FINAL Supercoach Rate My Team Thread

Published by Jock on

Rate My Team


All that is left now is to review team selections and make those final touches to our Supercoach 2017 lineups. We want to wish all of you extremely well over a crucial next 24 hours, and look forward to having a look at your teams in the comments below.
Make sure you’ve listened into our pre lockout podcast, where Higgo, Crouching and I run through our Supercoach teams.
You can also review my Supercoach team here
Hope to see you down at a CoachKings Venue this weekend! Click here to check for your nearest venue, and get yourself a slice of the $70,000 up for grabs this season!




Notify of
Newest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments

Have a gander at my first genuine crack at a side for 2017…
$10,200k left, never started a season with less than $60,000k in the chest!

DEFENDERS: K. Simpson, T. Adams, R. Laird, C. Marchbank, A. Otten, E. Vickers-Willis (N. Newman, T. Stewart)
MIDS: P. Dangerfield, J. Kennedy, A. Treloar, M. Priddis, M. Bontempelli, N. Fyfe, D. Beams, J. O’Meara (S. Powell-Pepper, J. Barrett, T. Bayok)
RUCKS: T. Nankervis, A. Sandilands (L. Strnadica)
FORWARDS: L. Dalhaus, J. Caddy, J. Roughead, T. Taranto, J. Pickett, B. Parfitt (D. Houston, B. Eddy)

All thoughts appreciated!

Cookie Monster

Cookie cutter 100%


Get some PODS


Disagree. Caddy is a POD. Priddis is a POD, even Bont is a POD. No Hampton is a huge POD.

No ruck cover for the risky lineup would be my biggest concern

Brothers FC

Its Rd 1 we don't need pods

Nick Fucking Duigan

Reckon you need to sacrifice at least one gun mid to add depth up forward. Caddy and Roughy both carry a bit of risk…think you need at least one more proven gun. Also risky ruck strategy…speaking from painful experience. I'd go Sandi or Nank and a safer option.


You need Hampton mate


Appreciate the feedback everybody!


Whack ed curnow in there mate and you can thank me later.

Brendan Casey

Hey! How do you rate my team?

B: K Simpson, H Shaw, R Murphy, C Marchbank, C Hampton, A Otten (Vickers-Willis, T-Stewart)

M: Danger, Pendles, Bont, Fyfe, Heppell, Jaeger, D Swallow, S Powell-Pepp (Wigg, J Pickett J Atley)

R: Gawn, Sandilands, (Strnadica)

F: Franklin, Lynch, P Ryder, Fantasia, Taranto, Butler, (Houston, Eddy)

Brendan Casey

I have $131k remaining. Not confident in my forward set up, And gone bit risky with fyfe, jaeger, swallow.
Any suggestions greatly appreciated!


Macrae and Dahlhaus for franklin and lynch for more stability

Brendan Casey

Good call on Dahlhaus. I'm thinking Toby Greene over Macrae though.

Brendan Casey

And i have enough money in the bank to keep franklin, and upgrade Ryder to Greene.


That would mean no cover for Sandi.

Brendan Casey

mmm good point. Tough one.


Wouldn't go R.Murphy with a 10 foot pole. Injury prone


This comment will probably never be seen but Geez you had a rough 2017


Please let me know what you think of my team! Most of the difference is in the midfield:
DEF: Simpson, Laird. Marchbank, Otten, Hibberd, EVW (Gutherie, Stewart)

MID: Danger, Pendles, Priddis, T.Mitchell, M.Crouch, B.Vince. Taranto, Powell-Pepper (Barrett, Miles, Parfitt)

RUC: Gawn, Sandilands (Strnadica)

FWD: JJK, Dahlhaus, Franklin, Higgins, Nankervis, Eddy (Pickett, Houston)

$68,100 left in bank.
Chose a few of these players because of the trading options between lines!
Let me know what you think,
Thank you!!


I question crouch, vince and Taranto in the midfield


Very cookie cutter


Vince is playing across half back. I'd look at getting a premium midfielder isn't easy of him


Any money leagues spots available




Have a feeling Rockliff will have a huge season this year


No chance!!


Why do you say that?


I just can't be bothered. Don't trust the bloke one bit. Rather Treloar or Selwood. Or JPK or Hanners. All similarly priced and much more durable.


I'm with you on this one , big risk but could be a big pay off considering the points he is capable of and does it in a losing team.


Definately agree. Gut says rocky is gonna go huge.


Could be a massive POD ..big risk, big reward


I feel I'm ready to finally leave this team alone & take it into Round 1!
What's your thoughts?

Def: Shaw, Adams, Laird, Marchbank, Hampton, Otten (EVW, Stewart)

Mid: Dangerfield, JPK, Treloar, Fyfe, S Mitchell, Beams, O'Meara, SPP (Barrett, Miles, Parfitt)

Rucks: Nankervis, Sandilands (Cameron)

Fwd: Dahlhaus, Franklin, Roughead, Steele, Hoskin-Elliott, Taranto (Eddy, Butler)


Very cookie cutter. If you're just in it for the leagues then you'll be alright. IF you're out to win the $50k then I would consider going a few PODS.
Also not sold on Steele


We all have a few that we aren't sold on this year. Mid-price mayhem! Steele has a high ceiling if he plays in the midfield.. in my opinion he will! high risk, high reward Flubber


Like the Smitch selection Robbie! Conscious decision to not run a strategic donut?


Cheers Patchy! I'm backing in Nankilands. High risk, high reward


Adams & Pickett (playing Eddy/Houston) on field


Mills & WHE/Florent (playing one of these two)


Also final thoughts on Steele vs Roughy?


I'm going with both!


I would go Adams & Pickett over the second option

I would also go Roughy over Steele. Not sold on Steele


Adams and pickett just named as starting winger

Zac Dawson

Anyone remember….JP Kennedy scores used to always be affected whenever Tom Mitchell seeing Mitchell's gone, big season for JPK?



Clock Management

He will play more fwd this season, hanners and Parker are better picks.

Busted Nuts

Indeed with Titch gone JPK's grunt inside will be needed more than ever. A huge year coming up!


Has the captaincy now too!


All the Sydney big three will have great years. All will be cheaper at some point anyway.


hey guys
here is my side…

Adams,Laird, Lloyd, Hampton, Otten, EVW (Stewart,Guthrie)
Danger, Pendles, JPK, Treloar, Fyfe, Mitchell, Beams, SPP (Hibberd,Parfitt, Junker)
Nank, Sandi (Preuss)
Dahlhaus, Buddy, Ryder, Roughead, Taranto, Florent (Eddy, Butler)

Thinking about howe in for adams and either tuohy or mills for lloyd?

Any help appreciated and good luck to all this season


What's your reasoning for picking Lloyd?

Ryder also a tough pick. Are you picking him just for the swapping capabilities with Nank?


not much reasoning behind lloyd, i thought he was the best option for 460k. Ryder is in there in case sandi goes down


Natural progression, ultra durable and confidence. I believe should average 95+. Freako likes him too. He's taking him over Adams.

Mikhunt Izichi

For some reason I do not like Adams. I'd go with Howe – he will be more reliable i reckin plus he is cheaper


Thanks Mikhunt


Love the Lloyd pick – back yourself on that one! Howe will have more durability but Adams will average 5/10 points more, so if you want to take the risk on him go for it, but you know you'll get 20+ games out of Howe, and we're praying we'll get that from Adams


Thanks so much Patch, In regards to ryder, are there any better options for a similar price. I have roughy at f4 and and nankilands in the ruck.

Anthony Williams

Doch, shaw, tuohy, marchbank, hampton stewart (vickers willis, otten)

Danger pendles Selwood trelore kenedy Fyfe beams SPP (Barrett, hibberd, parfitt)

Nankervis Sandilands (strnadica)

Rewoildt, Dahlhaus, roughy, Taranto, Pickett, Houston (eddy, black)

23k leftover…


What's your reasoning for picking Tuohy? Haven't heard about him all preseason!

Anthony Williams

Haven't been watching then?
All Geelong do out of defence is look for him.
He averaged over 110 in jlt most effective disposals I think too.. I'm a Geelong supporter so I may be biased but him danger Selwood will make the games extra fun


Agree, if you re not having fun, why play?
It's only a game 🙂


Are u being sarcastic?




My SuperCoach team
Thoughts and feedback much appreciated
Docherty T.Adams Laird
Marchbank Hampton Otten
(Vickers-Willis Stewart)

Dangerfield Pendlebury Kennedy
Fyfe Beams O'meara Taranto Powell-Pepper
(Barret, Pickett, Hibberd)

Gawn Sandilands (Stranadica)

Dahlhaus Mcrae Greene
Roughead Hoskin-Elliot Bowes
(Houston, Eddy)


If Beams is a keeper, then 6 keepers out in round 11 might be a problem


Are you confident that playing BOTH Hampton and Marchbank is the best use of your money? They're both expensive rookies.

Also what's your reasoning for picking Greene? He's been very inconsistent over the past few years


Everyone is saying you NEED to pick PODs to be in the chance for the 50k.
However when someone throws in a POD, they are always heavily criticized about their selection.
Trust your gut. Its going to be an interesting supercoach season!


Def: Simpson, Adams, Laird, Marchbank, Otten, V-W (Otten, Stewart)
Mid: Danger, Pendles, Fyfe, T.Mitchell, O'Meara, Horlin-Smith, SPP (Barrett, Pickett, Hibberd)
Ruck: Goldstein, Sandilands (Strndica)
For: Dahl, Buddy, Lynch, Roughy, Hoskin-Elliot, Taranto (Parfitt, Eddy)

$73,400k left over, cheers guys!


** Hampton at D5


Very solid team for league wins. Won't win you the 50k though because it's very cookie cutter. IF you're here for the big win then take a few risks somewhere


Ah yes, Beams


I think this is a solid team. Enough difference from the rest it could give you a slight upper hand, but too different to open yourself up to risk


Not too different*


D: Doc, Shaw, Laird, Marchbank, Hampton, EVW (Stewart, Otten);
M: Danger, Pendles, JPK, Fyfe, M.Crouch, JOM, Swallow, SPP (Barrett, Hibberd, Parfitt);
R: Gawn, Sandi (Strnadica);
F: Dahl, Franklin, Roughy, Nank, Taranto, Pickett (Eddy, Miles).


First time poster but thought I would put my team up before rd 1.
Pretty new to supercoach have gone for a lot of breakout/bargain picks mixed with some tried and true players;
I don't want to follow the crowd big bob murphy fan so he has to start in my team.
$25k left.

Simpson, Lloyd, bob murphy, jones, Hampton, EVW, (Stewart, gutherie)
Pendlebury, JPK, Zorko, Fyfe, Bontempelli, M Crouch, J Kelly, JOM. (SPP, Barrett. Pickett)
Sandi, Witts. (Cameron)
Riewoldt, McCrae, Hogan, Nank, Bowes, Florent (butler, Eddy)

Rookies will change based teams.

how did I go?


Good start! I would make a few changes
– Bob Murphy I don't trust. Huge injury last year he'll be shaky to start
– What's your reasoning for going with Jones in DEF? He only averaged 54.3 last year

– J.Kelly had a good year last year, true for his price. BUT Essendon are getting their premos back, so his scores will be affected greatly. I would rethink that pick

– Your R1 always should be a keeper for the whole season (hopefully). So with this setup you think that Sandi will be your R1 for the whole year?

– Hogan is a good FWD for melbourne, but for SC relevance i'm not sold. He is a key forward and they generally don't score a lot if they don't kick bags of goals every week. He'll have a few games 120+ but then will also have games where he scores 30

Hope this helps! 🙂


Thanks for you feedback flubber
bob I guess is just a go with your heart thing – he is cheap so I am willing to start out with him
zac jones I think will be put more into the midfield for the swans like the JLT 3 game. He will be given some of tom mitchells mid time. I believe he is underpriced for a player that will have a fair bit of midfield time this season.
J Kelly is Josh not James Kelly, I think he will break out this year for GWS
Going cheap in the rucks so I can beef up the midfield with Nank in the forward line
Hogan I see as a pod. Looks like he is going to play a bit more up the ground like riewoldt this year. Liked him during the preaseason. Hopefully he gets rid of those 30's to become a good pick.

Georgy Jones

Love the Zorko pod.


Selwood or JPK? And who should be my D1?


Selwood for me. But i'm just biased and don't like JPK.

D1 should be one of either:
– Docherty
– SImpson
– Shaw


Simmo's old and nothing special just consistent so he must drop one year


All the way with JPK for me buddy. Selwood is one of those players who can fc*k with you out of nowhere through either a mysterious form dip, some sort of injury niggle or have a patch where he just can't deal well with a tag. Almost like clockwork you count on picking him up significantly cheaper around the byes. There are reasons his starting ownership is so low so don't get sucked in. Also think the Cats list is over rated so they could have bit of a reality check this season and fall out of the 8. If they're seriously considering playing Taylor forward to kick them a bag well then they've got some major worries the way he kicks the sherrin. It wouldn't surprise me if the Dockers roll them handily this weekend. Get on Laird or Adams for your D1.


Selwood and Doch


Backline : doch, shaw, laird, march, Hampton, otten (Stewart, Guthrie)

Mid: danger, hanners, treloar, Fyfe, titch, beams, sps, Taranto (spp, Barrett, Pickett)

Ruck: sandi, witts (Strndica)

Forward: Kennedy, Dahl, buddy, nank, whe, florant (parfitt, eddy)

Thoughts? Trying to figure out if I keep Kennedy up forward or not, what is everyone's opinions on Kennedy or who is the best forward other then buddy and Dahl, need opinions on my rookies too

Also have 108k left


418986 code for A graders


Butler or Pickett on-field for round 1? And if possibly justify your choice.Good luck to you all community




Butler. Looks more like Brad Pitt.


Pickett. More secure role at the blues


Butler. Because I'm answering after the game.


Def: Doch,Shaw, Laird, Hampton, Otten, EVW (Hibberd, Stewart)

Mid: Dangerfield, JPK, Selwood, Fyfe, Priddis, M. Crouch, Taranto, SPP (Barrett, Miles, Parfitt)

Rucks: Grundy, Sandilands (Strandica)

Fwd: Riewoldt, Dahlhaus, Greene, Roughead, Butler, Eddy (Pickett, Houston)

Tossing up between PRIDDIS/T.MITCHELL/WARD/STEVEN thats probably the only spot I'm not set on, would love to know your thoughts community!


Biased hawks supporter but Mitchell will be massive this


Mitchell for mine too!


Titchell by daylight.




backs : shaw, docherty, adams, hampton, ed vickers willis, stewart, otten and zach guthurie
Mids : danger, pendles, fyfe, priddis, cripps, beams, SPP, barret, parfitt, picket and florent
Rucks: Gawn and sandilands
Fowards: riewoldt, dalhause, caddy, nankervis, eddy, houstan, butler and cameron

should i change gawn and zach guthurie to grundy and marchbank


DEF: Doc, Shaw, Laird, Marchbank, Hampton, VW (Newman,Otten)
MID: Danger, Pendles, JPK, Cripps, Fyfe, Beams, Swallow, SPP (Barret, Hibberd, Parfitt),
RUCK: Gawn, Sandi (Strndica)
FWD: Dahl, Macrae, Rough, TT, Pickett, Butler (Houston, Eddy)

Thoughts Community?

Still not sure on


I'm guessing a carlton supporter


nah mate dons


Carlton are cheap for their value this year


All good options. Go adams and crisps and bank some cash


Not chicken or plain. Maybe kettle chilli?


DEF: K.Simpson, t. Adams, laird, hampton, otten, vickers
MID: danger, gaz, treloar, gray, fyfe, beams, jaeger, SPP
RUC: goldy, sandi
FWD: dahl, macrae, caddy, roughy, butler, pickett
I know gaz is a risk but its one im willing to take


Love the gray and gaz call. Risky, but great lads to watch.


Alright, I think choosing Waite and Vlaustin are good choices for you


Def: Adams; Vince; Touhy; Mills; Hampton; McInnes (Hibberd, Stewart)
Mid: Danger; Hanneberry; Fyfe; T Mitchell; Gaff; D Beams; Omeara; D Swallow (Powell-pepper, Barrett, Freeman)
Ruck: Nankervis; Sandilands (Cameron)
Fwd: N Reiwoldt; Kennedy; Roughead; Steele; Z Cordy; Eddy (Pickett, Miles)

$6,500 Left over, Thanks everyone…


Cordy is interesting pick.. Look at will hoskin- Elliott or Taranto


Or McCarthy


Haven't seen mcinnes or cordy in many teams. Do you know something we don't know?



Def: Docherty, Adams, Laird, Hampton, Otten, Stewart (Macreadie, Guthrie)

Mid: Danger, Treloar, Bontempelli, Fyfe, T Mitchell, Beams, O'meara, Powell-Pepper (Pickett, Parfitt, Fox)

Rucks: Ryder, Sandi (Strnadica)

Fwd: Dahlhaus, Franklin, Macrae, Roughead, Nankervis, Butler (Houston, Eddy)


Good to see macreadie there. Think he'll go well if he gets a run.


At the moment he's an emergency


Def: Docherty, Adams, Laird, Tuouy, Hampton, EVW ( Otten, Stewart)

Mid: Danger, Pendles, Treloar, Fyfe, T.mitchell, Beams, SPP, Barrett ( Picket, Miles, Parfitt)

Rucks: Gawn, Sandi (strnadica)

Fwd: Riewoldt, Dalh, Nankervis, Taranto, Florent, Eddy (Butler, Houston)
7.7k in the bank

Thoughts would much appreciated


Florent being on field in questionable


Yeah not to sure on the rookies this year, who do suggest swapping him for


Florent on the field I rate.


Hi when are teams released?


6:25pm AEDT today for Tiges v Blues then the same time tomorrow for all the other 8 games. Then around 6pm Friday the Sunday extended benches get culled which is obviously ultra critical for all our rookie selections and final team structures.


Abit hard for picking rookies, wow


Thanks scaddict


Thoughts on my team would be much appreciated!
Strong emphasis on keepers with the exception of the rucks.

S. Docherty, R. Laird, J. Howe, (T. Stewart)
T.Adams, C. Hampton, E. V-Willis (Z. Guthrie)

P. Dangerfield, M. Crouch, L. Neale (H. Wigg)
A. Treloar, N. Fyfe, D. Beams (J. Pickett)
S. P-Pepper, J. Barret (B. Parfitt)

A. Sandilands, J. Witts (D. Cameron)

N. Riewoldt, L. Dalhaus, J. Macrae (L. Strnadica)
T. Lynch, D. Butler, D. Houston (B. Eddy)


One too many premo defenders and I question Croich and Neale


Neale, 23yo, last two seasons 104, 112…. can only see improvement with a fit Sandilands and Fyfe around him in the middle, a genuine accumulator of the footy. And Crouch is my breakout contender, as Jock has alluded to, only needs to up his TOG to be a elite midfielder.


Neale will have a shit one because Fyfe will take half his possessions


Neale had 37 touches and Fyfe had 38 in the last JLT game


Agree. Will score big with genuine premos in defence and attack


If your ruck risk pays off, this is an excellent side.

The forward rookies look weak. Reckon both Parfitt and Pickett will score better than Butler and Houston. Reckon you should get rid of one of them at a minimum and bring Parfitt or Pickett down to create a DPP swing.


Like it. Different and strong.


Very good side. I am not sure about Lynch, merely from a consistency point of view. But will certainly get some big scores.
Really good team!
Kick it to me… kick it to me….


I like your style and thinking.. what are your thoughts on my team at the moment?

Backs: Adams, Laird, Lloyd, Marchbank, Hampton, Otten / Vickers-Willis, Stewart
Mids: Danger, Hannebery, Selwood, Treloar, Fyfe, Beams, O'Meara, Powell-Pepper / Barret, Picket, Atley
Rucks: Sandilands, Witts / Cameron
Forwards: Dahlhaus, Macrae, Greene, Roughead, Nankervis, Taranto / Butler, Eddy

Hope to generate the cash to upgrade the backs and rucks before the byes.

Do me no favours, criticize to the max!


never done this before but some feed back would be greatly appreciated. Finished last year ranked 614 but have drastically changed my structure this year due to the very shallow mid rookie pool;

B: Shaw, Laird, Adams, Marchbank, Hampton, Vickers-Willis (Otten, Stewart)
M: Dangerfield, Pendlebury, Hannebery, Treloar, Fyfe, TMitchell, D. Beams, SPP (Barret, Hibberd, Parfit)
R: Sandilands, Witts (Strnadica)
F: Dahlhaus, Macrae, , Roughead, Nankervis, Taranto, Pickett (Houston, Eddy)

Pretty satisfied across all line and while my rucks represent a massive gamble i have Nank in the forward line to hopefully bail me out if shit hits the fan.


I'd downgrade Pendlebury or Hannebery for a swallow of JOM




Nankervis isn't going to bail you out… He is the one you will need bailing out FROM. 3 injury prone rucks is not considered ruck cover.


Hi guys, have not stopped tinkering with my side for weeks, now I'm almost set on what I've got here! Think I may be too midfield heavy but am happy with that as they're mostly all proven. Tossing up between Roughy and Nank as he would be good cover for Sandi. Would love them both but like my set up as is unless there are any suggestions?
Would love any feedback, cheers!

Back: H. Shaw, T. Adams, R.Laird, C. Marchband, C. Hampton, E.Vickery-Willis (A. Otten, T. Stewart)
Mids: P. Dangerfield, J.P. Kennedy, J. Selwood, A. Treloar, N. Fyfe, D. Beams, J. O'meara, S. Powell-Pepper (J. Barrett, J. Pickett, B. Parfitt)
Rucks: M. Gawn, A. Sandilands (L. Strnadica)
Forwards: L. Dahlhaus, J. Macrae, J. Roughead, W. Hoskin-Elliot, T. Taranto, B. Eddy (D. Butler, D. Houston)


Could you afford the swap Jack Steele for Hoskin-Elliot, if not I would downgrade Selwood a bit and then get Steele in, he will be a cash cow


Not sure about Steele yet Sauce, have tried to steer clear of mid price players unless they're coming back from injury and have proven they can do it before. Selwood would be the one to down grade if I did need the cash for Nank in the forward line as cover. But I'm not sure I can make up that sort of money without playing another on field rookie in the mid field (which they're aren't many of who can score well consistently).


should I get swallow or JOM


Agreed, he's definatly a Steele trap


Thoughts community?

Def: Simpson, Laird, How's
Mills, Marchbank, Hampton (Stewart, Guthrie)

Mids: Dangerfield, Pendlebury, Hanners, Fyfe,
T.Mitchell, JOM, SPP, Taranto (Miles, Parfitt, Hibberd)

Ruck: Nank, Sandi (strandica)

Fwd: Roo, Dahlhause, Lynch gcs
Roughy, Eddy, Butler (Cameron, tbc)

Mikhunt Izichi

hey would appreciate any feedback:





I think Greene is actually a good pick this year, I had him last year and he pulled out some whopping scores between his poo. I am confident with his age and experience now that you really need to be picking him. If he finds consistency (which i believe he will) he will be a weapon for SC – and a bargain at his current price.

I also rate Howe & Hickey. Big risks with O'Meara , Swallow, Beams tho. If O'meara and Swallow can stay on the park for a few games at the start of the year, it will generate serious but. but will check teams tonight and decide if I roll the dice!


I like the Mills pod those sydney kids never seem to be infected by the chronic 2nd year blues we see in Melbourne so im expecting his average to increase this year.


Sorry, bit of a computer glitch.

You are the first person I have seen who has gone in with Ward. He will be a consistent high performer for you (unless he gets knocked out early).


O'meara or swallow

Beams or swallow


I've gone Swallow. Lower risk lower reward. Cheaper. Round 9 bye so can flick him earlier.


Backs: Docherty, Shaw, Tuohy, Murphy, Otten, Hibberd (EVW, Ryan)

Mids: Danger, Treloar, Fyfe, T. Mitchell, Beams, Swallow, Taranto, SPP (Brodie, Barrett, Pickett)

Rucks: Gawn, Sandi (Strandica)

Fwds: Kennedy, Dahlhaus, Greene, Roughead, Hoskin-Elliott, Eddy (Butler, Parfitt)


Reckon Hampton is a must have. Take out Brodie, bring Hibberd down.


G'day Community! Here 'tis…… for now

Shaw, Lloyd, Jones, Hampton, EVW, Hibberd, Stewart, Guthrie

Danger, Treloar, Zorko, Fyfe, T.Mitchell, Barlow, Beams, Oliver, Powell-Pepper, Barrett, Parfitt

Sandi, Witts, Cameron

Dahlhaus, Buddy, Nankers, Rough, Steele, Taranto, Butler, Eddy

A few risks there! Any feedback appreciated! Good luck all. Enjoy your last minute tinkering!

Boltons Blues

Doc, shaw, marchbank, Hampton, Otten, EVW (Hibbered,Stewart
Danger, pendles, Kennedy, Selwood, Fyfe, Titch, JOM, SPP (parafit, miles, atley)
Sandi, Nank (Witts)
Riewoldt, Dahl, McRae, Steele, Taranto, Eddy (Pickett, Houston )


Hi community,
Thoughts on my team below please

Back: H. Shaw, Docherty , R.Laird, C. Marchband, C. Hampton, E.Vickery-Willis (Hibber,Guthrie)
Mids: P. Dangerfield, HannersJ. Selwood, A. Priddis, N. Fyfe, D. Beams, J. O'meara, S. Powell-Pepper (J. Barrett, J. Atley. Fox)
Rucks: Grundy, A. Sandilands (L. Strnadica)
Forwards: L. Dahlhaus, Roo, Buddy, T. Taranto, B. Eddy Parfitt (D. Butler, D. Houston)


Love the Hanners pick. I can't fit him at the moment but he usually starts the season on fire


Rate my team and feedback would be awesome

Def: Shaw, Adams, Laird, Tuohy, Hampton, Otten (EVW, Stewart)

Mid: Dangerfield, Pendlbury, Treloar, Fyfe, Beams, Clayton Oliver, Swallow, SPP (Barrett, Hibberd, Pickett)

Rucks: Gawn, Sandilands (Witts)

Fwd: Dahlhaus, Macrae, Roughead, Taranto, Houston, Parfitt (Eddy, Butler)

Tuohy will have a big year, not many choices in the backline, not much of a risk.

Clayton Oliver, may be bias as i am a melbourne supporter, but i watched him closely in the last few weeks, he will play in the centre, a big clearance machine, will rack up lots of points. Will get over $500K after first couple of rounds.

Gawn, surprisedly became more of a pod in the last few weeks, will be top 2 by seasons end, Spencer will not play every game. Gawn is worth a coin.

Had a few left over money so upgraded a rookie ruckman to Witts. Witts will play all year. Wont score big but will reach over $400K then trade him off later in the season

$14,400 left in the salary


Feedback please?


Lover the Oliver pick. It was between him and parish for mine but I went with parish.


I personally downgrade one of your defenders as you have 4 strong ones. I'd downgrade Touhy. But if you don't have anywhere else to fix up then run with what you got 🙂 may give you some coin to find another solid fwd


Thanks for your feedback
Yeah i understand i have a stronger defence and a weaker forward. Theres always one weaker position in every supercoach team.
If i downgrade Tuohy and strengthen my forward line, who would you suggest?


Def: Shaw, Adams, Laird, Hampton, Otten, Stewart (Vickers-Willis, Hibberd)

Mid: Dangerfield, Kennedy, Hannebery, Treloar, Fyfe, Beams, O'meara, Powell-Pepper (Barret, Miles, Parfitt)

Ruck: Gawn, Sandilands (Cameron)

Fwd: Kennedy, Dahlhaus, Franklin, Florentine, Schoenmakers, Butler (Pickett, Eddy)

$24 k in the bank.
Any feedback is greatly appreciated!


Shoenmakers won't get enough game time for F5


Rookies subject to team selection, obviously. Happy to provide reasoning for selections.

DEF: S Docherty, R Laird, J Howe, C Marchbank, C Hampton, E Vickers-Willis (T Stewart, Z Guthrie)
MID: P Dangerfield, J Kennedy, J Selwood, A Treloar, N Fyfe, D Beams, O Florent, J Barrett (S Powell-Pepper, T Miles, B Parfitt)
RUC: T Nankervis, A Sandilands (L Strnadica)
FWD: N Riewoldt, J Kennedy, L Dahlhaus, S Higgins, T Taranto, K Turner (J Pickett, B Eddy)


Taking a page out of Crouching's book.. will either end the season 1st..or dead last!

Cash in Bank: $625,600

DEF: Docherty Shaw Laird Hampton Otton Vickers-Wilis (Stewart, Guthrie)
MIDS: Fyfe T.Mitchell Kelly Beams Oliver O'Meara Steele SPP (Barret Hibberd Parfitt)
RUCKS: Grundy Sandi (Strndica)

FWD: Riewolt Kennedy Dalhaus Nankervis Mccarthay Eddy (Picket Butler)


Like the general idea but you're gonna be so far behind from the first few weeks it will be impossible to win. That $600k could instantly get you Danger for a rookie, or for more value it could get you JPK/Bont/Cripps


WTF! No ultra-premos, 2 midfield premos, 6 mid-pricers, 9 possible keepers,
Have fun getting beaten by 200 points a week


I think the idea of having a little bit extra cash in this uncertain year is alright, but surely that is too much. I think if you are going to try that sort of strategy you should have about 300k in the bank. That's enough to upgrade a midpricer into a premium, or a rookie into a good midpricer. Otherwise it will take you too long to get all that cash into your team. Personally I'd aim to bring Danger in.


I'd get Steele in for Frankiln


Tear it to shreds lads
Please note that I am going for overall rank this season hence the pretty risky lineup. Nank will be put into forwards in about round 8 and will hopefully be f7 as ruck cover

Def: Adams, Laird, Howe, Hampton, Otten, Vickers Willis (Hibberd, Stewart)
Mid: Danger, Hanners, Treloar, Fyfe, TMitch, Beams, O'meara, Powell Pepper (Pickett, Parfitt, Atley)
Ruck: Nank, Sandi (Strnadica)
Fwd: Dahl, Lynch, Greene, Higgins, Steele, Turner (Butler, Eddy)

Captain Cotch

Hi community, first time poster long time reader!

Just going out to the brains trust on this one as I feel it a little too cookie cutter and am really wanting to find a way to get T.Mitchell in looking at the Hawks early draw. Also been tossing up between T. Hickey or running Nankilands and having either S.Higgins up fwd or N.Riewoldt.


DEF. S.Docherty, H.Shaw, T.Adams, C.Marchbank, C.Hampton, T.Stewart, A.Otten, E. Vickers-Willis

MID. P.Dangerfield, J.Selwood, A.Treloar, N.Fyfe, D.Beams, J.Omeara, D.Swallow, S.Powell-Pepper, T.Taranto, J.Barret, H.Wigg

RUC. T.Hickey, A.Sandilands, D.Cameron

FWD. L.Dalhaus, L.Franklin, T. Nankervis, J.Steele, K.Turner, B.Eddy, J.Pickett, D.Butler

Rip in lads need abit to think about before the season propper

Captain Cotch

$260k in the bank to play with


I'd be swapping Pickett and taranto around. Have taranto playing as your 2nd last or last forward over turner and Eddy. Why have someone at 202k sitting on the pine? Have him on the field and only one of Turner or Eddy.


Alright: I've backed out of SandiWitts in Nan's crevice for now and am back with Max Gawn at R1. If Spencer is named my side probably goes back to my reveal:

Simpson, Laird, Marchbank, Hampton, Otten, Stewart // EVW, Guthrie
Danger, JPK, Selwood, Treloar, Priddis, Fyfe, Beams, SPP // Barrett, Hibberd, Parfitt
Gawn, Sandilands // Strndica
Reiwoldt, Higgins, Roughead, Nankervis, Taranto, Eddy // Houston, Pickett


I'm currently running two teams one with gawn – one without if spencer gets a gig which I think he will.
Just not prepared to spend $650k on a guy who shares the ruck duties and will suffer a point reduction.

Problem is have no idea who to put up as my R1 if gawn is not named solo. Probably Grundy but a he gets most of his points around the ground wont go huge but will be fairly consistent.

First 6 weeks is a scary proposition for the nank – he comes up against the best early.

love to lock in stiffy martin but again cant trust him to ruck solo. his start is unbelievable might still get a gig.


I'm sticking with Gawn on that basis, don't know who else.


Assuming you'd have a fair bit of coin leftover Patch?


For this side I've got about 65k

Shake n bake

Just not sure with your fwd line. It might work but to many ??? for me. Good luck thou Patch.

neil Demons Delight

Goldy / Gawn best two rucks but Sandy and Nank just too well priced. Running Gawn /Sandy with Nank forward.Beams seems to be a good choice but Lloyd cant be overlooked


Stick with gawn. Set and forget you'll be thankful in the long run.


DEF: Laird, Hurley, Lloyd, Hampton, Otten, Stewart (Smith, Guthrie)
MID: Danger, Hannebery, Treloar, Martin, Bont, Fyfe, Titch, Beams (SPP, Miles, Fox)
RUCK: Grundy, Sandilands (Strn)
FWD: Rioli, Miller, Higgins, Black, Parfitt, Houston (Eddy, Pickett)

Thoughts? A little bit different to everyone else which is a good thing


Like it but u need more fire power upfront.
Black looks like he won't play.
You have a massive midfield I'd drop 1 to make cash and put SPP on the field. Use that money to upgrade cyril to dahlhaus and lack to someone else 🙂




Understand there are a few risky picks but I'm happy with it.
Question is, what do YOU think?

Defence : Adams Laird Howe Marchbank Hampton EVW (Otten Stewart)

Mids: Danger Selwood Treloar Fyfe TMitchell Omera DSwallow SPP (Barrett Hibberd Parfitt)

Ruck : Gawn Sandilands (Strnadca)

Forwrads : Dahlhaus Caddy Ryder Roughead Taranto Pickett (Black Eddy)

91K left in the bank.


Simpson, Laird, Mills, Marchbank, Hampton, Otten (Stewart, Smith)

Dangerfield, JPK, Treloar, Fyfe, Mitchell, Beams, Swallow, Powell-Pepper (Barrett, Parfitt, Fox)

Goldstein, Sandilands (Strnadica)

Riewoldt, Dahlhaus, Macrae, Nankervis, Miles, Houston (Pickett, Eddy)

31k in the bank


Def: Simpson, Laird, Lloyd, Marchbank, Hampton, Otten (Vickers-Willis, Stewart)
Mid: Danger, J.Kennedy, Treloar, Fyfe, T.Mitchell, Beams, O'Meara, PP (Barrett, Miles, Hibberd)
Ruck: Grundy, Sandi (Strandica)
Forward: Riewoldt, Daulhaus, Rough, Nankervis, Taranto, Eddy (Pickett, Butler)

39K left in bank, feedback please!


Back: Shaw, Adams, Laird, Marchbank, Hampton, Stewart (EVW, Otten)
Mids: Danger, Treloar, Fyfe, Bont, Titch, Beams, Swallow, SPP (Barrett, Pickett, Parfitt)
Ruck: Goldy, Sandi (Cameron)
Forward: Dahl, Macrae, Roughy, Nank, Taranto, Butler (Eddy, Houston)

Any advice welcome!


Some explanations…

My top six defenders are pretty set: Doc, Shaw, Laird, Adams, Rance, Simpson. Starting with three. Didn't want Marchbank but seems like those North rookies will be in the VFL, need someone who's actually guaranteed to play. Not big on Otten either, no way he holds his spot. But what options do we have???

So many good midfield options. Really wanted Cripps but has the first bye. Aside from Danger I see every player I've selected scoring better than they are priced to average.

Goldy at his price seems a safe bet. I'm not worried about his averages in losses. I think North has lost those games BECAUSE he played poorly, at least in part. North will suck, but they will need Goldy more than ever. Sandi only needs 6-8 weeks and he becomes Gawn. Cameron should play round two and hopefully make some money. I'll downgrade him to Strnadica once he has appreciated.

Macrae I'm not sold on 100% but he should be top 8. I'd have gone Lynch instead, but he's got that round 9 bye. He'll be in my side after that. Didn't really want Taranto but the rookie stocks are just so shallow.


Only One More Sleep
Please give some feed back
Adams, Laird, Tuohy, Hampton, Z jones, Otten
Stewart, vickers
Danger, Hanners, Priddis, Fyfe,Beams, Jom,
PP, Pickett. Barrett, Hibberd, Parfitt
Grundy, Sandi, Cameron
Roo, Dahl, T lynch, Roughy, Nank, Taranto
Butler, Eddy
99k left over cheers and good luck

Big Al


Docherty, Adams, laird, marchbank, Hampton, Stewart, often, Ed VW

Danger, Kennedy, treloar, Fyfe, beams, jaeger, swallow, SPP, Barrett, Pickett, M Hibberd

Nank, Sand, Witts

Kennedy, Dahl, Rough, Steele, Taranto, Parfitt, D Cameron, Eddy.

450K in the bank. (Always start with a big reserve)


Get an extra premo for a mid-pricer


Hey guys are there any better options than ryder at a similar price or should i just get a rookie and use the case else where? I have rought at f4 and a nankilands ruck combo


in forward no but there are plenty of eligible options in defense

Clock Management

SPS will be named for the blues tonight anyone tempted or price to much of a concern. McKay will be named for the blues as well


Trying to fit him in! SPS is a rare talent who'll get tons of opportunity. The fact they selected him off little preparation shows how much the Blues want and need him out there.


I want him but Taranto just a few $ more and giants midfield gets more fragile every year, lol Delidio. If I had the spare $ I'd swap barrett for sps


SPS has way more job security than Taranto. The negative with SPS is that he is a midfielder. The midfield contains most of the best premiums, and in my opinion the best midpricers too.

The Ranger

You absolutely have to jump on the right rookies at the start so he's not in my team now but if he knocks out a couple of decent scores I'll grab him when he's on the bubble.

Nick Fucking Duigan

Righto…think I am just about done gents (and maybe the odd lady). Any thoughts?

Docherty, Shaw, Adams, Marchbank, Hampton, Hibberd (Ottens, Stewart)

Fyffe, J Kennedy, Cripps, Dangerfield, Beams, Swallow, SPP, (Pickett, Lloyd, Atley)

Gawn, Sandi (Strnica)

Riewoldt, Dahlhaus, Greene, Ryder, Taranto, Parfitt (Eddy, Butler)

$130K remaining – want a little insurance should we have to trade up to more expensive rookies.

Any thoughts appreciated.


Any reason you've gone Ryder over The Nank? Otherwise looks very solid mate!

Nick Fucking Duigan

Cheers. I just think Paddy can average 100 or so as a solo ruck. Not sure Nank can…and a bit of a POD.


Paddy won't average over 100 he never has. He's a roller coaster.

Nick Fucking Duigan

Apart from the two years he has averaged 100+. Agree he can be up and down though.


Is Taranto worth his price

Raging Bulls

Yes he is one of the rookies you can actually trust to start on field. Should score upwards of 70


Yes, should generate a good enough amount of cash early while Deledio and Coniglio are out

Josh Kelly

Thoughts on my FINAL team????

DEF: Rance, Adams, Laird, Marchbank, Hampton, Otten.
(Hibberd, Stewart)

MID: Dangerfield, Ablett, Parker, Treloar, Fyfe,
Josh Kelly, O'Meara, Powell-Pepper (Petrevski-Seton, Barrett, Wigg)

RUC: Nankilands (Strnadica)

FWD: N.Riewoldt, Macrae, Greene, Hoskin-Elliot, Taranto, Butler.
(Eddy, Houston)


just wondering why you went Kelly over a proven scorer like Beams?

Josh Kelly

First reason is that I am a Giants fan, and he's my favourite player (Bit Biased), Also I really think Kelly is going to have an outstanding year, I think it's his breakout year.


Any feedback would be great! 50k in bank

B- Simpson, Shaw, Laird, Marchbank, Hampton, EVW (Stewart, Otten)
M- Dangerfield, JPK, Hannebery, Trealor, Fyfe, Beams, Taranto, SPP (Hibbered, Barrett, Parfit)
R- Goldstein, Sandilands (Strnadica)
F- Dahlhaus, Macrae, Roughead, Nanskervis, Pickett,Miles (Eddy, Houston)


Any thoughts appreciated!

Simpson, Lair, Rance, Howe, Hamtpon, Otten, Stewart, EVW

Dangerfield, JPK, Treloar, Fyfe, Beams, Swallow, SPP, Barrett, Wigg, Picket, Hibber

Grundy, Sandilands, Strndica

Dahlhaus, Roo, Lynch (GCS), Nankervis, Taranto, Butler, Eddy, Houston


Howe to Marchbank. Swallow to Omeara. IMO.



Pepper,Barret. (Wigg, Hibberd, Parfit)

Gawn, Sandilands. (Strnadica)

N Riewoldt,Buddy,Dahlhaus,Taranto, Florent
B.Eddy. (Pickett, Houston)

Thoughts ??


Very strong. You've managed to avoid a lot of mid pricers



Shaw, Adams, Laird, Marchbank, Hampton, Stewart (Otten, Guthrie)

Danger, Treloar, Fyfe, T.Mitchell, M Crouch, Beams, Swallow, SPP (Pickett, Barrett, Hibberd)

Gawn, Sandi (Strnadica)

Dahlhaus, Lynch, Roughead, Nank, Taranto, Turner (Black, Eddy)

4.3K ITB

Any feedback would be greatly appreciated



Jock's Elite: 426156

Jock's Elite 2: 977624

Jock's Elite 3: 859988

Jock's Elite 4: 409936

Jock's Elite 5: 859092



Keen to get some feedback

Docherty Shaw Laird Lloyd Hampton EWV (otten, stewart)

Danger Hanners Treloar Cripps Fyfe Beams SPP Barrett (hibberd, pickett, parfitt)

Nankilands (Cameron)

Dahl Buddy Caddy Rough Black Eddy (Strnadica, Butler)

Cameron is actually the true F7 but looking to rookie loophole Butlers score for R1


Good premo mids? Already have danger, Fyfe, JPK and titch. Not considering Bont/Pendles. Cheers


POD priddis always does well




Docherty, shaw, Lloyd, Hampton, vickers Willis, Newman, Ryan, Stewart

Danger, pendles, treloar, Fyfe, t Mitchell, beams, omeara, sam pp, Barrett, wigg, hibberd

Gawn, Sandilands, strndica

Dahlhaus, McRae, Roughead, nankervis, black, Pickett, smith, eddy

Obviously rookies subject to selection. Contemplating laird and johannisen over shaw and lloyd


Hosken elliot, mccarthy or taranto…?


Taranto, averaged well in the TAC Cup should be able to average well enough in his first year


Hi community. Would love some feedback please
DEF: Simpson shaw laird marchbank hampton often Stewart vickers-W
MID: danger treloar selwood Fyfe beams swallow taranto Powell-p Barrett parfitt
RUCK: nank sandi witts
FWD: Riewoldt dalhaus Lynch Roughead Steele eddy houston butler
Obvious risks: ruck set up, beams swallow roughy steele


The team i have chosen, i would love for you guys to rate it and tell me what changes i should make. Cheers

B: H Shaw, T Adams, R Laird, C Marchbank, C Hampton, E Vickers-willis (A Otten, T Stewart)

M: Danger, JPK, Treloar, Fyfe, J Kelly (gws), D Beams, D Swallow, S Powell-Pepper (J Barrett, M Hibberd)

R: B Grundy, A Standilands (Strandica)

F: Riewoldt, Dahlhaus, Mcrae, Nankevris, Taranto, B Parfitt (D Houston, B Eddy)


NEW LEAGUE: mid priced madness.

Criteria: 13 or less players worth less than $250k.

League code: 517117.

All mid price maniacs welcome.

PS, someone running GnR should set that up…probably 15 players worth less than $250k, or a strict version, 16 players. Cheers


Nice idea mate. I'm always interested in joining themed leagues and I'm definitely a believer in a midpriced strategy this season so let's see how we go.

Addicts Anonymous just qualifies with exactly 13 <$250K players so I'm in for now unless final team sheets force an unexpected team restructure and it no longer meets the criteria so has to drop out.


Glad you can join! 13 here as well!


Here is the 2017 chevy chase supercoach team
Shaw, Laird, Vince,
Hampton, Otten, March bank
BENCH- Vickers Willis, Z. Guthrie

Danger, JPK, Treloar, Sloan,
Fyfe, D. Beams, SPP, Lloyd
BENCH- Hibberd, Barrett, Picket

Grundy, Sandi
BENCH- Preuss

Dahlhaus, Higgins, Nankers,
Steel, Taranto, Eddy
BENCH- Florey, Parfitt

277k spare Feel free to pick apart


Def: Shaw, Doch, Laird, Hibberd, Otten, Hampton (Ryan, Stewart)

Mid: Dangerfield, JPK, Fyfe, Pendles, Beams, Shuey,Titchell, SPP (Barrett, Wigg, Miles)

Rucks: Nankervis, Sandilands (Stk)

Fwd: Dahlhaus, J.Kennedy WCE, Macrea, McCarthy,Picket, Eddy (Butler,Houston)

Thoughts on team please


Keen for some feedback. What do you think?

DEF: Shaw, Adams, Laird, Marchbank, Hampton, Otten, Vickers-Ellis & Stewart

MID: Dangerfield, Treloar, Fyfe, Prestia, Beams, O’Meara, Swallow, Powell-Pepper, Barret, Florent & Parfitt

RUC: Martin, Sandilands & Cameron

FWD: N. Riewoldt, Dahlhaus, Greene, Nankervis, Steele, Turner, Pickett & Eddy

Thanks guys.


You qualify for the mid priced madness league! 517117 (13 players or less under $250k!) Don't change a thing. Welcome! Oh, I suspect Prestia is about a unique as one of my premo pods…sub 1%, I'm sure you have your reasons for him. Good luck!


86k in the bank.

B – Docherty, Laird, Marchbank, Hampton, Otten, Hibberd (EVW, Stewart)
M -Danger, JPK, Fyfe, Beams, OMeara, Swallow, Trealor (Barrett, SPP, Parfit)
R – Nankilands (Strnadica)
F – Dalh, Rough, Roo, Buddy, Steele, Houston (Eddy, Pickett)


def: shaw, laird, adams, marchbank, hampton, otten (Vickers-wills, stewart)
mid: danger, parkeer, hanneberry, treloar, fyfe, beams, omeara, spp (bowes, pickett, barrett)
ruck- sandi, nank
fwd- dahlhaus, macrae, caddy, taranto, eddy butler (parfitt, cameron)


I'm rolling with two teams, one with more midpricers. It'll all depend on rookie availability

Team 1
DEF: Shaw, Adams, Laird, Marchbank, Hampton, Stewart (EVW, Otten/Guthrie)
MID: Danger, Treloar, JPK, Fyfe, Bont, Beams, JOM, SPP (Parfitt, Barrett, Hibberd)
R: Grundy, Sandi (Strndica)
FWD: Dahl, Buddy, Nank, Rough, Taranto, Eddy (Pickett, Houston/Butler)


Team 2
DEF: Shaw, Laird, Mills, Marchbank, Hampton, Stewart (EVW, Guthrie)
MID: Danger, Treloar, JPK, Fyfe, Bont, Beams, JOM, SPP (Barrett, Miles, Pickett)
R: Grundy, Sandi (Witts)
FWD: Dahl, Buddy, Roughy, Steele, Taranto, Parfitt (Eddy, Houston/Butler)

$35,000 bank

Team 1 is my main team for now. My logic for team 2 is to gamble on Mills and Steele breaking out (and outscoring Adams & Nank). The POD is in Witts at R3 to gain coin and act as a Sandi cover. With wise trading I could gain $200,000 potentially. I'd love some feedback community


You have to go harder if you want to join the Mid Priced Madness league 517117 (13 players or less under $250k!) Welcome! You'll need to find the cash for both Nank and Steele most probably. A start would be with Taranto/Marchbank going…. to go balls out midpriced madness…my preferred risky structure. Good luck.