Aside from the fact that this will put a serious spanner in the works for our teams, we may never see Gary Ablett at his best again. That’s the cold hard truth that we grapple with today.
With the Marsh series almost upon us, many SuperCoaches are looking to complete a draft with their friends. As service to my community, I compiled my top 30 selections that I would take in a Read more…
Hello community and welcome to the Round 5 rookie scout report. We had a bit of a good news, bad news week with our rookies, on the good news front we had the continued performances Read more…
Carlton v North feature in this week’s CoachKings play-at-homer folks. There’s absolutely no doubt about it – if you know your SuperCoach, you’re a long way ahead of the CoachKing who has come into the Read more…
I am going to turn this into a positive. Move Dusty to midfield and upgrade Fwd saving money to upgrade backline to all premos!
Lucky I had Libba as my bench option this week also!
Par score for the round?
2100 will be par, plenty of sub-standard premo scores.
Bloody hell, Jock. Bloody. Hell. Could be the end of a golden era.
I think so David. I think so mate.
Ablett & Libba gone.
Who to bring in?
I have – Danger, Selwood, Pendles, Priddis, Ward, Parker.
Thinking of getting 2 of- Bont, Hanners, SMitch, Gray.
Anyone else worth considering?
Crowley
Hanners. Not keen on the others. If Gaz is gone long term Hall becomes an option
no Neale?
latest word on Libba is he could be right for next week. Regardless – he's gotta go
1648 with Jelwood captain.
Have Goldy Priddis Simmo Doch Laird and Montagna to play, hopefully can crack 2300.
How's everyone else traveling?
(Got rid of Libba last round Gaz to deal with now)
Cheers
Im 1542 with danger C still to be counted in along with halls score, docherty, laird, sloane, merrett, montagna. Hopefully might crack 2300 if im lucky.
1580 with 7 to go
May mid 2200
1448 with Gawn C
Have Laird, Riewoldt, Savage, Docherty, Simpson, Goldy, Priddis to come
Looking at 2050-2150???
2150 is about where I'm headed too, Thommo. Apart from Sidebottom and Gawn, my boys are not seeing their potential for greatness this round.
Same
Lucky I had Gawn C otherwise I would be in big trouble
1559 with 6 premos still to play and one rookie (Silvagni) on field. Had the C on Danger and thought that I had to stick with 135. Looking at around 2150 – I hope! With Ablett down, Dahl and Wells on the sidelines these are some dark days.
Libba cleared of internal injury according to the afl site
Hopefully we can hold onto one of libbba and gaz
I dont want to use too many trades
Only got 5 left.
12 premos have failed to crack the ton! Horrid round compounded by news of Gary & Libba stuffed! trades failed. Prick of a round. Move onto next week!!!
Only 5 of my team cracked 100. Going to be low scoring round.
1760 with Sloane, Laird, BSmith, Priddis & Montagna to play. Maybe 2300 at best
Only 4 for me so far! Treloar, ZacW, Lids, Shaw, Zorko, Ablett, Dusty all suited up for me yesterday and only Dusty butchered his way to a ton.
He turned the ball over so much night last he was probably best on for the dogs at 1/4 time
I've had 10 keepers under 100 to Sunday. But glad I went Libba to Neale before the round started
Whats going to be the par score – 2250 ?
I'd say 2150-2200 actually.
community, i had vc on danger and c on ablett. Wanted to take danger's score with loophole. Subbed wyatt onto the field and put emergency on martin on the bench. Sweet 🙂
….. I forgot to captain wyatt. FML
Ouch. All those potential points down the plughole. The community feels your pain.
Ablett injury sucks. Even if it's only a couple it's hard to imagine him coming straight back in and punching out big scores. Mega fork in the road here…
Welcome to SC
Sitting on 1707 with Laird, Simpson, Docherty, Goldstein, Kerridge and Zach Merrett to play.. Had the VC on Danger but stuck to my heart and kept the C on Gawn which ended up paying off. Pretty happy with the round to date – only real concern is Libba but hopefully he's right to go next week.
Surely GAJ to Neale will be the number 1 trade this week. Should be straight swap on price
Fremantle do play 4 of there last 5 games at home.
Herald Sun site suggests Liba will miss 1 match tops.
I was going to trade him going into finals but I think Ablett may be the priority now.
Was traveling well until I got caught up in my study yesterday and totally forgot to take dangers Vc score and left C on ablett. Projecting 2250 now
Taking a punt that Silvangi can out score Petracca's 52.. could end in tears…
Can't go too far wrong there mate
Thinking GAJ straight swap to JPK
I would recommend JPK. He hasn't really had massive numbers, but hasn't scored lower than 95 all season (except rd1).
Should get him for $543k next week.
Will play well against his old team.
Disclaimer: 70% of Derek's posts are to recommend JPK, which he would still do if the guy was 80 years old and/or lost a leg. Good player tho =D
I've been good and hardly mentioned him 🙂
I don't need to.
Alright Goldy brought you in today bloody lift
Heard that Gaz's shoulder isnt as bad as first thought.
Looking at anywhere between 1-4 depending on the results of the scans.
1778 with Goldy, Priddis, Riewoldt and Savage to come
Am up against my brother
He has a 12 point lead and has Goldy, Priddis and Montagna
I should win, right?
easy win
Way below par though
Rooy off injuried
back on
Jed Anderson with a goal. Who held him? Lol
I need Priddas to not lose by more then 3 points against McGovern.. both 70 at HT
Think you've got me covered shake n bake the gov is killin it!
Anything can happen let's see how they score to 3 qtr time.
Goin to be close Hedski! I hope priddis & McGovern continue there good form in 2nd half!
Yeah your safe now mate. Good game.
Tnx mate always fun playing you. Good luck for the rest of the year.
was it THE trade that got you over the line?
Cheers shaker. Better cap choice and I woulda had ya….woulda shoulda didn't.
Keep climbing the ranks.
Looking at a ~2350 this week if goldie tons up. Might be enough to move up to top 10.
Nice one! Share your glorious team name?
Crikey. I reckon that's a great score this week. Well done!
Well done mate I scored 2303 and my GF is giving hell coz she scored a whopping 2504 what a tin arse, I'll be hearing it all week now.
Ill have 0 trades now with gaz gone so things are looking great
A little bit like that scene out of Life of Brian. When all the lads are nailed to the crosses and singing always look on the bright side of life.
What the hell is the go with Savage #shit
I have him too
Brough him in for a POD but has been shocking since I got him in
Need JJK to score 10 more than Merrett to win two of my leagues, going to be close.
I am on 2391 with Montagna's second half to come. Might be in with a sniff this week!
Well done keenbutclearlynotclueless!
why did matt priddis get lifted from 105 to 126?
dunno but pretty happy he did 🙂
Anyone thinking of trading out Ablett? Thinking it might seems to be a sign of things to come for him?
Joey over Merret was a bad call, should have listened to patch and chosen his man!
Well Patch recommended Savage 4 weeks ago and look what he's done ! That's the way it goes
Is Savage injured?
Concussed quite badly by all reports.
You're full of shit balls up to your guts
Well serves you right for "upgrading" to Savage and being a tightarse in your backline. I'm sorry but the guy's a premo pretender.
Same goes to all those sh1tbirds who scrimped on Rich and Smith bwahahahaha!
most people with Rich & Smith would have had them from the start, just waiting
Well if you knew anything tosser 3 weeks ago he was top 6 defender and even patch jumped on him !
Go and flog yourself like your name suggests dickhead!
why cant the premos all play well the same weekend? is it to much to ask for SuperCoach gods? in a season of injuries and stars getting dropped, can we have 1 just ONE week where everyone performs well?
in one of my leagues we were dead even with two players different to play. I had Priddis and Montagna to his Stevens and Tippa. I was feeling very confident.
after Saturdays premos falling flat on their faces, it looked dark, really dark, but todays premos got my team to a respectable 2300.
I hope you got Sloane after all those weeks pretty much preaching his name Derek.
yep. Barlow to Sloane last week. he good boy
Went Tracca to Zorko and Libba to Pendles, decent trades id say
Lekdogs going great guns, sitting on 2539 before scaling with Joey, Rooey and Zerret.. well done big fella
make that 2553 now
What does everyone think the par score is this week?
I'm guessing around the 2200-2250 mark
Hard to say, maybe about 2200
i scored 2297 but managed to win only 5/10 leagues. All top 300 leagues. So I think 2300 is par for serious players this week.
Will 2315 climb me up the rankings?
Depends where your ranked obviously
Clearly smarter than he pretends! That is a seriously envious score!
2303 for me, not great but not bad considering I have Libba & GAJ – My GF scored a massive 2504 so I haven't stopped hearing about it.
wow, must be close to the cash
Nah Lekdog scored 2553 mate but still a whopping score believe it or not her lowest scorer was GAJ
2347 sticking with dangers score was the choice of the round
Had my opponent covered until he took a longshot and put the c on Steven.
I like peni
2335 this week, pretty happy with that.
Top 5 Studs (compared to projected):
Brand +36 (on bench)
Parker +32
Merrett +31
Gawn +28
Laird +16
Top 5 Duds:
GAJ -60
Jelwood -36
Rose -31 (on bench)
Simpson -29
Ward -28
Top 5 Scorers:
Gawn 141
Danger 135
Laird 130
Merrett 129
Priddis 126
Bottom 5:
Rose 31 (on bench)
Silvagni 49
Petracca 52 (on bench)
Collins 59
Bartel 65
Have only 2 trades & $112K left, 1 of which will prob go on GAJ to Pendles / Neale / Sloane / Bont – unsure which yet.
Team:
DEF: Heater, Simmo, Bartel, Pittard, Williams, Laird (Collins, Brand)
MID: Danger, Hanners, Jelwood, Parker, Ward, GAJ, Merrett, Priddis (Trengove, Petracca, Phillips)
RUC: Gawn, Goldy (King)
FWD: Dusty, Buddy, Zorks, Hall, Lids, Wells (Silvagni, Rose)
Need some luck from here! Aim is still to finish top 10K, currently 22K.
ya need Zerrett
Stevens beat me in 3 leagues. Didn't even know that many people had him 😉
He's been in pretty good form lately (other than last week) so some coaches would have upgraded to him during the byes. Not a bad buy at around $550K this week as a Gaz replacement.
ZMerret got you home against me this week SC, thought i had you going into the last game, if he got his projection i would have sneaked a win. oh well. done good
2158 for me
Shocking
Enough said
Next week please
Wowee 2395. Despite not having been able to captain loophole Danger. Ended up with Pendles
Youd be stoked with that score. Also a bit 'fark, what could have been'
So if Gaz is done who do we look at as best options?
Have Danger, Rocky, Pendles, Selwood, Hanners, Gray, Parker….
Hard to look past the Sloane Ranger especially with the Crows tantalising remaining draw.
Plenty of value options about the place if you want to bank some cash.
we will wait for news, but i'm not expecting to hold him if he is out for more than 1 week.
I have a few trades left just for these happenings.
already have Danger, Pendles, Sloane, Pridis, Gray, Rocky, JPK….
Hanners is the obvious choice for me, but i am looking at Hodge as a big POD.
I'm going to get him in as my POD move of the season. I was so shattered that i went full premium in the midfield one week before he came back from injury, and now with Libba and Ablett under injury clouds, i have my chance to get him. Also what rank are you at now Derek? I know Lobbe really set you back at the start of the year but how well have you recovered since then? Also what does your team look like?
had a year i don't want to talk about. still around 16k in rankings.
Shaw, McVeigh, Laird, Bartel, Rich, BSmith (Collins, Lee)
Danger, GAZ, Pendlebury, Rocky, JPK, Gray, Sloane, Priddis (Menadue, Joyce, Phillips)
Gawn, Blitz (Wyatt)
Dusty, Zorko, Delidio, Franklin, Wingard, Montagna (Motlop, Greenwood)
7 trades left. $88k bank.
Yep Hodgey could be a nice POD especially for someone like yourself with a few extra trades up your sleeve and can take a risk or two. Could go on a ton bonanza from here with Sitch copping all the close attention.
However for the rest of us, who are running close to E on the ole trade gauge, his durability is just too big a risk I reckon even with just 7 games to go.
You beat me by 9 points in one of our supercoach leagues, AddictsAnonymous right?
That's me. Went 8-2 in my leagues so you unfortunately ran into my side on one of its few decent weeks.
i hear you might be $50 richer as well SC 😉
Have Ablett and I know he injured his shoulder and how long do people think he will be out. Have him and thinking if getting zerret to replace him.
Current midfield is danger Ablett pendles selwood hannebery ward sloane neale.
I only have 4 trades :
We'll have to wait for official news but it's not looking flash.
Even if he does play he may be restricted like early this season and may struggle to ton up and the Suns may just put him on ice at some point.
Just slid into the supposed par score, i ended up with 2319. Players like Shaw, Rance, Ablett, Liberatore, Montagna and Bartel all let me down this week, and I'm probably going to be trading both Ablett and Liberatore out.
Still waiting…….
A mediocre 2232. Could have been so much worse if my last 6 boys did not grab 655 points between them today. That after stuffing the captain up AGAIN!. Backed Gazza again after last week with an even worse result.
THE FLU AND THEN YESTERDAY THE BLOODY SHOULDER TWEAK!
But I can live with that as Gazza has made me happy for so many years.
The good news is that I will have a new captain next week! I am going to have to let you go mate since you may not be back for 3 to 4. Thanks for all that you have done for my team Gary. "GOD" bless.
who wouldve ever thought that gary ablett would be your lowest scoring player on the field
How many points behind the leader can you be, whilst still having a chance at winning the whole thing?
Just depends on trades and bench cover. Leader could be eating donuts last couple of rounds.
This week I went bang bang as crouching would say. I traded Tippa for Rampe and Petracca for Buddy. Both seemed to work out nicely, although Tippa had a high score, Rampe still scored 138. I am now left with 3 trades to hold out for the season and might look to trade out my last on-field rookie, Kerridge. As long as I don't have many problems with injuries I should be climbing those ranks in no time. Scored 2320 this week (top 2%) and raised about 4000 places. Thoughts on trading Kerridge or just holding the 3 trades.
2430
Last backline spot to be filled
Docherty laird rance simpson shaw
Was thinking boyd or bartel any other sugestions
Boyd would be the way to go if you can afford him without a doubt mate. Great score
I'd look at Pittard or Boyd is a class player.
Eathier way you go you'll get solid scores – With Boyd his very consistent and capable of the big 120+
Or if you go the Pittard option his a reliable D6-D7 and saves you 47k for another upgrade.
Good luck with your selection 🙂
Thoughts on Luke Hodge to replace Libba?
Not a fan at all and Libba might be back next week or the following at worst.
Libba will average you much better scores than Hodge.
Look at these figures mate.
Hodge has only scored the following this season: 66,79,81,61,97,124 Only 6 games this year, injury prone and getting old.
Libba has scored the following this season: 115,118,82,89,95,70,99,128,82,89,120, 112, 74,94,47
As you can see Hodge scores are average at best I would STAY clear mate and if Libba is ok stick with him, even if he misses one week. .
breifly thought about him, good price, but won't. Hanners or Parker. But I already have McVeigh, JPK and Franklin.
Btw. Going to SCG on Thursday. Will be a cracking game, tough place to be a hawk supporter.
If you have enough trades I like it. Hodgey is a gun.
I wouldn't get him if I had a few older players already in my team, just in case of them getting rested or breaking down.
2450 this week. Slowly getting back to the top 100 after falling back to 3000 over the byes. Fingers crossed!
As I said a competent FD would have addressed this issue when they had the opportunity to .just like our tall forward issues and ruck stocks. Too late to address the problem once the horse bolted. Silly suggestion. Chaplin after the EF should have had his papers stamped yet we sacked our b and f winner in the VFL and picked up some skinny kid b4 a big back like Hartley.
I am Tiger Imposter on Big Footy. I am the best and also ass coach at Coburg.
His currency to a team like gws or gold coast is huge. Time the Tiges made a ballsy move like the Jeff Hogg trade. Its a shame that sh#t stain Dan Richardson wasted so many years with that top up rubbish. Its time to be like Elsa from frozen and sing let lids go let him go. Anyone who's seen our reserves play knows we're in for some years of doom n gloom. We're a fuc£en joke at trade time offering polished turdds and wondering why we never land a big fish. Offer up lids then stand back and watch the feeding frenzy we'd be able to play teams off against each other some team will be dumb and desparate enough to overpay for him. Or do we waste time and try and fool other teams to give us jack steeles and jaeger omearas for chaplins and marics. Sack Blair Hartley and Francis Jackson get hone and Rendell and use the bloody picks well.
like they said all year, after your best 4 players (Dusty, Cotch, Lids and Jack) its a very very dark hole you find yourselves in (As a carlton supporter, im happy as a pig in shit that richmond are in the dirt, along with the scumbag Bombers and the pies to a lesser extent)
I wouldnt trade Lids, he is to important, but then again, youve got rubbish underneath him that no club will take.
That Rance bloke goes alright…..
Markov looks handy
Rich is going this week. Should have done it ages ago.
Do I go Ablett and Rich to Ward/Boyd or Neale/Howe or any defender under $474400. Leaning toward the 2nd option
Shiel or Ward for Ablett?
I need to cash cash for next weeks upgrade of Petracca
Way out of it at 4300 but am happy cause this is the first year I have taken SuperCoach seriously. Usually I finished at about 100 000. I am still aiming to finished top 1-2k
Thanks community for all your help this year
For anyone who does not have SC Gold like myself, Herald Sun have a deal for 2 months subscription with weekend papers delivered for $10 total which gives you SC Gold until the end of round 23. Just signed up.
Who has the better job security – Silvagni or Markov?
I reckon they'll both play out the year. Markov was playing off half back Saturday night, a more fantasy friendly role than Silvagni
cheers mate
I want to go outside the square for my Gaz replacement. How about Prestia? Has gone 120+ last couple and Suns have a fairly soft run (or as soft as it can be for them). Or even more outrageous, switch Dusty to the mids and get Wright in. He is absolutely killing it at the moment.
I like the Wright idea, am currently tossing between Wright and Clay Smith from the Bulldogs, scores of 82 & 95 at 237k made him more attractive to me as a downgrade target.
Need to get my last premo into my forward line, Buddy or Zorko?
Zorko
Zorko
Zorko, midfielder, and can kick goals
Its constantly decent when you read something that is useful as well as enthralling. I will bookmark it. I have been hunting down data about this topic for quite a long time and yours is the best I have found. I truly making the most of your site post.
Maybe they could just play Ablett on Libba this week with a gentleman's agreement that no-one hurts them. wait….a vision….I see a future where the rules apply differently to different players….Oh No, there are GIRLS playing!!! and you can't tackle them probably!!! Oh No, its all going bad……….