add_filter('comment_flood_filter', '__return_false');

SuperCoach RD5: Trade Table

Published by Jock on

SuperCoach-Round-five

A SIGNIFICANT ROUND. A ROUND THAT OFTEN SORTS THE WHEAT FROM THE CHAFF. 

Time to sit around the Trade Table and break trade option bread as a peoples.
It’s simple..
Let us know what your trade plans are in the comments section below, with a bit of justification for your decision.
A place to come every Thursday to test your thinking, get some feedback – or just perv on everyone else’s Supercoach brain.

LISTEN: THIS WEEK’S PODCAST

LEKDOG’S ROUND 5 TRADE CHEAT SHEET

THE ROUND 5 SUPERCOACH ROOKIE SCOUT


 COACHKINGS QUARTER FINAL NEXT WEEKEND!

This weekend is your last chance to get qualified for the BIG one next Friday!
Finish 1st, 2nd or 3rd at a contest in your venue to get qualified – that bloody easy. Get down with your mates!

CoachKings Quarter Final Prize Splits

FIND YOUR NEAREST VENUE
FREE to play
$300 up for grabs in every venue contest
Finish 1st, 2nd or 3rd at your venue to qualify for next week’s $10,000 Quarter Final!

 


Subscribe
Notify of
guest
541 Comments
Oldest
Newest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
jez_m

Just one trade for me this week: Taranto out for Balic.

I could give Pickett or Eddy the flick, but I feel like I just wouldn't get enough cash out of getting rid of one of these two just yet. Chopping Taranto gives me about $130K for a future upgrade at some point.

Kev

Agree with jez here. Balic would be nice but is not a must have like Newman was. Not enough cash to be made from Eddy, Pickett, Hannan types. No trades for me this week. Hopefully my premo's bounce back from the shite they served up last week (not you Dahl ❤️)

John

balic out!

Tyruddanaut

Baltic is not playing

jez_m

Upon teams being named, that's trade will wait a week.

THE NANK

Thoughts on Jaegar out for Balic and this week then trade Rough for Franklin next week?

Sauce

Good stuff Nank I would pull the trigger

harryO

balic isnt named…

Tyruddanaut

Baltic is not plqyung

Steeeve

Taranto out for Balic.
Pickett out for Hanners.

No point waiting for their prices to rise a tiny bit more when there are bargains to be had!

TBone

Sounds smart to me mate. Looking to paint the fence myself with my two trades next week!

Steeeve

I want to get full premo ASAP and ride the sweet wave of tons to the end of the season.

Tyruddanaut

Balic wasn't picked

The Buttonsticher

Ainsworth ain't worth it, bye bye. M.Crouch can punch it, I should have known better. In, 2 other _unts

INPieman

He Ainsworth nothin. Crouching's slipper saw that coming

Bobby W

Jock… Matty Crouch output end last year was huge. This year quiet. Sure he hasn't kicked enough but I reckon the big difference is one Brad Crouch. He was inside feeding his brother last year. And is back from injury and torn it apart last week in the ressies. Hold M Crouch. Brad's coming to save the day…

TBone

As much as I want to trade down to Balic, I don't know about his ability to score decently each week. Also all rookies will play in my squad other than hibberd. Anyone know how young Williamsons js is over at Carlton? Or should I just wait for another def rookie to come about? Cheers!

INPieman

You'll know more about Williamson's JS in about 3 hours. If you've only got one donut I'd suggest holding. I've got 3 & it's giving me the shits

Tyruddanaut

Baltic isn't playing

Tommo09

One trade this week

Hannan or Eddy for Balic
Giving Rough one more chance
Roughy, you better deliver

Sauce

Good stuff

Tyruddanaut

Neither are playing

Seeker

Taranto to Balic is likely for me this week. My simple forecast is that Taranto on increases about $8,000 to $10000, Balic more likely to add 3-4 times that in cash. Then next week with a sizeable bank and Hampton, Marchbank,SPP or even WHE on the chopping block, I'll look to 'paint the fence' with Fisher and a fallen premo.

Tyruddanaut

Baltic is t playing

Sana

Mate! I've read this about 10 times now! It's Balic!!! No T!

INPieman

If none of Mountford Eddy or Barrett are named then one will become Balic. Undecided on JOM, might grab my doctor bag & go visit his knee. Of course if he is not named he's gone

thisisscoman

The first half of this is where I'm sitting. No good having three guys doing nothing. Might as well get one generating a bit of cash. If none are named, it's probably Eddy out for cash. If Eddy is named, it's Mountford cos I don't know if we'll ever see him again. Barrett is the most likely to play again soon, so the last to be traded.

That's my order anyway.

INPieman

I agree with that order as well. I'd rather not get rid of any. After all they were selected for round 1 so they must be rated

Tyruddanaut

Baltic isn't playing

Westy

Balic seems to be the panacea. In for JOM or WHE.

Need a bit more cash out of my rooks before I start fence painting.

INPieman

My rule of thumb is if your trading a player over 300k you send them up to a premo. A player under 300 you send them down. But I guess everyone is different. I'd therefore wait to send those boys up

Tyruddanaut

Neither he isn't playing

Choppers

I'd like to go Hoskin-Elliott to Macrae but need to also get rid of concussed Hibberd to have enough cash. So will bring Williamson in if named. Also have Barrett and Eddy on the bench. Or maybe I don't trade at all. Any thoughts?

C-Train

I am with you Choppers. All my rooks are playing and although not killing it, why waste a trade for a similar rook? Sit tight!

Peter Demetriou

300k in the bank
Looking at an upgrade in the mids to hanneberry, either from: J. Omera, S, powel-pepper, or Florent.

Then downgrade to balic from either: eddy, picket or tarranto.

What do you guys think?
Really want t.adams but not ready to move on any rookies just yet.

Macca

Personally I'd wait a week on the Hanneberry trade, BE of 108 so unless he goes off price isnt going to change too much, and allows a little extra cash gen from the others

INPieman

Goo advice Macca considering he's only passed the tonne once this season

C-Train

Hold SPP for this week Pete, he might get 100 against the Blues!

Krups

Swallow out for Balic?
Higgins up to Roo?

Tyruddanaut

Baltic isn't playinn

Dylan

Who's the better long term option out of Marc Murphy, Brendon Goddard and Ollie Wines?

Kev

Wines

Macca

Can either be aggressive and go Rough down to Balic and bank the cash
Or play it safe and just go a Barrett/Eddy (depends who is named) for Balic

Tough choices

Kev

I'd hold Barrett no matter what you do. He's too good for NEAFL and has a b.e of -22. Eddy, despite his -33 b.e, can't seem to nail down his spot.

Johno

Anyone have any thoughts on Shaun Burgoyne. Got him in to start with as a POD, but he is leaking cash almost as fast as Heater. I usually stick fat with premo's, but not sure whether he will/can turn it around.

DavidSA

Hawthorn is cooked
I started with Burgoyne but something told me to change him to JJ before they both played with unlimited trades

Josh Kelly

Swallow to Hannebery and Marchbank to Berry also would leave me with 100k in the bank, what does everyone think?

LtDraught

Going to North Melbourne would leave you with 9 million Josh, id consider that move

In all seriousness I like the swallow > Hanners move, its a classic upgrade to a fallen premo. However im not sold on Marchbank > Berry. Berry hasnt looked promising with his scores at all, and Marchbank's BE is only 47 so i still see cash to be made. Apart from his 56 in the heavy rain he's scored decently.

INPieman

After what Berry has dished up so far I'd wait another week till after his price drops

DavidSA

Insane to move on Marchbank he will be ripe when he has his bye

Chevy

The B. VINCE conundrum….
HOLD or TRADE?

Mason

Trade him out!

Rivo

I'm done with JOM & Roughy.
In comes Rocky & Balic.

Youngy

Solid trades.

DavidSA

Yup nice trades bro

Soothsayer

I just keep staring them thinking that surely they will come good, but they have to come good straight away or they lose cash compared to the premium's increases.. I want to bring in Sloane though, he he is reliable, but if he goes up more than 10k this week and JOM and Roughy spud it up, I won't wont be able to afford Sloane. What to Do?

Rivo

Sloane was very close to being picked but I think Rocky can go large and has a higher curling. Very tough call though. Sloane is in great form too. I would get him in now.

Tyruddanaut

Balic is t playin

Cr0magn0n

Good move

donn17984

I want to cut H.Shaw for Tom williamson or A.otten?? to make some cash and then bring in Balic. for M.Hibberd. This will leave about 375K in the bank due to cutting H. shaw and I can get a premium next week. Does this look good any suggestions welcome or open to try something else?? was going to cut roughead for sam reid but thought need to get Balic in whilst hes cheap?

Hey Guys current team:

T.ADAMS R.LAIRD H.SHAW
H. HARTLETT N.NEWNHAM C.HAMPTON BENCH- E. VICKERS-WILL & T.STEWART

D.HANNEBERY D.SWALLOW N.FYFE T. MITCHELL BENCH J.BARRETT & M.HIBBERD
P. DANGER D.BEAMS B.PARTITT S.POWELL-PEPER BENCH L.STRNADICA & D. CAMERON

P.PREUSS B.GRUNDY

L.DAHLHAUS J.ROUGHHEAD W.HOSKINS ELLIOT
j.MACRAE T.TARANTINO D.HOUSTON.

Macca

Wouldn't trade Shaw, is a proven premo and you'll probably wind up trying to trade him back in later

donn17984

You think surely he's got to go? get a money maker in what would you do

DavidSA

Jocks wise words:

Trading out Shaw, Simpson and Treloar your banking a loss

Tyruddanaut

Balic isn't playing

hedski

Everyone knows that now, don't waste your time typin it a hundred times mate.

Peter Demetriou

Balic not named throws a spanner in the works, absolute carnage.
No N.Newman, No J.O'Mera, No, O.Florent, No J.Barret, No T.Taranto, No B.Preuss, No B.Eddy!!!!
struggle city!

Cr0magn0n

Dont trade Shaw, it's a marathon not a sprint

Jeffreyhead

Oli Florent to balic, then mister handball crouch to Lynch up fwd. Crouch is a stain and i don't see lynch getting any cheaper. Still only have one on field rookie in the guts as i started with 6-1-4 there. Thoughts?

Patch

Torn between bringing Stef or Taylor Adams in – will have both eventually but will need to wait on one of them. Been on the Adams train most of the week but think I'll go for Stef, as it lets me play one less shonky forward rookie (Nank swings forward).

Although if SPP isn't named, as the whispers suggest, I might go to Adams and have him in the middle

DavidSA

I did Steff too Patch, I started the season with Hickey…. I know I know

hedski

I think SPP will be named Patch, Hinkley said on afl site he's backing him in. I got Stef in for Roughy swinging Nank fwd also, don't think we'll see Stef this cheap for a while.

donn17984

I want to cut H.Shaw for Tom williamson or A.otten?? to make some cash and then bring in Balic. for M.Hibberd. This will leave about 375K in the bank due to cutting H. shaw and I can get a premium next week. Does this look good any suggestions welcome or open to try something else?? was going to cut roughead for sam reid but thought need to get Balic in whilst hes cheap?

Andrew

Leave Shaw. He will come good and it will just burn two trades when he finds form again and you look to bring him in.

DavidSA

So many trades to cut off one premo for eventually a prem back that's insane

Trade Itch

Going Parfitt and SPP for Parsons and Matera.
Thinking Parsons will come back so will just get him now as I like the look of him, will pass on Balic. Punting on Matera into F6 as a limited risk. He may just make a few $ before the bye debacle kicks in.
Have stacked the Backline, Rucks and Fwds with mid pricers. Mids started complete with Fyfe at M8. A little bit different but you never know.
24 trades left and the premium upgrades of the mid pricers start next week. Roughy 1st to go then.

Andrew

Mate!!! Parfitt has a -30 BE. He will make money for the next few weeks and then you can go to Parsons when he gets back. Make yourself maybe an extra 60k odd. You may as well leave him on your bench to grow if you're stacked and then drop him for Parson's once he's actually playing again.

INPieman

Wow. Just wow

Josh

What are trades pieman? Still
Holding Heath Shaw as he bleeds cash?

Raging Bulls

It doesn't matter if they 'bleed cash' if you plan on keeping them all season. Which you absolutely 100% SHOULD with Heath Shaw as he is a Top 6 Defender… U don't know what you're doing or how to play SC if you trade out Heath Shaw this week. It's as simple as that… Everyone who doesn't have HS should be looking at getting him for a paltry amount next week anyway. First year playing SC Josh?

josh

nah mate traded Shaw last week when he was up around 560k for cash and points generation as I play for rank, will get him back later when he is around 450 if needed. Have kept him for the whole season in previous years but trying first mover principle. Not my first rodeo champ. Pieman lambasted me last week on Shaw and you can too but cookie cutter trading to Swallow last week didn't really work out did it?

Jager Bombs

I just laughed out loud on the train home. Mate step away from the computer and dont press the trade button.

Steeeve

Who to trade out?
Eddy, Hannan, Pickett.
All have more cash to make but that's only if they play. Pickett in particular has never come close to Balic's 73 scored last weekend.

Choppers

Correct Steeeve, Pickett hasn't come close yet. But are you aware that he's increased his score in every game he's played so far.
Don't think anyone else has done that…..just sayin'.

Choppers

should have posted…..over 4 games…

Spencer

I'm considering Dr Pepper down to Ball Lick then M Crouch into Hand on Berries had a gutful of Crouch can't hold any further he's leaking too much $

DavidSA

Know this sounds crazy but that's nearly a side ways trade and SPP will score plenty tomorrow I feel

Spencer

Potentially…..Crouch is shitting me beyond belief

Jojo

Is buddy worth buying this week

DavidSA

He is worth holding all year

INPieman

No. Has a BE of 138 & playing the Giants. However next week is the beginning of an easy draw….Blues, Lions, North, Saints then Hawks. Should be about 480K & ripe for the picking

Adrian

Community, am thinking Mitchell Hibberd to Ballic, just because Hibberd hasn't played and is a test for concussion…so at a minimum he's some time away for generating cash.

Although l am wondering should l just wait a week to bring Ballic in for Fisher……and save the trade….not really desperate for Ballic…just doing it for the cash gen this week, but Fisher will be on the bubble next week…think l am talking myself into reversing that trade…..l remember in previous years doing these types of trades, and ended up running out of trades…

What would you do….

Raging Bulls

hold.

DavidSA

Rookies are:
Newman, Marchbank, Hampton, Stewart
McGrath, SPP, Parfitt, Fox, Barett
Strandica
Butler, Houston, Bowes, Eddy

Trades have been done and locked for last 3 days they are Hickey > Martin & Hibberd > Lloyd
I'm worried about Howe moving back forward at times are even whole games so picked Lloyd.
Don't feel like I'm missing out on any rookies currently on the bubble

The Ranger

I'm seeing a lot of people trading out rookies that still have money to make.
In my experience you need your rookies to make a minimum of 100K (ideally more) before culling them if you want to get to full premo.
I know it's hard to do nothing but sometimes good things come to those that wait.

DavidSA

Agree Marchbank and SPP got another 70k to make I feel

The Ranger

You can add Pickett, Taranto and Eddy to that list.
They might be earning slowly but they're still earning and an extra 10-20K might be the difference between getting the fallen premo you really want or having to bring in a lesser player later in the season.
Timing when to jump off a rookie is crucial.

Lenny

Zach Merrett and Stefan martin or Rocky and Jack Mcrae

DavidSA

First option

DavidSA

First option by a mile

Lenny

Because next round i will have spare cash to updrade higgins to Grundy/Martin, do u still recon i should go option 1 DavidSA?

hedski

Stef will be worth +$50k next week.

Stirlsy

2 trades for me this week 1 planned from the start, trade 1 Balic in for Florent.
Trade 2 Sandi to Sloane via dpp Nank jumps up from fwd to Rucks for a while.
Yes i know Sandi still has cash to make but he was always only going to stay in the team for 5 to 6 weeks and if Nank held up and Sandi wasn't avg 105 he was going to be part of first upgrade.

Liam

Who should I trade omeara out for to be on the field? Or should I trade Powell-pepper instead?

Liam

Is it stupid to trade omeara for Balic to play on the field

Youngy

Yes because Balic isn't playing.

Steven Jurica

I think the best indication of whether your team is appreciating enough in price and your rookies are fattening up is your total team value. Mine is $11,187,000 (including cash in bank).

How is everyone else fairing in team value?

hedski

$11,099,000. + $82k bank.

The Ranger

$10.7 with 300K in the bank.
My supposed bloody premos have depreciated by $160K between them!

macca

$11,386,000 +75k bank

Moustachio

11.48m, sfa in bank. Same as at R4 last year, but much higher ranked which is testament to how shithouse the SC relevant players have been so far!

SCaddict

$11.4M with negligible bank after upgrading Roughie to Macrae this week.

Pman

$11,290,740 and $54K in the bank.

Swans2012

$10,998,000 and $295k in bank.

TRIGGER HAPPY

Hoping Perryman gets a game.
So I can use Hibberd DPP only reason worth holding.
Was keen on Berry but not with those scores.
Depends who is named and dropped.
Probably will bring in balic as have trading strategy all planned out who I am looking at bringing in and when.
Only one flaw – the bloody rookies need to start making some [email protected]#!

Stirlsy

Yes Trigger, lots of us in the same boat with these crappy rookies.

Kevdog

My current team
Def: Laird, Lloyd, Shaw, Marchbank, Otten, Newman (Hampton, Stewart)
Mid: Danger, Fyfe, Hannebery, Treloar, M.Crouch, Petrevski-Seton, Powell-Pepper (Barrett, Pickett, Hibberd)
Ruc: Grundy, Sandi (Strnadica)
Fwd: Dahlhaus, Nankervis, JJK, Buddy, Butler, Taranto (Parfitt, Eddy)
109k in the bank 28 trades left.
Thinking of going Pickett to Balic and Crouch to Dylan Shiel with 76k left
Thoughts ?

josh

need to strengthen that engine room I reckon. Shiel nice POD pick but only averaging 100. Could go 1 round early on Hampton, Powell Pepper or Taranto and get Williamson, Fisher as rookie and Sloane, Merrit, Rocky, Bont or Dependelberry as premo mid. Will Shiel finish top 8 mids is question you need to ask yourself.

RickeyRat

Thoughts appreciated on offloading Treloar for Rockliff then Titchell for Sloane with the view they go big and score 150+ ,the other two would need 50 possessions to score that as they butcher the ball.
Also ANB for Roughie as he's a dpp and forwards are horrible this year.

Surferboi

Terrible trades, I'll be looking to get Trelor in a few weeks

Sir Sam

Here's my current team: http://i.imgur.com/Z9n3Y3o.png
With 26 trades left and 257k in the bank, I'm thinking Ainsworth to Balic and Powell-Pepper up to Hannebery

Big G

Will Declan Montford ever play a game of AFL footy ever again?

Youngy

He should get another game, The question is will he play this year again?

Dildor

Can someone tell me Z.Merret's breakeven as well as some projected stats?

trader

136

Huggy

Break even of 127 this week Dildor.
Projected to hover around his current price for the next few weeks. $595k come his round 13 bye

Dildor

Brilliant thanks

BigBuggars

be is 128

Dryyak

Gone Stewart to Balic via Hibberd and had the cash so went Taranto to Nick Riewoldt, thoughts?

killer

Anyone else play both SC NRL /AFL,
I WAS WONDERING HOW I WOULD FIND OUT IF ANYONE ELSE IS TOP 1% IN BOTH COMPS,,
NOT GOOD SORTIN MYSELF PEOPLE IM VERY CURIOUS HOW MANY PEOPLE ARE GOING AT 1% IN BOTH COMPS ,ANYWAY OF FINDING OUT THAT INFO GUYS ..

hedski

IMO the only good NRL games are the state of origin and the granny.
(That's all I watch, Sry to the fans out there)

Joe T

Hey community! Tossing between using either 1 or 2 trades this week.

Option 1 (cash generation)
Roughy > Balic

Option 2
Roughy > Balic
Taranto > Macrae

2nd option uses an extra trade early in the season but adds a premo replacement for roughy, whereas the first option gives me solid cash generation to upgrade any other areas in the following week. Thoughts?

Joe T

never mind, absolute carnage this week with team selection. Looks like a week to hold trades!

Rick Grimes

Balic probably the only trade I'll look at. Not sure if he's essential tho. I see a lot of people on here taking about trading rookies with negative be. That's crazy talk.

Lenny

Is Tom Rockliff really worth it?

RobDog

Yes! Is fit and firing, and with Beams back he is in a much better midfield this year.

BradK

There goes my pod. I've had him vc every week so far. Dont know why he was doubted.

Pman

Rocky is gun but get's too injutred for my liking and have been burnt before (including twice in a one season a few years back!) so he is a No Go Zone for me.

ben andrews

does anyone know if harrison wigg is due for a game anytime soon, he is stuck on my bench

WinnerzRGrinnerz

Def: Adams, Shaw, Laird, Marchbank, Otten, Newman (Hampton, Stewart)
Mid: Danger, Bont, Fyfe, Treloar, T Mitch, Beams, Swallow, SPP (Barrett, Miles, Hibberd)
Ruck: Ryder, Sandi
Fwd: Dahl, Buddy, Nank, Roughy, WHE, Butler (Pickett, Eddy)

175k in bank

Thinking of going Marchbank to Balic via DPP with Hibberd. Would give me about $350k in the bank ready to go bang bang over the next couple of weeks in the back and forward lines. Thoughts?

WinnerzRGrinnerz

Scrap that

Liam

JOM or SPP for balic or for someone else or hold?

BradK

Hold mate

Jager Bombs

Everyone is bringing in balic but i just think zac fisher next wk could be a much better downgrade option.

He man

lol no balic. I love it. That's so funny