add_filter('comment_flood_filter', '__return_false');

SuperCoach RD2: Trade Table

Published by Jock on

SuperCoach Trade Table Round 2

Welcome to the first edition of the SuperCoach Trade Table!

It’s simple..
Let us know what your trade plans are in the comments section below, with a bit of justification for your decision.
A place to come every Thursday to test your thinking, get some feedback – or just perv on everyone else’s Supercoach brain.

PUMPED for week 2 of the game we bloody love!


LISTEN: THIS WEEK’S PODCAST

LEKDOG’S ROUND 2 TRADE CHEAT SHEET

 

LIVE CHAT WITH JOCK FROM 5:30PM TONIGHT ON THE FOX SPORTS WEBSITE: SUPERCOACH Q&A SESSION CLICK HEREย 


ย COACHKINGS ROUND 2 VENUE FIXTURE

FIND YOUR NEAREST VENUE
FREE to play
$300 up for grabs in every venue contest
Finish 1st, 2nd or 3rd at your venue to qualify for the first $10,000 Quarter Final!

CoachKings Fixture


Subscribe
Notify of
guest
452 Comments
Oldest
Newest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Nick

Nick roo for Jack Steele bank 250k and if turns to shit have cash for trade

Or roo to jjk and leave him there

Either gonna make or break me

Matt

Silly, don't go proven premium to break out contender, stick to your structures

Ledge N Dairy

JJK Is so unreliable tho

Jib_Jib

Week by week he fluctuates a lot, but over the course of a season he regularly averages 90+ . So if you're going to get on him you may as well do it as early as possible.

SCaddict

If you believe in Steele as an option as I do then go for it. There was nothing we saw in Rd1 to discourage the view that many coaches had of him by time the JLT concluded and chose to start him. Of course it's a risk but given the cash generation issues we appear to have with the 2017 rookie class we need to seek out value wherever we can.

Then you can apply those hefty savings to patch up holes elsewhere in your side and potentially jump on some of those more expensive cash cows next week. So it gets the green tick from me. Structures don't count for much if you are fielding a bunch of spud rookies.

Abel

I'd go to steele

Jib_Jib

The big issue I see with Steele is that he's only played 18 games. With such limited experience I think it's totally unrealistic to expect him to maintain premium output, therefore you'll be just trading in a player who is going to need to be upgraded later. Steele is the type of player you either start with or avoid altogether.

Swans2012

For me he's the type of player you start with or wish you had, unless he cops a significant role change can't see him averaging less than 90, but as I've said many times I'm an optimist.

Jib_Jib

He would be doing extremely well to average 90 by the end of the year, would require him in increase his average by 27 points. How many 20-40 gamers increase their average by that much and/or are capable of averaging 90 for a season? Not many I bet. I think an 80ish average is much more realistic.

But I've been wrong before.

Swans2012

Very true, although I don't think he got a fair crack in the middle at his previous home, so his previous average while still relevant is not as relevant, especially with the saints seemingly letting him do what he's good at…. also gotta remember he's been in the system for a couple of years now, just hasn't had the opportunity, anyway good luck! I wish bloody cd would fix the scoring glitch!

Jib_Jib

A certain paige on fb has accurate updates each quarter if you need to check something

Swans2012

Ripper thanks, onto it

Dylan

Nick Riewoldt for Elliot Yeo is it worth a look at? Yeo went big last week and will help me make money to trade out Smith if I don't have enough rookies in defence to play this weekend

INPieman

Dylan. Before you ruin your season I suggest you do some research into Yeo the Yo Yo man. He is up & down & generally useless as a long term SC option. If your trading NRoo trade him to another premo
http://www.footywire.com/afl/footy/pu-west-coast-

Yeo
Year Games Average
2012 8 58.0
2013 19 61.9
2014 13 65.5
2015 21 82.1
2016 19 75.2
2017 1 139.0

That is not how you replace your F1

dan

that 2017 avg doe

John Smith

simply staggering

Abel

Premium, rookie or steele

Rocksta

You're kiddin yourself.
Yeo is in the top 5 burnmen category.
If you trade out Roo, you bring in another premium full stop!

Randomcliche2

I got the scar to prove it.

Jacob

Can anyone give me some thoughts?
Gotta trade Riewoldt and I'm looking at going either JJK, Buddy or higgins? Leaning toward Higgins because of his % owned!

Patch

Would go Buddy, Jacob – will be more consistent and has a good run coming up

Cash is boss.

Snag Higgins mate will be top 6 forward this year with his mid role safe as houses at a bargain price.

Crippler

I know the accepted wisdom is to wait until round three before pulling the trigger. However, with Joel Smith confirmed out for months and possibly needing to make more than one correctional trade next week i've gone;

Joel Smith OUT
Dan Butler IN

(through some DPP movements)

Finnius123

Try Hannan instead of Butler if you are going to. Will probably be more consistent.

Kev

If you haven't got Hannan, Crippler, he's the better option imo

Abel

Agree. They love Hannan

Jib_Jib

Did the same thing, can't see Butler being dropped before his 3rd game. Only real risk is injury, I'm prepared to roll that dice.

Darren

What about St Nick for Touk Miller???

Casey

i like this, Touk is looking on fire, i think its a consider

Finnius123

Risky

Abel

Maybe. Risky

Zoomer

Trading out Rooey Riewoldt – tossing up between J Macrae or Touk Touk Miller. Doggies under the roof against a depleted Swans are tasty, while Touk is only $428k and set to get more mid time minus Hanley… thoughts?

INPieman

Macrae every day of the week. He's proven. And Hanley will be back in 2 weeks

Blackie White

Touk goes well, though needs high possessions to score well as only a career 61% DE. Looks like he will get plenty of the ball though. You'll need to cover his Rd 9 bye, most likely with weak Rookie coverage.
I'm prob Higgins instead, excluding his injury risk, has similar role, but better DE & bye than Touk.
A lot depends on your teams injury risk profile and whether you're comfortable with that risk.

Martin

do i go Joel smith/ hibberd to mcgrath – option 1 (thinking hibberd so I can rookie loophole joel smith)
or taranto to hannan/Houston/butler and the Hibberd/Joel smitht up to zak jones

Kev

McGrath did absolutely nothing in JLT. Unless he was assured of a round one game he wouldn't have been going at half pace. Reluctant to jump on.

Prefer option two. Though it won't hurt waiting a week

Phil

Hello Kev, to say McGrath did nothing in the JLT is true in a SC sense, but he did play lockdown….and actually played quite well, hence why he was selected Round 1.
In Round 1 he got let loose and showed a lot of pace and good disposal. Now, Hawthorn possibly have the best 3 small forwards (collectively, not individually) in the competition, so if he didn't play lock down against them I can't see it happening. Add to that, Mark Baguley plays that role. Furthermore, they have just lost Michael Hibberd who was ther best rebounder up until last year and last years run and dash from McDonald Tippawuti is now in the forward line.
I see McGrath averaging very well for the season, but not as much as Marchbank.

Abel

All options OK. I'm gonna bring in McGrath and Hannan. Will which Jones again to assess role.

The Magpie Dentist

Only potential trade is Joel Smith to Hannan or Butler via DPP swap. How long should I stick with KK?

INPieman

I'd give KK 6 weeks then reassess

Flanno

Roughy down to Hoskin Elliot

Nic Newman/Vickers up to marchbank

Was hoping to keep roughy for the year but missing out on marchbank may put me behind in points and cash generation while hoskin elliot will make cash and hopefully average not too far behind roughy

JTread

why trade roughhead? and starting newman and EVW

Traders

I was just going to say the same thing? Fought possible keeper it was his first game back in over a yr.

Traders

Fought*

Traders

Roughy*

Juzzy

Watch the team sheets. EVW a good chance to get named and Newman an outside chance. Does seem you may be jumping the gun.

nope

nope

jimmy_raiders

Last Wednesday night I swapped Dusty for Cripps and boy did I pay for it. So this week trading Cripps back to Dusty even though it's a sideways trade, I need to maintain my sanity….

Casey

damn thats a very nice trade lol, keep it up aha

Jamie

Watch Dusty have a stinker tonight, Cripps will score 120+ ๐Ÿ˜‰

Happy Hippie

yeah mate lets not forget to have fun and enjoy ourselves.

Randomcliche2

Sleep soundly.

Tom

Holding McCarthy, Hibberd and Pickett for 1 more week if I can hold my nerve. Feel I may need to jump on Hannan up forward but where are all the good rookie defenders?

Casey

all the good Defender rooks are at 200k + mark, Marchbank, McGrath and Harrison Marsh

Tom

Have Marchbank and if the scores this week follow last week's may go McCarthy+Hibberd->Hannan+McGrath. Or not, not keen on McGrath's js

Leeds17

I think McCarthy will be fine looked much better when he started to roam late in the game.

Shake n bake

Newman to play this week

abdul

started the season with 6 premo fwds & 2 premo defenders + z.jones …….looks like the defender rookies have let me down big time and if i dont fix it now then it could be the end of my SC year …so the plan is to trade out one of my premo fwds …Lynch has copped the chop only because of his rd 9 bye and joining him will be the injured Joel smith …coming in will be WHE and marchbank to bring half decent scores aswell as being able to generate cash , which then gives me an extra $200k which will be spent on 2 more cash cows next week most likely A.McGrath & H.Marsh , which will then stabilize my defence and my entire team ….

Traders

I wouldn't trade out lynch….premo fwd….equals big mistake

abdul

i have 6 premo fwds ………i am lacking in defence ……..dont want to see anymore 23,44,46 scores in my defence ever again lol
by trading out 1 premo fwd and 3 rookie defenders i am receiving in return 4 decent cash cows that can all average 70-80+ and guaranteed job security …sometimes the coach has to make the bold moves ๐Ÿ™‚

Juzzy

Know where you're coming from but that move has the potential to eat up almost a third of your trades in the long run. Have you thought about bringing in a premo defender for lynch via dpp?

abdul

Juzzy…im $3k short on bringing in Adams ..( i hate when that happens lol) …., i can however get JJ but i really want my remaining 4 defensive premos to be the best 4 eventually , adams,simpson,shaw & Docherty … and even if i brought in adams then i wont be able to get WHE and ill be getting 1 of Hannan or Butler and im not too confident in either of them playing 7 games strait …so i got stuck with marchbank & WHE for now and hopefully they will generate enough cash and give me decent scores at the same time

Abel

Do what you need to do to balance your team. Cash generation may be more important than trades if you've missed the best rooks

abdul

yes Abel ..thats how i see it at the moment aswell

Randomcliche2

Well that is some quantum team plumbing. I hope your season doesn't go down the toilet….Marchy and Mr 120 WHE appear good picks in isolation….but as someone who runs out of trades it's still a little OTT.

Rivo

Hold this week, as if looks like Swallow will play. J.Smith donut can stay on the bench. Might swing in Berry if named next week as a DPP swing with Hibberd.

INPieman

Swallow is a confirmed starter

BadSupercoacher

Thinking of getting rid of Joel Smith and Callan ward for McGrath and Gaff or someone like Gaff
Thoughts?

INPieman

Hold fire. You don't trade Ward

Docker4life

Smith, Tarranto out for Hannon and Marchbank

SCaddict

Marchbank is definitely worth getting in either this week or next but I would probably give Taranto another go against the Suns, assuming he isn't dropped of course. Heaps of Giants flopped last weekend including many of their stars but you will be hating yourself if he has a good performance this weekend particularly if Hannan then does a disappearing act on Sunday.

If Taranto does get dropped tonight then by all means pull the trigger on those trades right away.

Abel

Only if you're gonna trade next week too. If not best to wait.

Micky_B

I have rooey and smith, worth using my trades this week or wating to see some more games until nest weekand potentially hold rooey? With some dpp i can have witts on for riewoldt and smith on the bench.

30 trades run out quickly so not sure what to do. Thinking of wating a week to see the rookies again for smith and hopefully riewoldt is back in 1-2

Seeker

Roo won't be back in 1-2. Split Synovial capsule which sits around and protects the knee joint. Leaking synovial fluid might cause the surrounding knee to develop scar tissue and also general, painful synovitis which could lead to arthritic reactions. So even though it is Roo, at his age I'd suggest the club will take a cautious approach to avoid surgery and give him 3-6 weeks to heal.

I'm not a doc by the way, just did a heap of research last night (I have him too)

Spencer

I like your thoroughness here

Lazza

two considerations … move this week in case you have more forced changes to make due to injuries that might occur in R2, you could end up snookered if you need 3 changes next week.
Or, wait till next week to ensure you are selecting the right rookies based on 2 rounds of scoring.

Both have risk.

TRIGGER HAPPY

Posted this one on earlier but as this is the avenue will post again:

Very tempted to trade hannas to Gawn. I went deep in the mids light up fwd, and Ryder R1.
I have SPP at M9.
Gawn trade would bring SPP on the ground at M8 which most teams have anyway, Ryder into Fwd line so relying on 1 less rook up Fwd and Gawn at R1.
I know you r not meant to trade Rd 1 but this is very good structurally I feel. Strengthens the fwd line, Ruck and puts a guy on the ground at M8 who most have there anyway?
Downside besides using a trade?

will watch butler tonight if he goes ok and looks like generating some good cash may need to pull the trigger on Hannas tomorrow as will need 2 trades for corrective rookie trades next week.

Finnius123

I like it. Risky but I think you got your structure wrong to start with so it is a hell of a lot better to correct it now than in 6 weeks time when SPP is averaging 75 and hanners pulls out with his knee. It is only one trade and without the doubt about Gawn and and Spencer Gawn is going to be gun this year.

I am considering something similar except getting rid of Roo. I will swing nankdaddy into the forward lines and bring in Gawn at R1. In order to do this I need to go Taranto for Hannan, but I think that this was always going to be inevitable as Hannan is 100k cheaper and will therefore make much more dosh. Furthermore I already have an upgrade in that I have the number one ruck in the comp, as well as now having back up for sandi in the forward line which I previously didn't.

I will try to make as little trades next week as possible, as I am pretty happy with my rookie structure other than this.

Affa's Mob

I'd never trade premo…. however that looks to be a great move. Do it now

Moustachio

Do not trade out Hanners. Gawn carrying back issue, could be the one to spud it this week.

Shake n bake

Just reversed my trade Trigg. left Nank as R1 for another week just scared with the Gawn noise.
No Trades for me.

Martin

thoughts on castagna

Russ in W.A

36 points…that is all ๐Ÿ™‚

Touk tuk

FWD – Roo to WHE

DEF- Smith to adams

Keenbutclueless

Congrats. Great trades.

Rufhead&SheSwallows

Hey community. Looking at trading Roo to the likes of Buddy? Or maybe JJK..
Also considering trading to Steele or Miller or Nank as this will allow me to upgrade one of my weak defensive rookies in to Mcgrath.. as I only have two premo defenders and marchbank. Cheers community. All thoughts and opinions welcome

INPieman

Think I've met you off Tinder. Roo to Buddy for mine

Finnius123

Definitely go Buddy. Picking a midpricer if you didn't at the start would be very risky as they are simply not proven. As Pieman keeps saying on other threads the goal is to get to full premium, so why would you get rid of one now! Furthermore Mcgrath is looking like he will get rested pretty consistently, as they really don't want the number one pick to go down

INPieman

Trading a premo down to a mid pricer or rookie will mean it takes you longer to get to full premo. Those that don't do that will get there before you

JEL

Going with Roo -> Buddy as well.

Also running with the same Def structure as you.
Will be giving my Def rookies a bit more time to see how it pans out.

I don't want to drop Roo to a Mid pricer as that is 2 more trades to fix to a Premo later.

Kevan

Traded Taranto to Hannan. Will keep ROO unless Butler scores less then 80, he has the E.

INPieman

TT to Hannan after 1 week. Brutal Kevan. It's crossed my mind but I'd like to see another week. TT & Hannan's scores could easily reverse this week

Kevan

Already hit the reverse button. Need to focus.

Russ in W.A

Good call, no point trading a spud for a spud and who knows what they are yet?

Patch

Going Roo to Howe via DPP sneakiness. Backline is a big pile of poo at the moment with Marchbank at D3, and I also need the 50k gained from that trade. Leaves my forward line extremely open but the rookies there seem okay. Have enough to go Smith-McGrath next week

INPieman

I like that Patch. I think a D3 is desperately needed with the rubbish defence rookies

TRIGGER HAPPY

Patch were you poppin prozac like lollies last week?
Thought 4 rook Def was a bridge to far this move is a good one makes sense just need to action before kick off tonight
McGrath next week all of a sudden a lot more sound down back

Patch

I was happy as Larry Thursday, but then things went very south very quickly. Hampton should turn it around but the rest are concerning at best. Pity Joel Smith was looking the most promising of the lot before Roo fell into his shoulder

SCaddict

I'm doing a very similar thing in AFL Fantasy Patch, using the NRoo injury to bolster a somewhat vulnerable looking backline. If Hibbo and/or Otts get dropped either this week or next it's going to leave plenty of coaches extremely thin down back.

Patch

Indeed – I've swung hibberd into the middle as part of this move. Think he might be okay, but Otten is absolutely gone in my humble opinion – Lever in is a like for like.

Seeker

Pretty good trades as long as you have plenty of scoring power in your forward line

Blackie White

I don't see the need to wait on Rooey, as have him too, and top deck looks solid but how confident are we in Hannan's JS?
Particularly, if he has a poor game this week, a more expensive rookie with better JS may be a better selection?
You're also weakening your fwd line for def line strength, so your making a correction to your structure also?

undypuncher

ive got nank at f3 and hoskin elliot at f5 amd bringinf johanison into my defemce gives me 4 premos there… dont like xhanging my structure but was planning on making my money on defence rookies and they are smelly

Randomcliche2

If you consider jj premo then it's fine. Premo for premo, especially as it appears the fwd rookies scored better/will need more of. I spent the Roo cash in the mids.

Chopsticks

Max Gawn subject to fitness test….

Craig

riewoldt to Steele? Thoughts

INPieman

See how Steele goes over in WA against the WC midfield. That will test him. Don't pull that trade this week. If you really want to trade Roo this week go to MacRae Buddy or JJK

Darby

Jackson Thurlow

Russ in W.A

He plays for Geelong.

Captain Risky

No Trades this week.. Holding Roo on the bench for this week just for clarity, but come next week he is out. ( have steele and Nank fwd already)
I've got Butler and Eddy on field as a result. Conditions didn't suit Eddy last week so I think he'll be better this week. (Was on bench last week thankfully)
Sure, I'll probably miss a few points but I can make a better decision next week. Tossing up Heppell, Oliver, Miller, Buddy, JJK etc too many options so I'll see what another week brings..$550K is a fair bit of patch up money so I want to spend it wisely.

SCaddict

You can certainly do that and it would in fact be the recommended initial course of action for all those who could loophole Butler on the bench tonight just in case he mega spuds. And if he does lay a nasty turd then you consider trading Roo straight up tomorrow.

Just be aware that next week is mainly about jumping on all the must have cows so you may need to use him for that purpose which would effectively see you miss out on potentially two weeks of premo scoring at F1. So long as you're cool with that then waiting always gives you another week of data to make better decisions with.

Captain Risky

Thanks, that's a good option for Butler.

I think I've got all the main cash cows except Hannan, ( pending week 2 performances..) so don't need to fix up much next week at this stage. A Sandiwitts ruck combo helped ๐Ÿ™‚

Dukes

It pains me having to trade roo. Im unable to decide on a premo to trade him for so im trading him down to hannan who i view as a must have and holding on to the cash til next week where ill be looking at upgrading hibberd/picket if they fail to give me somthing this week

Box

I'll be there!

Cliffy

The main conundrum only for me is J.Smith this week, and as tempting as it is to bring in Hannan already for this week, potentially I could utilise Smith (pending the rest of Rd 2 team selections tonight) as a D6 loophole for Otten/Stewart. What do you reckon about that idea community?

Cliffy

I would use Smith also to get Hannan in next week thanks to DPP links I should mention also.

Cliffy

Or Taranto could become Hannan next week to generate cash even potentially, should Taranto have another poor game, not going to write him off yet however.

Cliffy

I also thought of the idea of going Smith – McGrath if he can back up what he did in an impressive Rd 1 debut. DPP eligibility is also a nice feature too for McGrath.

Tony

I'm also sitting on Smith to loophole Otten / Stewart. Then he's out next week, probably for Hannan via DPP unless he spuds it up this weekend. Not convinced of McGrath's scoring potential for SC, but he will be a super footballer for many years to come.

My priority next week is to get Marchbank in. Haven't worked out how to get the cash to do it with 2 likely rookie trades, though.

lewy hewy

do I hold hanners for 1 more week

INPieman

No. You hold him for the next 22

The Wyld One

roughhead and otten out for Hoskin-Elliot and Marsh

12345

Need thoughts community,
If I trade roo to Steele/miller that means i have cash for rookie corrections next week.

But if I trade roo to buddy i have no money for rookie corrections and since I have smith I might need to downgrade Taranto to hannan next week to make smith into Mcgrath or someone. even if Taranto scores well I might still need to trade him to Make sure I dont get a donut in defence.

Urgently need thiughts????

12345

Plz need thiughts I'm stuck

Jib_Jib

Don't trade Roo to Steele.

Tom

Should I sideways Robbie gray or hold for another week and evaluate then…

INPieman

Definitely have another look. His price isn't changing this week

Youngy

Hold

SCaddict

Hold but if he plays again mainly up forward and under performs then you may have to jettison him next week. Having an unfavourable role change change that appears it could be permanent is one of the few scenarios where you could justify a premo sideways. Goldy owners may have a similar worry on their hands if he again spends plenty of time up forward for the Roos this weekend.

However you really have to give 50 Shades at least one more week just in case he kicks 4 goals and has 25+ touches at home against a struggling Freo outfit.

BestCoastEagles

Tom the word sideways should never be used specially in round two, hold your horses and emotion in tact.

Daniel

Hold!!

Steeeve

Definitely not! Although talk of him spending more time forward worries me and players who cop early head knocks often struggle for a few weeks after.

Marc

Don't understand why anyone has to trade this week, I started with Hickey in ruck, yes I do have Taranto, rookie Smith on the bench in my backline. I am happy to see what happens this round as the comp doesn't start till Rd 3. Remember trades are not to be taken lightly we may need them for the byes, finals. Anyone else have the same views!!!!!

Jib_Jib

Well since you don't have any injuries to premo players I can understand why you don't need to trade this week. I wish I was that lucky.

Imgonnalose

Should I vc Pendles or Shaw this week?

INPieman

Pendles. Don't think Shaw will see much of the ball down back this week

Imgonnalose

True – was just thinking about his record at spotless

BestCoastEagles

De-Pendlebury

Liam

Trading out Roo.
Can either go to Buddy or Howe.

If I go Buddy I have an extra rookie on field in defence (out of Stewart,Otten,Hibberd) and if I go Howe then I have an extra forward rookie on (out of Eddy or Pickett).

Daniel

Buddy for sure mate!!

Daniel

Want to Riewoldt out to either yeo, higgins or nankervis?? Thoughts???

To free up cash to trade smith to marchbank.

Daniel

OR Riewoldt to kennedy and smith to otten?

redherringfc

I have a lot of spare cash, i know the wisdom is wait until round 2 to trade but can anyone tell me a reason not to straight swap Smith to Laird.

Seb

Why would anyone tell you not to do that you have an injury and if you can correct it to a premo defintaky do it

INPieman

If you have enough cash to do that, what are you waiting for!

SCaddict

Don't even blink twice – Laird is close to a must have mate and he's not going to get much cheaper any time soon.

redherringfc

thanks. it was done monday morning, just wanted confirmation.

Steeeve

If you have the cash for that just go for it or else you have an injured player (wasted) and a huge warchest that could be earning you points (also being wasted).

John James

Going against the SC law and trading in the first week,but they were really only guidelines anyway.So trading out Smith,which is a shame since he was playing well till he was injured,trading in,Laird who of cause will be a keeper,until he get's injured.The the second trade happens so I can afford the first,Taranto out for Hannan,who I was interested in to start with,but didn't pick,since he had no preseason games.So overall I think this should be a positive outcome for my team.

Steeeve

Love the amount of people trading out premos for mid-pricers. Always the most entertaining week in Supercoach.

Seb

Most are doing it for cash for rookie corrections

SCaddict

Yes if you've got a lot of holes to patch up in the next fortnight it can make a lot of sense to at least consider the standout midpriced options. Although you should really only be ditching injured premos like NRoo this week and not the simple under performers like Hanners, Cripps and Hickey.

And if you are going the midpriced route you should really only be selecting ones that have some basis behind them, like a role change or an opportunity to shine at a new club, not just solely because they scored huge in Rd1.

jack

Wanna trade roughead out for someone else
Should i do it and who should i get
got 7000 to spare

jack

someone please help me

INPieman

Roughead

Browncow

To the point, sound advice and entertaining. Post of the week for mine

Steeeve

I'm holding him. If he puts up a sub-80 this week I will drop him for Hannan.

redherringfc

don't do it.

Stupid Coach

Thinking of making only the one trade this week – Roo to either JJK, Buddy or Lynch (GC). Already have Steel and Dalhaus.

Keeping Smith in DEF in case I can use him for loophole purposes and will look to trade him out next week.

Will also look at trading Treloar or Ward to Pendles (corrective trade) next week depending on how each of them performs this week.

Thoughts ???

SCaddict

Looks like back soreness wasn't enough to send shock waves through Gawn ownership circles this week. Now's there a wrist to worry about. Better keep him away from DeGoey's dog for the next few days! ๐Ÿ™‚

http://www.afl.com.au/news/2017-03-30/maxs-wristy

Dave

Seriously FFS!!! It's almost like he's destined to miss this week. I give up Supercoach is too hard.

Cliffy

I am an owner, I'm still thinking he'll be alright come Sunday.

Finnius123

Spencer is in now aswell…

Traders

Bet yawn a late out

Traders

Gawn

Ty Webb

Anyone with Reiwoldt considering trading in Charlie Cameron? I don't have Reiwoldt but if I did I'd be very tempted. Don't know how I missed him during the preseason but Cameron fits the bill age/games wise for a big breakout year and his performance against GWS was delicious! I don't think the Crows gave him 23 for no reason.

Captain Risky

Will be watching this week.. Tempting.

Ty Webb

Definitely. !4 CP and 8 CL in round 1 seems to make it obvious he's now part of the Crows' first choice midfield rotation along with Sloane and Crouch. I'm almost hoping I get an LTI in my forward line this week ๐Ÿ˜›

Jib_Jib

He didn't exactly light up JLT. Rd 1 was his highest ever score.

I didn't see the Crows game – is he rotating through the midfield or did he just have an outlier?

Ty Webb

Could be an outlier JJ. It looked like he was getting a fair bit of midfield time against GWS to me but don't have centre bounce attendance numbers to back that up.

Jib_Jib

Could be the shark move of the year. Could ruin my season.

Ty Webb

lol maybe. Can't see him averaging below last year. Where does one get CB stats from?

Ty Webb

I traded out Turner and Smith for Hannan and Marchbank. That gives me those 2, Mcgrath, Butler, Witts, SPP and Florent as rookies I have reasonable confidence in

deeman

I've done the same exceot swapped smith for Laird instead

Cliffy

Hey if Taranto was to be and out for team selections tonight and not play this Round, is that a legitimate enough reason to move him on for Hannan? I'd think that he'd be alright to go for another run this Round, but just wondering.

Cliffy

*an out

Chook

i dont have eitber player yet, but I'd hold Taranto until next week. Hannan could get injured or dropped next round and you'll have egg on your face if you'd got him in early.

Chook

Would appreciate your advice community.
I think I'm settled on making 1 trade this week. I currently have 2 non playing rookies in defence. If Vickers-Willis isn't named i want to burn him off and bring in T Stewart or Hannam. how do you rate their respective job security?
Cheers!