add_filter('comment_flood_filter', '__return_false');

SuperCoach RD4: Trade Table

Published by Jock on

The-Trade-Table-Supercoach

HOPE YOU’RE HAPPY AND WELL HEADING INTO EASTER COMMUNITY! 

Time to sit around the Trade Table.
It’s simple..
Let us know what your trade plans are in the comments section below, with a bit of justification for your decision.
A place to come every Thursday to test your thinking, get some feedback – or just perv on everyone else’s Supercoach brain.

LISTEN: THIS WEEK’S PODCAST

LEKDOG’S ROUND 4 TRADE CHEAT SHEET

THE ROUND 4 SUPERCOACH ROOKIE SCOUT


 COACHKINGS ROUND 4 VENUE FIXTURE

FIND YOUR NEAREST VENUE
FREE to play
$300 up for grabs in every venue contest
Finish 1st, 2nd or 3rd at your venue to qualify for the first $10,000 Quarter Final!

CoachKings-Round-4-fixture


Subscribe
Notify of
guest
329 Comments
Oldest
Newest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Eric_the_Red

Have a ripper Easter Jock you glorious human.

Mick

He really is a glorious specimen of man. His wonderment brings tears to the eye. God bless you, Jock.

Dean_R

Gonna have to trade out jaeger omeara. He's not playing anywhere near his previous levels before injury, and his BE Is too high. considering trading his to n .newman. Let me know what you think

Jay

Good trade. Jaeger not earning his spot and Newman will make you heaps of cash.

TheScacman

I've traded him up to Dusty and dropped Tuohy down to Newman this week, going for both point accumulation and the cash that Newman will generate. O'meara out is a good call, as long as he doesnt burn us with a ton this week

Josh

should i be trading lynch (suns) out for nick riewouldt?

SCaddict

Riewouldn't!

TheScacman

Would give it a week at least to see if Lynch can bounce back, hold for now, likely to be bigger issues on your team than sideways trades for premiums

Choppers

Just going the one. Smith to Newman.

Happy Easter to all.

Mitch

Did the exact same. Happy Easter mate

Krups

Tuohy to Adams. Tuohy wont finish in top 6 so out he goes.
Stewart to Otten. Yes i know i missed out on the first price increase but he will still nearly make double cash. Stewart going crap.

TheScacman

Stewart to Newman if you don't already have him. Will get the full price value and not cost yourself any of your bank

Krups

I stuffed up last week and grabbed Newman when i should of grabbed Otten

Steven

Im doing the same tuohy to adams but getting newman for smith

Also keeping gawn for this week as got nank as cover and play houston on field

undypuncher

Thats dangerous otten a chance to be dropped any week and your just chasing points

Steven

But otten will play now because mcgovern is out for while so he will be second/third forward and covering in ruck aswell

TRIGGER HAPPY

Hands up who is not trading in Newman?
Straight in for Smith for mine.

Trigs Happy Place Match ups Rd 4

LEK V Liam
INP v SC Addict
TRIGGER HAPPY v dontblushbaby
Billy v BVC
Gator v Kev
Neilsdemondelights v Rick Grimes
Shake n Bake v Moustachio
Patch v Jock
Swans2012 v Tophawk

No easy games. Have to bring it.

Looking at that lot the two that immediately that jump out are:

Pie V Addict – what a classic that one will be

and

Jock v Patch. The master versus the apprentice. With some patch work to his team who knows.

The birds also take flight in the swans and hawks.

Mouth-watering stuff.

Have a great Easter, lets hope we don't have to pull a rabbit out of the hat on Sunday.

Don't forget if you want Newman to bring him in before tonight's lock out.

Hop to it.

INPieman

I'm surprised on 36k have brought in Newman. I was expecting more than double that number. A match up with SCA. Couldn't have picked a worse week to weaken the team & restructure! But I sill like my chances

Wedge

I'm bringing him in just waiting for teams to drop. Might be many more to jump on still

SCaddict

It's perfect timing if you ask me INP. You will get to greet my latest addition in the Champion Data Golden Boy a.k.a. Bont with a delightful VC on the back of his jersey. 🙂

INPieman

I need to borrow Ben's team this week!

SCaddict

Haha thankfully that isn't permitted under the rules when I last checked … or I would be in a world of strife.

INPieman

Next year I'm xeroxing his team!!!!

Top hawk

Stress free trading this week. Just Joel Smith to Nic Newman. No worries.

I am steeling myself for another huge battle this week against Swans 2012. I have to admit, there are 0 easy games in this league. This would have to be the toughest league I have competed in. Lovin it!! Good luck and happy easter to all. Cheers TH

gator59

Great stuff Trigger..I'm playing Kev this week and i hope my players put up a better fight than last weeks effort

Yep have brung Newman in

Good luck to all and Happy Easter to EVERYONE in this great community!!

Randomcliche2

Hand raised.

Davo

Thinking of trading Taranto to Swallow. I think Swallow will provide great cash generation and points scoring if he stays fit. Thoughts community? Cheers.

Mitch

Sounds good to me

Leon

Was thinking the same. Negatives are we lose a dpp and it gets tight to cover both him and SPP in rd 9 bye. Also have to question. Are we wasting a trade to be in same situation, only a month early?

Jay

I'm keeping TT. Good job security and he isn't bleeding cash yet.

Neverweaken

Would not trade in swallow. I started with him so happy enough but could easily be a JOM in a couple of weeks. Rolled ankle and now corked thigh. While not major he seems to attract niggles. There will be better rookies in a week or two and Taranto will pick up

Sir Sam

Making two trades this round.
First is Max Gawn to Stefan Martin. While Nankervis was tempting and would've put even more cash in the bank, I think Stef will be a bit more solid as long as Archie Smith doesn't come along and bugger it up.
Second trade I've made is Ed Vicker-Willis to Nic Newman. My backline is a bit shaky with two players on the bench not having played a game (Hibberd from the Roos and Willis), so trading him out to Newman is good for some more cash generation and some coverage on the bench (putting Stewart on the bench to bring Newman into the playing six).

PD09

I'm leaning the same way with my trade for big Max.
I think Martin most solid of rucks now & has done it before. Expect him to avg 100/110 for rest of yr
The other option I'm considering is Witts as think he'll avg 85/95 for rest of yr & gives me a nice bank of $315k

I'm also trading hibberd for Newman

Mitch

I'm going grundy over him

Jay

Stefen is a solid choice.

Cane

I'm doing exact same thing

Finnius

I seriously recommend you get in Nank. DPP and will finish a top 6 forward

Sir Sam

Aye, since I left what I was doing I decided against going Gawn to Martin and instead went Gawn to Nankervis. While I don't see Nank as a premo just yet, I think seeing he leaves me with 257k in the bank overall and with him being a DPP he'll be a good addition. Might also save me having to fix my ruck in case Archie Smith buggers it up later in the year, messing with Stef's scoring.

Mitch

Hello community here are my two trades I made –
Firstly I swapped Smith (Melb) for Newman (SYD), Obviouly smith is injured so that was an obvious swap as Newman will also generate heaps of cash and descent points,

Secondly I decided to move on hibbered to fox. Wanted to fix all my rookies so I get maximum possible cash generation. Hoping fox will consistently get game time and make cash. As I don't believe hibberd will find any games anytime soon.

Thanks community happy easter!

INPieman

Newman to one of Hibbo Jnr or Mountford is signed off. If Preuss is named he's coming in for Goldy. WItts comes off the pine & an enormous warchest awaits for fallen premos to be exchnaged for failed mid pricers or rookies that hit the wall in cash gen. The likes of Marchbank Steele JOM Taranto & other's will be under the microscope this weekend. The question is who's next to wear the blindfold at Pieman's firing range

BrownlowBoy

How much $ in the bank Pieman and how many trades you got left?

INPieman

488k & 27 trades

BrownlowBoy

Wow!

INPieman

I don't like the thought of waiting till Round 7 2020 till Pickett gets to 200K

Steeeve

Me neither but only needs one score in the 60s.
Granted that's double his current efforts.

Josh

So who you picking with all dem $$$

Jay

Newman in for V-Ellis and Eddy out for Taylor Adams.

Figured I can keep him in my mid until I downgrade a Def rookie and then move him back into my Defense.

Rock

hello community would love some insight and tips for this week please

def: docherty, m boyd, laird, otten, hampton, stewart (e vw, hibberd)
mid: danger, pendles, JPK, fyfe, beams, treloar, spp, swallow, (pickett, miles, barret)
rucks: grundy, sandi (pruess)
for: dahl, macrae, nank, houston, steele, parfitt, (taranto, eddy)

50k and 29 trades left cheers guys

Thr mongrel punt

Evw or hibberd out for newman. Otherwise your team looks good.

Rock

just what i was thinking cheers mongrel, dont think anything else needs to be done this week

Jay

Definitely bring Newman in for EVW. Maybe look at a downgrade for Steele? Mids looking solid.

Finnius

Don't downgrade steele. He is looking sweet.

Yeooooooo

Goldy to nank, goldy will not be in anposition to pump out consistent 100's like previous years due to preuss.

+ cash from goldy gets pickett up to swallow, need some points and pickett doing nothing for me on the bench

INPieman

Like those trades indeed

Thr mongrel punt

Is a trade up from pickett to swallow a good idea? I have 275k in bank. Happy with my sandi witts ruck combo. I have marchbank otten and hampton as D4 to D6 with stewart and newman on bench. Hsve Roughy Steele and WHE as F4 ti F6. SPP as M8.

TheScacman

If Pickett isnt on-field and you're happy with mid premiums, i'd hold a week or two and trade down roughy/steele and upgrade pickett to a premium without burning a trade by going pickett – swallow – premium given one/both of roughead and steele will have to go anyway

Thr mongrel punt

Cheers. Scacman . I think I'll hold at this stage. Already made 4 trades this year!
I haven't given up on steele yet though. Hoping with stevens and armitage out he'll get more midfield minutes. Also hoping roughys 99 is a sign of better things to come.

Finnius

I am making that trade

Zac

Should I trade Taranto for swallow would leave me with 50k and 26 trades

Youngy

That's a tough one.

If you don't have any other problems, Id go for it.

Col

any rookie that gets dropped is getting the chop for Newman & Gawn is going to NRoo, Nank in the rucks

T-Man

O Meara is worrying me and feel like bringing in David Swallow, may not do it if Horlin Smith plays.
It's a 50/50 situation

Leroy

Thinking the same trade dont know about GHS though

I Steele Your Girl

WHAT DO I DO WITH GOLDSTEIN!

Jay

Trade to Stefen or Sandy…. possibly Nank or Witts.

INPieman

Get rid of him Girl thief. Plenty of options to go to

I Steele Your Girl

Great comment INPieman, out he goes

Rufhead&SheSwallows

Hey community, trading Gawn out, but to who… Grundy, Martin or Nank? Leading towards Grundy. Cheers community!

INPieman

1. Nank: (Gets you money, has DPP & he's killing it)
2. Grundy: (Without Cox he's scoring well)
3. Martin. (View this link for what will happen if Archie Smiths name pops up on the team sheet) https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xZLCoYrmZwk

BrownlowBoy

Do you think Smith will get a look in Pieman?

hedski

That's gold Pie, I no longer own a computer for similar reasons.

ScoMan

Gawn to Stef Martin. I've got Nank in the forward line and Sandilands as my other ruck. Choosing Martin over Witts or Grundy.

Mitch Hibberd out of the mid & traded to Hayward, switching Pickett to mid.

I looked at Newman but could only get there by switching Jake Lloyd into the midfield, and I didn't want to end up having him trapped there. I've also get a pretty stacked defence in terms of rookie cash generation, but mid and forward I'm lacking.

DEE

thinking of trading murphy (bob) to newman
gives me marchbank, otten, newman on field with Hampton and stewart on bench which I think is ok.
started 4 strong def with 2 rooks on ground.
Think it will be ok to have 3 on field.

Upgrade JOM to ?
Can spend up to $600k.
Was thinking Sloane but have Crouch at M7.

So here is the plan.
Have two rookies on the field in the fwd line at the moment as Hogan is on the bench
So was thinking of bringing in Roo leaving $80k in the kitty.
When Hogan returns no rookie forwards on the ground.

Then next week upgrade Crouch to Hannebery?

Jay

Not a bad plan.

Finnius

Cop that. Just be wary of burning too many trades. Think as hard as you can a bit how you can get the same results but with less trades. No issue with getting sloane and crouch in the same team. Their output will stay the same either way.

Neverweaken

I was thinking that but turned JOM into Newman by moving Adams and keeping BMurph.

Cpt Pugwash

Keep bob. He's of half back this week. Clay smith in will play forward and Biggs out. He will pump out 90+

Mitch

Everyone pulling the trigger on JOM to Swallow?
Also getting Newman in, Stewart or Hibbered out?

Jay

Hibbered. Won't get a game.

Jordy

Thoughts on Pickett into Robbie Fox. I feel Pickett has much better job security as a slow burn, but think if fox can survive at least 3 weeks he will make more than Picketts whole season in that period. He will probably be shafted as soon as Heeney is back

Young_Guns

True! I'm in exactly same frame of mind…….but on the bubble too! I think i'm going to have another look see at him on a big Subi Oval for a 3rd gamer. IT'S A HOLD FOR ME HERE!

Kevdog

Should I hold Matt Crouch or trade him to someone like clayton oliver or josh kelly. ?
Thanks.

Jay

If you've got the spare cash maybe side trade to Marc Murphy?

TheScacman

Go to an ultra premium if you've got the bank, if not, wait till you do. Other good option is swallow if you don't have him

Thr mongrel punt

Probably needed to make the crouch to oliver trade last week. I'd hold him now and wait until you can go straight to a fallen premo like hannebury.

Micky_B

Hold or trade lynch from gold coast?

oldmate65

Hold for now, too early to trade him. Also GC is playing Carlton this week, hopefully can get a bag.

Nathan

Started with Nank & Sandy in ruck with Witts on the pine. Thinking of trading Strnadica in for Eddy or Pickett get Witts onto ground and move Nank into the Fwd. Will keep loophole option make $40k. Will bring in Newman also. Only used one trade at this stage Roughy for WHE

Backs – Adams, Shaw, Laird, Marchbank, Otten, Hampton
(Hibberd, Stewart)
Mid – Danger, Kennedy, Treloar, Fyfe, Beams, Kelly, O'Meara, Swallow (SPP, Barrett, Pickett)
Ruck – Nank, Sandi (Witts)
Fwd – Dahl, Macrae, Steele, WHE, Taranto, Butler (Eddy, Parfitt)

Scac

Gone with Tuohy down to Newman as a cash grab, and JOM straight to Dusty. Not expecting Tuohy to be a top 6-10 back, nor is he going to make us any money. O'Meara's poor effort on the weekend sees him upgraded to Dusty for big points output, and ive still got SPP and Swallow to make serious coin in the mid. Roughy down next week at around 400k to fix up one more premium back.

Thoughts community??

Backs: Adams, Laird, Otten, Marchbank, Hampton, Newman (Stewart, Hibberd)
Mids: Dusty, Dangerfield, Fyfe, Mitchell, Beams, Treloar, SPP, Swallow (Barrett, Parfitt, Florent
Rucks: Grundy, Sandi (Strnadica)
Forwards: Nank, Dalhaus, Franklin, Macrae, Hoskin-Elliott, Roughead (Houston, Eddy)

SCaddict

I plan to do likewise with Tuohy -> Newman and JOM -> Bont.

TheScacman

Is Dusty going to have a higher ceiling throughout the season than Bont, or will the time forward ultimately hurt his scoring via no clearances/inside 50s if he doesnt kick bags?

SCaddict

I've got nothing against Dusty and in fact will likely be trading him into my Real Dream Team side this week, so I believe he is an excellent selection in all fantasy formats this season. But I'm just so sick of the Bont getting looked after by CD and not owning him that it's a case of 'if you can't beat em join em' ha ha.

Westy

This week bringing in:
Newman for Hibberd. That's the easy one.
Second one is a little more controversial.
Sandilands to M. Murphy via Nank to Ruck and Parfitt to Fwd

Brent

Need everyone's thoughts on the following please Community. Either going to one of the following

1. Trade out M. Gawn and J. O'meara for S. Martin and D. Swallow

2. Trade out M. Gawn and M. Hibberd for S. Martin and N. Newman

Cheers and Happy Easter to all!

Jay

Tough one. Newman is almost a must have this season but O''meara is starting to bleed money.

Personally I'd get Newman in this week. Hibbard wont get a game and Newman will make a lot of cash. Maybe wear the possibly average score form O'Meara for another week.

Damo

Steele into Riewoldt… too early for this kind of thing?

SCaddict

I intend to keep Steele at least whilst there is still cash to be made. NRoo has traditionally struggled against the Pies too with a 86 career average although I realise this is an opportune week to pounce on him from a BE perspective. He's too much of an injury risk for my own liking but there is no arguing if he can stay out there he will be a top 3 forward.

Damo

Yeah cheers mate have a tough matchup this week and probably chasing points

Neverweaken

Was thinking JOM to NRoo after trading him out week 2. But very nervous of injury. Will wait and watch. Steele should make more cash

CoachDamo

Give Steele more time.

Ben

Hi all,

Needing some advice on my team and possible trade options if people wouldn't mind. Currently ranked 26,024 overall.

DEF: Shaw, Laird, Howe, Lloyd, Marchbank, Otten (Hampton, Stewart)
MID: Dangerfield, Treloar, Fyfe, T. Mitchell, M. Crouch, Beams, Steele, SPP (Barrett, Parfitt, Hibberd)
RUCK: Grundy, Sandilands (Cameron)
FWD: Dahlhaus, T. Lynch(GC), Nankervis, Hoskin-Elliot, Butler, Houston (Eddy, Pickett)

Will certainly go Hibberd –> Newman (via Lloyd DPP)
However, I do not gain cash from that trade and remain with $27.6k.

No other major issues (I dont think), except have a few premiums who just are not quite producing the goods as I thought they would (e.g. Lynch, Treloar, Crouch) but dont think I should trade just yet as I dont really have the $$$ to get anyone super worthy and "performing". Thoughts??

This means I will only make 1 trade this week.

TheScacman

Could do worse than bring crouch down to Swallow which gives you 200k to upgrade a rookie next week, having butler and houston both onfield long term is scary, could bring in a touk miller or even a gun mid via dpp

Mitch

Hey guys ive already traded out EVW for Newman this round, but for my second trade im not too sure if i should try get swallow in for O'meara (he's gotta come good but isnt in my final team plans). I've also considered trading Pickett as hes not going to make any more useful cash, but cant find a suitable replacement having no cash spare.

DEF: Larid, Shaw, Lloyd, Marchbank, Otten, Hampton (Newman, Stewart)
MID:Danger, Fyfe, Titchell, JPK, Beams, Treloar, SPP, O'meara (Taranto, Parfitt, Barrett)
FWD: JJK, Dahlhaus, Higgins, Macrae, Butler, Houston (pickett, Eddy)
Bank:$600 Trades:29

Also what is everyones thoughts on Ryan Burton? seems to be in a role that will score well (104 & 80) and has job security, but is awkward at 254k

TheScacman

Wont make those scores each week, and too awkward to make cash. Swallow is your best cash grab at that mid 200-300k price, but get on him this week or dont bother

HappyFyfe

As you can see from my post below I'm looking at Burton too. The 80 was in a game where he missed most of the first quarter off the ground after a head knock. Not a bad score for three quarters. Price is the issue as probably not a keeper and so would need to keep up this form if to rise sufficiently.
Pick 19 in 2015 and the word was the Hawks were surprised to get him that low and only did due to an injury hit Year. His role this year off half back interests me given the ball will be in the defensive half for the hawks this year by the looks of it. Clarko will want to put time into this kid. He's got Mitchell's no.5 jersey so there is a feeling he will be an important part of the teams future.
Classic risk v reward POD midpricer!

Neverweaken

I started with swallow and JOM. Trading out JOM but wouldn't trade in swallow. Hold JOM for another week or two for better rookies.

HappyFyfe

Ok so I (like many others) lost Gawn last round. I like to try and see this as an opportunity to get in a player I missed. For me this has to be someone I could use, as I would have Gawn, as a VC option. I therefore am thinking Bont now any doubt over how the reduction in hitouts would affect his score has been removed. Given he has North and Brisbane coming up I don't see his price dropping anytime soon and it might even be the lowest we can pick him up for before the end of the season.

I already have Newman, I have Nank to swing into the ruck but the issue is I only have 6k in the bank so cannot do this in one trade. This leaves me with some choices…

1. Give up the Bont and go to a premium ruck, probably Stef as it suits my byes.
2. Downgrade a playing rookie to Hayward e.g. Hannan or Eddy allowing Gawn to Bont
3. Downgrade JOM to Witts allowing Gawn to Bont and 27k in bank
4. Downgrade JOM to Burton (POD, playing halfback in a weak Hawks team and SPP which could be useful if BLong ends up being named) allowing Gawn to Bont and 65k in bank.

I am currently on 29 trades having only gone from Smith to Newman. I was set on option 3 for the week but am now leaning to option 4 as I don't like the idea of giving the advantage to all those who started with Witts and the more I read about Burton especially in his role this season the more I think he is highly relevant.

Thoughts and advice would be welcome. Thanks

slats7

Happy Easter community!

Dusty Spurs

I have 300 K in the bank and am considering upgrading Marchbank to T.Adams this week as I am going against a seemingly worthy opponent this week. Should I pull the trigger now or hold off with the aim of getting in Dusty once one of my rookies appreciates enough?

Rivo

While the temptation to trade Gawn to Dusty, Roo or Bont is strong, I can't justify it as it would leave me no ruck bench cover. Is it worth the risk? Option 1 still my preferred path..

1. Gawn & Hibberd to Stef Martin & Newman – Nank stays at F3, Strnadica loop;
2. Gawn & Hibberd to Riewolt & Newman – swing Nank to R1, Sandi R2, Strnadica R3 (no cover);
3. Gawn & Stewart to Dusty/Bont & Newman – swing as above (no cover).

Knackers

Ruck cover is overated. Take the gamble, you can always swing Nank back fwd in a few weeks when you have generated enough $$$ to bring in another premo ruck.

oldmate65

Hi lads, just wondering about some potential options.

I am looking to trade out Matt Crouch this week as my second trade, (Newman in as the first)
Who should I get in?
Crouch is priced at 496k currently and handballs too much,
I have only 78k left.

Would love some potential options, thanks.

Danners

Hold Crouch, wait a couple of weeks. Trading out under-performing premos should be the last of your worries at the moment

Youngy

Wouldn't recommend trading but if u really want to get rid of him I would suggest wines or Titch. The problem is you want to bring in a player in the top 8 mids. And Titch and wines may be in the top 8 or may not.

Or you could bring in Macrae or Dahlhouse allowing you to swing from mid to fwd when you need and Im pretty confident they will be top 6 fwds.

Norgs

Big decision to be made. Gawn to one of either Roo, Grundy or Stef. Any help would be greatly appreciated

TheScacman

Grundy should be top 2-3. Hold out on Roo to see if he stays fit, definitely one to look at around the byes when upgrading Fwds. Plus you can bank 70K off the bat

Youngy

Ill be bringing in Stef or Preuss for him

Danners

Roo, so you can see how the ruck situation unfolds

Steeeve

Goldy out to Witts seems like premo for non-keeper. But I don't care. Because Witts will end up around $400k and sooner rather than later. Also I already have Preuss, Sandi and Nank.
But most importantly it gives me juuust enough war chest to bring in Hanners and Simpson in the next fortnight.

One premo out for two in the long run. Plus bigtime cash gen. Just wish I'd done it a week earlier. If only I'd known Goldy was going to lose the number one ruck slot to a bloke who wasn't even supposed to play round two.

Derek

I'm not convinced about Preuss.

Steeeve

Doesn't really matter for him, because he will stay on my pine. But it's now or never to jump off Goldy. Even if he resumes the number one ruck mantle he will be sharing with Preuss AND Majak, in a losing side.
He could average 120 from here on and make me look silly but I think there's a better chance he struggles to reach his usual glorious heights.

Pherso

Is Fox a definite trap or worth the risk?

Kermo

Im wondering same thing. Going to bring him in for Hibberd. Has to be worth it doesn't he? Only $102K. Should make us $150+ in a few weeks.

Youngy

If you have a donut and NO other problems I would bring him in for the likes of Mountford.

Derek

Heeney trained really well this week, have on good authority he will play next week.

Pherso

That's what I'm thinking exactly but getting rooks right vs having trades later is the main conundrum.

TSB

Gawn To Taylor Adams via swingset
Trash Backline rookie too Newman

This evens out my backline to 4 premos

TSB

Nank + Sandi in ruck

John

Gawn out for grundy and taranto out for newman via hibberd swing. This gives me a link between def and mid, allowing me to then swing adams into mid meaning i only have spp as a rookie on field, while having an extra rookie down back where they are more reliable. Also alows me to pocket over 100k.
Thoughts?

Derek

Love the DPP. You can't have enough of them!

Sam

My 1 trade if used will be Eddy to Fox, via Pickett. Purely for cash generation so may hold….how much is a trade worth???

Youngy

Do you have Newman

Danners

Good trade, making cash always helps

Sam

Yeah have got Newman already and didn't start with Gawn or Goldy so no ruck issues

KSinny

Guys do I trade Tuoy or Bob Murphy to Newman??

Soothsayer

It would give you cash to get on a fallen Simpson or Heath Shaw when they trough out..

KSinny

Which one do I trade to Newman though, Murphy or Tuohy?

BigBuggars

Murphy a better chance to improve for mine.

SCaddict

Tuohy tweaked his shoulder against the Dees. Not sure how bad it is but it could be an issue in the future affecting his ability to tackle etc so he may as well go first if you are undecided.

KSinny

Alright I'll do that cheers mate

Youngy

Do you have any Donuts on your bench?

KSinny

Yeh I've got Zac Guthrie but trying to get some cash, not sure who's gonna come good Tuohy or Murphy

OleUnited

Hey community,

Thoughts on Hibberd to Newman
Caddy to either the bont, sloane, or dusty? via dpp

Much appreciated!

Youngy

Yep solid trades. I watch Richmond every week and I don't see Caddy getting to 100+ output.

TheGreatBozza

I'm stuck with Hibberd on my MID bench and Smith down back, but I don't have the cash to go Smith > Newman. Here are my options:

1. Hibberd > Newman via Adams DPP (SPP bench, running 4 rooks on field down back)

2. Hibberd > Fox
Smith > Newman

Other issues are Roughy and JOM but id rather drop dead beat rookies

Youngy

Id go option 2

Soothsayer

Is it too late to get in Preuss?

Youngy

Id say no.

Considering going Gawn to Preuss, giving me extra cash for other problems But I am unsure.

Derek

2 weeks ago he wasn't even in the team….. everyone seems very sure he is the real deal…… not convinced

undypuncher

Jaeger omeara will burn everyone by seasons end unless he get injured same roughy back these fellas in. They started in your teams for a reason back them in its rd 4 !

Youngy

What you said does not make sense…

BigBuggars

I'm with you Undies. JOM BE not huge, so if he pumps out a ton this week he'll still generate more cash, and Roughy just had his best result and is improving every week! Knee jerk reactions are poison in SC. Look at all the dolts jumping off Gazza last week.

Derek

JOM had 36 touches two weeks ago. I can see him scoring good

BigBuggars

Happy Easter all. Bowes out, Nank to F4 (or 3, depending where you rank Roughy), and Witts into Nanks spot (Sandi and Preuss the other 2). Then Hibberd to Newman. Leaves 26 trades (2 corrections last week) and $280K in the war chest. Trades for rest of year then become injury enforced, or upgrading mid pricers to premos via rookie rotating. All thoughts appreciated.

jimmy_raiders

Hannan to Broomhead this week?

Youngy

I'd hold.

ben andrews

Good thought, Broomhead had 26 disposals last week and would be a very good selection for a low price