add_filter('comment_flood_filter', '__return_false');

Round 2 Supercoach Fat Chew

Published by Jock on

Round 2 Supercoach Fat Chew

Someone give Dan a bloody can.

He’s given up the drink. And he’s driving his owners to drink. What’s up with Dan Hannebery?

COACHKINGS FREE $500 PLAY AT HOME ON SUNDAY ARVO! ENTER HERE

It’s time to chew the fat about the round in progress for the first time this season. Be sure to join the chat below every weekend.

Facing a selection conundrum?
Need to chew the fat about a loophole option?
This is place the do it every week.

Let’s chew some round 2 SuperCoach FAT


 

TAKEN IN THE LIVE VENUE COACHKINGS EXPERIENCE? GET DOWN, GET AMONGST IT!

Finish 1st, 2nd or 3rd at your venue are you’re into the $10,000 Quarter Final on April 28th!
We’re giving away $300 to the top 3 in EVERY contest

CoachKings Fixture

 


Subscribe
Notify of
guest
724 Comments
Oldest
Newest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Anth

Bloody Will Hoskin Elliott…. is he a must have as of next week?

INPieman

Don't expect 120's every week. But if you fit him in without compromising your structure then get on

Dan

Looking like Simpkin out WHE in for me.

#NANKFORPM

Trade Taranto down to Willba.

Dan

WHE for Dahlhaus could be a shark manoeuvre. Gets rid of a guy every man and his dog owns and allows you to maybe jump on another premo thats under selected.

Third Man Up

Only works if you don't think Dahlhaus is gonna be a top 6 forward. Otherwise in what way are you gaining an advantage on anyone who has him?

Lach

WHE will not be a premo wtf is that train of thought?? You would be trading a guy every has to a guy every has… smh

The Ranger

You just have to be careful you don't end up with too many 200K priced players, they tend to earn cash slowly.

Thomasyates17

Who do u guys think will be a good inclusion for next round I'm looking for some good forwards

OldOcker

Hanners is gone next week, Big stain in underpants.
I have many non playing rookies this week and no cash in bank.
Hanners will become the best 2 playing rooks i don't have next week and have some cash in the bank to pick up the NEW ROOKS on the scene the week after.
Hanneberry has not scored this bad since he was a rookie and I find it hard to believe that he could possibly be a top ten mid in 2017,
Arguments on this subject are welcome but please do not bother. When I am right I am not wrong.
Cheers.

EatChickenNuggets

Pickett, Parfitt, Bowes or take Florent's very average score?

OldOcker

If you were talking about captains and whether to take their score or not about 120 is points in the bank and take it.
When it comes to rookies you have mentioned, Florent has scored 48. Others are yet to play and I am sure one of those will score higher this week but at the same time I thought Hanners was top ten mid too. Clearly I was Wrong.

One thing I love about this site is the fact we try and teach people to think for themselves and make a decision in life.
Yes SC and this website is a life lesson full of Wisdom and Teachings.

Bottom line here is that this is one decision that you will have to make for yourself. Rookies are a lottery ATM.
Buy a Tattslotto ticket and hope for the best.
Cheers.

Beezneez

His run of poor form started in the JLT.

Annie

Dan is the new rookie to have… Gone next week.

Skindog

Glad i got rid of him doesnt look 100% at all, bye Hanners, ill drink for the two of us, bloody hack 😉

Mike

613k and after this round SPP will a higher SC score over the 2 rounds than hanners. Straight to bont for me . Like many others have said he truly dosent look like a top ten mid this year . These younger 6.5 mids ( cripps bont fyfe martin wines )ect are better athletes and are ripping games apart . Hanners is not a goal kicking mid . He tackels hard but cant see him getting his 32- 36 possies like he has in the past. ATM he hasent gotren 20 in a game . Possies is where he gets his points ;he just camt find it and its looking like he cant match ot with these young guns quickly developing and killing it . Sorry hanners you have killed it for me over the years with massive averages and scores for that matter ,but straight swap for atheletic youth. Enter the Bont . That is all

JamiesNinjas13

2 rounds…wow talk about premature analysis.

Cogla13

Goldy on crutches, unlikely to play.

Cogla13

From Fox Sports website. And popular swingman Nanks has already played and locked in the forward line.

INPieman

Holy Crap! To make matters worse by the time that game starts we won't know if Max Gawn is a late out

INPieman

The article looks legit & no mention of April fools

INPieman

It's now of the afl site. Ain't no joke
http://m.afl.com.au/news/2017-04-01/big-roo-in-se

Captain Risky

April 1st?

INPieman

Liked the look of Newman last night. Looks a nice replecement to Hibbo Jnr ina couple of weeks. Hayward looks a player as well. And those that elected to start with Darcy Cameron can send a thank you card to Kurt Tippett. He's as durable a 1 ply toilet paper

Captain Risky

LOL, Started Cameron and Pruess, I was regretting it but with Tippert injured and maybe Goldy the day has improved..

Sabsy

I hope so too (as I have him) but I suspect Sinclair will get the nod out of seniority. They both played in the magoos today so hopefully Cameron had the better showing.

DEE

If he goes OK next week Smith to Newnan Rd 4 could be a goer.
Saves me trying to find an extra 100k to bring in McGrath who will probably score similar to Newman

Freddy

Stuck in a dillema. Miles, Parfitt or Pickett on field?

INPieman

Parfitt

Stirlsy

Agree Parfitt, playing north lock him in.

Neil Demons Delight

parfitt slightly better

Seb

Barret or parfitt on field? Weather will be really bad in Brisbane so will that affect barrets score to much?

Phil

The weather will effect everyone though and there's still 3300 points on offer, so I wouldn't let weather decide for you. A smaller player like Barrett might be better suited to the wet than, say a ruckmen would, so could work in his favour

Bock Choy

A bird in hand… Let pass a solid 120 from Pendles as my VC backing in JPK to beat that. Egg. Face.

bAps

Do you not have Danger or Fyfe??

Luke

This happens year after year with premiums, they start slow and everyone rage trades them. If hanners gets going after a month your gonna hate yourself for punting him. Hes a proven gun, hold fast and work on building your team instead of side swapping premiums, kennedy also scored crap last night. Sydney have lost the games also patience people they will come good.

Mike

If hanners is not scoring like a premium as well as losing money and not looking like a top 10 mid ,then he is NOT a premium

crusher

I agree and whats with people wanting to get premiums that have fallen in price. They are obviously not performing if they are a fallen premium?

The Ranger

The reason we try and get premiums that have fallen in price is in order to get a leg up on those that bought in their premiums at the top price Crusher. A few bad games in a row means you can get someone at 450-500K that others bought at 550-600K
and thereby gain an advantage.
Obviously by the end of the season you want to have as many premiums as possible and when you pick up a fallen premium it's in the hope, based on your research, that there scores will return to their usual standard.

The Ranger

Yes he is. He is performed over a number of games and seasons therefore he's a premium.
You can't judge someone on just two games Mike, take a look at Old Ockers spreadsheet, it gives you a statistical and longer term viewpoint. http://www.jockreynolds.com.au/2017/01/22/old-ock

Borko

hannan v houston? who has better js and scoring potential? I know pittard is coming back but Amon and Sam Gray are in the team too and could make way? Trading this week to allow more flexibility next week to move Hanners on

Steeeve

I don't like Houston's JS with Pittard coming back

SCB

Houston will not be picked over Amon & Gray. JS to me is bad unless there is another injury.

Sarah

If goody doesn't play is he a must trade?

Seb

Depends how many weeks he's out

Neil Demons Delight

whos goody

Phil

Jock Reynolds you son of a gun!! I must say you really have an eye for the big boys! Last year he was banging on about Maxy Gawn pre NAB cup so I picked him and the rest is history.
This year he says Goldy is starting to pickup injuries and predicted Brodie Grundy to overtake him. Early days, but looking spot on. I believe he is on the Nank Train too
You sir, can come down to my club and have a part time gig as my ruck coach anytime. What a legend!

Steeeve

Couple years back he started with Will Minson and Ivan Maric.
But as all great me do, he has learned and improved.

John

I'm making 2 trades next week out hanners and florent in comes Bont and WHE

Defying

Here is my rookie structure:

Defence: Marchbank, Hampton, Hibberd, Otten, Stewart

Midfield: SPP, Barret, Picket, Partfitt

Forward: Taranto, McCarthy, Housten, Eddy

Obviously I am missing a few possible must have rookies. So should I make the 1 trade this week and move on Eddy/ Hibberd to McGrath or Hannan. Currently have 180k in the bank also so cash next week for the WHE trade should not be a problem.

Thoughts?

Neil Demons Delight

It is important we remember we need to get to full premium as quick as possible post byes.. To do this we need two things trades and money.one without the other wont cut it.Trading Hanners is just mind bogling .If my memory is rite he had 4 sub 100s 2016 could be wrong someone will pick it up but hes a gun .two trades per premium is at least 22 plus corrective rookies doesn't leave much particularly two trades involving Hanners Crazy

The Stiv

Please trade out Hanners. I'm looking forward to him being a POD.

Steeeve

If Hanners is worth $450K in a few weeks he is in my team for sure.

Neil Demons Delight

A Quarter of my rookies are duds and I cant do anything with them THE THREE ending in T T barreTT pickeTT parfiTT Hibberd and Miles.the last two could be good loops but the TT s well just prey

Russ in W.A

Wait till after this week mate before you write em off, sometimes they just need to read that they're gonna be dropped if they don't perform this week.

Neil Demons Delight

exactly Russ cheers.gor relos in W A but never been there reckon its great

Russ in W.A

Get over here mate, it's a beautiful place, no stinking pollution, lots of space and natural beauty.

Swans2012

Jom looking bloody good……54 to half time

Randomcliche2

Sshhhh….holding the ball, changer handpass….3rd q…this is a jinx free Zone

crusher

Otten killing it

Captain Risky

At least that should ensure he makes it to week 3 and makes us some cash..

Back to a 73 avg which is probably what we were hoping for.
And Laird back to earth as well. At least Hampton is consistent!

INPieman

I am a goldy owner. But I probably won't have enough info abou this injury by tomorrow. So I've pulled Straindick to Witts for insurance. Hopefully witts can be cover & a cow. And if I find out tomorrow Goldy is cooked for a long time I've still got the coin to go Goldy to Gawn

Valens_FC

Nice move INP. Despite the Suns getting caned, Witts is one of the few to stand up. GAJ on the other hand… think he just got his first kick!

Neil Demons Delight

Did the same yesterday PIES NO BRAINER REALLY nank permanent forward for long time matbe F6

INPieman

Agree gents. It's. It without risk. But witss looks good for an 80 Av as long as he's number 1 ruck. Gary looks disinterested. I've got him but I'll back him in

Abel

Ripping move

Noirlust

Pieman, your team is well structured atm, very impressed

gator59

Has Laird gone to the pub with Hanners

INPieman

60 at HT & still on 60 half way through the last! Just called crime stoppers & lodged a missing persons report

Dogs

Hi community, I started mostly guns n rookies this year, with only a few mid prices in sandi, roughy, nank. Round 1 was great, 29 green lights. Rd 2 already have 4 non playing , 5 including strong peni. Only have 66k in the bank, and cand can't afford to upgrade any rookies to the premium rookies, so I'm thinking maybe downgrading roughy to a rookie, to allow some rookie corrections over the next few weeks. Here's my team, what do you think.

Shaw, laird, marchbank, Hampton, otter, Stewart ( smith, hibberd)
Danger, Pendles, JPK, Selwood, Fyfe, titch, beams, spp ( Barrett, parfitt, mount ford)
Gawn, sandi (strong peni)
Dahl, macrae, nank, roughie, butler, Houston ( eddy, Pickett)

Neverweaken

Anyone rage trade otten? Couldn't decide between him or Hampton on field so kept both on. Knew whoever I took off would score big.
Now will pepper pig out score swallow?

Neverweaken

Oops. To late. Swallow on field for me.

Neverweaken

Thoughts on Roughy. Will he improve on 80 to 90s? Or flick to Hannan or WHE for cash generation?

Dogs

That's what I'm thinking now that I have 4 non playing rookies.

Russ in W.A

It's a tough one, I want to dump him for WHE or Steele, but I'll have to wait till Steele's score first, I reckon Roughy will improve but how long will it take?

Danners

Keep him if you can, trade him if you are desperate for cash

Russ in W.A

Good week for Otten to have a good one for me, flicked Joel smith onfield and bam!

jpb

I did the same

tanker

heath shaw on -1 nearing end of first quarter

Tommo09

Roughy to WHE next week?

hedski

Tempting. No. Maybe.

The Ranger

Too sideways for me Tommo.
I bought Roughy as a keeper. Even if it's only F6/7 come seasons end.

Neil Demons Delight

Don't do it Tommo Roughys still got a bit yet

hedski

Otten done good.

Westy

Looks like a choice of bringing in Otten or Newman for Smith in DEF.

Neil Demons Delight

Benched Ottens thought he was a dud think its a once off now got to work on a loop

Jack

Can't remember a season where I have missed so many rookies….Hannan, WHE, McGrath, Otten, Ainsworth, Houston, Newman

Neil Demons Delight

spot on Jack now for some aggressive trading without that we are history. Have to get Mc Grath Hannan maybe Hannan WHE Newman to start some of the others will come good

Russ in W.A

Remember though, Hannan was an unknown, WHE had a history of mediocrity, McGrath wasn't expected to start round 1, and is expensive, Otten everyone was saying he'd lose his spot fast, Ainsworth, also expensive for a rook, Houston, quite a lot had him I think and Newman didn't play round 1.
You're not alone is missing out on a lot of these guys, many guys are in the same boat.

Derek

That is what this week is for.

Mac D

Hanners never gone sub 100 in his career except rookie year….. I'll be very concerned next week, he seems like Pendles last year, avoiding the contest….. But there was improvement this week compared too round one. I think you owe it to the gods to give the kid one more crack…….and if he bombs again well…….. One can won't be enough.

Mac D

Sorry – meant sub 100 three times in a row lads.

Russ in W.A

Gazza's looking a bit shadowy of his former selfy…hope he has a big last quarter, just for Matchday's sake.

Tommo09

Lynch. Hopeless.
His teammates haven't helped though

Anth

What are you thinking to do with him, trade? Hold?

Tommo09

Hold for sure but he he's been really bad today
His teammates might help him if they got it into their F50

jez_m

Not much he can do when the ball isn't coming down his end, Tommy. He put up a 37 in Round 11 last year and then pumped out a 116 the week after, so he'll bounce back.

Russ in W.A

Taranto seems to be looking to get his ass canned this week too.

Top hawk

Taranto is toast this week.Bloody spud. Taranto out and WHE in. Easy decision now.

Russ in W.A

76 ain't terrible though, I'm gonna be a bit torn on that one.

Off The Bench

76 ain't too bad. WHE has started well but will also probably whack in stinkers from time-to-time. I don't think this should be an easy sideways decision to make.

Spifflicator

I burned Pickett to get WHE. I will keep Taranto for now and see what happens this week, he's still going up in value (more than Pickett and Parfitt anyway). Remember their week 1 scores cycle out of their average in round 4, so all the guys who scored low can suddenly jump in value as they drop those 20-30's. Fingers crossed anyways.

Reiwoldting

Will Hibberd play? Hoping to loop for otten.

Russ in W.A

Not this week, if Goldy doesn't play, Preuss will probably come in for him and share the ruck duties with Daw.

Boltons Blues

thank you north melbourne, dropping Hibbered forced my hand and made me play Otten, thank the supercoach gods!!

Top hawk

Otten on the bench as an emergency and Joel Smith on the field! Thanks Joel, you champion loop holer! Partially makes up for the Aaron Hall disaster today. Completely sha t is jocks.

Joe

Have Taranto's 76 on the bench right now, should I play Eddy on field so I take his 76, or play Houston instead?

Russ in W.A

I'd take the 76 Joe, Houston could get injured in the 1st 2 minutes…or perform like a superspud.

Finnius123

Cop the 76 for shizzle

Holty

GAJ WTF.

Russ in W.A

Kennedy, oh Kennedy, where for art thou Kennedy?…lol

Top hawk

Jack Steele and JJK on fire at quarter time. Combined score of ZERO. -1 and +1 respectively. LOL I just shake my head……..On a positive note, things can only improve from here. You'd think…….

hedski

Happy with Bud and Rough when you look at it like that Toppa, bit to go tho.

INPieman

On 11 & 12 at HT. seriously large turds being deposited at Subi

Russ in W.A

JJK's more of a yoyo man than the Yeo Yeo man.

hedski

Nice move on Witt's Pie, still hoping Maxy plays.

INPieman

Cheers Hedski. Witts should make some money

Abel

Could be a top 5 ruck. Champion against the odds

Michael

As a Greene owner feels good looking at Steele and JJK spudding up. Shows never to be reactionary over round 1 scores

Iamme

Can wait till Sunday night Steele = WHE and Hanneberry out for Beams or Heppel.

Rick Grimes

You gonna drop Steele after a big ton round 1? He'll easily hit his be. Could ton again R3 and WHE do f-all. What's the point??

Iamme

Cash gen, only got 17K At the moment…..if Steel ends with a 60 I think I will hang on to him…as for Hanneberry two total shockers and don't think he can finish a top 10 mid now.

Danners

Have faith and patience. Find another way to get WHE in. Hannebery will find form, don't go point chasing

Jack

Current Rookies: I feel like I need to make a few trades…

DEF: Marchbank, Hampton, Otten, Stewart, Hibberd
MID: SPP, Barrett, Parfitt, Pickett
RUCK: Strnadica
FWD: WHE, Taranto, Butler, Houston, Eddy

Russ in W.A

Lions coming back at the Bombers..that'd be a story!

Russ in W.A

Mcgrath 29 points from 7 disposals with 8 mins to go in the 3rd, spudley effort.

Derek

He looks very good

Russ in W.A

How good is Beams being out for so long and being right up at the top in points?…wish all midpricers were like Beams this year lol

Rick Grimes

Will be impossible to ignore this week. Watch me curse him. Haha