THE PANIC ROOM – HELL
Community, I have a confession to make.
We’re out a little bit late this week, and I’ve told Jock it was because work kept me back late last night and it knocked me out of whack.
I’ve always found the best lies are wrapped in a slither of truth. I am indeed out of whack, but work did not keep me.
No, I’m late this week because I looked at the team selections this morning and cried.
I lay in the foetal position and caused a flood far greater than the dreary skies that have lashed this damp, muddy country could ever muster.
I’ve had master tutelage. I’ve learnt from the best. Jock took me under his wing and showed me the Ways of Fantasy Sport.
Crouching has taken me to the jungles of South-East Asia and pushed me to my physical limit. He bestowed on me the knowledge of the fly-kick.
Higgo taught me mathematics behind the comprehension of mortal minds – in fact, years before the Higgs-Boson or ‘God’ particle was announced as an integral part of all matter, our dear friend Peter told me of the Higginbotham Particle, or the “Gaz” particle, which showed Gary Ablett Jnr makes up every successful supercoach side.
After all this, I opened my side this morning to find sixteen. bloody. players.
Sixteen
I promptly took a very long and very hot shower.
I am ashamed.
THE NEWS
Now is not the time for self-pity. Lockout has begun, which means trades cannot be reversed. For the next three weeks, we will be subject to locking our trades in before we know the teams – or we trade around this annoying spectacle that is Thursday night football.
Although, the brilliant thing that comes with Thursday football is the Jock Reynolds crack commentary team. They were a huge selection for our lives this week, and for the quarter I was able to stream at work it was 100% top notch.
Onto team selections – Daniel Wells missed last night’s match with a dodgy calf. Hopefully after the bye next week he’ll be a-ok for the rest of the reason. Hopefully.
The BIG news this week is Dayne Zorko is missing from Brisbane’s lineup for personal reasons, which is a huge blow to them, and to us in the toughest week of the year. Cyril Rioli is also attending a funeral up north, and will miss this week’s game.
Jacob Hopper is OUT, being managed. From what, who knows. Sam Reid has also been dropped for those looking for a rookie this week.
For those poor sods still with Suns rebounder Kade Kolodjashnij, he’s going to miss this week with concussion, possibly from ramming his head against the wall in order to rediscover his form.
Ben Crocker, Corey Ellis and Daniel Rioli are all out for a variety of reasons – Rioli joining cousin Cyril up north – and anyone who picked up Daniel Gorringe will have to find a way to cope with his hip injury as he will miss this week.
Gold Coast dynamo Aaron Hall returns after running rampant in the NEAFL. Let’s hope Rocket puts him back in the midfield against the Hawks.
Luke Hodge has been selected for the Hawks this week, which hopefully will not come at the expense of rookie Kade Stewart. I’d think he’d be reasonably safe, but you never know with the Hawks.
Those still holding Connor Spudadue Menadue rejoice, for he will be blessing us with another 30 this week as Richmond have – for some unfathomable reason – selected him again. Which would be great news for me if I hadn’t traded him out at lunchtime yesterday. WHO’S THE POTATO NOW, PATCH?
(Speaking of me being a potato, I missed Rhys Mathieson‘s return to the Lions side. He’s been picked! Cheers to Reece for pointing that one out for me, as I the names were a bit blurry through the tears.)
THE PATCH UP
Patch’s helpful visual guide to surviving this week:
Whatever I write here would be far surpassed by Lekdog’s magnificent, beautiful thing of a cheat sheet. Go look at it.
That’s not a suggestion. If you’ve kept scrolling and haven’t looked at this week, move your mouse back up and click on the hyperlink.
Do it.
I’m not going to tell you again.
TRADING PLACES
Eddie Murphys
-31 – Sam J. Reid (DROPPED)
-24 – Kade Stewart
-22 – Jack Trengove
-18 – Toby Nankervis
-16 – Aliir Aliir
1 – Logan Austin
4 – Bailey Williams
13 – Tom Ruggles
24 – Jayden Short
Dan Aykroyds
199 – Bryce Gibbs
168 – Todd Goldstein
168 – Adam Treloar
160 – Lachie Neale
160 – Scott Lycett
154 – Dylan Shiel
148 – Callan Ward
142 – Heath Shaw
137 – Scott Pendlebury
CAPTAIN McCAPTAINFACE
To anyone who put the VC on Goldy last night – yeah nah let’s not take the 99.
Let’s put the C on Paddy Dangerfield. He’s averaging 147.5 over his past five and a MAMMOTH 175.3 over his last three. Ca-ching.
For those still with the VC to slap around, I’d have a gander at Scotty Pendlebury tonight or, if you’re feeling really dicey, Michael Barlow, who is averaging 125 over his last three.
I would avoid Dustin Martin, as he’ll get the Mitch Robinson tag this week.
Just as the tears have dried I feel them coming on again… if Dusty has a shocker I might not be seen for a week. I brought him in this week and didn’t even think about the Robbo tag. BREAK IT SON. If not for your sake, for mine.
I know you’re reading, Dusty. I believe in you, son.
And community, I believe in you. Do me bloody proud this week. Hold your heads higher than mine.
We will survive.
The Thursday Night PLAY AT HOME Winners
Thanks to the MASSES of Community stalwarts who jumped in and had their first crack at the CoachKings special Thursday night Play at Home game – get down to your local to play and feel free to jump in again for the next three Thursday night home sessions. It’s bloody FREE and its bloody FUN – Get around it folks!
Rd.1 4 CoachKings Fixture
CLICK HERE TO CHECK OUT OUR ROUND 14 COACHKINGS LINEUPS
5.00 EDIT: I AM DOWN TO 15 MEN. KADE STEWART IS OUT. F&#*ING HELL.
I’m sick of this round already, so I’m going to head down to my local tonight and try and win a thousand dollarydoos to make myself feel better.
ily patch
Patch you are my hero
its lit
love u patch you lit human
I only have 14 on field after the news on Hopper… Should I axe him or just accept my team is stuffed this week? Still have 2 trades for the week and 160k.
Depends on the rest of your side, Sana, but if you're down to 14 you almost might as well cop the loss in your league and move on to next week
If you're focusing on rank, you'll need to paint the fence
You could cash in with Hopper and trade in Mathieson if you don't already have him
mathisen?
Cheers Reece, missed him through the tears mate. Will chuck him in now!
Is it worth considering Eric Hipwood (DEF/FWD) as a downgrade target, after only 1 game?
I wouldn't unless you desperately need him. He's a key position player and will be inconsistent, and likely dropped at some stage. I'd have another look if you could
I love the quantum physics reference, nice work Patch! I'll always think of it as the 'Higgos-Boson Particle' from now on.
OMG!!! I brought sj Reid in to my team as he was playing no he isnto WTF!!!!
same here, dont stress
The fact that I still have Spudadue in my team really speaks for how bad a year I'm having…
I appreciate that Jock is purposefully in the trenches with us.
I've spent the last two months wishing I didn't have him, and the second I get rid of him I realise I need him. Enough to drive you mad!
Maybe with Dusty copping a hard tag, Menadue will ton up.
I love that about Jock, purposefully scoring poorly so he knows what it is like to be struggling at SC. he is like the team riders in the Tour de france, who go back and stay with the fallen leaders and nurse them back to the pelleton, sacrificing themselves for the good of the team leader and ultimately the team.
Agreed, having my worst year ever. Feel like a spud until I remember the father of fantasy is in the trenches with us 🙂
Sorry to have Menadue now?
Martin or Lids in this week?
Cheers
Martin
Dusty
Docherty or Simpson? Will Tom Phillips (every average in 1st game missed target many times) be a JS for rest of the season? Sneaking suspicion he may well be!
Docherty. Not sold on Phillips, give him another week before looking to bring him in
Yep, exactly what I'll be doing
Down to 16, as well as my opponent in the cash league on 16.
The issue I have is my backline : Shaw, Gibbo, Rich, Collins, Ruggles, Lee (Boyd, Tippa)
I have 2 trades remaining and have 500k in the bank to upgrade (16 playing this week, 16 or 17 next week). Do I upgrade tippa to Docherty or Simmo this week OR wait until next week, use Tippa as backline cover and upgrade Ruggles next week.
Cheers guys
I'm keeping Tippa myself but no reason for you to if you want to upgrade him. I'd go up to Docherty this week Ciaran!
Brilliant work Patch. Best fantasy football article on the market.
Slightly unrelated, but Jock and co, I like this new 'play from home' CoachKings thinga-ma-jig. Significant, as Higgo would say. Some of us cant make it to such venues each week, or just cant be bothered. But if you had a play from home set-up for at least 2 games a round, I'd be all over it (and I reckon others would too).
Thoughts community?
agree
Good idea, but what does Jock and his investors get out of it if we are playing it at home and not going to the pub to drink beer.
I would imagine the business model involves the clubs and pubs paying for the service in consideration for people coming and buying beer (and chips), if there was other ways for us to play it, the clubs & pubs may not want to support it.
Without CoachKings, we might not have Jock back with us. (we all still remember that awful day about this time last year – the time that we don't want to talk about when we thought we had lost Jock forever)
I like how we all get a bit of a look at it and if we like it we can go and find a place that is serving it.
my nearest location is 374.2km away. oh well.
Pay to play? Not much just enough to generate interest. Maybe a jackpot like gallops – quaddie. Potential huge jackpots if all SuperCoach players get on board.
374.2k's, maybe just go every second week then Derek 🙂
Means a lot mate <3
I'm not able to talk for anyone on the CoachKings play from home because I simply don't know what's needed, but the idea is based around getting bums in pubs to play.
There's nothing more we want than everyone playing, but we do need bums in pubs to keep the thing rolling along
good luck with that
Fair call, I understand. Great work regardless fellas!
Pendles Into Danger? or
Danger into Ablett?
I'm going Barlow in Danger – I think Barlow will score 150+ this week. Pies no good at tagging
Me too
I'm going Paddy into Gaz, with the assumption I probably won't need to use Gaz.
Danger in to Ablett
Either way I think you'll end with Danger's score, but would take Pendles over Gaz, who's playing the Hawks
Shaw to Danger
Best less then $117,300 option this week?
Matheison, Phillips
If it has to be "less than" 117,300, Joyce if he makes the final 22.
Can look at non-playing DPPs if you've got the cover mate.
Thanks all – yep going Joyce this week, Phillips next as both on the bubble!
Thoughts on holding or downgrading Hewett? Was thinking it might be worth riding it out until that 11 that he scored was out of his rolling average and he makes up the lost money, even though he will lose cash again next week. Have 19 playing this week but only 70k in the kitty, so not much coin for upgrades. Thinking of holding at this stage.
I like that thinking, Ollie!
Cruel outs Patch, cruel indeed. A big test of SC Character this weekend, I have no doubt whatsoever you will bounce back stronger whilst gaining a SC God like wisdom that will hold u in good stead for years to come. Chin up
Cheers Grahame. I've had a long hard think about it and am getting back on my feet mate. Makes it a truckload easier having blokes like you lend support. I love you mate.
Stuck on what to do this week community would appreciate some help!
Team is
shaw simpson docherty laird bartel adams byrne-jones collins
danger pendles ward parker ablett libba kerridge dunkley stewart trengove d.cuningham
goldy gawn cox
zorko barlow martin hall amtippa petracca menadue philips
have 220k left and 13 trades
Have done Dunkley to Sloane so far
thanks everyone
Sloane in has paid off! Could go Petracca to Montagna, or Byrne-Jones to Rance (which I like more).
Thought of keeping petracca for a couple more. amt/adams worth moving on for lids or Montagna
?*
so with the news that zorko is out i still have 7 playing forwards that i cant swing..
i have 19 on the pitch that are scoring but my question i dont get in the bye rounds
i have phillips (collinwgood) and menadue on the bench, one of which i will replace for zorko.
if i put the emergency on phillips tonight, and he scores well if i keep zorko on the pitch will phillips replace zorkos 0 with his score..
i was going to do this so that if he spuds it up real bad then i can still put menadue on the pitch..
yes, normal E rules will apply
That's spot on.
If Phillips scores 40 it may be a difficult decision though …
Sidebottom worth a punt in midfield as a Libba replacement?
yes. was considering sloane/sidebottom for this weeks upgrade.
ended up going sloane which i was happy about but i rate sidebottom, proven premium
Cheers Josh!
Wouldn't have much of a problem with the Sidebum, Stevo!
Should I trade Hopper to Phillips or Mathieson to field 18 players or hold?
depends what you're going for in overall scheme i guess.. i always play for overall rank regardless of how close i am..
so i traded hopper this week.. seeing as he is out this week and bye next week.. i bought in phillips but if i were you id get mathieson in
Don't like Thursday night or Monday night footy. Why can't they just leave it on the weekend (Friday night to Sunday afternoon) and be done with it. (Long weekends are different, but think of the players as well as the public.)
If they want to emulate NRL, then fine, but NRL only get between 10K and 20K turning up to most of their games.
When is the final 22 named for Sundays game?
Great article Patch.
You have to laugh at the "Menadue Situation".
Nine shocking games straight and he wasn't dropped. Hardwick must love the kid.
I believe this is the universe balancing things out.
It is the absolute antithesis of the Longmire, Tom Mitchell situation of a couple of years back.
If Mitchell had played a Menadue-esque game that year he could still be playing in the Neafl today.
Hahaha absolutely true, mate!
Going to struggle to get 18 players over the next two weeks
Here is my team: https://imgur.com/a/OhH5h
Looking for some advice on trades, but I think Wines out is the only way to avoid a donut this week. Was so close to going Wines to Sloane but did not pull the trigger and now am regretting.
Any advice is appreciated
I think we've all seen your team enough this week. I've lost track of how many times you've posted it. You pretty much spam this site. I for one will be ignoring your repetitive posts from now on.
Your team is shit let's leave it at that mate.
You are scum mate go kys
Mate I know imgur is for shitposting but leave it for the dank memes. Just type your team in.
great work patch. I tell ya, it is these bye rounds that will kill supercoach. I have a few friends who don't play SC anymore is because it gets too hard around the bye rounds. Why do we have byes anyways?
Cheers Derek.
Players demanding them. I don't have a problem with them, I just wish we were able to have 3 weeks off SC for them
To set the cream apart from the crop!
lol. sounds like you have been to the Jock Reynolds School of cliche
Your friends are somewhat fickle then Derek. Been in the fixture since day dot.
I thought they only started in 2012
I have 16 too Patch
Thinking Rocky into Danger this week
don't think DO
I'm doing the same Tommo. Did that last week and was foolish enough to take Rocky's 130. Sounded like a good idea until Danger punched out a lazy 100 to half time.
Nice mate, Rocky slipped my mind
Was goin to bring in rance didn't really want to spend so much
on Docherty. I know I'm thinking far ahead but tigers play Syd
last game blues play Ess. Should I just spend the extra coin?
I had same thoughts yesterday, I went Doch for higher ceiling and plays (named) on wing which gives him freedom to roam while Rance is one dimension player, but still a v good choice. I believe Doch will perform against any opposition, potential GUN.
Docherty will outscore Rance for the rest of the year, SnB. Would go the Doc
I had Doc locked in all week until about 4pm yesterday when I changed it to Rance.
I need every bit of cash I can get in order to get to a proper full premium team and have decent bench cover so I just can't justify the spend.
Hopefully the money I have saved will be spent in such a way as to make up the possible points difference.
Pendlebury into Danger or Dangerfield into Gaz?
Adam Saad out of the GCS squad with hammy tightness.
Thoughts please community
Which option to bring in this week:
Simpson and Dusty Or
Simpson & Deledio???
Cheers
Dusty mate!
Have vc on Sloane should I be nervous Danger plays saints
at Etihad? & Richo said he won't be tagged?
145 is normally a score you'd like to take. Nothing wrong with 290. Every chance Danger scores 160+ so just depends on how lucky you feel. Gotta risk it to get the biscuit, but 290 is still mighty fine.
I'd take a 145 personally mate. Even with Danger on fire
Not taking a 145 is amateurish………..
STILL HAVEN'T DECIDED…
MERRETT, DELEDIO, MONTAGNA FOR LAST FORWARD PREMIUM???
deledio
Mate you know where I lie on this. Merrett all the way for me
Cheers Patch.
Bringing in Docherty
Upgrade Adams or Mc- Tip
Adams for mine
only fielding 15 cause of wells and zorko, actually want to kms. plus and awful thursday night by the likes of brodie smith and talia
How many players are the community fielding? Also what do to with Hopper? Time to cash in?
Down to 15 now, Mac. Truly dark times.
Patch what should I do with Hopper?
Stewart not named, but Joyce and Menadue are, i will have 19 onfield.
That will include plenty of rookies who usually play poor when i have them onfield – Collins, Menadue, Joyce, Gresham Mcgovern (done good) and BSmith
19 now Zorko is out… Assuming no other late outs.
Is Barlow in our final 8,also would Libba be the last upgrade or should I be keeping him at M8 ?
I won't be trading Barlow out that is for sure, held him all year and now reaping the rewards.
Top 8 who knows, not in total but probably average well from here on out and be top 6.
You could trade Libbe, or you could keep him at M8, it really depends on how good your other lines are and your total team value situation.
Danger obvious VC
Gaz for C because.. played magpies x 13 avg. 133
average at AU 138, and…. Hall is back, should create more opportunities.
yes? or Shaw VC into Danger C
Looks like stewart is out 🙁 sad times
Bugger
i wanted at least one more game out of him. i'm not going to stuff around, he will be traded now.
What was the point of getting him in then? We all knew he would most likely get dumped.
What a surprise. I thought he was a permanent replacement for Hodge.
thats what i mean, we knew he would get dumped, i was hoping it would be after this week. oh well, i'm not going to hold onto him, prefer to get maitherson in who is playing and might make a bit of cash. stewart won't.
I'd rather save the trade
How many trades you got Derek? Brand was dropped a while back and he is playing again. Stewart will make cash just not right now so I will hold, also I do not have the luxury due to my trades
I got 11 after this week
Patch – awesome as ever. Thanks for the visual guide and Simpsons reference. Has helped turned the tears into tears of laughter.
In a similar foetal position – 16 players. Traded DBJ for Laird, however, has not left me enough to upgrade AMT or Adams.
Options :
1) Hewett to Maitheson/Phillips (who has the better job security and scoring potential) and use the cash to upgrade AMT or Adams to Lids or N Riewoldt. Leaves me with 13 trades but 18 on the field.
2) Hewett to Maitheison, upgrade next week and cop two donuts.
Thoughts
Thanks Patch. Was leaning towards Mathieson only because he is on the bubble but he might be the first to lose his spot when Zorko returns. Phillips may be the better option.
Who are the downgrade options this week?
Tom Phillips the obvious one
What are the communities thoughts on Joyce, on the bubble and wait to see if Phillips gets named next round?
Not sold on Joyce myself, Gav. Would go Phillips myself
I'll pick Phillips up even if he's not named next week, need the dpp swing.
Stewart dropped
No worries mate! Glad to hear I brought some smiles amongst the pain.
I like option one – would go Tom Phillips personally and then Adams to Lids.
Just realised Ollie Wines to Docherty bring Rich into the centre is my way to avoid both my donuts as this allows me to use one of my bench rookies in defence onfield. Then ben ken to lids and nic nat to martin. Wondering what you think about these trades. I will be left with a tonne of cash after these trades also which is nice. I think it is worth it to save myself from two donuts just wondering on your thoughts.
Actually dw this only saves me one donut thinking I will just accept my crappy score
I realised the same with Libba out this week and keeping DBJ and putting Rich in the middle. Was tossing up between 18 and 19 on field and to keep libba. Now Stewart out as well, will have to do go Libba out. Planned like crazy for the byes and then this shit happens.
Do you think it is worth it even though it only gets rid of 1 donut, I will still be left with another donut and no way to get rid of it as I do not want to get Pendles at his price and no other good options from last round apart from Sloane
Did anyou have th vc on sloane last night and are you take the double points for a 290?
Probably should have proof read that sentence.
Would take Sloane's score Holla
Taylor Adams to Lachie Neale or wait until next week given BE of 159?
Or is there any other mids I should consider. Last spot will be zaharakis to hanners
Without seeing your team, + 1 for Neale.
Wouldn't mind paying abit more for a keeper
+1 = another week?
Cox is in! I love cox!!!!
Especially 6'11 Cox 😉
Arousing
Oh boy….
I wanna play….
I'm disappointed because I thought the favorites were Ryder … And … Swallow 🙂 (Too much?)
MacPherson to Mathieson
Or
Stewart to Mathieson
Or
Just hold
Am goin to get 1 of these players in Docherty or Deledio this week who should I take?
I look at all other matchups in my leagues and there is carnage eveywhere…. Then I look at my opponents. Ill be stuffed, in every one of my 5 leagues, every opponent has at least 18 on ground. Disheartening.
Stewart or Hopper out? Either one has been a wasted trade
Hopper, make more cash
Barlow, Pendles or Shaw as VC?
Nearly jumped on Tarrant in Defence. And Goldie still not worth the dollars. Hampson v Martin for ruck spot
Tarrant was a spud last night wasn't he? That's why you don't lock in key position players unless very proven.
Need some help finding some good trades this week BOLD is players who are not playing this week.
Laird, Smith, Rich, Shaw, Bartel, AMT, Collins, Brand
Ablett, Danger, Selwood, GRAY, WINES, PRIDDIS, LIBBA, PARKER, MACPHERSON, Smith, STEWART
Cox, Nic Nat, GAWN
Barlow, Martin, WELLS, ZORKO, TRACCA, FRANKLIN, BEN KEN, Phillips
10 trades and 470k in the bank.
Good luck with the carnage this week!
Quick!!! Who to upgrade first out of Tucker and Collins???
A. Rance
OR
J. Bartel
I really need help on this one as I am unsure who to go with. Looking at Geelong's last 4 games – that is when Bartel will likely be rested (it is finals time also) so I am unsure what to do.
HELP MEEEEEE!!!!!!!!!
Bartel for sure!
I have Barlow and have been happy with his form. Depends whether you think Bartel will be rested
Collins or Tucker on the field?
So I'm guessing you've got the E on S.Col like me?
Dont think you'll get his score.
My question is if I pull Ruggles off (ha ha) and put Suckling on will the emergency count?
Any help community I'm normally pretty au fait with these things but this is a doozy.
Yep you can do that
Cheers Southern.
Pity I didn't play Collins over Shit Smith.
Yea I have Collins on the bench, looks like I will have to loophole his score
Pendles – Whats going on ? I bought you in 2 minutes before the game started ?
Same. Oh well he'll do alright surely.
Heard someone on fanfooty chat saying he is carrying an injury and had been in fwd pocket nearly whole of 2nd quarter
Has the flu
Ahhh good intel. I thought maybe it was a return to bucks start from start of season D=
*strat
yup… sick
What would Collins need to score to be considered to loophole him into my defence? I have him on the bench as an E but my defence is shaw, doch, Simpson, Bartel, rance, laird (played already)
Probably 90? I'd consider benching Rance going by the stats but go with your gut looking at the matches being played
I just did this
Thats a good def BB. 100+ for who tho?
Bartel and Rance could both go big other 3 are solid.
Good problem to have.
I'll be waitin on his score to assess Ruggles.
I reckon if Collins goes 90+ which looks to be the case it is Rance for mine that most likely score less against the deplorable lions who won't get it to Rances half enough
Or he will take 83 intercept marks as they bomb away and score 234.
Plausible
I've got the same backline this week BB, and the same problem! Collins could get a 120, maybe bench Rance? Maybe Bartel? Good problem to have I guess.
You could trade in Joyce or Hibberd into midfield and swing Bartel to mids. Always handy to have DPP exactly for this
Very nice derek
Joyce is playing and Norf played.
get aaron francis in
Done 3 upgrades this week (Bartel was one) so can't do another trade, rance to the bench it looks like
Nah Dusty has reached a new level for mine, tank is huge this year
Agreed I locked him in this week 😉 Whats this comment in relation to though anyway?
To Patch lol I just noticed too I did not reference anything 🙁
I VC him this week btw reckon he can go large
just noticed Z.Dawson on 43 half time lol
Could he beat his 96 back in round 3 2011?
Might trade him in for Brodie…
Significant output from zac dawson should be a solid captain pick for the rest of the year!
He has increased $2k. Might have missed the boat
Come on Pendles, need you to find something.
The bloody ball would be a good start.
S.Collins – Skills are sensational
Oh no guys Pendles on the bench whole of 8 mins into the 3rd not good signs
Pies supporter but loving collins tonight
Slapped the VC on Pendles tonight and hasn't that just gone crackers so far. Pathetic doesn't come close to describing the man's game tonight
I think Dawson even has Pendles beat tonight.
Who else has Collins on the field. I have no choice. Only got 18 players. But looking good. And Barlow and Treloar 🙂
I have him as emergency but will take his score over Brands. I have Collins, Barlow, Cox, Smith and Phillips so I am a happy man apart from my donut
I am benching Gibson to take Collin's score….
6 premos on the defense line and cant believe i have to take the rookie's score
I'm benching the Rug.
Have Gibbo now your making me 2nd guess.
Bloody sc.
First 3 players for me this week. Collins Barlow and Treloar. Have VC on Barlow. So will probably go danger. Although there will be some scaling
Yes put him on in the last 3 min before the game started instead of Tucker, guess he makes up for Pendles whom I bought this week. Oh well that's SuperCoach.
If one was to have Rocky/Trelor/Collins etc… as VC, what score would suffice as to not put the C on DANGER?
130?
140?
more?
Last week passed up 130 on Rocky for Danger but don't know if I'd push my luck to far.
hmmm.. you did gamble well.
I took rockys 130 last week… to be honest id do it again … I think…
Hi Hoot. I took Rocky's 130 last week too. Got the VC on him again and i'll take his 130 again if he has a good one. Danger is a beast but I generally take anything over 125 from my VC.
Normally i'd say 130+ is a good time to take the VC score. I think though that if Danger keeps the form up, you'd probably want 150 from a vc so you get at least 300 points. 130 is a great score from Rocky (which I took last week) but when you have guys like Danger who score as big as he has been doing. It's really all or nothing. You break from the majority of the pack who are going to put the C on Danger and you either get a good score from your VC and Danger just goes mad and pumps out 350+, or your VC scores good and Danger has a downer, and the majority of the field gets a dodgy captains score. I have a feeling though that if Rockliff gets another big score, and I decide to stick with Danger, he will probably have a average game.
Had Collins on the bench this week as an emergency, and i have decided im going to loophole him. My backline is full premium and ive narrowed it down to two players that will be sitting this week on the bench, either Bartel or Rance, im thinking Rance is the better option because richmond are playing brisbane this week and i dont think itll be in their back half alot. Thoughts?
Rance for sure
Same dilemma, taking the punt and putting rance on the bench, even if he gets 120, 117 from Collins is a safe score to lock away
Can you bring Joyce into your midfield and swing Bartel into the guts?
I've already got Joyce in midfield just for this.
Unfortunately no, didn't have enough trades to spend one on getting a dpp/loophole player like Joyce
Have you seen Rance's previous scores V's Brisbane
SC predicts a sub 90 which is in line with history.
Take Collins 😉
The question wasn't whether I take collins' score or not, it was who he replaces in my back line, thanks though 🙂
Hi Tux. I'm benching Rance to take Collins' score. I've got Shaw, Doc, Simmo, Bartel, Rance and Laird this week and will bench Rance as Laird has already played.
Like Derek's idea but can't afford to use a trade just for this purpose.
We have the exact same backline Gherkin haha
Those pods tho…
Same Delimma for me as well. Got one of Gibson, Bartel, Docherty, Simpson, Shaw to put on the pine. Who should it be? That was my order of preference
Gibson. The Hawks backline will get real cold on Sunday, won't have to do much
Interesting. i only got 17 due to Zorko,wells,stewart,hopper debacle. So collins score sweet as,so to the new big cox.The answer is there grayson,u know the answer.
Thanks Derek for confirming what I thought as well! Cheers
Hoot 130 I'd take that usually but there was a bit of a debate on weather the loophole worked so I didn't want to risk losing my c points, I was very happy it payed off but nowwe know the loophole works I probably wouldn't risk it.
thanks for the feedback 😉
I think Geel V's the Saints, id require a 130+ from my VC to not go Patrick.
Pendles, Hanners, Neale all cheap soon. I am indeed aroused. Will be bringing 2'in soon for Wines and Libba which 2 do I pick?
Neale and Pendles for me, I love hannebery but he has a lot of players to contend with in the Sydney midfield. Also less ownership for Neale.
Likewise. I'm thinking Hanners and Pendles but you can't go wrong with either of the three really.
I've already got Pendles and am looking at Hanners or Neale for after the byes. Leaning towards Neale for a bit of a POD compared to Hanners and he's so consistent (last week aside). Looking at Hanners scores, he's been a beast but dropped of significantly over the last few weeks. Not sure if he just needed a rest with and he'll come out firing after the bye or if it's something else.
Pendles and Neale for mine.
We all forget what Ross Lyon can do. Pick Neale at your own risk.
Normally i'd agree, Derek. Ross the Boss tends to rest players leading into finals, not likely an issue this year. It seems Barlow was dropped earlier in the year to work on his defensive gam and is now getting 100's as a defensive mid/tagger. Highly doubt Neale will be dropped or rested given Freo's shocking run of injury, I think they've only got 28 fit players to choose from.
Having said that, it IS Ross Lyon so anything is possible I spose.
neale is my new favourite player, except for the robbo tag, has been magnificent this season. Not a surprise he is the leading poss getter in the comp.
good call. I do like that Freo play 4 of their last 5 games at home.
BUT, 6 of their last 7 are against top 8 teams. Hmmmmmmmm
I planned to trade Collins to Rance next week, that won't be happening now.
Is Tom Lee injured or omitted?
Hi Derek,
The best laid plans … then this round.
My backline looks ok so I was hoping to keep Collins as bench cover going forward. Smiling after tonight.
Having said that… if you have another def as bench cover why not go to Rance ?
I know your views on cash generation but if you think Rance will outscore Collins by 30 to 50 pts per round for the next few weeks, and it helps you through next weeks bye, then I reckon pull the trigger.
P.S. If Lee is your bench cover hold. He wont be back for a few weeks.
Hold Collins I mean 🙂
good call.
My defence is currently: Shaw, Laird, Bartel, McVeigh, Rich, BSmith (Collins, Lee) – plus Joyce in Mids.
Was going to upgrade Collins to Rance and then loop Rich, BSmith & Joyce as D6.
Collins good form plus hold for cash generation, changes the plan a bit. Collins has bye next week. Still have 11 trades after this week.
Maybe upgrade Rich next week to Rance, then upgrade Collins to Doch in a few more weeks? And still keep BSmith at D7.
All week to think about it, unless Rich gets chopped this week.