonner, is it worth doing?

TheScacman

Absolutely. Rookies are there for cash generation, and Naughton isn't going to end up beyond around 200ish come season end if he pumps out scores like this, whereas Bonner is the perfect stepping stone to a premium, or even a D5-6 come season's end

Derek

do the maths. Bonner won’t make much more than Naughton.

What do you think they will both score over the next 5 weeks?

Give me some numbers and I’ll do the maths for you.

TheScacman

Bonner with a breakeven of -44, will score mid 70s at lowest you'd think given his role, which should see him score between 350-400 over the next 5 weeks conservatively. Bonner to make 100K in the next 3-4 weeks, with around 120-140 over the next 5. That has him just short of 400K (probably around 380k mark)

Naughton to score 40 points a week, bringing him to 200 over the next 5 weeks. wouldnt even make you 50K on those numbers, bringing him up to 210K

Bonner is the running defender in a team that sees a reasonable amount of the ball, and will average around 20 odd touches a game, with a high kick/handball ratio which makes him hugely SC relevant (kicks, rebounds from 50, running bounces)

Naughton is a young key back in a team with little defensive structure who are getting belted. Naughton not having the intercept role that he was potentially earmarked for preseason by the SC community (low disposal tally, poor defensive numbers)

Pitch72

Top wright up Scacman, totally agree, if you can get Bonner in do it, Naughton is a slow burner and a bad one at that, could use Bonner as a stepping stone before rd 14 anyways if his form drops of.

Ryan

Trade or keep Hibberd?

FranklinShow

Hold, you are likely to trade to another premium backman who has a few ordinary weeks and Hibberd scores well. Give him a month at least then if still under performing look to move on.

Disco

Disagree, he is playing a different role with Lewis and Lever in the backline, not taking kick-in which stops his link ups, and not playing the QB role he did last year and with Bombers. Unless this changes fast you're only going to be able to make a sideways trade to a mid $400k Def. Hurley/simpson playing better scoring roles currently.

ToneStar

Keep. Seasons end, you’ll be happy having that trade there.

Derek

Must hold

b_sh3p

I am keeping him although trade to Simpson is tempting… Short term!

Stirlsy

Messing it up but gotta keep him ATM his going to leak cash but ya have to back ya premo's in for more then 2 weeks…… The temptation to trade is high tho very high.

FranklinShow

Started with armitage and cyril (i know mid price madness) but took a punt. Both have failed. I dont have Liam Ryan or Bonner. So was thinking following:

Rioli to L Ryan.
Armo to Bonner via Finlayson.

Thoughts??

TheScacman

big yes for both, other option is to go Armo to Coniglio

Derek

I’m glad someone started with Cyril. I’d love to say hold him, he hasn’t played for a long time, missed a lot of pre season, hawks have a really great run of games after Richmond, but he not making money and he not a keeper.

FranklinShow

Massive hawks man and got Rolls with my blinkers on thinking he would produce what he has always produced. Love him as a player but not sure he is SC relevant anymore.

Scacman – Already have cogs, Armo looks like he will avg around the 80 mark which means only a 50-$100k increase which isnt worth it when I could have bonner who could go up $200k in the next 3 weeks.

Done & Dustied

I am looking at trading Crouch to Cripps and Cameron Raynor to Justin Westoff, Westoff is scoring well and appears to be taking on more of the ruck duties with Ryder out for a while. Talk me out of it please.

r_calve

if your looking for a forward option go for toby McLean, he is playing more midfield and is cheaper than Westhoff

David C

Plus Westy has the crap early bye.

fcabel

I like the trade idea. Not sure on Westy. I’d go another fwd promo. If you feel him though why not

Cam

What's everyone's opinions on brayshaw (freo), will he slowly get used to the standard or stay the same?

I have most rooks apart from: L.Ryan, Bonner, L.Fogarty

I don't think Ryan is a must get so will leave him, but from what I saw of naughton he just isn't cut out for it.

So am trading naughton to Bonner. Is it worth the trade?

Da Boysh

i won't be,

He will make cash eventually I dont need him on field.. wont be wasting that trade.

Derek

Bradshaw can play.

He kicked a 50m pass laces out across his body at full pace yesterday (not sure who to). I thought of Patch who would have said “he is good at the kicking thing”

David C

No

On the ball

Peoples thoughts on Westhoff?

INPieman

Trap

fcabel

Think he has 4 weeks of great scoring left in him

TheScacman

Thinking of trading Hibberd down to Bonner as both a cash grab, and that Bonner is scoring around the same rate in the same role, and using the money to upgrade Jack Graham to Coniglio, thoughts community???

r_calve

get coniglio, no matter what, he will end up scoring in the 105- 110 average

Hegs

I've made the Hibb to Bonner trade and banking the cash to grab Danger in a few weeks. Long term play but I'm scarred from Shaw last year.

r_calve

what does everyone think about Taranto, is he a good option and should i downgrade zorko or merret to someone like whitfeild or gibbbs

David C

Keep Zorko and Merrett. I like Taranto, attending center bounces and good JS now Scully has gone down. Good POD.

Ja191

Whitfield is an interesting one, without big last quarters in the last 2 weeks he could have been looking at 70-80. Hope he can maintain a 105-110 average

fcabel

I’d hold z man

Steeeve

What is my best option in your opinion?

1. Hold Naughton and Andrew Brayshaw
2. Brayshaw down to a cheaper rookie and Naughton up to Bonner

I have most of the good rookies already. Don't have Waterman, Venables, O'Connor, L Fogarty… worth bringing them in so I can upgrade Naughton? And if Naughton keeps averaging about 50 from here on how much cash should he make?

r_calve

hold, Brayshaw he has only had 60% gamnetim ein both the games, if that gets up which it should, then his scores will

b_sh3p

Wasted trades for me

MRmoMAN

Well im trading out merret cos idgaf 🙂

David C

I might get him cheap in a couple of weeks.

fcabel

I like your style and attitude

Derek

I don’t have Naughton, but I say hold him. His 25 first round score will be gone next week so even if he scores 50’s and 60’s he will make you $100k.

I think he will improve. Already had a better game this week, did a few good things and his JS is good. He was even thrown forward for a bit on Saturday. You just need one good score from him to make good coin. The dogs draw is good for the next 6 weeks, 5 home games!

Bonnars big first round score will be gone next week, so his BE might be pretty high next week once the first round drops out. Might not be the cash cow people think by looking at his BE now. He is a very high priced rookie and I can’t see him giving a very good ROI. He was lucky to get over 70. If he continues with 70’s you will make a bit more cash than Naughton but not worth a trade.

If you have Bonnar, you will feel as though you need to play him, where you can just park Naughton on bench and let him slow burn.

Liam Jones

Agree completely hear derek

TRIGGA_HAPPY

Yep gonna hold onto naughton as JS is good slow burn on the bench.

Started bonner as i wanted a D3 who could score 75 plus each week.
Think bonner more than capable of this. Port look for him out of defence.
Laser kick.
Reckon he can score this most weeks with the odd big one.
As for bringing him be a solid pick but not sure i would move heaven and earth to bring him in

SCdonkey

Like your thinking Derek, will hold on Naughton. My gut and head tells me to move Hibbo on, somewhere in the back of my mind says one more week.

I have $219K in the bank, not sure if I should upgrade Cox now or wait a bit for him to increase some cash and then get Kreuzer when he drops in price.

I was originally gonna do Hibbo for Simmo and Cox for Witts this week. What do ya think mate?

Should I do
Simmo and Witts
Or
Just Witts this week and Cox out
Or
Wait for Kreuzer and hold all trades this week.

Defying_Madness

It would be easier for me to hold onto him if I could just bench him however Naughton or Murphy have to be fielded as my D6 which is kind of worrying

BVB21

Agree with Bonner. Have been saying the same thing about him. Lots of people going to regret it if he pumps out 70’s each week

Da Boysh

Hi All,

I have the gold pass but when I press projections on my PC it only tells me the BE, not the actual cash movement.. any ideas?

Thanks

David C

Click on analyser and then cash cows.

Da Boysh

usually it tells me on the team page.. it does it on my mobile

flying mullet

Crouch for Dusty or mitchell???

Da Boysh

I like Titch personally. I like hawthorns chances after their game yesterday. Although Dusty has been consistent end of last year and this year he does know how to go missing.

flying mullet

should i give hibberd the flick for simpson????

Derek

it might just be the one who suites your bye rounds better

johnno2908

You want both sooner rather than later, but I would lean Mitchell first.

Mitchell had 40 touches and 2 goals against a Geelong side who put a fair bit of work into him early, scoring 148 points against Ablett, Danger and Selwood, maybe even chuck Kelly in there.

Apart from Dusty and Nank, Richmond players haven’t turned up in the first 2 games. There’s 3300 points that go out in a game no matter what, and Richmond only got 1388 of them, so I think that’s a big reason Dusty scored 160 from 25 touches and 5 goals. Richmond have to turn up eventually you would think.

Da Boysh

Big call here,

Merrett to Coniglio,

Will give me enough cash to turn O'Meara into a Dangerfield after one goes up and one goes down..

I am doing this because Merrett is going to burn me 70k if I hold him this week, Coniglio seems like a must have. And it means I can grab Danger.. surely this isn't that stupid. Someone convince me otherwise 🙂

SW Roosters XXX

Why trade Merrett? HIs price is irrelevant, you included him as a season long keeper??
What is reasoning behind Cogs being a must have – do you see him as a Top 10 Mid at seasons end? If yes then he is outstanding value..

If not you are essentially just burning trades – getting a rid of a premium mid for Cogs and then potentially needing to trade Cogs back up to a premium mid later in the year??

Only get 30 trades!!!

Da Boysh

thank you, i think thats what I needed

NoLanguage

Hold Merrett. Trade JOM to Cogs.

fcabel

Try and find another way to get cogs in

Da Boysh

im going to go O'Meara to Coniglio, it means i wont have enough for Danger but oh well

jvm

Coniglio will have a higher average than Merrett by season end. and dangerfield upgrade is a must…good trade.

Johno

Season Average is irrelevant now. The only important thing is average from this round onwards. Of course Merrett's average will be lower because he's had a 17 but from this point forward I think Merrett will outscore Coniglio.

Milos

Hello community,
Armitage to Coniglio before price rise?

Da Boysh

yes

Derek

could be your best trade of the year

fcabel

Hell yeah

Stirlsy

Easy call

KSinny

100%

SCdonkey

I must be out my head of getting rid Hibbo for Simmo. I just don't want to make the same mistake as i did last year with Shaw. I held Shaw most of the season last year thinking yep he'll come good and will get his role back.

Hibbo(Shaw 2.0) Seemed to have lost his role like Shaw did last year. I struggled to find a way to get Doc his price just kept getting higher and higher, by the time season ended. Still had no Doc<img draggable="false" class="emoji" alt="😓" src="https://s.w.org/images/core/emoji/2.4/svg/1f613.svg"&gt;

I know it's only round 2, i have used 4 trades so far and maybe one more next week. Will set back for a while after the trade next week until all the rookies are ready for culling at around Rd 5 or 6 barring any injuries will have 25 trades until then.

INPieman

If your going to burn through those trades make sure you look back at them at the end of the season. And what you will find is the sideways trades will have proved pointless. Hold your nerve

SCdonkey

Looking back at last weeks trade, if that's pointless. Then I must be doing it wrong, Ryder to Curnow and Rocky to Danger.

fcabel

Wish I’d gone rocky to bloody anyone last week?

fcabel

I’m a fan of using 4 trades early to correct team if required. I also think Hibberd to Simmo is an upgrade so like it. Not a fan of Hibberd which may make me a poor source of advice.

SCdonkey

That's what i was thinking before the season started, 1st two or three rounds will do corrective on premos and rookies who i didn't start with.

Luckily I started with all the must have rookies this year, had Ryder who got injured had to move him on. Corrective trade has to be made, the likes of underperforming premos or change of roles.

I'm happy sit back for a few weeks after doing some corrections in my team this week. Unless injuries occurs.

neil demons delight

I agree with you Doncs. Those two trades were must do's but Hibberd is all Australian who scored 40 in a qtr. keep him. Ryder to Curnow is a wise trade as is Rocky to Danger GOOD TRADES.but not Hibberd. Trades should be preserved but those are dead set corrective trades. I TRADED Corey ELLIS and LAMBERT FOR DUSTY and Murphy 2 corrective trades my teams better good luck doncs go with your heart then sit back

Marty

Too early after two rounds to wipe out Hibberd

Phildev

My thoughts exactly. Shaw never came good and trading him gets me Danger. Anyway you can get Danger in is not burning trades

Patch

Would concur on moving him on but four trades down by round 3 is a lot of trades down. Pull the trigger if you back yourself to bunker down and conserve trades until we begin culling rooks

SCdonkey

That's the plan Patch do my corrective trades now and sit back watch my rookies fatten up until Round 5 or 6.

If I go with
Hibbo – Simmo
Cox – Witts
This week, will have 26 trades left until the Rookies are ready for culling, barring any injuries by Rd 5 or 6.

This is my team after the trades, will conserve trades after this week.

Back
Laird, Simmo, Doedee, Finalyson, Naughton, Murray
Murphy, Mihocek

Mid
Danger, Titch, Oliver, Kelly
Fyfe, Cripps, Kelly, Holman
O'Connor, Banfield, Garlett

Ruck
Witts, Gawn
English

Fwd
Heeney, McLean, Smith, Taylor, Curnow, Fritsch
Langdon, Ryan

TheScacman

Do I trade Crouch to Dusty given Crouch has done a hammy as is going to miss serious weeks, or do I take Coniglio? Would have a bank of 234K for future weeks and the future bank of Coniglio or a genuine top 3 mid lock…..

Soothsayer

I have pulled the trigger on crouch to dusty and paid for it by downsizing Dow (195k) to TKelly which will make big bucks next week. Crouch will bleed cash on return and can be picked up after his recovery nice and cheap.

BVB21

Only pick cogs if you think he is top 8 mid

Luke

I have hibberd and Merrett and ranked about 40k usually finish top 1000 and thinking of going Merrett to coniglio to free up some cash ready for early upgrade to try make up for lost ground I alReady have all the correct rookies and feel like coniglio will be a keeper or average 5-10 less then Merrett

Hibberd I will keep as I feel all defenders have a rough patch and drop in price and he will bounce back!

Thoughts guys

Harry

Should I swap Crouch to Oliver?

or downgrade to Parker / Cripps and bank the 60k

Soothsayer

Oliver is a great trade, if I couldn’t afford dusty I would have gone crouch to Oliver.

Ja191

Refraining from going hibberd to simmo but is O’meara to conigs worth a trade? Don’t see yaeger averaging over 80 and conigs looks like a must have

Derek

do you have the cash to do the trade? is JOM your M6 or M5?

Ja191

Currently m6 doing the trade will leave me with 117k in the kitty

KSinny

I have 30 Trades left and 32.7k in the Bank.. Should i do any trades this week? 

DEF: Laird, Hibbo, Sicily, Finlayson, Doedee, Murphy (Naughton, Murray) 

MID: Dusty, Titch, Kelly, Zerrett, Fyfe, Cripps, T.Kelly, Holeman (Brayshaw, Banfield, Garlett) 

RUC: Gawn, Nank (Olango) 

FWD: Heeney, Billings, Smith, Tracca, Langdon, Fritsch, (Keefe, Venables) 

Would love some feedback and advice. Cheers community!

BVB21

Langdon out for 4 weeks.

I wouldn’t trade him but u can’t play Venables for 4 weeks

Nige

I’m keeping Langdon and using him as my only loophole.

GAZ

Downgrade Zorko to Congilio or Parker or Cripps or trust Zorko to go back up and score or is the tag too much for him

Naughton to who ??

luke

Hold zorko

Simo

Gday Community. I have the spare cash to turn Naughton into Bonner. Hold fire, or pull the trigger?

cheers

Northerner

Pull the trigger

Shukes

Definitely pull the trigger. Bonner is a must have

Maverick_

have you got doedee murphy Murray and finlayson Down back already simo?

John

Thoughts on trading Mccartin to Christensen?

Sir Alex

Yes good move, depeding if you have all other fwd rookies at lower end of scale.

Dice

Didn't watch Carlton game but does Kade Simpson clearly have his old role back??
Any info appreciated..

Northerner

Looks like it. He's such a good user. He scores every possie he gets

hedski

I have English F6 and Flynn (r/f loophole) at R3.
Thoughts on parking English at R3 and trading Flynn to Ryan. (W.C.)?
I'm not expecting him to score like he did on the weekend all the time but looks to have good js and will be an extra cash generator which will be handy.

Derek

gee English look way off AFL level on the weekend. he might be your loophole soon.

hedski

Yeah he was ordinary Derek, that's the thinking behind bringing in another money maker.

Northerner

That's what I'm doing. Think Ryan's cash generation is required. I'm happy to lose the loophole for a couple of weeks for the extra cash.

hedski

Cheers Northerner, now I have Crouch to worry about.

Northerner

Clarry is a legend. Always gets positive scaling at the end of each game as all contested. Never has a shocker.

Stirlsy

English wont be in team for long, 2 big guys to return his days are numbered.
Kid is simply not ready needs another 2 years on the weights and to grow into his body.

Patch

Don't mind an extra cash generator hedski – cash is king, as they say

Liam

Should I trade Garlett to Ryan.

Ryan could make some quick cash due to that 115.

luke

Not worth a trade in my opinion

Da Boysh

i wouldnt waste the trade personally, i am bringing in Ryan but only because I am downgrading a mid price

fcabel

No

Ado

Nup not worth it

Luke

Traded crouch to D Martin, Lambert to Z Fisher, 400 k war chest plan on bringing in Danger over the next few weeks for a rookie, thoughts?? Current rank around 20,000 averaging 2,200 so far..

Northerner

Solid trades.

Darcy Franks

I understand Lambert isn't performing but FIsher is anything but a safe option, he average mid 40's last year can you expect him to hold his average where it is now

luke

i plan on making 100 to 200 k and use as stepping stone.. thoughts?? this allows me a 400 k war chest

Sc_Wow

You’ll spend 2 trades on fisher, seems silly to me

Darcy Franks

What do I with Tom Rockliff, projected 77 and if he hits that he loses 75k. I wanna get rid of him but don't want to burn a useless trade.

luke

Must trade doesnt look the same as he was @ brisbane,

Matt

If you you want to keep getting sub 50 scores keep him haha, if not trade to Parker or coniglio

Darcy Franks

Got coniglio but already have a lot of people in the sydney bye round do I still get parker or go to like a wines or someone

TRIGGA_HAPPY

I reckon he has gotta go.
I watched the game he was unsighted till after half time.
Cripps, parker,,whitfield, selwood all much better options for about the same price.
Or if u have cash go up to one of the big boyz
Clarey be a good pick.

Darcy Franks

I want parker but already have a lot of people in that bye round what do you reckon

ProTravo

Hold my trades or pull the trigger?

Considering JOM to Cripps/Gibbs & Hibberd to Bonner…