add_filter('comment_flood_filter', '__return_false');

Round 21 Supercoach Panic Room

Published by Patch on


HAhA HahAHA HahA hA Ha hAha HAH Aha HA hA Ha hA HA Ha hA hA Hah Aha HA HA ha hA HA ha HA hA HahA HA Hah AhA Ha hA
ha HA HA ha HA hA Ha hA HA Hah AhA Hah Ah aH AH Ah  aHh AHa haH Ah A




*deep breath*











We’ve been given the finger this week by the Supercoach gods. If you scored a week off this week, you’ve missed something shocking. Something astronomical. I’m not one to exaggerate but this may be the single worst thing to have ever happened in the history of literally everything

Hey you know how the midfield was a thing? NOT ANYMORE, BITCH. Joel Selwood is done for the home and away season. He’s gone. Kaput. Done. Gary Ablett may as bloody well be kaput for all the football he’s playing. Which, for those playing along at home, is practically none.

The tribunal, in the midst of having an absolute mare of a week, decided to suspend Zach Merrett for a week because they hate you. They also suspended Mitch Duncan for the softest thing I’ve seen on a football field since Lance Whitnall’s stomach wobbled out. Disgraceful.

Sydney captain Josh P. Kennedy won’t return. He’s still injured. He also hates you. Sam Powell-Pepper has been rested (cheers Lazza for picking me up on that)

So good thing you have Alex Witherden as cover, eh? WRONG. He’s done a hamstring. He’s out, which makes him as useless as a one-legged man in an arse kicking contest, which coincidentally is what Brisbane vs Gold Coast will be for Lions players.

Perpetual 2017 disappointment (aside from that one game just after everyone traded him out) Tom J Lynch has had his season ended with a PCL and good bloody riddance. Or he would be IF WE HAD ANY TRADES LEFT. He’ll join Jarrod Witts on the sidelines, who has been confirmed to miss the rest of the season because reasons. I’m too angry and disappointed and hurt to even check any more.

There’s still no sign of Jeremy Cameron, which is concerning for those unfortunate souls who brought him in at my recommendation.

Nick Riewoldt headbutted some dude to win a game of football, which would be admirable if he hadn’t concussed himself and caused himself to miss this week, but considering it’s Supercoach finals and he scored 3 points for it instead of the required 25 for kicking the winning goal it’s not good enough.

Speaking of being angry and disappointed and hurt: the tribunal did some more nasty things by suspending several people’s entire ruck lines. Brodie Grundy executed “the perfect tackle”, before getting a holding the ball free kick and a subsequent two-week ban. Shane Mumford also ran through a big, bearded bloke, but instead of letting him do his thing (as they’ve done several times this year) the Tribunal decided they now hate us and everything we stand for, so they suspended him for a week.

Then the Tomahawk grabbed some jumper and LA DI DA that’s now a two week sentence to the gulag two weeks of running laps in Geelong.

Shout out to Collingwood for being even more annoying than usual, naming Josh Daicos on a bench, which means they’re either not going to play him and troll everybody by playing Blair and Maynard ahead of not only every male and female player on their list, every netballer on their list and all the support staff, including Gary from accounting, who at 42 is likely to play more of a role in Collingwood’s next premiership than either of those two. The other option is him playing, which will ruin his 2018 price. But what do I care, I don’t even like Collingwood?

It’s been a long week month year.

Jarrod Berry and Pearce Hanley have both been withdrawn from the Q-Clash.

Fortunately there’s good news! Perma captain and Our Lord And Saviour Patrick Dangerfield returns, unless of course you traded him out last week. In which case you’re stuffed. RIP you.

The Chad is back, as is Matt Priddis, Luke Hodge and Sean Darcy. But that’s it. By way of consolation, it’s like throwing a few peas at a starving man. And by gum are we starving.


The patch up is a bit useless this week. I mean, how can you patch up this week’s carnage?

It’s like turning up to a raging inferno with one of those itty bitty water pistols. And the water pistol is filled with petroleum distillate.

I’ve prepared a list of how to deal with this mess.

Step 1.

Cry. Let it all out. It’s okay, it’s healthy.


Step 2. Gorge yourself on your Everything Will Be Okay food.

This step is not healthy, unless celery is your guilty food you eat at 1am after finishing The Notebook for the first time, wrapped in several blankets, in the midst of a mid-life crisis. Chocolate is my go-to, but ice cream also works well for this.

Step 3. Believe in yourself.

Jock has the tonic. Strap yourself in to this. Listen to the podcast again. Breathe. You can do this.

Step 4. Open your Supercoach Side

Realise you can’t do this, and all hope is lost and that your guilty food is in fact donuts because you’re currently having them rain down in front of your eyes and EVERYTHING IS TERRIBLE.


Step 5. Repeat steps 1&2

At least until making a panicked decision three minutes before lockout and regretting it.

Step 6. Pick your Draftstars team instead


What a segue. You’re a professional, Patchola. Pity you’re not a professional Fantasy Footballer, but hey, one day.

* note from ed.. there’s a juicy $400 layed on to of the $2 Graduates contest this week. VERY good week to get cracking! See below.

Obviously pending Sunday teams, here I am for the North Melbourne vs Hawthorn clash on Sunday, or the Tassie Clash (apparently?). Tom Mitchell is undoubtedly a lock – starting without him puts you 130 points behind the eight ball.

Shaun Higgins should push into the midfield, and if he can kick straight should be good value. I’m backing in North’s young midfield guns in Ryan Clarke and Declan Mountford, partially because I need to afford Titch.

The ruck battle will be interesting, but I’ve gone with Ben McEvoy due to Norf’s insistence on playing two rucks. Goldstein and Pruess will duke it out for ruck minutes, and despite Big Boy’s bad record against North, he gets the nod.

Who are you looking at, community?


Draftstars Buy In

MASSIVE prize pool in the $2 buy-in graduates contest this week – Enter Here.

Enter the Academy contest here



Oh god I’m about to start manically laughing again. What a mess this has been in 2017. So much for ‘set and forget’. Five ruckmen have played every game this year, with one of those being Jackson Trengove, who isn’t really Supercoach relevant.

Brodie Grundy has been a very good pick, or at least he was until he accidentally buried Ben Brown’s head in Etihad’s grass. Stefan Martin has had a few very poor periods when he’s had to play alongside Archie Smith, while Sam Jacobs has rewarded the 5% of coaches with him. Big Boy has been… alright. At least since I traded him in.

Everyone else has been middling average, and it begs the question of what we should do about it next year – I feel like I’ve done well only spending 3 trades there for the year.

In terms of 2017, Grundy has to go. We can’t have him missing two of the remaining three weeks. Bring in Max Gawn or Matty Kreuzer if you can, depending on which your opponent this week has.


Dangerfield is back. Literally no other midfielder is playing. I don’t feel like I need to spell this out. Lock him in.

For the other option (whatever Dangerfield isn’t), The Bont has finally found some form for the Doggies and could be worth the punt against GWS, while Rory Sloane looks unlikely to be tagged by the Bombers.

Obviously though, if you have one of Dustin Martin or Tom Mitchell, give one of them a shot. Now’s not the time for Dicey selections, your PODs should be doing that at this time of year. If you’re feeling dangerous, or need something big to get your side over the line, let me know who you’re going in the comments!

And I’m out for the week, community. Lots of panic, not a lot of help, but that’s what comments are for! Get in, get amongst it, let us know your thoughts.

You’re a bunch of good eggs, community. Don’t forget that. Remember to chuck your Draftstars sides in, and good luck for this weekend! Rip ‘em a new one!

  Twitter : @PatchToTheMax

Notify of
Newest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
neil Demons Delight

Great read Patch as usual splash of humour and a lot of frustration and who can blame you. I seen Mark Jackson punch Ronny Andrews after Ron whacked him in the nuts out of the umps sight . Now that's what I call a punch Robbie Flower would vouch for that Great job all year Patch

Rick Grimes

Great write up, Patch. You've brilliantly encapsulated the mood of the SC community. Not only have the SC Gods burnt our season to a blackened crisp, they've served it up with a side of soggy brussell sprouts. Absolute [email protected]


Patch, I was gunna say it looks like you've lost your Ha Ha for the year, but there it all is right at the top of your post !!!!! The one good thing about carnage of this nature is that it usually affects your opponant as much as it does your own team ( assuming of course you have long since given up hope of winning the whole thing and are now jus content with a league GF. For me I had 3 trades up my sleeve going into this round and have picked up T Mitchell for Jelwood and Neale for Witherdan. Came close. Few weeks ago to picking up Grundy or Mummy in Ruck for Witts but luckily spent he extra coin for Ryder.

One trade left and still finals of both leagues. Here's hoping to then end of the carnage. One trade left for emergencies.


Hoping for you Mograt! Big moves for you this week, I love it!


Ruck me.
What a mess.
Fortunately I have two big boys who are playing (but who knows -there may be more sting in the SCorpion tail) but feel for the teams who have both big boys missing.

As u said not much better anywhere else either. Mids ripped to shreds with a twangy backup.

Danger is it.
But to provide a little bit of sunshine i give you this.
Last 6 games scores v Kangas
Rd 20 – Taylor Adams 127
Rd 19 – Oliver 170
Rd 18 – Heppell 115
Rd 17 – Ebert/wingard 150
Rd 16 – Fyfe 140
Rd 15 – Lyons 138

So if for some reason Danger doesn't quite get the job done u can lock in Titch with confidence against the roos.

Can field 22 just.
If Shaz is named tonight have 1 loop.
Who to loop? Shaw or Lloyd?


Beautiful stuff, Trigger! Titch has torn the comp a new one this year.

Personally would loop Lloyd, McVeigh has cut his output in half

Spam Notifier



Rockliff or R.Gray


Gray for mine. Rockliff is just slightly too off-kilter at the moment


Ok then, that's one trade now what to do with T.Lynch only have 18K in the bank now


I'd say reverse the previous trade, get Rocky in and see what you can get with the extra 100k.

Leaves you about 530k I think. Makes most forwards affordable (only Macrae and Ryder are out of reach) If you can swing a dpp from the mids (or ruck) it opens up a lot of possibilities.

If you go with Gray then consider Charlie Dixon, might go large this week and in round 23.


If I get Rockliff I get 120K in the bank to upgrade T.Lynch


That changes things, T. Rockliff in and then McLean? Red Herring's suggestion of Dixon isn't a bad one either


Didn't think of McLean actually


That would mean I would have 4 dogs players tho


SPP is out


Cheers Lazza

Hb prince

Like most of the community I have selwood and Grundy out this please advise me on which combo is better:




Cheers community


Kruze will go bananas v Eagles this week. Couple him with Parker. Dusty/Smartin a close second


Dusty + Stef I say.


I'm team Dusty and Stef


"Lots of panic, not a lot of help" – that's the unofficial motto of the Panic Room, right? 😉

I've found my vice to be those $7 tubs of iced vovo ice cream. Will be demolishing a few this weekend. Best of luck to all!


A lot of us are beyond help this week. If you need help, Lek's cheat sheet is absolutely where you should be going after my last attempts at helping (Zorko, Gibbs, Mumford, Jezza Cameron) have all been absolutely appalling, I feel I'm helping more by not helping!


Look at the bright side, at least there are plenty of loophole options


Yeh, but loop hole to who ???? There's no one there … bench is empty … or same game for the single one I have . 🙁


Berry and Hanley have also been withdrawn from this week


Thinking big POD…Jwood to Rocky which would allow witherden to likes of Roberton, McVeigh, Rance. Rocky looks to be getting it together and so cheap. Two home games v GCS and Roos and away v Dees. Or do I downgrade witherden and Jwood to Dusty who opt has ?


I'd be very, very hesitant to bring Tom Rockliff into your side. He's ridiculously cheap, but he's cheap for a reason. His run home is great, and he needs to play well to bring his market value up for trade period, but… personally I couldn't do it. I'd go option 2 myself, Dan – but back yourself here!


I'm sitting pretty with 5 trades left and a week off since I'm in the prelim. I was hoping that Grundy would only get 1 week for a perfect tackle but that wasn't to be:

DEF: Doc, Adams, Laird, Howe, Shaw, Ryan (Witherden, Scharenberg)
MID: Danger, Dusty, Fyfe, Bont, Neale, Treloar, Mitchell, j.Lloyd (Selwood, Cousins, Bolton)
R: Nank, Gawn (Grundy)
FWD: Macrae, Yeo, Heeney, Dahlhaus, Greenwood, Deluca-Cardillo (Lynch, Cameron)

Do I go hard the next 2 weeks, using 4 trades to load up for the prelim and give me an even better shot at making the GF, or downgrade Witherden this week to build a chest, and upgrade Selwood & Grundy next week, leaving Lynch for the GF.



Having 5 trades left at this stage is awesome,I'd be trading out Selwood and Lynch,since they won't be coming back.


I sacrificed my ranking for league play after a slow start and held trades. I'm definitely offloading Lynch, Selwood and Witherden. Im more trying to plan out who to bring in.

Toby Greene up forward is looking good, as is Matt Crouch and Merrett in the midfield next week


I like the idea of Greene and M.Crouch.Crouch more so,his last two months have been great,Oliver could be another one,a little bit cheaper.


I'd go BANG BANG now, Bozza! No point saving Lynch for the grand final – how much cash have you got? Can you go Lynch to a Buddy/Dahlhaus/JJK or, if you're feeling dicey, a Sicily (ave 110 in his last 3) or a Charlie Curnow (91 in his last 3 , but with WCE, Haw, Syd to come, maybe not)?

Would go Lynch and Withers this week, then the other two next week


Only have 12k.

Thinking Witherden > Junker as a loop, then Selwood > Coniglio, and offload Lynch next week.

It's good having a week off to play with

B rian

Congrats Bozza, You've done very well. I think in your situation you should be looking to get in a better option than Coniglio.
Witherden to Junker
Jelwood to the highest points scorer you don't have


I don't want to make you sadder than you are Patch,but for once I have managed to avoid the carnage,have my best players on the field and have cover on all lines.Am in five semi finals,the only one I might lose is in the ''Barron's Cup'' League,will be putting the VC on Danger and the C on Mitch.


You ripper John – that's the Friday pick me up I needed! Best of luck to you mate!


Thanks Patch,up to round 17 it seemed like I had an injury to deal with every two weeks,since then been alright just hanging on to my last two trades,which hopefully I will be using for either the Preliminary finals or GF. To the community I say this,we can plan all we like and think we are set,but luck or no luck at all,plays a huge part in how we go through the season and where we end up.


Hi John, I managed to avoid the rampant blood and carnage decimating a lot of teams this week also…don't know how, it's all just luck really I think.


Hi Russty,that's good to hear,it does go to show that you can do all the research you like,get your structures right and plan your trades really carefully,but nothing will protect you from massive outs on any particular weekend.


Wonderful patch. Those last now will later be first.


I posted previously and leaning toward option C. I have 2 trades remaining and playing an elimination final. Roo seems to be injured which means Greenwood will be on field regardless.

What to do out of these options?:
A. Trade Jelwood to Bont, trade out Roo for Ryan Burton. It would kill any loophole option in my fwd line moving forward.
B. Trade Jelwood for Dusty, trade out Parsons for a cheap non-playing rookie so I can loophole and keep Roo.
C. Trade Jelwood for Gibbs / Yeo / Parker / Heppell and hold my 2nd trade
D. Trade Jelwood for Billings, trade out Roo for Yeo. It would kill any loophole option in my fwd line moving forward.

Thanks in advance!


I like option C with a side of Lukey Parker, Nicko!

The Ranger

Ablett, JPK, Selwood, Grundy, Lynch, Rooey, Witherden OUT
Greene and Menegola IN

Still got 22 if Schazza plays but one of those is Pickett so 21 really.

The Ranger

Who's got the most outs?!
Can anyone top seven?


6 out (Selwood, Grundy, Lynch, Witherden, Merrett, SPP) this week, 2 (Witts and Cameron) out last week! No in's either, other than Brown this week who has been sat on my bench all year….


Winner winner Chicken dinner
7 wow that has to win

The Ranger

Hedski has a fair few out, think he might at least equal me.
In theory there might be someone out there with all of my seven plus Duncan, Merrett and Mummy!


Witherden, Jelwood, Zerrett, Mummy, Lynch, Rooey, Bolton, Cousins + my 2 loopers (Junker/Strnadica).

Going in with 20 on field thanks to Deluca.

The Ranger

And the award goes to….

Got my fingers crossed for ya Hedski.


Nope that's a lot I have Witherden, Mumford, T.Lynch, Merrett and Selwood out this week


That is a lot of outs. Ouch!


Pickett is Playing

The Ranger

He is indeed Corza but does that really count?


Probably not haha


C on Zorko or Sloane?



I'd go Sloane as the Dons don't tend to tag, but also the Suns are useless so I'd also go Zorko.

Zorko. Just.


Another brilliant post Patch. You have soothed our mere as in a season of utter chaos.

Amazingly, I have a full team to field and one bench defender this round, swinging Lloyd to M8 and Greenwood to F6. DPP swings so vital this time of the season.

I'm still in 3 Ieague finals so Captain choice is key..

1. Danger into Sloane?
2. Danger into M.Crouch?
3. Dusty into Gawn?
4. Dusty into Doc?

Leaning toward 1 or 2 though..

I have22starters

Two supercoach rules…never trade sideways unless an injury, and don't ever leave danger out of c or v loop.


Hey do you have 22 starters this week mr 22 starters


I'm going Danger into Gawn Rivo…just for another option.


Same 2 for me Russty


I like option 5, Danger into Gawn

I have22starters

Oppt and I have almost identical teams…so, start Ryan or Heater ?


Ryan for me. Heater has been rubbish.


Ryan, Heater is cooked




This is carnage! I've now copped outs from Grundy, Lynch, Jelwood, Merrett, Witherden and SPP this week, to go beautifully with losing Cameron and Witts last week.

I'm now looking at 2 donuts this week. Meanwhile, my opponent who had the second chance is welcoming back Greene, Priddis, Swallow and Hannan with no outs.

A risk on the captaincy table is looking like my best bet at this stage!


That's rough mate, yeah you're gonna need a pod Captain this week for sure.


18K in the Bank Tom Lynch to who????


Who do you already have Corza? Josh Caddy's been in some good form lately. $424,200


Yeo, Macrae, Dahlhaus, Ryder and Heeney


Under 430k, is that correct?

Tough call, but Dixon at 391k has potential this week and round 23. Round 22 against the dogs at etihad is a concern. You would definitely want to be using a loophole option with him.


Yeah 428K I only have Parsons as cover in the forward line


I'm thinking Greenwood at this stage 401K or I can get more money by Trading J.Selwood to Rockliff instead of Selwood to Gray and have an extra 100K to get somebody else


Would go Rockliff so you have more cashmoney to ditch Lynch




Absolute bloodbath! Trading out Grundy and Jelwood, trying to pick between trading in:
1. Kreuzer and Luke Ryan (swing Adams to mid);
2. Jacobs and Gibbs? Gibbs' run home doesn't have any obvious taggers which bodes well for his output.


Option 2 for mine mate!


So Howe from Hawks isn't an obvious tagger?


2 trades 107k left in bank
3 non playing mids – Merrett, JPK, Selwood
MIDS: Danger, Dusty, Merrett, Fyfe, Hanners, Treloar, JPK, Selwood

1. Can use my last 2 trades on Selwood and JPK but no clue who for with only 107k in the bank. Best options seem to be Kelly and Parker… 3k short on Kelly and Bont 🙁

2. Can swing Witherden to DEF for Lloyd and play Ryan and Shaw on field using 1 trade only (Selwood to Zorko or Kelly) and use Greenwood to cover for Merrett

Leaning towards first option cause playing this week


I like the second option,you have cover in defence,[I have both Ryan and Greenwood on field,]Selwood to Bont would work.


If you're up this week, option 1


Great intro Patch. As soon as i came onto the home page and saw all the ha has, i knew exactly what was going on haha. It's been that bad of a week for most of us but funny enough, my opponent has next to zero carnage, and i have one trade, but because i won in my other league and have the week off, im saving the trade incase more mess happens next week. So i've decided to just play a lot of low scores and just back them to hopefully do well and hope my opponent has an off game unlike last week where everything went right. I switched Dahl to the mid to cover Merrett while swinging Bolton to the forward and having to play Parsons on the ground, then i switched Adams to the mids and put Witherden in the backline with Ryan covering him and Adams covering Duncan. I guess if there's a late out, i'll have to use a trade but thanks to the guys here who helped me at least fit a full team this week with the carnage. Good luck to everyone this weekend who are still playing finals.


Nice Crowy! Escaping it this week!


First class work Patch! Love it. Every year I say get to finals with 6 trades. But it never happens. And the carnage comes & I say to myself you needed 6 trades for the finals. Meh. F you SC gods


Planned for the same here too Pieman, but all those plans went down the crapper with an express ticket this year haha


Yep six trades would be very handy right now and then you look back at your trades for the year and find those three or four that never should have happened.


Cheers IN!


Get to finals with 6 trades means you may not get there in the first place.


Plenty of teams with 6 trades left haven't made the finals… would take supreme luck or the most astute of SCers, particularly this year..

B rian

I think 4 is the magic number.


They going to need boats over in Perth sat nite 80 mm of rain here from now till monday and saturday is the worst of it, thats on top of the 50mm we have had in the last couple of days.


Wow! Not good for key forwards like JJK


nope anyone thinking of a wild C option on him better look at whats hitting perth now and whats coming in the next 24 hours loads of water, 2 pools got pushed out of the ground yesterday.


That's just Bloody Great Stirls.
I didn't need to hear that

Brought in JJK as a pod to boot a bag against the blues and now you r telling me he will need to do that with a snorkel.

Dang. Was gonna be my big point scorer to cover the "outs" this week.



Iv got him too Trigga but started with him.
Can only hope he gets a bit of it but goals might be a tricky affair over here in the big wet.


on field Brown pies or Deluca docker … ill have 20mins to have a look at Deluca before i picking one. Thoughts.


I think Brown will play we all know what's across Ross Lyon is like……


Brown for mine


3 trades, $74k in the bank, have the week off because I made it to prelims.

My first option is next week trade Grundy to Mumford, and Selwood to a decent midfielder and have 1 trade left if I make the grand final

My second option is trade Witherden down to a cheap rookie this week and next week upgrade Grundy to someone like Kruezer and upgrade Selwood to someone like Titch, and have no trades left.

What do I do??


I'd hold James. Put the feet up mate. No telling what this game will throw at us next week

B rian

I think it depends on the rest of your team mate. Im in a similar situation with 3 trades left and I have decided to make one trade this week. Jelwood is out for the year so there is no point in keeping him. I want to have my best possible team on the park next week so if I pick up another injury this week then I wont be able to make 3 trades next week.
Yes its true that the player that you bring in for Jelwood may get injured but that is a long shot. Its much more likely that another player in your team will get injured this week leaving you short next week if you don't make the trade.


So really confused. Do I trade Selwood and Witherden for Oliver and Maynard which would leave me with two trades and $211k or

Trade Goldy for Gawn and Selwood for either Parker, Menegola or B Crouch. This would leave me with no cash.

My opponent is bringing in Gawn and usually I'd go option 1 but this is do or die. The second option would give me more fire power I think for this week


I agree – option 2. The cash isn't going to be any use to you next week if you lose this week. You may as well go for it :).


What Dan said ..


Good luck this week everyone!
Need the help of the community. 1 trade left. Selwood out, who comes in:
A) heppell
b) gibbs
c) menagola
d) sloane (not a POD vs opponent)



I like Menegola, Edo. No Jelwood or Duncan. Will surely get amongst it


Sweet thanks mate


Your intro sums up my last few days perfectly Patch, the missus has just let me out of the padded cell where I've been a dribbling mess.
20 playing this week, no hope in my last cash league semi that I'm alive in.
Massive hail Mary this week, Lancelot into Sloane as my opponent has neither (+ he has 22 playing, can probably loophole too the bastard).


Loophole Heater or Lloyd for Ryan?


Great work Patch!

I'm either going to bring in Kelly or Neale. What are people's thoughts? I'm leaning towards Neale.


I reckon Neale goes bigger more often than Kelly at this stage, might be different next season though.


Fyfe coming good and Ryan have taken away from Neale in my opinion but I would still go with Neale over Kelly.


Neale for mine


3 trades left…no danger but have selwood. Do I use 2 trades to get Danger for Selwood or just trade Selwood to Oliver/Kelly/Zorko/Parker and use 1 trade.


I had no danger until round 12 and it probably cost me the 1800 points I'm behind the current sc leader. So… I'd imagine you're screwed completely, might as well stick fat and go with someone else and brag about how you did what you did this year never having him in your side. Gibbs is a good switch for selwood. G'luck!


JPK and Selwood out out, got $1,041,300 to play with for 2 mids who are the best options?

Currently have Danger, Martin, Titch, Zorko, Fyfe, Treloar


Bont and either Sloane or Heppell?


3 trades, $74k

Grundy to Mumford next week and Selwood to someone similar to his price


Witherden to Spencer this week, Grundy to Kreuzer or Ryder and Selwood to any premium mid



I can't understand why everyone is whingeing, I only have 2 trades left and Z Merrett, J Selwood, B Grundy. Witherden who i had cover for in Berry but he has now been withdrawn with a foot ailment and now my other cover in M White misses out too.
I never thought i would ever say this but thank the God's for Z Fisher and C Glass who both get another game to make my 22 players.
Congratulations to the 3 teams that will probably beat me this week but i will be saving my last 2 trades for the other 6 teams that i play next week.
Due to the recent carnage i am very reluctant to make a trade this week just in case the God's do not have a week off like I do in 6 leagues.
Great work again Patch and chin up mate, I don't know whether you drink or not but I will have one for you just in case.

B rian

you should trade out jelwood this week. it doesn't make sence to hold him, he is done for the year.


I don't want to make a trade this week because of fear of injury to whoever i bring in.
I only have 2 trades and get Z Merrett and maybe others back and I am playing in 6 leagues next week.
Selwood's value is going nowhere if he is not playing.


But if players you're targeting (such as Menegola) go up in price you may be in trouble


Price is not a concern for me or I would take the risk and trade this week.
I am afraid of the carnage that has already happened and do not want to put someone in this week only to get injured.


Cheers mate. I don't drink, but it's appreciated at any rate!


What's the chance of Sloane getting tagged against, Essendon?


Just read that Myers could be sent to tag him – source: Worsefold on SEN radio.


Sorry it was Mark Harvey talking about Sloane's susceptibility to a tag. He did score 160 last week with a Boak tag.


We'd be dumb not to, but we've been dumb a lot this season, like when we let Kelly off the chain. I'd say he'll get attention


C & VC could be the diffference this weekend …. I expect the community will drop off somewhat post this week , so good luck to each and every one of you…


2 donuts this week and I avoided most of the carnage!


What's everyone's thoughts on Coniglio? Think he is good value. I'm considering bringing him in for Selwood


I have always liked this lad but the mid's have been a minefield this year, Go with your gut mate.


Would have been in my team from Day 1 if he hadn't got injured.. will be in my team next year for sure … he is the GWS engine .. do it ..


Going to hold off for now. Dogs have been good at shutting down opposition mids. His price won't rise too much if he goes large


Good player if he can stay on the park…but he can't seem to stay on the park.


Jelwood to menegola,gray or gibbs?


Menegola for me


Gibbs or Rocky in for Jelwood?


Like Gibbs myself


3 trades $74k and made it to the prelims so have the week off. Was thinking of downgrading witherden to spencer and upgrading Grundy to Kreuzer or Ryder. Just not sure if I should hold this week and do it next week. I also have Selwood.

Any suggestions??


I think Jelwood needs to be your first trade unless you are getting donuts somewhere.


I'm going to get a donut from grundy next week


Looking for a mid-forward. Need the flexibility for next week. Trading out Jelwood. Will have $517k. Thinking Billings or Caddy. Thoughts? (I already have McCrae, Dalhaus & Yeo.) Is there anyone else?




Pickett!…No, Billings or…Caddy's in good form too.


Definitely Billings.

Avoid Caddy – kicked a few goals from the goal square last week but had 8, 8 and 9 touches in the previous 3 weeks.


Billings it is. Many thanks


Alright, time for loophole options. Cheers in advance.
Back line: Should I bother loopholing Sharon? Of the Berg variety? I can start him on and take Ryan off. I don't know right now but
Ryan has been going great.
Mid: Deluca-Cardillo or Jake Lloyd. Okay, never mind. Actually, Lloyd or Nank? Who will go bigger? Or will both of them go bigger than Greenwood?
Fwd: If I do loop Nank, Dixon or Greenwood comes off?

Thank you!


I think it's dangerous loopholing during finals, what if you have a late out?…I reckon just play your best players and whack anyone on the bench you are lucky enough to have on the bench.


No games this week, of 4 leagues, 1 eliminated and 3 won qualifying


So you're asking for hypothetical purposes?…if you're not even playing this week..why are you asking about loophole options?


Playing for a rank boost

Don't Blush Baby

Knob head & Heater doing fcall


Zorko's gotta go big against the Suns. Surely !?!?!


Not nececelery


If the game finished now, Dahlhaus would have gotten a Brownlow vote…. How is he only on 27.
Bontempelli with 3 votes: Fantastic so far! Glad I have him in my team


Hope the Doggies get up..over those manufactured, overpaid insta-team guys.


Dirty little cu%t