CHARLIE CURNOW – 2018 Supercoach Spotlight

Published by Lekdog on

Charlie Curnow has been spoken about as a breakout contender since the second Supercoach closed in 2017.

Blues fans think he’s ready to become the next Anthony Koutoufides but I believe that a more apt comparison would be with Lance ‘Buddy’ Franklin.

Before you jump into the comments and tell me I’m an idiot, I’m not suggesting that Curnow will kick 100 goals in a season and win countless goal kicking awards. I do think that he could replicate that Supercoach career of Buddy Franklin.

In his first season, Buddy averaged 59.4 Supercoach points per game, in year two this moved to 63 and in his third year he broke out with an average of 91.3 across 20 games.

In Curnow’s first season he averaged 49.2 Supercoach points, this jumped to 74.2 in his second year and based on the second half of 2017, could jump well past 90 in season three.

Whilst Supercoach scoring has drastically changed since Buddy’s second year in 2006 (the only way to break the ton was basically kicking six or more goals), his jump in average related to his movement up the ground and an ability to rack up possessions outside of the goal square…although he was still pretty good playing deep forward.

In 2018, Curnow is set for a move up the ground and *touches all the wood* should make more of an impact on the scoreboard when he plays forward. His ability to impact around the ground as well as in front of goals (rightly or wrongly) reminds me of a young and majestic Buddy.


2018 facts $408,100 FWD
2017 games 21
2017 average 74.2
2017 100+ scores 4
2017 sub-80 scores 14
2017 highs and lows High of 122, low of 37

In 2017, Curnow averaged 92.7 Supercoach points per game from Round 14 onward.

In his last 8 games Curnow averaged 90.6 Supercoach points with 15 disposals per game, 7.7 contested possessions, 2.8 tackles and 1.3 goals. These numbers are all above average for forwards his age and he achieved them it in just 77% game time.

It’s pretty safe to assume the Curnow’s tank will have improved in the off-season and that he’ll being seeing some more game time throughout 2018.


Curnow showed some really positive signs in 2017 and he’s going to be a big part of Carlton’s future moving forward.

He has shown an ability to score above 90 Supercoach points on a somewhat consistent basis and in a year of poor forward options this could be priceless. In particular his tackles, contested possessions and marks excite me.

Carlton has indicated that they want Curnow to play through the midfield when Cripps is playing up forward. I don’t know if that’s good for the Blues but it’ll probably be good for our Supercoach sides…I hope.


There’s every chance that giving up F2-3 for a breakout candidate who has only played 27 games and will be in a poor side could blow up in your face.

Curnow has the scope to post some less than desirable scores as a forward target, if Carlton decide he’s the man to use as a permanent forward we’ll be in trouble.


I think that if you lined up all the breakout contenders for 2018, Curnow would be the one who fills you with the least dread.

He has everything laid out before him to become a prolific Supercoach scorer for many years to come. In 2018 he has an opportunity to play around the ground, kick goals, lead Carlton’s attack, improve upon his tank and combine his attacking instincts with his defensive pressure to become a complete player.

An average of 92.7 across his last ten games in 2017 is enough for me to lock him in. His low price tag, his potential and a lack of other forward options are just an added incentive.

I’d love to hear what you all think but before you ask, yes my Carlton bias might be getting in the way and yes I’ll be backing him to the hilt.

Let me know community, are you picking Curnow?


Follow Lekdog on Twitter @Lekblog

Notify of
Newest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments

In my team at F3


Not for me old china, but a curious watchlist candidate. Likely output depends on the blues form and while they will be better, will they be "that" good?

Dubious proposition for rd 1, mid season target maybe.


How many games did Carlton win when he was averaging 90+ late last year?


Have just taken all safety out of ny team and added Curnow. And Coniglio. And JOM. And heater Shaw. And Petracca. Wooooo preseason


Like him a lot Lek, but have a preference for
Mid- Fwds at F1-3 for now. So for now Petraca just ahead at F3.


I've had him and Petracca as F2 and F3 for most of the preseason but seemed a bit thin, I've taken Tracca as F3 now, DPP and more mid time has him ahead of Charlie atm. Could still make his way back into my side yet.


Did Cripps play in the last 8 games of the season were Curnow averaged 90? If not then would Cripps steal his points?

David C

Gibbs out and Cripps in, should cancel each other out.


Docherty out too. That's a lot of points for someone to take


I understand the selection of Curnow, but I haven't had him in any of my preseason drafts so far and I can't see that changing. Devon Smith for 30k more is a more solid option imo and I'm even playing with the idea of Mitch Robinson from Brisbane at 406k at the moment. Still very early days, Charlie will be on the watchlist come JLT.


I think I've got some bias towards Curnow, come to think about it. I remember hopping in the car after a game in under 16s against Torquay and Dad told I had played against Ed Curnow's brother and that he played really well. I didn't see him get a touch and couldn't understand the fuss about him. 3 years later he gets drafted to Carlton and at the time I had no idea why. To his credit, his back half of last year proved he more than belonged at the top level.

The more that time passes, the more I'm warming even more to Mitch Robinson. I reckon he'll get more midfield time this year and that will boost his average for a guy who loves a tackle and a contested possie. It will also lower the amount of 60s-70s he tended to pump out when he was restricted to playing more of a forward role. And when he does go forward, he still does a bit with his goals and tackles etc. Currently sitting at F3 behind Smith and Heeney.

psycho Muppet

You also need to take into consideration his brother Ed curnow who was out for a lot of last season too….. curnow took some of his points. I like Charlie but I am not sure of him increasing his input and as a mid priced aaround 400k, he is risk v reward.


On the flip side some of docs points have got to go to someone


Not for me this year, Lek. Buddy comparison is nice, that 10 game stretch he was good one week, poor the next. His TOG% is already low 80’s, so any bump in scoring will be from greater consistency rather than an increased role.

He’ll still play predominately forward you’d think. A consistent KPP? Nah


Hey mate good to see u up and about.
The last 10 games.
92, 83, 118, 76, 112, 97, 64, 122, 102, 61.
If u take out the last game where he was probably cooked and a bit banged up after a long season its only 1 bad score in the 10 games.

I reckon i would take that from a fwd this year. 👌


that, and we got flogged by Sydney


Would take some serious testicular fortitude to pick him.


Walters or Tracca?




Currently at F2 I'm willing to go thin at the forward line at this stage


Ive had him in my team since day dot locked in at F4.

Decent old analyis too. Be crazy good if he pulled a buddy.


Leo, would you take Charlie over Sicily?


Lek I mean, six.


Not Lek or Leo but a big yes from me.


I am going Sicily


I've got Lobb in F3 at the moment but since he's under a cloud as to whether he'll play Rd 1 i think Curnow is probably a decent back up option. BTW I need to mention that i was a fellow victim in the burns ward due to Tex. In my defence I had just watched him tear my Bombers a new one and may have put him in whilst suffering PTSD.


Mate you're not paying for it so stop whingeing


Rubbish has always been free Pieman what's your point?


Laird, Brayshaw(Freo) Curnow
Ellis, Cripps, Forward Rookie


Number one


Bit harsh


Disappointed the linked article didn’t end with a whole bunch of heart emojis tbh

He averaged less than half a tackle more if you split his season (first 11 v final 10) 2.8 v 3.2. Hardly relevant.

sc tragic

I currently have him at F4, shallow pickings for forwards this year. Sometimes you have to risk it for the biscuit. Will continue to monitor in JLT.


Dermott Brereton, quoted on SEN radio, that Curnow will be the AFLs best player. Attached is a link to this

Craig Nugent

And Dermott thought Trent Mckenzie was the best player out of that particular draft. I don't mind Dermott but he is no better than the rest of us when it comes to picking young talent


thanks for adding the link !!!


In my team. Absolute lock based on his later half of his season and take out the game against Sydney where we got flogged then he averaged mid to high 90's.. Should score very well.


No need to be so rude


I have Lobb as my F4 as we all know the number one ruck he will score well and probably constantly however if he is not going to start
round one i will need to make a change.The way i look at it is there is three contenders which i will be keeping a eye on in the JLT Curnow,Stringer and Jake Melksham. Stringer may go well in Ess Mid field and Melksham well i watched all the games on tv and he is the fittests footballer i saw from Thury and fridy nights games. I know it is different footy but he is fit. So for me it's a wait and see over the next few weeks with the JLT if Lobb is not fit for round one.


Not the worst mid pricer. I didn't get angry reading this review. Which is unlike me. Looks like he's heading towards being a beast of a player. Is he a reliable SC option. Probably not yet. In the 250-500k options I personally have quite a few ahead of him. At a similar price & with DPP I'd role the dice with Sicily ahead of the Kouta the 2nd

neil Demons Delight

much prefer Mclean or petracca both similarly priced.


He wasn't bagging anyone out, he was expressing his point of view..sounds like you're bagging him out about that.


I'd rather my nans left nut sack then that useless prick Curnow. Way tooo expensive for what he is, especially with cheaper options who are superior available.

Trevor Rubbish

For Christ's sake nan! Would you put your left nut sack away, we are trying to eat dinner!


Great POD with potential

Big NO from me though – I would prefer Christensen in the team – cheaper