add_filter('comment_flood_filter', '__return_false');

Lekdog’s Team Dissection|PORT – WB

Published by Lekdog on

LekdogThis week Lekdog discusses which players are the best picks at Portย all the way through to Western Bulldogs.ย He covers each position and who we should be looking at.

Lekdog covers Port Adelaide, Richmond, St Kilda, Sydney, West Coast and Western Bulldogsย in this video extravaganza!

Iย would love to hear what you all think so make sure to leave some comments and suggestions for topics of discussion in the comments community!

ARE YOU A CLUB JOCK MEMBER YET? CLICK HERE AND REAP THE BENEFITS


Subscribe
Notify of
guest
133 Comments
Oldest
Newest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Clancy

Thoughts on my team pleaseee !
Shaw, Johnson, Newnes, Goodes, Mcintosh, Saad (goddard hamling)
Ablett, Pendlebury, Fyfe, Selwood, Dangerfield,Cripps, Anderson, Heeney ( borkhurst, ellis yolmen, miller)
Goldstein, Nic nat (cox)
Gray, Goddard, Martin, Bellchambers, Salem, Clarke (Hogan, Lambert)
Thinking im a bit light down back let me know what you think !! Thanks ! ๐Ÿ™‚

I N Pieman

The job security of the defender rookies is almost non existent. Except for Nathan brown who’s not going to blow the roof off the joint. I’d remove TBC & grab a mid pricer defender. Good luck

tom

thoughts??

Simpson, Shaw, Newnes, Goodes, Brown, Saad (hamling, mcintosh)

Ablett, Fyfe, Selwood, JPK, Parker, Wallis, Cripps, CEY (heeney, touk, anderson)

Goldstein, Maric (brooksby)

Gray, Martin, Swan, Salem, Clark, Hogan (lamb, lambert)

I N Pieman

Wallis Tom. Big ball. If he’s removed from tagging could be an awesome pick. Touk Miller good pick. Brown on the ground. Nup. Bench him.

matt

i believe your backline is a little fragile, one more midpricer maybe wallis for a rookie then upgrade a back rookie

I N Pieman

Nice Vid Lek. You might want to hit the weight room & start working on some guns. If you want to fast track the process you know the team to call.

MASO

collingwood ? ๐Ÿ˜›

Dools

Hahahahahahahahahahha Owned INP

Classic!!! High cal.diet and steaks. Lots and lots of steak

I N Pieman

Leefe & Thomas will need to make a living somehow lol

I N Pieman

Nice. I like it Lek. Was the mo inspired by Jock?

Josh

guys i need some help! my team atm is
d: Shaw, Kelly, Newnes, Higgins, Goodes, McIntosh (Hamling, Saad)
m: ablett, fyfe, selwood, watson, griffen, cripps, heeney, ellis-yolmen (c smith, miller, krakouer)
r: maric, dogdog (cox)
f: gray, dusty, swan, bellchambers, salem, clark (hogan, lambert)

i would like to take out higgins for hibberd, would you guys go for
higgins, watson, selwood, gray
or
hibberd, dangerfield, JPK, bartel

thanks guys

I N Pieman

If you looking for a durable mid Watson is not the answer. His number of games & average is declining since his Brownlow year. I don’t like Higgins. Be carful with Hibberrd dodgy hammies go twang lots.

Rick

I would go higgins, watson, JPK and bartel. Hyrbrid between the two

Gollyontong

Dont second guess yourself. All are viable options, and if it was as simple was going on previous stats, we would all be champs.

KJU FC

Mitch Wallis is doing a QandA on the doggies website today and he should answer what role he will play this year.

If he says he definitely wont play a tagging role he is locked into my side.

Redgumwon

Lock as well at M6

Browny

Who should I go with out of Griffen and Wines? I'm thinking Griffen just because GWS has an easier draw, but Wines could be a bit more durable throughout the year. Thoughts?

Just_Genetics

Griffen all the way in the final H&A round of last season he scored whopping 188 points and then scoring 142 in his first appearance against Gold Coast in the NAB Challenge. id say he should be a lock in most teams.

Borko

Nicnat v Minson as my r2 behind Goldy

Rick Grimes

Minson a safer option, but I think Nicnat has the higher upside. If you haven't taken many risks across the rest of the team, maybe worth a punt.

harry

Nic Nat, and not even close

Just_Genetics

when Nic nat was r1 at westcoast he averaged 120 points per game. he should do the same this year being the number 1 ruck.

r2d2

Currently have both wines and danger in my team, as well as swallow ! Is this a bad thing ?

r2d2

Gaz and Pendles m1 and 2

Rick Grimes

Possibly a premo short. Question mark on Danger, but he'll give you some big returns (Sloane more consistent). Wines is a gun and I dearly want to include him in my own side. Swallow I'm not as sold on, don't see as big an upside.

r2d2

Swallow up to griffen or jpk?

Luviboy1

I'd go Swallow up to Parker. But out of them two Griffo, if you already have GAJ and Pendles.

Give It A Go

On another note will anyone go Ess players now? Would Hibs be a lock?

Crowmagnon

seriously considering him.

jim

Pick 1 out of:

Ibbo
Geary
Hunt
Hendo
Pearce
WhiteX

Redgumwon

Henderson

Sarah

Geary

Harry

role a dice, assign a number for each player, whatever number it lands on go with it. If they all play, should do about the same

Rick Grimes

If you could please help me out with conundrum I would mighty appreciative:

Option 1) Go Mummy and Goldie in rucks and play 3 rookies in D (Goodes at 4)
Option 2 Go Mummy and TBC in rucks and go deeper in D (Newnes at 4)

I'm running GnR but the D has me worried. Just wish I could see into TBC future, could be worth $50k…

John

In the same boat as you, but think option 1 may work out,
someone will pop up, because i just cant justify the midpricers in defence,
let me know which way you decide, good luck mate!

Redgumwon

You've answered your own question. Go with your gut and beef up defence

Jordan

Sorry to ask but does anyone know what the formula is to know how much a player is priced to average?

Cheers

Samuel

approximately $5,375 per SC point

Brillsy21

Wallis or Rich??

Redgumwon

Wallis

jack

wells

Tony

Wells

gabe

assuming you have supercoach gold – check his break even

Samuel

Dane Swan is 31 years old now and averaged 86.4 last year. His NAB average was 75.5 from 2 games. Is anyone else not sold on him?

Redgumwon

He played most of the year with injury. Most have Swannie in there sides. So why not go with him and if he doesn't fire use him for an upward trade? At the price he is you really can't go wrong and if he fires you've got a scoring machine

Luviboy1

He was disinterested in the NAB. I think he'll have a decent year.

Harry

Also Collingwood don't expect him to be fully fit until approximatlely round 6. Aswell as playing the same role in the nab cup as he did last season, it would be extremely risky to pick him.

jason

pick him will avg 95 minimum more of a risk not having him

Samuel

What about Bartel? is he safer

Harry

Bartel's looked great so far. Almost a certainty he'll be top 6 forward and average over 100, can't say the same about swan

jack

thoughts on my team???

shaw, taylor, newnes, Higgins, goodes, saad (McIntosh, Goddard)

pendles, fyfe, selwood, jpk, griffen, cripps, heeney, ellis-yolmen (vandeberg, miller, lambert)

Goldstein, nicnat (Obrien)

gary, martin, swan, bellchambers, salem, Clark, (Hogan, Steele)

7.6k

Crowls

got like it as very similar to mine in structure

David

Deliberately haven't posted a team or played around with the chopping and changing over the last few months…..just watched, listened and tried to absorb all the wisdom from these pages and from my own research……with the final week upon us I will do my own TEAM REVEAL"…..please let me know your thoughts…

BEAGLIEBOY UNITED F.C
Backs: Murphy, Hurn Taylor Broadbent Geary Whitecross (Saad, McIntosh)

Mids: Ablett Pendlebury Fyffe Martin Griffen Newton Cripps Ellis-yolmen (Cockatoo, Anderson Heeney)

Rucks: Goldstein Bellchambers (Reed)

Fwds: Gray Franklin Swan Salem Clark Hogan (Lamb Lambert)

I know that Martin should be a fwd….but I wanted as many cash cows there as possible……I know that Bellchambers is a huge risk, but if he can string 5-6 games together at the start he will be the first out and I will pick who is travelling best out of Maric, Jacobs Minson NicNat etc

David

…..Martin will move fwd at first upgrade…..

SCaddict

Wow you're definitely in contention for the POD backline of the year award.

No doubt you would only lock in WhiteX if he gets a game on Easter Monday which is probably unlikely to happen at this stage unless you've heard something that I haven't.

Your other lines are much more conventional although the jury is still out for me on whether Newton is a good pick for the money. Hopefully he turns out to be more a Dom Tyson than a Viv Michie circa 2014.

Buddy is an interesting selection and could really carve up a match underdone Bombers defence this weekend. I just wish he had a full preseason under his belt and there wasn't rain forecast at ANZ this Saturday.

David

yeah….WhiteX will probably be moved on once teams are announced….On Newton, I have no doubt he will be an absolute gun….Being a Port man I have watched him play for the Magpies in the SANFL week in week out and collect thirty plus posses and 10 tackles most weeks….a real hard nut who will be a champ….spitting chips Port couldnt keep him….next year Cornes will be gone and that spot was his for the next decade…..jump on him I reckon.

Luviboy1

Love your backline. Id move Martin forward and upgrade Belly, but you've already stated your intentions. Overall pretty solid side. Wish you all the best.

Dr Spock

Judd or Scooter Selwood?

SCaddict

I like Scooter a little more myself as I think he generate more cash than Juddy but neither are season long keepers but only stepping stones to elites I'd say.

Both are good picks if you need to slot in a midfield midpricer and I would also add Wells and potentially Rich to this category too.

Dr Spock

Does anyone know what the rough formula is for working out potential price rises after X number of rounds?

I’m thinking Selwood can average 105-110, whilst Wells maybe 95 and Rich 90, but not sure who will rise the most by the time the byes come around. Also thinking there’s a sneaky chance I can keep Selwood at M8.

SCaddict

The price change formula is basically this Dr Spock:

New_Price = 3/4 * Old_Price plus 1/4 * Recent_Market_Value

where Recent_Market_Value = $5,375 (approx) * Average_Points_In_Last_Three_Games

It's not exact as all players prices are scaled to fit within the global salary cap each round but I reckon it's close enough.

So just whack this into Excel and you can do your own price change calculations per round.

If Scooter averages over 100 trust me you'll be laughing all the way to the bank.

Dr Spock

Thanks heaps SCaddict, much appreciated ๐Ÿ™‚

Dr Spock

… It’s basically coming down to Selwood at M6 and Leuenberger at R2 (his per minute scores in NAB were good IMHO) OR Rich/Wells and Naitanui at the same positions

Donald

maybe look for a wells or rich instead,similar scores, save money

Patch

Love the video Lek. Brilliant as always. Hard to say what the videos should do without knowing what's already getting done each week.

r2d2

Anyone thinking of running with lids and dusty ?

SCaddict

Reckon it's doable but a slight Lids's durability concern tips a Bartel inclusion instead for me.

Jack

Higgins or lumumba

Parker or boak

Tulendeena

Lumumba and Parker

bob

Could i please have some help with my team its looking something like this:
DEF: H Shaw, Newnes, Lumbumba, koladshnij, goodes, saad. (oxley, mcintosh)
MIDS: Fyfe, parker, heppell, griffen, j steven, rich, cripps, CEY (heeney, anderson, t miller)
Rucks: Goldy, minson (obrien)
FWDS: Gray, dusty, swan, bontempelli, clarke , salem (hogan, lambert)

What do you guys think and why is no one considering d heppel for their teams?

SCaddict

If HepD still had his 2013 DPP eligibility he'd be in a lot of backlines but it's a bit tough to squeeze him in as a pure midfielder much like say a McVeigh.

Bombers are quite an unknown quantity with no preseason competition to speak of and have a punishing opening fortnight @Sydney and v Hawks so that would put many off starting with Dons players as Lekdog so eloquently stated in his vid.

But in general I reckon you are running with a very solid side there Bob.

Adrian

Is anybody running with a team that has dyson heppell havn't seen him in any recntly?? thoughts

Stevo

Read above, but IMO he is a nice POD, young gun, but will get tagged along with Watson

matt

believe hes a great pick, reckon the pressure on him and essendon has been lifted and now can unleash

Ethan

Jack Steven
was his 2013 season a fluke or is he seriously good

Stevo

He's a gun

Scarlo

A few quick questions before lockout
Sheed or newton ?
Goddard or Bartel ?
Maric or Naitanui ?
Gibson or johnson ?
Let me know what your thoughts are (:

Stevo

Hmmmm
Sheed, Bartel, Maric, Gibbo

David

Is it possible KK (AKA Thumper) could score simlar to Newnes?

I am really interested in taking a POD risk by leaving Newnes out. Saints stink.

Thoughts? Can someone talk me into this plz?

Stevo

I'm thinking the same thing. Bruyn said this in his article yesterday:
'Newnes – Hype player of the preseason by far! A lock? I can’t see it. Not because he is a bad pick but simply because I don’t think he’ll be a top 5 defender. Isn’t cheap at all and plays for a poor side. Will feature in heaps of teams (mine included I’d say) but he isn’t David Swallow.'

IMO he won't go up much in price, even if he does average 95 or above. That's only around 490k plus. But if you do pick him and he stuffs up, you really won't have to worry cause everyone's got him and they'll all worry too

David

Ok, so my rationale is, if I get someone cheaper like KK, and he gets 80-90's early on (which he should, Suns are a good team this year) and Newnes gets 90 – 100. I am losing a few points to everyone there but the value of my team is going up. If Newnes spuds it up when St Kilda get flogged then I have a huge win. I guess im finding hard to pick Newnes over KK, but so so many people are on him and i dont get it! Saints stink so hard.

SCaddict

While Newnes will be hugely popular he's one of the supposed must haves you could probably skip on and not get too badly burnt, however the penny falls, so long as you have an adequate replacement.

I like Thumper's game a lot but will he just tread water in 2015 with the 2nd year blues like Zorko did??

So if I was going to leave Newnes out I'd probably want to spend decent coin on an alternative such as a Hurn, Kelly or Taylor.

Thumper certainly at D2 or maybe even D3 is probably leaving yourself a bit too exposed in defence imho.

Stevo

Anyone got a league almost full that needs someone to join?

adam

bob murphy and nic nat – 4,700 left
kade kol and goldstein – 26,700 left
back up ruck is TBC

Luviboy1

2nd option is probably a tad safer. But if you're willing to take a risk go with 1.

adam

thanks mate ๐Ÿ™‚

Stevo

KK and goldy

Glenn

Goldstein, Naitanui

Maric, Minson

Can’t decide which two to pick. Thoughts?

Luviboy1

Goldy and Minson ๐Ÿ™‚

Nah, but if I had to pick number 1.

matt

more upside if number 1 works (Nic Nat goes 120) and goldy does what goldy does
but safer bet is number 2, like minson should average 100 and maric should go 105-110

Adrian

Is anybody running with a team that has dyson heppell havn't seen him in any recntly?? thoughts

Motsy

What are the communities thoughts on Krakouer vs Steele?
Who will make money first and get a run?

Is it worth jumping on one now for a dual mid/fwd swingset with lambert to allow loopholes in both lines for the best rook scores?

Jakey

Buddy or martin ??
Thinking less teams will have buddy and he may have more upside ? ๐Ÿ™‚

Luviboy1

Hes gonna score 15,000 points against Essendon on Saturday. Could be a good enough reason to select him over Dusty.

matt

Mitch wallis has just said hes not going to be tagging this year is this a good reason to pick him up?

gordo

i currently have him in my side as a stepping stone to gaz

james

whos the best options out of dangerfield, wines, cotchin, lewis, heppell, watson and b gibbs?

SCaddict

Lewis is the only one of that bunch in my side although you could mount an argument for picking any of those stars really.

But for me just have a look at Jordo's scores from the back half of 2014, and much like Parker too, I reckon that bodes very well for 2015.

Luviboy1

In order: Lewis, Wines, Danger, Heppell, Watson, Gibbsy, Cotchin.

Rick

I need a view on my team

Def: Shaw, Newnes, Lumumba,Higgins,Goodes,Saad/ Goddard, Mcintosh

Mid: Fyfe, Sloane, Sidebottom, Parker, Wines, Griffen, S. Mitchell, Cripps/ Vananberg, Yoleman, Lambert

Rucks: Leuenberger, Bellchambers

Forwards: Bartel, Goddard, Swan, Salem, Clark, Hogan/ Lamb, Caleb

Reason for this team: Everyones defence is a bit risky this year so I have decided to go with Shaw who should average over 100. Newns who is a lock. I reckon Lumumba will definitely go up in price and bump up his average with his new club and new role. Same with higgins. Goodes will play a vital role in WB with the loss of liberatore and saad is just a playing rookie.

Mid: Ive tried to go with a lot of POD picks in my midfield who I reckon WONT attract the tag. Fyfe will obviously get the tag but his score output is to much to ignore. Sloane wont get a hard tag with dangerfield in their. Sidebottom wont get a hard tag with pendlebury in their. Same with Parker and Wines. Griffen is a lock no matter what. S.mitchell is a fallen premium. Lets not forget that this man was over 600k at the start of 2014 and then I have cripps.

The rucks is where I am most skeptical. I do not worry about leuenbergers performance in the nab cup, he will and should average 85+ if not 95+. Bellchambers is obviously going to be the number 1 ruck and should DEFINITELY average 80+ and if were lucky 90+. My plan is to get a keeper in one of them, and to trade the other one out by either downgrading someone OR by downgrading the ruckman to a returning Kreuzer in round 4.

Forward: Bartel, Goddard…… Do I really have to say anything? Swan is a fallen premium. LOCK. Then salem, clark and hogan.

I would really love some suggestions on this team and some pointers. I am confident in lumumba and higgins so dont even attempt on swaying me away from them.
Cheers ๐Ÿ™‚

Dr Spock

Agreed on Leuey, his per minute in NAB was solid enough for me. Haven’t seen enough of Bellchambers so speculative pick, would prefer maybe a premo ruck instead? (Although I reckon with new rules we’re paying overs for most rucks and expect many to drop in value). Looking at your team you must have a bit of spare cash?

Luviboy1

Need a D3/D4 Player that is under 453,000 and isnt Taylor or Newnes. GO!

Rick

Lumumba, Higgins

Dr Spock

Ibbotson, KK or Geary maybe if it’s D4? Higgins for D3 I reckon, Lumumba will get attention in season proper.

Keg

KK and pocket the cash

Bonters

Totally disagree on the Essendon warning.

Their lack of NAB games will make them even more raring to go for Round 1. This, combined with the not guilty verdict, should really inspire some emotion and strong performances, and I reckon they're even a chance to beat Sydney Round 1.

matt

honorable loss

Pete

Beams or J Lewis?

Keg

I’ve gone Lewis. Reckon he will kill it this year and can go HUGE!

eatemalive

agree

Harry

Beams by a mile, proven sc gun, lewis only 1 good season in a decade

Paddy

A league for some readers to join

NoFatChicks (196197)

Gordo

rich, wells waliis pick two
the gift, thumper, rampe savage pick two

SuperSteak

Lambert named as an emergency.
Gets me thinking what r people's stance on picking rookies not playing rd 1??
Like to know the communities thoughts.

kevwal

My thought's, if a rookie is picked to play, on the field, round 1, pick them. A non-playing rookie is a non-money maker. They can sit on the bench, but rookies are there for one thing and one thing only, making money.

Keg

Guys, can I get some help please!

Team at the moment

Gibbo, newnes, lumumba, KK, Goodes, saad (mcintosh, brown)

Gaz, pendles, Fyfe, selwood, Lewis, Cripps, v’berg, Ellis-y (heeney, miller, lambert *not playing i know**)

Goldy, Maric (cox)

Gray, Martin, swan, Salem, Clarke, steele (hogan, Lonie)

HOWEVER::::

IF I downgrade Gibson to a rookie (say Oxley as bench cover) I can upgrade a mis rookie (eg heeney) to griffin
OR- even more adventurous, I also downgrade maric to Nic nat and I can have Parker as M6

Have I gone completely insane????

Please help!!!!

matty D

Simpson, Shaw, Newnes, KK, Goodes, Saad (Hamling, Mcintosh)

Fyfe, selwood, Heppell, Danger, Griffen, Cripps, Heeny, CEY, (Vanderberg, Smith, Miller)

Mumford, Bellechambers, (Cox)

Gray, Lids, Martin, Swan, Salem, Clark (hogan, steel or playing rookie)

thoughts would be greatly appreciated,
feels like christmas eve tonight.

eatemalive

Bob Murphy – lockity lock Lekdog

Paddy

NoFatChicks (196197)

Join up, looking for a competitive league. Almost half filled up

Just_Genetics

i was wondering what people thought of my team as it stands
defence – shaw , newnes , lumumba . goodes . brown . saad (oxley , mcintosh)
midfield – pendles . fyfe. selwood. parker . boak. griffen . cripps. eliis yolman (heeny , vander .miller )
rucks – goldy . nic nat (read )
forwards – bartel . martin . swan. salem . clark . lamb (hogan . lambert)
( 118k left to spend )
i am not sure about read. i also dont know if i should stay with bartel or get gray.

Paddy

Good side, not much wrong with it. One option I'd maybe consider is downgrade one of Parker, Boak or Griffen to a rookie (I don't know if all 3 will be in the top 6-10 midfielders at end of season. Maybe upgrade Goodes to Higgins and then get Gray.
I was in a similar conundrum, I had Goddard for my F1, and just tonight I upgraded Goddard to Gray.

Also if anyone is interested, 4 spots left.

NoFatChicks (196197)

Just_Genetics

i have enough cash fro gray atm should i upgrade bartel to him?

Wombat

Please help me and my team, all thoughts appreciated! =D
Back:
B. SmithJ. Newnes J. Adcock
T. LangdonB. Whitecross H. Goddard
Bench: M. ScharenbergD. Viojo-Rainbow

Mid:
G. AblettS. Pendlebury N. Fyfe R. Sloane
P. CrippsI. Heeney B. Boekhorst N. Freeman
Bench: A. VandenbergN. KrakouerK. Lambert

Ruck:
T. GoldsteinN. Naitanui
Bench: T. Read

Fwd:
R. GrayP. RyderJ. Roughead
D. SwanT. MembreyC. Daniel
Bench: J. HoganJ. Laverde

Just_Genetics

look into researching your rookies
your missing some of the essentials

Paddy

Midfield is ok for the premiums.

Your backline is weak and you need to get rid of Sharenberg, he has a knee injury and won't be back until late in the season (if at all). Look at McIntosh, Hamling, Saad for rookies in your defense. I'd also look at upgrading a couple of your key backs for some guys a bit more reliable.
Forward line, I'd look at getting rid of Laverde (not sure if he will be in R1) and Membrey, and look at Clarke and Lonie (if named).

Tim

Join my league 923319
You wont regret it 7 more spots ๐Ÿ™‚

Ben

Thoughts on my team?
Def: H.Shaw , B.Goodes , N.Melceski , J.Newnes , Saad , Mcintosh!! Bench: Brown,Goddard
Mid: Ablett,Fyfe,Priddis,Cripps,Newton,Parker,Ellis-Yolmen,Pendles Bench: Miller,Heeny,Steele
Ruck: Goldstein,Maric!! Ruck: Read
Forward: Swan,Gray,Martin,Hogan,Clark,Salem Bench: Saad,Lambert!!

Your thoughts would be much appreciated !!