add_filter('comment_flood_filter', '__return_false');

AFL PODCAST – Round 10

Published by Jock on

afl-rd10

In a week where the big guns were down, Jock gives his team a rousing speech to inspire them to reach new levels.

In this casting of the pod ….

  • We start with a big one – Is Gawn gone?
  • What genuine FWD options are around and is Tippett the real deal?
  • Crouching’s skates right on the edge with his Pyanmanese Children’s Story ….. but that’s what we have come to expect.
  • Higgo goes again with his Quantum Team Mechanics segment, suggesting Brett Deledio is a must have.
  • Wayno  … Fantasy News Daily …. and HEAPS MORE!

As mentioned in the podcast – there are TWO HUGE SUNDAY SESSIONS this weekend for the COLLvDOGS game. Get on down to either DOYLES BRIDGE HOTEL in Mordialloc or THE COVE in Patterson Lakes.

coachkings-sunday-session-doyles-email

fi

get-social

plynow

This week’s CoachKings Fixture

afl-fixture

**SOUTH AUSTRALIAN VENUES TAKE BOTH THE CROWS AND PORT GAMES ON THE SATURDAY.

www.coachkings.com.au

Enjoy the podcast – enjoy the week!

Jock Reynolds


Subscribe
Notify of
guest
472 Comments
Oldest
Newest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
sc king

i have 438k to spend on a forward, who should i get, dont have to spend it all

cashcows

Not a lot you can do with that price.

I feel like your doing a cashcow + cash trade and it's not enough. If it's a kerridge or a benken I'd wait. Or do another trade for more $$$ to a premo forward

sc king

im reaaly looking to get rid of brown asap and i have just downgraced mills to hopper to make the extra cash, but it still only gives me an awkward price of 438k when trying to get rid of brown

Hubba

Best look for a hopper alternative then . Will pick you up another 60k to hey a proper premo

Northernsoul74

I'd hold off and build cash until you can afford someone you really want in a week or 2.

Kev

What options do you have, sc king? It's too late in the season for a stepping stone type player

Steeeve

Wingard your best chance at a premo

Danners

Find more money

Leeds17

Not sure what price Gunston is but he'd be a good in this week with the run Hawks have coming up

Cam

Mate if you get in matheson instead of hopper youve got an extra 80k to work with. Much more options then

@wheels_1987

Do not buy anyone with that

pointless

Make more $ and get Lids

dean

thoughts on my team and any trade ideas would be awesome cheers!
DEF: SHAW, DOCHERTY, SIMPSON, LAIRD, BOYD, TIPPA, (DBJ, BROWN)
MID: DANGERFIELD, PARKER, GABLETT, WARD, LIBBA, GAFF, SMITH, PETRACCA (DAVIS, MACPHERSON, DUNKLEY)
RUCK: NIC NAT, GAWN (LOERSCH)
FWD: MARTIN, BARLOW, WINGARD, HALL, KERRIDGE, WELLS (MCGOVERN, KENNEDY)

CHEERS COMMUNITY

dean

currently have 20 trades and 100K

cashcows

Sitting pretty with that team, i like it.

Only one I see is probably DBJ to Williams for the 200k.
Then look to upgrade in the midfield.

I N Pieman

Cracking intro Jock. One of the all time great rev ups. You give one to Ross this week old mate! We want Barlow

Liam

Great stuff fellas.
Does anyone know if Wells is going to play ?

jake

Probably, he has to get through tomorrows training session, but if he does he's a certainty.

Lucid

Triple m radio Brayshaw said he assumes he will play if he trains well. He's on hold for me. Imo should be a premo forward if not for injuries ruining him.

@wheels_1987

Already got rid of him

throw around the word "Achilles" then your OUT

cashcows

If it doesn't then he's gotta go. Either way we'll get a decisive answer.

Liam

Why do you think he has to go. If he doesn't play this week he might play next.

cashcows

Thats what we said last week. At some point you just gotta call it. With him we just don't know if 1 week is 1 week. Yes we've already waited the 2 or 3 he's been out and 1 wouldn't hurt but his track record doesn't help.

John

This week is it better to go mitch brown to chad wingard or darcy bryne jones for bailey williams thoughts?

Pinidu

Downgrade DBJ and get the cash mate, I reckon there are better options than Wingard out there if u can find the cash

@wheels_1987

I got WINGARD last week

I think he will bounce back

I went DBJ to T.McDONALD. risk v reward move hoping Tmac can get back to last year form

Pinidu

Thoughts on my team and trades this week community?

36K and 21 trades
DEF: Shaw, Laird, Simpson, Rance, Gibson, Adams (AMT, DBJ)
MID: Danger, Pendles, Gazza, Priddis, Libba, Mills, Parish, Smith (Hewett, Menadue, Dunkley)
RUC: Gawn, Nic Nat (Wyatt)
FWD: Dusty, Hall, Barlow, Greene, Wells, Kerridge (Kennedy, Petracca)

DBJ (BE: 106) –> B. Williams (or Tucker/Lee if named)
Parish/Mills –> Robbie Gray
Who needs to go first: Parish or Mills?

CJudd3Votes

Parish. Given a BE of 52 id say it's not the right week to get rid of Mills if you got other options

Kev

Breakevens say Parish

cashcows

Williams got some good comments out of Bevo on his performance v GWS so he's in, but if he's not I wouldn't even consider tucker or lee, esp if DBJ is out, no price change.

Whoever has the higher BE i suppose or wait. Think Gray still has a high ish BE but i've got him already pre injury.

Roger

Thoughts on the best option for this week
Def : Shaw, SImpson, Laird, Brown, Hartley, Tippa, (Byrne Jones, Brand)
Mid : Dangerfield, Hanners, Pendlebury, Parker, Ward, Ablett, Libba, Petracca (Smith, Davis, Mccpherson)
Rk: Gawn, Martin (Grimley)
Fwd : Zorka, Montagna, Franklin, Hall, Greene, Kerridge (Short, Cox)
224k spare change.
Obvious trade is Byrne Jones to Williams
Which leaves me with 409k.
Not sure what to do with the second trade.
If I trade Short for a premium Mid/Fwd I'll still have Both Brown and Hartley on the field which is a weak link.
I'm keeping Hartley for another week because his BE is reachable so Brown is probably the likely one to go.
The question is, who should I get. I want to get Bartel next week because his got a high BE and Hartley should make another 10k so I'll upgrade Hartley to Bartel. But is it too late to get Docherty ? 550k is a lot for a defender and there is really no one else who is cheap in defence that scores consistent.
Any thoughts community ? Thanks

Liam

DBJ to Rance.

@an3vilmonk3y

Rance next week? His BE is 135…

cashcows

For what its worth, I brought in Docherty this week. Low BE but yes his price should come back down at some point but I'd expect him to still float around 500k towards the end of the season. So losing 50k to fluctuant prices for a consistent 90+ with a ceiling to go 130~, I'd bank that.

Plus someone said here he has kick in duties. Kicks = more points for us.

The GOAT

panda panda panda panda panda

Dan

I got broads in altlanta

hedski

Come and have a gander

min0008

Hey community, I have a few options for trades.
Option 1: DBJ to Williams and Martin to Goldstein
Option 2: DBJ to Williams and Brown to Priddis
Option 3: DBJ to Williams and Brown to Hopper and bank 320k.

CJudd3Votes

2. If you run low on trades you'd be more annoyed to still have Brown in your side than Martin

min0008

I have 20 trades before making any and need 1 def, 1 mid and 2 fwd upgrades needed presuming Libba and Wells are keepers.

Danners

Tough one, Option 1 since this is the last chance for Goldstein

Randomclcihe

I like one. I bought goldy last week 🙂 just wish I'd started gawn nic nat instead of bloody kruzer!

@wheels_1987

2

CJudd3Votes

Personally i reckon Jock has every reason to be considering Gawn to Goldy, if you are in a situation that is low on trades stay the hell away but if you're looking good with trades you could do worse becuase i reckon the entire community would back Goldy in to get more points for the remainder of the season

Pinidu

Is this instance…what would u classify as 'low' or 'high' trade numbers for those contemplating a Gawn –> Goldy trade?

Southern S

20 trades

Southern S

The problem with this is, if Goldy gets an 80 next week and Gawn gets 150+ then what?

They will be equal in score for the entire season that's what.

People were talking about trading Goldy after he got his 49 and said he looked cooked, he's injured, he's gonna get rested etc etc etc

This is ludicrous.

He's had a couple of bad scores in the last two rounds but remember he was the number one ruckmen a week or two ago.

Three scores of over 160. HOLD PEOPLE (Unless you have Stefan Martin)

Tommo09

I agree Southern
Gawn goes MASSIVE

Southern S

The bloke is only human, people forget this, could've been sore or could've just been down on form.

I reckon he'll be pumped for a big game vs Port this week.

@wheels_1987

agreed , in a perfect world that would be a good trade

however in a perfect world you would have started with goldy already

and that said, you wouldnt want to trade into goldy only to see him rested through the bye rounds (possible)

DARBY

Is this a good trade

Dbj-Boyd
Ben Ken- Buddy Franklin

please answer community

CJudd3Votes

Unless you're set everywhere else I'd leave BenKen for the moment, assuming your team is like everyone elses there are bigger fish to fry

Randomclcihe

In isolation it is a perfect trade. However I prefer lids priddis montanga and some north ruck who seems to go okay over bud.

@wheels_1987

Ken to Bud = good
DBJ to Boyd = bad

CJudd3Votes

Kade bloody Kolodashit what do we do with him? Hold seems like the obvious answer but the bastard is just embarrassing now

Scott

Yeah he's let us all down, but have to hold him now and just hope he gets better.

Steeeve

Hold and hope you find some money later to upgrade the useless prick

@wheels_1987

have to hold mate unfortuantely

DEF line should be your last priority. concentrate on FWD and MID

Brent

Thoughts on Chad wingard? So tempting at that price of around 380k

Danners

Seems to be playing the Monfries role, wait another week though to see what happens

Derek

Chad plays well when RGray plays well

Dean

I got a lot of time for the wingard especially at these prices.

@wheels_1987

i got him last week and enjoyed his 100+ score

@winterjames5

my team with $41,200 in the kitty

DEF- Shaw, Docherty, Laird, Enright, Tipungwuti, Byrne (DBJ, Ruggles)
MID- Dangerfield, Hannebery, Ward, Ablett, Shiel, Priddis, Ziebell, Lewis (Hewett, Davis, Gresham)
RCK- Gawn, Nic Nat (Lorensch)
FWD- Martin, Hall, Kerridge, DeGoey, Petracca, Benken (Menaspud, J.smith – who is a 102k non playing rookie)

was thinking of getting rid of DBJ for Williams giving me about 250k for an upgrade

advice on who i should upgrade?

@an3vilmonk3y

bank the cash, get a premo next week.

Leeds17

Worth waiting till Tursday to see what Defender Freo bring in for Pearce, Collins was solid in the NAB and Tucker is on the bubble.

Neverweaken

Thoughts on J Kennedy for forward?
And someone other than Williams for cash. Have Boyd Adams and Suckling

Kev

Lee, Tucker, and O(ld) McDonald are backline rookies on the bubble this week. JS for all three is shaky

Mickey P

I am thinking Josh Kennedy too … can score big and has been pretty good all year. Will carve it up this week I reckon

@wheels_1987

i like to avoid KPF in my team. i like Fwd/Mids but up to you

JB_Tank

Billy Smedts. 190k def. ruggles and bews won't hold their places. Jake Kolo and Smedts will be in the best back 6 in their places and he's ready to break out now. Tearing it up in the twos and playing for his future.

Mb88

No one talking bout down grading to hopper??

cashcows

Mathieson and Trengrove are upcoming mid rookies who are cheaper.
Unless you in a trade surplus I wouldnt go hopper. Depends what you using him for. Stepping stone or keeper?

Steeeve

I'd considered grabbing him as a keeper m10. Use as an emergency if I have an injury later in the year. Or as m8 if I have two short term injuries.

Worth it?

Randomclcihe

I'm doing it…but I've got plenty of csh to start with…

@wheels_1987

Cookie Cutter move in my opinion

Micky

communtiy plz tell me gawn to goldstein is crazy right?

Papsmear

I wouldnt

Danners

It's crazy

Southern S

It's not completely crazy, but it's not wise.

Hold.

Brook

it's a.good move I think … if you'd done it last week it was the classic bruen manoeuvre ,,, but still worth it this week in my book, you would have jumped on a straight swap at the start of the year.

Southern S

Actually rethinking it, yes it's freakin crazy after two low scores.

If he can't score well vs Port this week then consider it.

Dean

I think it is something to seriously consider for a number of reasons. Firstly because of Goldy's massive decline in price and those with Gawn he seems to be carrying some injury.
Gawn also has a massive break even of 236, so Gawn is projected to drop a further $61,000 this week alone meaning you wont be able to get Goldy for a straight swap with Gawn after this week as Goldy's breakeven is only at 66 so he should increase in price.

It is a shame those who make this trade cannot see what Gawn scores against Port Adelaide because if he scores another sub 75 then this would almost certainly confirm that he is playing injured and if thats confirmed then pi$$ing him off would be crucial.

Most importantly if your have less then 21 trades left then I would NOT do this trade however if you have more then 21 trades then for Gods sake play it safe and Trade Gawn to Goldy.

John

Well said, although I disagree with 21 trades. The less you have, the more you can't afford to lose out on this trade! Great move!

@wheels_1987

Good move in a perfect world

Micky

thoughts on these trades community
DBJ to williams
and
brown to docherty
thoughts plz

bUCKET__

Gunna be a popular move I reckon Micky, thinking of doing the same. Doch isn't underpriced anymore, but is looking like a top 6 defender.

Just depends on whether you would rather pick up a bloke who is underpriced instead and upgrade a different line (e.g. Priddis, Lids). If DBJ is missing some weeks and won't decrease in price I might hold him a bit longer and upgrade elsewhere.

Dean

EXCELLENT trades. I am doing similar trades, however im getting Shaw rather then Docherty.

@wheels_1987

you must worry about your MID and FWD line first

golden rule of sc

dont stuff around with DEF until last

Tulendeena

MacPherson or Davis out for Hopper?

Longterm I feel macpherson will be better

Steeeve

Davis is making money, MacPherson is not. And Gold Coast could bring a lot of talent back before MacPherson returns. Might not be easy to break back into the side.

Dean

Pi$$ OFF McPherson mate.

@wheels_1987

i think this bloke is trying to troll people

ridiculous comment

Lesley

Hey community, just wanting to know if I'm still on track for a full premo team:
DEF:Shaw,Rance,Laird,Simpson,Birchall
Dea(AMT,Williams)
MID:Pendles,Danger,Hanners,Pridis,Libba,
Mills,Smith,Keays(Davis,Dmac,Dunkley)
RUC:Goldy,NicNat(Loersch)
FOR:Martin,Montagna,Greene,Hall,Kerridge
Wells(Petracca,Menadue)

I would really appreciate your thoughts

Stevo

Need to get that midfield upgraded. Otherwise pretty solid.

Kevdog

here is my team

DEF: Shaw, Simpson, KKolo, Brown, DBJ, Adams (Hartley, Broad)
MID: Danger, Hanners, Ablett, Jelwood, Steven, Shiel, Libba, Keays (Smith, Davis, Macpherson)
RUC: Gawn, Martin
FWD: Dusty, Zorko, Barlow, Hall, Kerridge, Petracca (Tippa, Wells)

are these good trades ?
Brown to b.Williams
DBJ to Docherty

Danners

Good trades, although running a risk with two Carlton defenders

Blueth

your defense is making me emotional

Southern S

Classic

Leeds17

What to do with Tom Mitchell? Tempted to go to Pendles or Hanners, might be sideways but least those to are real Premos… potentially just a early in the week rage trade.

Randomclcihe

In not surprised that is the case that you have rage trade itis. Any player that is not 100 percent with the coach /group must be avoided. Any coach that is not 100 percent with his players must be avoided…glares at ross*….

But. You must hold. Your research ya would have identities a ball magnet who was out scoring his sublime team mates on a per minute basis. That was the gamble you took that it would hold for a season proper. Should an injury or two hit the swans mids…who were fantastic against the hawks…you'll be in the money before you know it. Just chances are it won't happen. But go sideways and you lock in your losses and lose a trade.

*Fyfeislife….you know they say about rules

Randomclcihe

Sorry about phone auto correct…

@wheels_1987

hold mate

make him your final trade once all your lines are full

sideways trading now… may as well give up

randomcliche

Dear God I hope you held!

Leeds17

Haha yeah mate! Not bad from young Titch should never be mad at him only Longmire.

Tophawk

How long will Jonas get rubbed out for community? The hearing is not going well for Jonas. He has forfeited a one week discount with an early plea. He didn't take it, as he argued his actions were careless and not intentional. The judge is not impressed and has implied that he is lying.

I reckon he could cop at least 8 weeks now.

Tophawk

I was close. He got 7 weeks by the looks of it.

Randomclcihe

Bloke comes out on media says he'll cop his walk the goes on to argue… #foolish #deceitful #contrivedcrap #suckstobehim

Randomclcihe

*Wack

@wheels_1987

6 weeks gone

confirmed

but who cares, not fantasy relevant

Mickey P

Trade Gawn to Goldy – thoughts Community?

Before you shout me down, just looking for arguments both ways to make an informed decision as I know it is sideways and burns a trade which may not be worth it??
– Goldy is $7k cheaper and averaging 119ppg compared to Gawn average of 111ppg
– Goldy has two sub 100 scores and Gawn has five – more inconsistent
– Goldy averages 113 at Etihad and plays there 7 more times while Gawn averages 93 at MCG and plays there 6 more times

I have 23 trades left and Nic Nat as my other ruck, would prefer to focus on upgrading cash cows, but Gawn about to plummet and Goldy about to shoot up means this chance wont come again this season – what to do!!!!????

johnno2908

Goody proven ultra premo. I'm really contemplating doing the same thing. Although you know when you do it, the beard will come out and go massive. He is playing a pretty much ruckless Port Adelaide this week. The trade to Goldy also gives you another reliable Captain option.

Danners

Seems stupid, Gawn is not a ruckman that much out of form. HOLD

Tommo09

Really?
Gawn scores huge

FisherDan

Why would you burn a trade in the ruck? Gawn as your number 2 isn't going so badly with three scores 160+. I had to burn a trade in the ruck last year because I (like many others) had the Skin-flute Minson who gave us NOTHING then got himself dropped. Gawn is no Minson!
Trust your intestinal fortitude that made you select him in the first place.

Southern S

Didn't someone do a side trade of Pendlebury to Ablett this year?

Brook

I must admit I did and it still hurts … live and learn!

Southern S

Think Jock did it too? I could be wrong though.

Randomclcihe

I favour of gawn is potential to go real large and get massive avg. Goldy more likely to do it.

Here is the killer. Nic nat to Goldy. If you belive in gawn you've gotta chop nic nat. Just an idea.

Southern S

Nic Nat to Goldy that's a spanner in the works.

JamiesNinjas13

Surely you have more pressing concerns than a weak sideways trade especially when you haven't used many trades. A big argument against is you are wasting 1 trade. This is supercoach, not AFL fantasy.

Randomcliche

We just shark fishing. Wot u doing?

Jojo

How do my trades look fellas
DBJ > M.Byod
A.Gaff > J.Hopper

@wheels_1987

rubbish

@t_woof

Surely Gaff will only miss one round if any, use your bench cover and hold him.
Wasting 2 trades there, when no LTI's.

Randomcliche

Garbos in Canberra are on strike. Maybe they can come pick up your trade in their spare time. You missed the Boyd boat. Simpson to outscore from here.

Steeeve

22 trades and $343k in the kitty. Here's my team in case it helps you to help me.
Back: H Shaw, J Gibson, R Laird, K Kolodjashnij, A McDonald-Tipungwuti, D Byrne-Jones (M Brown, T Ruggles)
Mids: P Dangerfield, S Pendlebury, J Selwood, G Ablett, T Liberatore, O Wines, T Rockliff, G Hewett (D MacPherson, R Davis, J Smith)
Ruck: T Goldstein, N Naitanui (S Grimley)
Fwd: D Martin, A Hall, D Wells, C Wingard, S Kerridge, C Petracca (B Kennedy, C Menadue)

Which option do you prefer?
Byrne-Jones and MacPherson to Kade Simpson and Jacob Hopper
or
Byrne-Jones and Ben Kennedy to Brett Delidio

Other options would be Sam Docherty instead of Kade Simpson, or Daniel Wells (if still out) instead of BenKen.

Any thoughts greatly appreciated

Stevo

Option 1 looks solid. Wait another week on Deledio, though he could go large against the Dons this weekend.

Tiges

I'd be trading out DBJ to Williams and Menadue to a FWD or DEF premo (by swinging Tippa forward)… $550k is pretty steep for a defence premo and still reckon Lids hasn't bottomed out… all solid options though.

Southern S

Agreed.

Steeeve

Footywire predicts LIds will keep dropping after that 125 comes out of his price, but I'm not so sure. Last year everyone kept waiting for him to drop and it just wasn't happening.

Thinking I'll take your advice and go DBJ to Williams/Menadue to Lids.
Unless of course Williams is dropped.

Votes

Priddass Or Robbie Gray?

Danners

Priddis this week

@wheels_1987

flip a coin

Gibbs

which out of these 3 options do I take?
Hewett to Gray/Priddas or
Brown to Boyd
Kenedy to Daulhaus

Southern S

option one.

Danners

Tough one, but Brown to Boyd

@wheels_1987

option 1

breakevens

brown to boyd

RoughNuts

Ok community what are peoples thoughts on McVeigh from the swannies. Break even is 131 so you could hold at least a week but surely to good a player not to come home as a top 8-10 backman this year.

Southern S

Could hold for 2-3 of weeks the way he is scoring, doesn't get any midfield time it seems.

And no can't see him being a top 10 defensive player this year, which is kinda sad because he is a great player.

Might grab him as a very cheap D6/D7 though later.

Leeds17

I brought him in 2 weeks ago and have regretted in, looks really off the pace, there were signs late Friday that he was coming good but genuine concerns he's over the hill.

RoughNuts

Yeah i was meant to watch him closely on Friday night when I was at the G but ended up having to many cans so don't actually remember to much of the match. My worry with McVeigh is he got 28 touches a 3-4 wks ago now and took 14 marks but only scored 91. He is getting close to sub $400k though which is to good a price I reckon to ignore. Best scenario for me is DBJ has a week or 2 off and I wait for McVeigh to bottom out completely and swoop on him at around $400k.

@wheels_1987

after the byes will be a must look but not for me right now

Geoff

Make Kennedy Captain if you have him against the Suns
Good call-Bad call???

RoughNuts

May is back and will be looking to make up to his team mates. I thought I read somewhere Rory Thompson could be back also. Risky pick but could pay massive dividends. I'm saying a not for me call, safer picks this wk.

Blueth

dont see it as risky at all. He can be dodgy but not against the suns at home.

@wheels_1987

if you have the stones for it do it

Tophawk

Jonas copped 6 weeks.

Southern S

Made an example of him that's for sure.

@wheels_1987

k

Stevo

Sterling Podcast and rousing speech Jock.

Trade conundrum, have $53k kitty. Team:

B: Shaw, Rance, Rich KK, AMT, DBJ (Hartley, Rug Munch)
C: Pendles, Danger, Ward, Selwood, Parker, Ablett, J.Smith (Keays, Gresham, MacPherson)
R: Goldy, Gawn (Grimley)
F: Zorko, Martin, Hall, Wells, Kerridge, Petraca (M.Brown, Menapoo).

To get Priddis, I'd have to trade DBJ & J.Smith to get Priddis & B.Williams. That would take the mid to near full premo.

Think it's too early for Deledio & Docherty too expensive.

Any other options really appreciated.

Danners

Priddis isn't a must have this week. Maybe trade Brown to Montagna/Z.Merrett or another premo forward

Stevo

Thanks Danners, though that move would put Petraca at F7 while weaker Rookie J.Smith at M8. And moving on Brown loses that DPP swing with AMT.

Tiges

16 trades with $90k left in the bank.
I'm considering downgrading DBJ to Lee/Tucker and banking the $200k.
I'd be able to in R11 then trade out Davis/Hewett for Mathieson/Gray and then in R12 trade out Tippa for Dahlhaus.
Would only leave a mid spot left in the forward and defence for Dusty and Rance in R14.

THOUGHTS?

DEF//
SHAW, SIMPSON, BOYD, GIBSON, LAIRD, DBJ
//BROWN, WILLIAMS.

MID//
DANGERFIELD, WARD, ZAHARAKIS, ABLETT, MITCHELL, LIBBA, PRIDDIS, SMITH
//HEWETT, DAVIS, KEAYS.

RUCK//
GOLDY, GAWN,
//WYATT.

FORWARD//
ZORKO, MONTAGNA, HALL, BARLOW, PETRACCA, KERRIDGE
//TIPPA, COX.

Tommo09

Def: Shaw, Laird, Docherty, Tippa, DBJ, Brown (Adams, Byrne)
Mid: Danger, GAJ, Parker, Pendles, Hannebery, Libba, Smith, Petracca (Keays, Gresham, MacPherson
Ruc: Goldy, NicNat (Grimley)
Fwd: Martin, Franklin, Barlow, Hall, Wells, Kerridge (Kennedy, Menadue)

Thinking Menadue and Gresham/DBJ to Priddis and Hopper/Williams
$345k and 19 trades left
Scored 2412 last weekend and am ranked 2500
Thoughts??

Blueth

yuo should definitely start trading in some premo defenders, maybe Simpson for DBJ?

Tommo09

Don't have enough if I get Priddis

Alex

Can someone please post the relevant break evens, thanks

Blueth
@wheels_1987

or buy SC Gold …

Tommo09

Barlow better play this week!
Ross, we're on to you!

medadsson

On local news tonight … if you can believe him, Lyon said that Barlow is a definite starter for the game against St Kilda.

@wheels_1987

Ross is a flog #putyourchopsticksoutforbarlow

Alec

Traded Barlow to zorko last week as I couldn't handle it any longer!

adam henwood

hey jock and higgo,thoughts please on cognilio,neale as a pod in my midfield,V dalhaus as a dpp and my last fwd for later on in the year?team as it is,is pretty good,going well altho keep shizenhousing my C but still in top 100 ;P 82nd..going for the big prize boys,just need to get this next few decisions right,im 2 shy of full premium and dont give a stuff about worrying about full premo backs,ive got 4,thatll do,its our strategy this year as sticking too it,no need for 6 primos in backs,they all suck sometimes anyway 😛 Adam

@wheels_1987

Well with typing / grammar like that i highly doubt you have the brains to be ranked in the top 20,000 let alone 82nd. That said, I also highly doubt someone ranked 82nd would be asking a pretty straightforward / stupid question.

That said…

If you can justify it, then do it. Don't ask us what we think. You tell us what YOU think and tell us WHY

Learn from this, and maybe one day you actually will be ranked 82nd

Good Luck

Pom

Stef martin to Goldy? Only 100k difference

Or mitch brown to priddis? 200k difference

Mad to trade martin?

Tom

im in the same boat and thinking about getting rid of martin, might give him chance to make back his losses though and get gawn in soon enough

bUCKET__

Looked to me like West was bought in to basically nullify Gawn (ala Tom Campbell). It worked, but pushed Stef forward for a lot of the game. And the ball wasn't there all that much.

Watching him take back the main ruck role this week.

Blueth

people say he has a totally new 'role'. I'm not sure what this means when he is still first ruck, perhaps someone can fill us in…

Anil

He was rotating between rucking and playing fwd. And playing fwd for Brisbane is supercoach suicide

@wheels_1987

you answered your own question at the end there…..

dont trade Martin

Blueth

Pre Round 9 team (Rank: 2556, top 1%)

DEF: Shaw, Docherty, Simpson, Bartel, Laird, Hurn (Brown, Cuddles)
MID: Danger, Parker, Shiel. Bont, Ablett, Libba, Priddis, B. Crouch (i know i know, calm down) (Hewett, J.Smith, Davis)
RUX: Goldy, Gawn (Cox)
FWD: Merrett, Greene, Hall, Wells, Petracca, AMT (McGovern. Grimley)

Definitely gonna cut Brown for Williams if he's selected. My question is, do i go to Dusty (BE 83) from Tippa (BE 45) this week or hold?

Blueth

20 trades left btw.

Tiges

Team looks solid, plenty of POD's.
Would you consider trading out Wells to Dusty and then Tippa can go around the bye rounds instead?

Blueth

Would you still suggest doing that if Wells is named this week?

Tom

williams or hopper?

Papsmear

williams

Northernsoul74

Wait and see if Williams keeps his place. If he does with Boyd and potentially Adams, Suckling it's a good sign. His form warrants keeping his place.

Steeeve

Then he'll still make way for JJ in a few weeks I fear

Northernsoul74

JJ is at least 5 weeks away and they will be ultra cautious with him.

@wheels_1987

If you want to distance yourself from the heard, dont go Hopper

Southern S

Yep I already failed with MacPherson can't take the Hopper risk.

Tommo09

Captain and VC options this week??
Thinking Danger C and maybe Martin/Shaw for VC
Any other better options??

Papsmear

I threw the C on Shaw last week. But throwing the VC on him this week not sure if I will Go Pendles or Danger? Think Danger might come out and be a bloody ripper this week with the last 2 poor showings and the lose to the Pies?

Southern S

I'm thinking Hannebery (or maybe Parker) in what will be a big clash vs North on friday night,

Or possibly Gawn vs Port.

Then there's Shaw vs Carlton at Etihad, even after a 200 not convinced he's my best choice this week.

Then probably captain Danger (or even Docherty – risky)

There's even Ablett or Nic Nat on the Sunday who I could captain too.

Too many choices right now………………

Tommo09

Shaw is up against Adelaide I think

Southern S

Yep it's danger vs carlton at Etihad, I reckon he'll go big.

Not too Shaw about Shaw at Adelaide Oval.

Leeds17

Montagna VC Danger C

@wheels_1987

Im going Goldy friday night and probably Pendles against the Dogs.. Either that or Danger against Carlton

Chevy

Breaking the #1 rule side ways trade- stef martin for goldy!

Derek

Norfs next 5 games don,t worry you?

They have had a pretty easy draw so far

Chevy

Not overly… but there is always a but … lol

Tommo09

Top 6 defenders that are SuperCoach relevant??

Southern S

Dawson, Docherty, Simpson, Laird, Rance, Bartel, Boyd

The reason I have Dawson as my no.1 is because he is about to hit all australian form, and Shaw is going to spud it up and get about 20-30 for the rest of the year 🙂

That's my top 7 can't think of who to cull.

Tommo09

Not Gibson

Southern S

Nah not for me, he'd be 7-8.

Realistically there'd be 10+ guys who can make the top 6.

Thomas

Who do you think they are

Southern S

Shaw, Docherty, Simpson, Laird, Rance, Bartel, Boyd, Gibson, Enright. There's 9 I can think of.

Maybe Pittard, Savage, Williams, Rampe, Rich or even Jeremy Howe could all possibly have a crack at the top ten too, there's a long way to go in the season.

Southern S

Would like to see McVeigh in there too but not sure at this rate.

Rooster

Why do people continue with the stupid Dawson "jokes"?
Soft as sh** and not one bit funny!

Derek

Have you ever watched him play?

Southern S

Emotions are running high tonight on the internet.

@wheels_1987

you should get Dawson in your team

he is amazing and ultra premo DEF player

@wheels_1987

Dawson of the Zac variety is so amazing. Everyone keeps saying that what he did against Richmond was a dog act, i call it bravery #putyourchopsticksoutfordawsey

Joe

Going with a double downgrade this week community:
Brown to Williams & Menadue to Hopper via dpp
This gives me 17 trades and 405k, leaving my team like this:

B: Shaw, Simpson, Gibson, Rance, AMT, Laird (Ruggles, Williams)
M: Danger, Pendles, Hannebery, Shiel, Libba, Cripps, Smith, Hopper (Davis, Keays, Dunkley)
R: Gawn, Naitanui (Loersch)
F: Dusty, Zorko, Hall, Greene, Wells, Petracca (Kerridge, Adams)

Thoughts community? Should I do something else instead?

Derek

Priddis is a good price this week, playing the Suns at HOME

Papsmear

Menadue to hopper isnt much of a downgrade and well you will eventually trade out hopper?

Papsmear

If your going to downgrade down grade big with a fallen premo or injured who will miss many matches. Menadue to hopper is not worth it at all!

Joe

Might just stick with Brown to Williams and go Menadue to Priddis giving me 90k and 17 trades left instead!

Rocksta

Definitely the way to go

Micky

CVommuntiy
boyd or docherty

siri

Doc

Papsmear

Cant believe you are actually asking that?

Southern S

So what is this comment?

self centered
egotistical
You think you are such a know it all and you are a narcissist!

Nice job Pap. Pot calling the kettle black.

Papsmear

LOL you are a Skippy turd like someone said a week or 2 ago. cant even come up with your own material and steal other you are a loser Southern. They were right calling you a Skippy turd!

Southern S

You have some sort of deficiency that is quite obvious.

I'm not going to call you names or anything like that to feed your strange lust for conflict, but I do feel sorry for you.

Papsmear

Don't feel sorry for me! I want no sympathy for you! I know your mum is lacking a deficiency and it a lack of protein by not swallowing your egotistical, narcissistic, think you know it all loser arse!

Blueth

Papsmear or southern S?

Southern S

?

Blueth

just wondering who to trade, probably paps

Southern S

Yeah I'd trade Paps, Southern is a keeper.

😉

MY TWO CENTS

Double downgrade!

Hawker

Need help should I trade Birchall? nearly below 400K bleeding cash. Hawthorn's draw opens up, should I just stick with him.
Thoughts much appreciated

Papsmear

IMO keep him should do well in the next 8 rds??? But I'm no expert. He has Bri, Mel, Ess, NM, GC, PA, SYD, RICH, CAR and Mel? Its ur call? Think he might do well in this run? You have had him this long.

Papsmear

Or dump him for Williams to free up cash?

@wheels_1987

nah dont trade him.

SammyBoy

Is Wingard a legitimate trade in this week? Only $380k and average 90-95 last two years, seems a steal

Southern S

So you're combining his averages to make him more appealing?

He averaged 80 and then 97. Now he's averaging 75 this year.

But anyway I'll stop over analyzing (if it's possible for me to do that) and say yes he's a good buy at the moment.

@wheels_1987

i got him last week and he treated me too a tasty 100+ score

risky but big ball get big win

Neverweaken

Ok. Really not sure what to do. Team is
Shaw, Simpson, Docherty, Boyd, DBJ, Hartley. (Brown, Ruggles)
Ablett, Treloar, Danger, Selwood, Libba, Zaharakis, Hewett, Oliver, (Smith, Hall, MacPherson.)
NicNat, Goldie. Currie
Tippett, Martin, Kerridge, AMT, BenKen, Petracca. (Suckling, Adams)
342k and 18 trades.
Thinking big upgrade. DBJ out and has to be BenKen out to bring in for the cash for Priddis and Kennedy.
Or Priddis and Buddy. Going big and bold!

Leaves me not much but hopefully some Rookies about to trade Essendon and Melb players into at bye time

Nathan

With the b/e in mind you need to treade bdj and brown
Thatll give you 635 + the 342 you have leaves 977
So id look at maybe an oremo back and Wingard in the fwd line

BanthaFodder71

My side as it stands
DEF: Shaw – Simpson – Docherty – Dea – Adams – Laird (Tippa / DBJ)
MID: Danger – Parker – Jelwood – Zaha – GAJ – Libba – Smitchell – J. Smith (Menadue/Keays/D. Mac)
RUC: Goldy – Gawn (M. Cox)
FWD: Zorko – Hall – Kerridge – Wells – B. Kennedy – Petracca (M. Brown/Papley)

Have 187k before trades

thinking Gawn for Nic Nat
then possibly zaha for Dependlebury, Hanners or L. Neale but you can't trust Lyon to pick who he should atm.
Both have huge BE's this week and will lose plenty

Pendlebury has exploded over the last month!
Hanners has a S.D of 10 which is insane!
OR a simple Gawn to NicNat and DBJ to Williams leaves me a nice 480K in the bank

Any thoughts or suggestions appreciated community

Southern S

You can trust Lyons to play one player and that is Lachie Neale, because if he drops him he'll leave the club and then they may as well merge with a WAFL team and leave the AFL!

Don't like your trades. I bet three weeks ago you were walking around gloating to your mates how you got the steal of the year with Gawn and how he's top dog in the ruck division, now you're throwing him to the bloody curb!

If you bought Zaha for 415k like I did, hold him too, there's no real loss there and he will score good again, had 31 touches last week but a horrible DE. Think priddis….same boat, now scoring better.

You've got Sam Mitchell stinking it up like no other, but no mention of culling him? He's lost 100k and Zaha is still up 50k!

Stick by your guns.

Lets keep it simple and logical mate, DBJ to Williams and Menadue to one of the premo mids, so you can chuck Smith on to the bench, zaha will be your M8 and a fine one at that.

Welcome 🙂

Papsmear

Southern S you are suck a self centered egotistical person why dont you shut your mouth for once. You think you are such a know it all and you are a narcissist! Give it a rest…..Welcome : )

Southern S

You obviously don't understand my humour, nor can you read properly.

Welcome 🙂

Papsmear

You obviously dont understand when to shut your mouth and people are sick of you! Someone called you a a Skippy turd last week or the week before and starting to think they are right! You need to get one of Wayno's fly traps or leaf screens because every time you open your mouth sh*t spews from your mouth or some sort of sh*t coming out of it that attracts fly's! People asking simple questions and you try to demean them!

Southern S

'Sigh'

Notice how my two top lines are so ridiculous? It's called humour.

You can trust Lyons to play one player and that is Lachie Neale, because if he drops him he'll leave the club and then they may as well merge with a WAFL team and leave the AFL!

Don't like your trades. I bet three weeks ago you were walking around gloating to your mates how you got the steal of the year with Gawn and how he's top dog in the ruck division, now you're throwing him to the bloody curb!

There it is again for you, try to read carefully.

Now back up the page a bit someone asks a simple question of who is the better player out of Boyd and Docherty, both are scoring really well.

You reply with 'Can't believe you're asking that question'

Go take a look at yourself in the mirror you can't judge me lol, you were a prick to that person and acted like a know it all yourself.

Learn how to acknowledge humour from a serious post while you're at it.

Welcome!

Papsmear

Your mum must be proud big mouth! I'm sure she is wishing she had swallowed you now! Welcome! ; )

Southern S

lol best thing you've said tonight

Papsmear

Cant say you have said anything good tonight or ever! 1 me 0 you! Welcome! ; )