add_filter('comment_flood_filter', '__return_false');

PODCAST: Lockout Day

Published by Jock on

 

Crave Designs - stunning water features

Supercoach 2015

It’s time.

We’ve toiled as a community all preseason and a lot comes down to the decisions you will make over the next 24 hours.
Will you rise to the occasion? Will you set your Supercoach ship sailing majestically on a course of success? It’s all up to you and your constitutions now.
Enjoy the show – and the very best of luck in this special time.

 


Subscribe
Notify of
guest
530 Comments
Oldest
Newest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
schmit

39k left would love some opinions on my team…

Back: shaw, newnes, Lumumba
goodes, oxley, mcintosh (hamling, saad)
Mid: ablett, fyfe, parker
wines, stevens, rich
newton, cripps (Anderson, heeney, CEY)
Ruck: goldstien, maric (read)
Fwd: gray, martin, bennell
TBC, salem, clark (Hogan, lambert)

Cheers schmit

Ben

Newton is a tad overpriced I'd look for a cheaper option and use the cash elsewhere

steve

You kidding? The bloke averaged 68 from 55% game time

jimbo

Thinking the same.
Overpriced???

schmit

surely he'll get a first round gig? any chance of the vest though? who would be a suitable replacement?

jimbo

No chance of vest for me.

Kel

just wondering can anyone help regarding how sc does not show you which players you have saved as emergencies or captain is this just happening to me

Ron

It is hard to see – but the background colour does change. Doesn't have C or VC or E like last year

Tofor

I've gone with Sheed instead of Newton.
Tough call though.
I want to pick Anderson (huge Hawks fan), but just think he'll get lots of vest and struggle to get into the 22..?

Wllys Guns

MIDS need more premos.

maka

Thoughts on Geary or Ibbotson?

@TylerCArmstrong

Tossing up between defensive mid pricers also Maka, I'm liking Ibbo, Henderson and KK. But Geary… hmm idk, very risky and unproven. Would probably steer clear.

maka

Ibbo spare in defense you think?
Or 3rd man lockdown?

geoff_SCgod

@Maka

Hendo or T.Hunt could be a good option if you like.

I'm falling for Geary though, because of how much the ball might stay there every week.

samenglish

Very good call Geoffy Boy lovin your thinking mate

geoff_SCgod

The community does big things to your imagination in Supercoach.
Cheers mate.

demon

not sold on that theory, how many melbourne, gws, saints defenders have been big scorers the last 3 years?
not many that I can think of!!!

Ben

L. Dunn for melb had a purple run last season

maka

LEKD0G mentioned Colin Garland. He has little chance going big every year, but sometimes he does have that purple patch as you said Ben with L.Dunn. Both give you spud scores. Not worth it. You really might actually have to wait and see about each of Ibbo's and Geary's Role.
Uncertainty about Ibbo's.
Unsure about Geary's too.

@TylerCArmstrong

I think he will play spare man in defence, and if i'm right will average 85+

maka

Good to have the re-assurance.

Will the Freo defenders ever become fit though?

SCaddict

Both have shown ceilings that are much higher than their 2015 pricing so there is undeniable value there if they can play the first 6 or 7 games when you can look to upgrade them to dipping defensive guns.

There is even a slight chance they could be keepers but more likely to be a stepping stone to a Malceski or Simpson.

jimbo

I think Geary could avg. 80-85 due to Saints getting a lot of the ball in the back-line. He can be a good ball user.
I'm struggling on this decision.

Jimi

Feel your pain buddy, I've even gone as far to consider Laird and Bugg in the mix for my D4 equation, but for some unquantifiable reason my gut just keeps going to Geary.

There's no logic to it, but that's who I'm going. If it all blows up in my face, he won't be the first to burn me.

jimbo

Ibbo – 50 odd points in an half – less then 20 points the next half (In 1 of his NABs.)
Second half he played as a KPD (Key Position Defender)
1st half he roamed free.

High Risk = High Reward.

Jarryn Geary.
Looked solid through NAB – but thats only NAB.
Saints could have a 1000 touches every game considering how their list looks at its current state.

Again
High Risk = High reward.

maka

cheers guys!

Anymore thoughts please?

vinnymac

Ibbotson. I’m still not too sure who will take command in defense for the saints in this testing time for them.

Hangingforthelockout

Only have $3,700 left… Any suggestions welcome, obviously, rookies are subject to change as the teams are named

DEF: H. Shaw, M.Johnson, Newnes, Lumumba, B. Goodes, A. Saad (Goddard, Mcintosh)
MID: Ablett, Pendles, Fyfe, Beams, Griffin, Cripps, Heeney, Elllis-Yolmen (J. Anderson, T. Miller, Lambert)
RUCK: Goldstein, Maric (Read)
FWD: Gray, Martin, Swan, Salem, Clark, Tarrant (Lonie, Lamb)

Jack

I love this.

Slatsy

Seeing lots of similarities to my side

Out: Johnson lamumba pendles Anderson Maric tarrant
In: malceski Higgins jelwood vandenberg nicnat hogan

Samuel

who has better job security… Jed Anderson or Aaron Vandenberg?

Ben

Anderson at minute only because VDB hasn’t been promoted as yet.

Anderson is a big sub risk though

steve

Anderson will cop the vest most of the games he plays

Ben

Might sound stupid but do I run with:

Def: Goodes
Mids: Ablett, Pendles, Fyfe, Selwood, Beams

Or

Def: Hibberd/Higgins
Mids: 4 of the above 5 mids + Griffen

Ben

Depends on how deep your backline is

@TylerCArmstrong

If the Goodes option goes down to d5 then that.

Ben

Goodes at D4

Tyler

Go with the 2nd one then griffin should do well and go higgins I reckon.

@TylerCArmstrong

2nd option then

jimmydowland

only have 6k left, please give thoughts!! should i have goodes in there ?? maybe remove cockatoo down to a lower rookie to get goodes??

Def: Shaw, newnes, hibered, ibboston, brown, mcintosh, hambling, saad
mid:ablett, sellwood,beams, kennedy, griffen, cripps, cockatoo, ellis-yolmon, heeney, miller, vanderburg
ruck: maric, minson, o'brien
forwards: gray, martin, shaw, bellchambers, salem, clark, hogan, lamb

please community !

SCaddict

If Goodes is named it's pretty hard to look past him given his 2013 production.

I would just temper expectations a little as it's probably unlikely he'll soar to anywhere near $500K ever again.

PreviouslyOnLost

Some tough decisions before round 1;

The Prince or Burn Man (Higgins)?
Danger, Griffin, Wines or McRae?
Dusty, Bennel or Floggard?
Henderson, Ibbotson or Langdon?
Cripps or Sheed?
Shaw or Hibbered?

Been chopping and changing between these blokes… at least i still have another few days =]

Been loving this preseason, better then ever! (although I miss the Nab challenge worksheets).

PreviouslyOnLost

than* (face palm for rushing)

Luviboy1

-Prince
-Griffo
-Dusty
-Hendo
-Cripps
-Heater

vinnymac

-Burn man
-Wines
-Dusty
-Ibbotson
-Cripps
-Shaw

Jimi

Thoughts or Laird or Bugg?

jimbo

Bugg might not tag…
Could be POD greatness

Jimi

Both averaged in the 80's in NAB. Just need them to get me to the byes. Don't know much about either, can any Adelaide/GWS fans out there give me some insight?

Mike

GWS fans??

SCaddict

I know Mad Mick started with Bugg but I think he admitted in hindsight that was a horrendous decision. Still 2015 is a brand new season and the kid is likely to improve.

Seb

Is anybody still starting lambert now that he's been named emergency?

Jimi

Nope dropped him.

LEKD0G

I'll likely hold onto him

jimbo

Love your work Jock. Keep that up!

maka

Cheers also for giving us the PODCAST tonight.
Re-assuring.

CJay

Big thanks Jock. get plenty of zzzzz tonight mate you have earned it.

Rocksta

I am!

Make sure you've got a bit of money left over in case you need to change your other Forward line bench player if he also doesn't get named

SCaddict

A no for me if Tarrant is named onfield at CHB tomorrow.

Rawkus11

Tarrant's a REAL chance of getting his arse in my fwd line!

Throttlefinger

Hold. Will definitely play sooner than later.

Tyler

I still need him for the Mid/Fwd swing so I'm keeping him

Rocksta

Just finished my team for the 200th and LAST time, subject to Rookie's being named.

Pumped!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Bring it on!

Andrew

Jed Adcock? Thoughts… I have him in atm, but thinking maybe I should swap him to a KK or someone similar?

Rocksta

I think with Pearce Hanley injured, he will come into his own. Adcock is a very good footballer.

SCaddict

Yeah I guess who out of Adcock or Rich will excel in the Hanley void is the $50K question. Perhaps they both will to some degree.

Rocksta

Have 14 genuine Keepers, and still have $50K in the bank. Really happy with my Final Team.

Crabb

i've picked higgins, jock – sorry mate

matty D

Simpson, Shaw, Newnes, KK, Goodes, Saad (Hamling, Mcintosh)

Fyfe, selwood, Heppell, Danger, Griffen, Cripps, Heeny, CEY, (Vanderberg, Smith, Miller)

Mumford, Bellechambers, (Cox)

Gray, Lids, Martin, Swan, Salem, Clark (hogan, steel or playing rookie)

Think im more excited than a kid on christmas eve
Let the season Begin

The Ranger

Hilarious and informative as ever Jock, good luck for the season.

dylan

hibberd or brodie smith?? as D2

Rocksta

Have the exact same problem!

I've gone with Hibberd, but think that Brodie Smith could get into the Mid 500's this year.

He was a first round draft pick and is still on the up!

CJay

I have Hibberd at D2. Good selection for mine but MIick the MDI hasn't spent the $ on him though.

shake n bake

none gibbson!

Cozza

Hibberd for me – has a slow end to last year, so think he is underpriced. May be a game or two to hit his straps, but a proved performer in the backs.

keg

I’d love some thoughts guys. I’m in a bit of a headspin:

Currently I have Gibson as d1, then newness and lumumba

But I’m wondering if I should get rid of Gibson for a rookie, run with newnes and lumumba as d1 & 2, this would allow me to upgrade a mid rookie to griffen at m6 (or even Parker at m6 if I also Downgrade maric to nic Nat)

I just can’t decide if it’s too much to pay or if I’ll regret not doing it (especially Parker)

Can you guys pleeeeeease tell me what you think??

Rowan

Go with the option that will leave you with the most players you’ll be happy to keep for SC finals.

Just depends who you believe will be good enough to keep

Keg

Good advice, thanks mate.

This is why I’m leaning towards keeping my current team. As much as I’d love Parker, I would have to give up Gibson and maric to get him. I’m not too sure Nic nat will be a keeper. I’ll just have to look for a way to bring in Parker as time goes by
Thanks mate, you’ve helped me see a bit of clarity.

Good luck for the year!

T-mitch

This time of year we have to go with our gut, if you can’t back yourself you can’t back anyone. Stick with your guns and good luck

Keg

Cheers mate. I loved my team at 8 this morning, yet somehow started to convince myself I needed to tinker with it. That’s it- I’m done!

Thanks for your input

medadsson

That would be a very thin defence indeed. Personally I lean a little to what Higgo is preaching in defence. I am going with four keepers (he is advocating 5) but 2? That sure would be backing yourself in, big plum stuff. Good luck with whatever you choose. I like you first choice best.

@GOODO71

Hi all,
Thanks to all the Jock Reynolds crew and community for their help in moulding and shaping the final make-up of I LIKE IT ROUGH. Appreciate any last minute thoughts.

DEF : Shaw, Newnes, Higgins, KK, Goodes, McIntosh (Oxley, Saad)
MID : GAJ, Fyfe, Beams, JPK, Griffen, Cripps, Anderson, Heeney, (CEY, Vandenberg, Miller)
RUC : Mummy, Nic Nat (Read)
FWD : Gray, Martin, Swan, TBC, Salem, Clark (Lonie, Lambert)

Good luck to all in 2015

maka

Thoughts on Malceski to Hibbo? or any defender? (besides Ibbo, Goodes, Ox, Simmo, Newnes)

Or hold on to Eski?
My team looks balanced, with him there though.

Rocksta

If it feels good to you, go with it!

I just changed Hibberd back to Brodie Smith because it feels better to me!

Need to back yourself in this game!

Cozza

Like Malceski > Hibbo for the reasons Jock said in the podcast – too much uncertainty around Malceski's role in a team of up and coming guns.

Jacob

Think i've finally decided on my team. Thoughts??

Def: Shaw, Newnes, Higgins, Kolodjashnij, McIntosh, Saad (Oxley, Hamling)

Mid: Ablett, Fyfe, Parker, Dangerfield, Griffen, Swan, Cripps, CEY (Anderson, Heeney, Miller)

Ruc: Maric, Naitanui (Cox)

Fwd: Gray, Bartell, Martin, Salem, Clarke, Hogan (Tarrant, Lonie)

Redgumwon

You might want one more premium in defence. But each to their own

Cozza

Love it – great team. Only though is whether you swap swan to forwards and replace Lonie with a mid rookie like Vandenberg is he is named – thinking Vandenberg is likely to generate more cash than Lonie.

Tom

Wallis said today in a q&a that he will no longer tag.

Locked!

Rowan

Just to double-double check.

We can make unlimited trades right through the weekend?? (Obviously with players locked in at first bounce in their game)

Rocksta

Correct

t-Mitch

Going on with a mid pricer on each line community
Back- newnes
Mid- Wallis
Ruck- tbc
Fwd- swan

Two will be kept and two as stepping stones

Happy with my line up this year, I’ll be going for the top prize along with everyone here, been a long preseason but let’s get into it!!

Best of luck guys!!!

T_Mitch

Keg

Good luck mate.

It sure has been a long pre-season. I reckon I’ve put more hours into this year than ever before, which has really only led to me being more confused than ever before!

I reckon there are 30 guys i would like.

Cheers

Damon

G’Day community! Thoughts on my team would be greatly appreciated!
D: Shaw, Taylor, Newnes, Kolodjashnij, Goodes, McIntosh (Hamling, Saad)
M: Fyfe, Selwood, Parker, Dangerfield, Griffen, Rich, Cripps, Ellis-Yolmen (Heeney, Freeman, Miller)
R: Maric, Bellchambers (Cox)
F: Gray, Martin, Dahlhaus, Swan, Salem, Clark (Hogan, Lambert)
Cheers, Damon.

Ageneral3

I agree, no Ablettsen.

DaNeediest

What's the deal with t.hunt? Don't know much about him, is he named in the guts for a tagging role or something? Can we run with him and Goodes in defence or is that too risky?

T-mitch

Stay right away, whatever it is he does is not SuperCoach relevant

Josh

thoughts on parker vs dangerfield?

scrofl

Parker will be more consistent and score better. Also won't cop a tag, unlike Danger.

bobby

Parker

Dean

I had HIBBERD in defence as a lock and forget if the ASADA went in there way which it did, but LEKDOG is suggesting to NOT go in with any Essendon players due to not having a pre-season.

Now im not sure what to do. Your advice would be greatly appreciated.

SCOTLAND THE BRAVE

Lambert not in tigers side, are we picking someone else or sticking fat?

T-mitch

Sticking with him for a couple of reasons
1. I think he will be a late inclusion for Newman
2. If that’s not the case we have seen enough from him to say he will play before too long and to take him out now and trade him in later, you will be trading out a rookie who’s price has not peaked which is not good, we all want to keep our rookies until there price has reached as high as it can

SCOTLAND THE BRAVE

Agree also he is my switch between fwd and mid

Northerner

But your mid pricer in your defense could be fat when he's on the bubble! I plan to use that strategy. Better to have price appreciating. If he's not named, he's only coming into my side when on the bubble

SCaddict

Community appears fairly divided on this one.

A lot will depend on what happens with team sheets tomorrow I'd say, as coaches consider their options.

Keg

Keeping him

Reckon he’ll play at least 10 games this year, and I don’t want to burn a trade to bring him in. He still may well play tomorrow night too I reckon

shake n bake

silly to keep him, just say tigers win well & they keep pretty much the same team the week after bar injuries. That would then 2 weeks without him while if you went with someone else after rd 2 they would be already on the bubble!

BeerIsYum

I have Higgins!!

B: Shaw, Newnes, Higgins, Ibbotson, Goodes, Saad (McIntosh, Hamling)
C: Rockliff, Fyfe, Selwood, Griffen, Swallow, Cripps, Heeney, CEYolmen, (Miller, Sinclair, Smith)
R: Mumford, Goldstein (Cox)
F: Gray, Martin, Swan, Salem, Clark, Hogan (Lonie, Daniels)
Remaining $239,300
Option of upgrading Swallow to Ablett if he's going off his tits

PHIL

Do we find a new rookie to replace lambert???
Or back the kid in??

medadsson

I am leaving him out of initial 30 as I believe he will make a good trade down target.

OldOcker

Jaden McGrath (fwd) is going to play for the Lions this week I have just heard.

BeerIsYum

Great Podcast Tonight…….

BUT YOU MADE ME CRY from I'm laughing too much

T-mitch

Got an std from swan hahahahahaha loved it

T-mitch

Beers before the game tomorrow at transport community, get around it. Go blues

KingiesTigers

Ok hi all first post here and gunna lay my manhood on the line this is my team tell me your thoughts please and don't hold back. I'm happy with it so just want to give back to the community. Thanks to jock and all the fellas for your wisdoms the mag is great and love the podcasts.
Backs: Newnes, Higgins, KK (collarjazzknee), Geary, Goodes, McIntosh, Oxley,Saad
Mids: Gazza, Fyfe, Sloane, Parker, Griffin, Cripps, Heeny, Ellis-Yolman, Vandenberg,Miller,Lambert
Rucks: Maric, Nic Nat, Read
Forward: Grey, Lids, Dusty, Bennell, Salem, Clark, Bryne, Krackor.
Good luck all and may the winner come from a club jockolien.

Sarah

Risky backline but I looooove your midfield. Wishing I could fit Parker in myself but he doesn't fit into my structure at this stage. Good luck, with that backline, you'll need it!!!

Mitch

Hey guys just need advice on which way I should go with having Simpson, Burgoyne and luenberger or m Johnson yarran and minson cheers 🙂

medadsson

Minson is far more durable and a lone ruckman. I like Johnson who's role is to sweep across backline, takes many intercept marks. Never been a fan of Yarran, Supercoach wise, promises plenty but has never really delivered. The more I think about it though, if you have ruck cover Simpson, Burgoyne and Luey probably way to go. That'd be my choice.

scrofl

I'd steer clear of Burgs and Lueuy personally, so go the second option.

luke

thoughts on clancee pearce

SCaddict

Didn't show enough in the NAB to get our supercoach juices flowing. Could have a breakout season but is a speculative pick at best. Group thought is that Goodes is a better option if named and save $30K in the process.

medadsson

Ross mentioned the T word on Monday night. Said he would be a good match up on Boak. Like him but if he tags, too risky.

luke

what about ibbo

SCaddict

I like Ibbo much more and in fact he's in my team as it presently stands alongside Goodes.

At least he's shown he can average well over 90 at AFL level but he's had a helluva time staying on the park so big questions over his durability and role in 2015.

Of course he's $100K more than Goodesy which is a significant consideration too for those deciding between the two. On the flip side I believe firmly that Ibbo is in Freo's best 22 when fit but Goodesy I'm not quite as convinced on his JS although reckon it'll be pretty decent nonetheless if he gets named tomorrow.

medadsson

Greetings, kicked off another league if anyone interested. 518031. Thought this the best place to get dedicated coaches 🙂

Keg

I’ll join!

dognino

I'm in

Jessica

Is Wallis a lock now?

T-mitch

Wouldn’t say a lock, needs to show a lot of improvement but that being said I’ll be rolling the dice

scrofl

Would love some thoughts/opinions community!

DEF: Shaw, Newnes, Lumumba
Goodes, Brown, McIntosh (Hamling, Saad)
MID: Ablett, Fyfe, Selwood, JPK
Lewis, Cripps, Heeney, Ellis-Yolmen (Miller, Vandenberg, Lambert)
RUC: Goldstein, Maric (Read)
FWD: Gray, Deledio, Martin
Bellchambers, Salem, Clark (Hogan, Lamb)

Got $42k left in the warchest.

Mike

Clem Smith anyone?

SCaddict

Not if there are perceived better options as he really showed bugger all in the preseason although it appears Mick really rates the kid starting him on the HFF or so it would appear.

But if enough of Miller, Anderson, Heeney, Vandenberg, Krakoeur, Cockatoo etc don't get named tomorrow we may be forced to look at him.

Kev

Won't teams for Saturday games be named on Friday night?

david

no thur

SCaddict

I believe this is the team announcement schedule for Rd1.

Thursday – the Wednesday night beforehand
Saturday – as per usual on the Thursday night
Sunday – squads of 25 are named on the Thursday night beforehand, with the squads trimmed to 22 on Friday evening
Monday – squads of 25 are named on the Thursday night beforehand, with the squads trimmed to 22 on Saturday evening

Tim GG

With the breaking news hitting:

TBC (F4) + Anderson (MBench) vs Wallis (M7) + Rookie (FBench)? – might be a bit hard to answer with no team showing, can add my lines if that helps.

Swan vs The Bont vs TBC at F4? (rucks are goldy + flute)

mike

Higgo ! Showing some form with the tonsils sir.

marcus

please help me, any feedback

shaw newnes higgins hunt mclntosh saad (hamling goddard)

ablett pendles selwood lewis watson griffen cripps heeney (anderson vandenberg ellis-yolmen)

goldstein lycett (cox)

bartel roughead swan bellchambers hogan lamb (daniel, lambert)

Kev

Not a fan of Hunt scoring potential. Will be used as a run with player as the Tigers don't have that type of bloke (calling Grigg a tagger is an insult to all the great taggers in the game). Love the Lycett pick, if you can find 20k to turn Roughy into Dusty you're golden I reckon

luke

clancee pearce, brett goodes or gerrick ibbotson

Kev

Goodes, Ibbo, daylight, Pearce

Tommyurds

Hey guys just would like some opinions on a choice between beams/Neale or Lewis/A. Swallow. One a premo and the other likely a trade for premo later on in the piece…. Cheers guys

mike

Toss a coin with those choices. Each one a solid premo and a guy who should up his average.
Beams Neale for me.

kyle

is jed anderson going to get the green vest if plays?

SCaddict

Decent chance although no way of knowing for sure until Easter Monday which is far from ideal obviously.

Still needs to get named in the 22 in the first place before we even worry about potential vests as the Hawks have great depth as we know.

Kev

I see him as burst player really. Fourth quarter fresh legs so could find himself in the snot vest more often than not.

Tofor

I'd say so. Highly likely

Phil

I'm pretty set on my team which is unusual for this time of year. Collingwood could throw a spanner in the works with selection though.

If Oxley isn't named I'll have to consider changing my structure to add a premo defender for a forward. If Karnezis is named i will even more strongly consider it. If Freeman is named I'll take him but at least that won't change my structure. Then there's N.Brown too

Dougie

Good morning! Dedicated Supercoacher with a league which needs to be filled 773106! Bring on another exciting year! All the best with your side in ’15!

marcus

am i crazy for considering sandilands? lots of hit outs to advantage, POD?

SCaddict

Hard to justify his selection given his age and injury history when compared to say Goldylock for the same money.

He served us well last season when initially priced in the bargain bin but I think we've all moved on in 2015.

Levi

McIntosh locked in defence anyone?

Kev

I reckon if you looked at every community team reveal for the last few weeks he's been in there. Named on the wing last night. So yeah, popular choice

Trevor

join my league filling fast 782643

Rick Grimes

I've been running Bennell as F3 for a while now. Am I safer to go with Martin. He seems to be a lock in a lot of teams. Similar average last year, which one is going to take it to a higher level?

Kev

Back your gut, Rick. Stay strong and don't worry what everyone else is doing.

zeesus

I have gone Bennell. Get a bit of POD in ya!