add_filter('comment_flood_filter', '__return_false');

Round 5 Supercoach Fat Chew

Published by Jock on

Marc Murphy

CARLTON FLOGGED.

MURPH HAS STAINED HIS FIRST UNDERPANT.

A testing round of SuperCoach is underway and there is plenty to discuss below my friends.
Firstly, let us reflect on the greatness of one of our most beloved contributors, experiencing the wonder of the #CoachKingsLife last night;

The CoachKings Series 1 Quarter Final is NEXT FRIDAY NIGHT!

$10,000 IS UP FOR BLOODY GRABS!

Get down to your venue, finish top 3 in any contest and get yourself qualified this weekend folks!

FIND YOUR VENUE HERE

CoachKings-Fixture

Facing a selection conundrum?
Need to chew the fat about a loophole option?
This is place the do it every week.

Let’s chew some round 5 SuperCoach FAT


COACHKINGS PLAY-AT-HOME SUNDAY IS GO – CLICK HERE TO ENTER


Subscribe
Notify of
guest
1287 Comments
Oldest
Newest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
The Coach

Take SPP's score or field Parfitt??

Sam

SPP's score is locked in if you fielded him

Sam

I'm confused… maybe too many rum can last night, but isn't it locked in if he was fielded?

Sam

Of course, the rum haze is clearing…

Jordy

Hmmmm besides his 99 Parfitts high score is 52. What a conundrum. Worth the punt you rekon Jock?

macca

if you had the emergency on him on the bench then you can field a donut and get his score

Sam

Are you expecting much from EVW today jock? Trying to decide between him and Stewart

Steven

which player for vc Stef Martin or Dahlhaus don't have the Bont

Swansational

Looks more like a dour defending type. Pretty low scoring SC wise.

Jay

Anything north of 50 from this motley bunch of rookies this year I'd be happy to lock in. It's a gamble that any of them will go big.

undypuncher

Ive all ready got parfit on feild so do i take ppeper or bowes from gc ?

INPieman

What a crap game last night. Thank god for SC

Sam

Not sure why the blues were given a prime time game to be honest

INPieman

Should have been Giants vs Swans

LoganJosh7

did i miss the trick big time by not picking up GHS?

Zak

Still haven't finalised my trade.
Taranto to Yeo or Tex (as a pod)?

Kev

Tex. Murphy showed last night that the fast starters eventually come back to earth. Tex should have a day out against GC this week

Dukes

Tex is also a fast starter tho

INPieman

The Suns have absolutely zero key defenders available this week. Tex will have the time of his life. He literally won't have an opponent

Davo

Worth trading Toranto to Balic even though he is not playing this week? Need the cash to upgrade Rough to Macrae. Cheers community.

Kev

Macrae's price won't move heaps. Worth holding off and see if Balic returns next week before pulling the trigger

INPieman

You'd want some details on that hip injury. If he is even injured. Who know with Ross

ChasingFinals17

Not sure who to make captain, Rockliff, Danger, Bont, Fyfe, Dahlhaus?

Marco_Polo94

Was a little nervous about trading spp so early but pretty happy with the zerrett trade after last night!

Anthony

Thoughts on Rory laird for vc?

INPieman

He's been told to bring a blanket. Ball won't be down there. Have a look at the Suns backline

Swansational

Yeo could be this years Zerrett. Could.

Captain Risky

And Murphy and Higgins or maybe not…..

Cliffy

Have Strandica as my captain's loophole option for this Round so my VC has to come from one of the games today… Dahl or Stef Martin for VC guys? Can't go JPK since they play pretty much at a similar time as the Dockers do tonight.

Raging Bulls

Beams.

Cliffy

Yeah I have him but it might be tough for the Lions today and hence he may be kept honest today Beams.

Moustachio

Dahl maybe tagged? Stef worth a try maybe. Rucks typically didn't score well vs dogs in 2016. So far this year just Sandi cracking a low ton.

Josh

Take Houston's score of 73 or punt on Butler? Also, very pleased with young WilliamSON on field

Darcy Kelly

Take houstons m evrryday of the week.

INPieman

Take the 73

Kev

Take it

Cliffy

Also, is it worth going Roughy to Yeo? Can't afford NRoo as my first choice in terms of upgrading Roughy. Already have Dahl and Macrae as my other premo forwards.

jabba

i'd hold and have a look at heeney

INPieman

Just had a look at Connor Spudadue's numbers from last season recalling he was rubbish. Well his number's slaughter Pickett. I therefore anoint Jarrod Pickett as the worst Rookie EVER! You can see why the Giants didn't put up a fight to keep him. Rubbish

INPieman

Think i'll shoot him

gator59

Pickett 's about as handy as a hip pocket in a pair of undies !!!!

The Ranger

Pick 5 wasn't he?
Off to the shops this morning to get some Royal Purple. http://royalpurple.com.au/dev/other-special-produ

gator59

That's Gold Ranger

hedski

Ha ha ha ha ha

INPieman

Pick 4 he was. Not sure what the Giants recruiting team was smoking when they picked him. And Ranger can you grab me a can of the Royal Purple for the firing range. Brilliant

gator59

You may need a case of it before the seasons over INP..

INPieman

Believe me Gator I was stroking the shot gun watching Pickett last night

gator59

Next week he's gone Pieman like a shot out of a cannon..Knowing my luck the fuse will be a dud..

Steve1

Oh yeah, now we are talking. blind fold drawer at the ready 🙂

Col

Even ranked above Relton?

SirSamuel016

Still contemplating a trade of Tom Mitchell to Tom Rockliff. Is it worth it? With Mitchell's BE of 138, and Rocky's of 87 or something, is it worth it?

gator59

HOLD

INPieman

Ask yourself that question when you run out of trades. No

SirSamuel016

Aight, holding.

Nathan

I pulled the trigger, I'm not missing rocky in beast mode

Randomcliche2

He was in such a mode with 111 SC points early in the 4th I put the bloomin C on my dummy loophole, somehow went backwards (wasn't watching) didn't get it off in time…..guess we both missed 4th quarter beast mode….. (good trade though, provided you've only used 4 or so).

Saundo

Has anyone heard latest on Dusty?

Waz

Thinking of painting the fence this round..Down-trading Taranto to Berry to free up some cash..then upgrade Watson to Rocky? Berry is a risk, but at least he is playing.. worth the risk?

Finnius

Not Berry. Probably missed the boat on the rookies this round would hold off unless absolutely desperate.

Jackson

If it wasn't for Robbie Grays slight inconsistenties (which I believe is more is body letting him down) he would be the best player in the competition….No midfielder is as devastating forward and no forward is as good in the middle.
BTW how gorgeous is Lekdogs girlfriend? I've gotta grow me a mo it seems

Kev

Look forward to him being a mid/fwd next year

Andrew

Is Hannan going to be named for Melbourne?

Kev

Few whispers that JKH will come back in. Nothing concrete yet

INPieman

Ah Jock. In reference to the above picture of Lek & the ample chested super babe, well I can see why Lek calls his team Lekdog's puppies. And can you get me her phone number please? I'd love to add her to my collection

gator59

I now know why Crouching calls it COCK KINGS!!

INPieman

And apologies Lek I've removed you from that picture & made her my screen saver

Derek

Is she real or a cardboard cut out?

Westy

Wife her, Lek.
If that doesn't happen to be your lady, your lady must be awesome!

Borko

Thoughts on GHS for TT? Will he avg 70-75 and stay in best 22? R12 bye is handy … would move him on then

INPieman

TT isn't playing Borko, Managed aka Dropped. Stevie J took his spot

Daniel

Is JOM to Hanners worth it? Need to give Jaeger the flick and feel as though this is going to be the cheapest we are going to be able to get Hanners for.

INPieman

Tick from me

Hammer

Disappointed I didn't have the aggots to downgrade Hampton to Williamson. Pulled out at the death knock. Will he still be worth it next week despite missing out on his first $65k price rise? He looked impressive.

Kev

Reckon you've missed the boat unfortunately. He will be similar priced to Stewart so nothing to be gained from that. Hampton single digit b.e this week is still making money.

He'll be up and down like all rookies, scored 45 last weekend. The ball spent a hell of a lot of time in Carlton's back half last night

Tim

Bet you're no longer too disappointed.

Sana

Hope you fielded him Hammer

Spanky

Corrective trade on Gunston. Suns Lynch or Macrae?

Finnius123

Macrae for shizzle if it works with your bye structure

Spanky

Yeah I looked at that after I posted – Macrae seems to work better.

Cheers!

Finnius123

Yeah it is all about the bye. I brought Tex in this week instead of Macrae because I already have 6 premos out in rd 11 – which is my limit for any round.

Luke

Do I trade Taranto to Bont or Rocky?

Finnius123

Bont I reckon

Luke

I'm thinking the same durability wise, but as we saw last week Rocky is also a viable VC option and can go massive in a losing side

Finnius123

Bont for consistency – Rocky for ceiling. I would take Bont just because he is going to deliver.

HowiePhucter

Rocky is looking the goods again this year

Satre

Is it 5pm that Melbourne/Richmond teams will be announced?

I'd like to loophole Hannan if he is not named.

Cheers

Andrew

Thinking the same thing mate, need to know rhis!

hedski

Bloody frustrating

Chopsticks

5.30pm today according to Melbourne FC twitter

INPieman

You playing chopsticks?

Chopsticks

I'm playing – wouldn't miss the ANZAC Day Eve match! Dimma assisted with a myofascial groin release so I am good to go!

Finnius123

So many people are bringing in the most expensive premiums such as Rocky and Sloane and Bont. Surely it would be a better idea to trade in fallen premos and other bargains to save cash. Dosh is so hard to come by we need to spend our kitties more efficiently.

Luke

what about if you already have the fallen premiums like Treloar, Hanners etc? why not bring in a set and forget player instead of another risk for 50k?

Finnius123

Probably more like 100k and that is a lot. Not saying that it isn't right 100% of the time but there is no way you own JPK, Hanners, Treloar, Shaw, Simpson ect. and they are way better value for Dosh than 650k Sloane which will definitely drop in price.

Luke

Sloane is flying and Adelaide aren't going anywhere I don't think he drops below 600k, id rather finish will a full midfield of guns instead of discounted blokes in shit form who score 20 points less a week

Finnius123

I disagree. I reckon Treloar and Sloane go at the same average for the rest of the year and finish up on the same price – with Treloar at 80k less. Look for bargains mate don't just splurge on the most expensive guy in the game atm.

INPieman

It's a real tough year for cash gen. Value must be sort after

Luke

I have Treloar, Hanners and Shaw already mate

Finnius123

JPK? JJK? Zerrett? We need to be careful with our dosh. The 70k between Sloane and Merrett is more than the cash gen you will get from Jarrod Pickett. Be careful thats all I'm saying.

Finnius123

*Twice the cash generation from Pickett

Sean's Mob

Who will Robinson tag the Bont or Dahl? Will help with choice of VC – Thanks

Finnius123

Probably Bont – but no one knows. I would VC Dahl.

Tom

Do I take Ollie wines 122 or try out danger or Fyfe as captain

Luke

130+ rule for captains I reckon Tommy

Finnius123

It is right in the middle range. But Danger's 90 shows that we should take the VC op more often than not. I would cop a 120 from any skipper every day of the week.

Beezneez

+1

Beezneez

Meant to be a reply to Luke i.e use 130 rule.

Finnius123

122

Saundo

Take it don't get greedy

hedski

5th week of vice captain shittery from me.
Treloar, Treloar, Buddy, Parker, Doch.
Might as well put it on Spud Pickett next week.

INPieman

Don't think I've taken a Vc score yet either Hedski. Giving Gary a turn today. He's due for a decent score

Steeeve

Shark move!

Josh

Have 300k in the bank, is it worth trading O'Meara straight up to Shuey/Zerrett/Adams or should I hold?

hedski

Zerrett don't think, do.

FCAbel

Trade

Finnius123

Pull the trigger

hedski

Hate to be a Lachie Hunter owner -8 at qtr time!

DacZawson

Lachie Hunter owners hardly exist

hedski

LIONS!! wow

Anth

Forgot to take barrett off field so my attempted Powell Pepper -> Parfitt loophole can't happen anymore!

If Parfitt tonnes up you can all thank me.

DavidSA

FanFooty site not loading live scores

TEM

i have williamson as emergency, should i replace hampton or otten with newman

Finnius123

Hampton

DacZawson

hindsight is a powerful thing

Finnius123

Yup… both tonned up though so wouldn't be disappointed – an 80 odd from a rookie is a gun score

DavidSA

It's such a rare case so I need to share this.

5 players in my team for Dogs vs Lions 3 qtr time

Dahl 93 JJ 92 Macrae 85
Beams 84 Martin 79

Alwx

I thinks Beams as my VC is gonna give me a very awkward score?!

DavidSA

Yup 110 probably

Finnius123

105 odd – would take a punt on your skip

cashcows

I'm probably taking Dahl's VC score. 120~ atm with a few mins to play. Hope he stays or gets scaled up a little.

Finnius123

Yeah I would take it

jpb

Take Zorko's 124 as VC or risk Dangerfield ?

Finnius123

Take it

DavidSA

120 is bench Mark this round I am feeling

jpb

I have gone to Fyfe !

hedski

#when your cash league opponent has the captain on Bont…..and the VC on Danger.

DavidSA

Ummmm fe horget to twap shem round

hedski

Na just clueless I think.

INPieman

Damn. Wish I was playing him

hedski

Ha ha, didn't even see what you'd done there Dave, I'm possibly Dyslexic.

Finnius123

Mark Robinson has the same thing

hedski

Dyslexia?

Derek

Wow…… Berry was poor. Not sure he even made his BE. Looks like another donut rookie next week.

DavidSA

He will get dropped

INPieman

His BE was 21 & he scored 14. Wow!

hedski

Take it you won't loop his points Derek?

Derek

Pickett and Berry can stay on the bench this week and let….. gulp……. Stewart and Parfitt do the scoring. Oh my.

hedski

I'm gonna play Parfitt over Nemos 51.
Will take Hampton over Stewart.

Touk tuk

Hope hampton goes big today… 2 goals already….

hedski

Hope Newman is not a late call up.

Westy

Hampton has started well.

Mikey Moose

Have a bit of a swag to spend. Could do:
1. JOM to JJK (moves Hannan off the field). Helps with bye round (12)
2. JOM to Hanners/Zerrett
Advice?

Mikey Moose

Now Hannan is out, might do 1. to avoid the doughnut.

Finnius123

probs one if it works with your bye AND avoids a doughnut

DefyingMadness

Swallow is gone next week. Clearly something is wrong with him

Ben

Is swallow playing midfield?

Sully321

take dahlhaus' 120 or go with Danger as C

DefyingMadness

I am taking it

Conan_the_Westy

120 in the hand…

hedski

Leks Puppies in the bush…..

Dutch

I'll be taking it I think

DavidSA

Matt Crouch is back!

INPieman

Matt Crouch 42 at 1/4 time. Must have finally been to kicking lessons at the bungalow! Jock will be pleased

Finnius123

lol everyone who was bagging Jock's call during the week and who traded him out

INPieman

79 at HT. Punishing the haters! Jock will be sporting a sizeable erection right now

Timmy

It would be ever so pointy

Sully321

EVW or stewart on the field?

Finnius123

EVW

hedski

Stewart could have a few in the bank, haven't seen V-Dub yet.