add_filter('comment_flood_filter', '__return_false');

Rookie cheat sheet – pre lockout

Published by Jock on

Concrete Booking AgencyThe Gary Ablett Poll

How good is this time of year folks.

I can taste the nervous energy in the air. I can bloody smell it.

It all comes down to the next 48 hours community. Are you ready to put your hand up as one of the ELITE of the Supercoach competition this year?

If you’re keen to have a shot at the title of Jock Reynolds – The Father of Fantasy – in something a bit different.. come and have a look at Moneyball. Click here to learn more – and try to knock me off on Super Saturday this weekend.

Best of luck – here is the final rookie cheat sheet for preseason 2015. Remember – MASSIVE Wednesday night podcast this week. See you then.

Jock Reynolds

CLICK HERE TO DOWNLOAD THE PRE LOCKOUT ROOKIE CHEAT SHEET


Subscribe
Notify of
guest
341 Comments
Oldest
Newest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Sully321

Really helpful once again jock
Just couple of things I need help with is picking one of:
Lumumba, Higgins, Kolodjashnij or ibbotson
And which two of these Pendlebury, beams, JPK, parker, wines, Lewis and boak
Won't be able to afford Pendlebury and another over 600k

@brycewhitneyyy

I would go with Lumumba or Kolodjashnij.

@brycewhitneyyy

As well as Pendles and Parker

Donavan

Higgins then Kolodjashnij

Pendlebury & Lewis

scrofl

Of those go with The Gift, with KKolod a close second.
I'm going with JPK and Lewis this year.

Sully321

Sorry but who is the gift?

scrofl

Lumumba, God's gift to the earth

Ck

Who's the gift?

schmit

i think the gift is lumumba as he called himself a prince. thats my guess

derek

the "Gift" & "Thumper"…I love this community

Squawking_Hawk

Mate I would take defenders in the teams that are likely to be good therefore ibbotson and Higgins. With regard to premiums take those that can score regardless of a tag and that is pendles, JPK, Lewis, Boak

Marco_Polo94

Boak struggles with a tag dude

Matt

Why not make your own decisions???
Sure seek advice on structure if needbe – but wouldn't you like ownership of your own decisions in relation to players??
No one on here can safely predict who will score the most out of Lumuba, KK, Higgins or Ibbotson norcan they tell you who the best combo out of Pendles, Beams, JPK, Parker, Wines, Lewis or Boak would be??
Grow a set of kahunas and make a decision for yourself!!!

Tom

Always brilliant jock, all preseason you have been incredible! Itching to start the season.
Quick question, is there a good justification on putting Robbie Gray at m5 and using the vacancy in my forward line on a mid pricer. I'm worried about midfield midpricers and I feel like it could come in handy with trades. Thanks.

Phil

Personally Tom I reckon not having Robbie Gray would be worse than having him in the midfield. I wouldn't do it just for swing factor but if it was because you actually prefer the mid pricers in the forward (like you stated) then I'd say why not.
As soon as your done with those mid pricers though I'd be switching him into the forward line and getting a genuine midfielder in there.

Jesterhawk

Love the idea of gray at m5. Adds flexibility to structures as can swap in and out of fwd line with other Dpp. I currently have Swan as m6. Everyone will have these 2 so it adds a POD to their obvious selections

Liam

Please?? All you are doing is wasting spots in your midfield and weakening your forward line. You don’t need to be swinging blokes between lines till mid season. Utter nonsense imo!

derek

if you have Lambert in the mids, you have your swing set anyway

Tyler

Good stuff jock always love the cheat sheets for quick and easy info

Anthony

You are a legend among men Jock, thank you.

Ageneral3

Like a beacon in bloody foggy conditions; the Rookie Cheat sheet will bring us into safe harbor.

KJU FC

Bloody brilliant Jock!
but no Touk Miller? Pretty sure Eade said he would play round 1 and looks to be quite a player

Donavan

Agreed, Miller is a mid rookie bench lock, if there is such a thing…

Redgumwon

Miller could be the defencive forward for Gold Coast. Which could mean lower scores than other midfielders. I'd look elsewhere at other rookies

yurkins

be intersting to see him named. Pundits said with gazza out he was a monty

lll

used to play with this kid for local footy. Gonna be a star.

700 Krusty Burgers

857375,

Just started up a league for readers of Jock Reynolds,

Quality teams wanted to join, be quick

Donavan

Thanks Krusty, the Happy Hawkers are in.

chase

Im in!

Filthy

I'm in..(I hope)
Wino United
( formerly "The Filth")

Crabb

Mason cox is $102,400 not 150k Jock. Bloody brilliant work though mate!

chris

thoughts on freeman?

Tyler

Might get a gig because of Levi Greenwood's injury but I still don't see he scoring well

scrofl

Won't feature early, may be a good mid-year downgrade target.

Rocksta

I reckon he is overrated.

tom

Brilliant stuff Jock. Need your help community! Best midfielder under 580K??

scrofl

Parker, Wines, Boak, Lewis are all around that price.

Sully321

Parker, wines, Dangerfield, Griffen, Lewis, boak (I know parker and Lewis are just over in case you could afford them

Brett

Need help guy, Danger or Sloane?

Donavan

Sloan, no contract talks hanging over his head, and I think was starting to take over the mantle from Dangerfield last year, as best Adelaide mid.

higgs boson

Sloane is also due to a contract this year.

Fact is he is more likely to resign and doesn’t get a mention in the Vic news .

scrofl

I'm going with Sloane personally. Danger has the contract looming over his head, and will always cop the tag leaving Sloane to go nuts.

harry

DANGER, much higher upside, cheaper cost

Viscount

Outstanding work Jock!

Definitely given me a sense of comfortable satisfaction

KJU FC

Thoughts on Ciaran Byrne? Has FWD/DEF eligibility and pretty sure he was promoted from the rookie list

Donavan

We dont need another Burn-man, or even a Byrne-man.

Rascal

Jock. After the decision today how many Dons will you be looking at swinging into your starting lineup? The likes of The Pig Hibberd, Watson, Heppell even Hooker have all of a sudden become more relevant and possible POD selections. Thoughts?

Donavan

I would put them all on the possible upgrade list. They havent played a NAB challenge match, so expect a slow start.

Rocksta

I don't reckon that matters. a Lot of Guns from most teams have only played one NAB match. I'm sure the Bombers having been playing intra club matches. Hibberd is now locked and loaded into my team!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

The Ranger

Snap! Just locked him in today.

vinnymac

I feel Watson will let oit his emotions and explode first few rounds. Essendon will be rusty so I’m hoping Hibberd will be doing a lot of ball carrying out the back.

yurkins

god could it be possible that hibbo and watson will be PODs? they will hit the ground running with a lot to prove.

Samuel

No love for Touk Miller, Jock?

I N Pieman

Surprised me too Sam. Declared a certain round one starter today. He’s in my team. Has been for a long time

SCOTLAND THE BRAVE

mine too

Boydo

Might mean less people have him lock in my opinion.

@TylerCArmstrong

Guys need some help! Who will be the top 2 defensive mid pricers (300k to 380k) ??????

higgs boson

Sutcliffe and Kolo

Tyler

I would say Thumper (KK) and Geary

benjamin

pretty much all irrelevant

Jambo

Rohan Bewick.

Sully321

Thumper and ibostson

schmit

39k left would love some opinions on my team…

Back: shaw, newnes, Lumumba
goodes, oxley, mcintosh (hamling, saad)
Mid: ablett, fyfe, parker
wines, stevens, rich
newton, cripps (Anderson, heeney, CEY)
Ruck: goldstien, maric (read)
Fwd: gray, martin, bennell
TBC, salem, clark (Hogan, lambert)

Cheers schmit

scrofl

I honestly wouldn't change a thing, looks the goods!

higgs boson

Oxley over Macintosh for me.

Couple more years under his belt, better job security.

sean

Lewis or Parker?

Donavan

both guns, both priced on the high side following great 2014 seasons, slight edge to Lewis, because he has been a better player for longer, whereas Parker bust onto the scene, and maynot be able to back it up now there is expectation to perform.

Marco_Polo94

yeh all true. in saying that tho i believe both will be top 10 midfielders this season. i had to choose once once i was set on bringing gary back in 🙁

PAB

Lewis is about to turn 29 and only hit a 100 average last year for the first time. Would not go near at this price.

@TylerCArmstrong

Parker for me. Last yr was the first yr Lewis averaged over 100! Close one though.

Tofor

Both!

matt

thoughts on steele JOCK the great

Boydo

I have him in my team ATM have to wait for sides to be announced will score well if given TOG.

Rocksta

Google his name and you'll find an article written in the Sydney Morning Herald earlier today. Jack Steele himself says he isn't ready to play just yet, which isn't a good sign,

tom

pick two out of
Parker, Lewis, Beams, JPK, Griffen

matt

JPK and Griffen

lewis

beams, jpk

vinnymac

JPK – will improve due to injuries last year.
Parker – breakout age and very high average towards the end of the season.

Luviboy1

Beams, Parker.

Avzmo

Just to cinfuse things even further for you…. Lewis & Griffen

andy

Really need feed back please community.

H.SHAW,LUMUMBA,NEWNES,HIGGINS,SAAD,GODDARD. Bench: HAMLING,MCINTOSH

PENDLES,BEAMS,FYFE,PARKER,JUDD,CRIPPS,COCKATOO,HEENEY. BENCH : STEELE,ELLIS YOLMEN,VANDENBERG

MINSON, MARIC. BENCH: REID

GRAY,BARTEL,SWAN,MARTIN,SALEM,CLARK BENCH: KRAKOUER, LAMBERT

Donavan

Def – Good except Goddard unlikely to get an early game, Oxley is more likely i think.

Mid – Not sure Cockatoo will get an early game, particularly given the opposition Geelong face early.

Rucks – solid

Fwd – Great, but Krakouer hasnt yet been upgraded, doesnt mean you cant have him on your bench, just be aware that until upgraded his value wont increase.

I N Pieman

It’s worth noting Krak needs a long term injury to get elevated. They don’t have any at the moment

andy

Thanks mate, really appreciate it.

Sulzeer

hey guys, looking to fill the last few spots in our league, so feel free to join

579819

Cheers

@JackLKelly19

I'm strongly considering Dale Thomas, finally seems to have recovered from injury and has had a full pre-season. Averaged 109 four years ago, been affected by injury since then. I know he burnt people last year but he clearly wasn't 100%. Anyone else looking at him?

Bloke

The only people looking at him will be the sheilas if he’s grown his hair back. Could be analagous to that bible story I suppose.

calvin

out: minson / swan
in: bellchambers / adams

should free up enough cash to upgrade judd / lumumba / higgins to premo's

marty

I’ve done the same thing. Worth the risk I think.

Bailey

Lumumba or Hibbo
Lumumba obviously saves some coin

Rocksta

Yea……………. But Hibbo is much better!

Steve

Hibbo every time

juggs

plus the prince is a knob

SCOTLAND THE BRAVE

great stuff Jock might help us put our finishing touches on our teams, speaking of which little help community with the two scenarios
taylor and the bont (he has big shoulders may be able to carry who ever sits on him)
or
Thumper and Bennell (would love martin but funds wont stretch that far – think bennell may be right in the breakout category and could def finish top 10 fwd.)

Thoughts?

chevy

Bellchambers, worth a punt?
Took lycett out for him, but dunno…

Bloke

Yes, the extra money means one more locked gold premo elsewhere. I read yesterday Lycett’s hit-outs to advantage were very low. So his average won’t be as good as hoped.

Dee

You're the coach… Follow your instincts mate!

Sully321

Which two of these Dangerfield, wines, Parker and Lewis

dannyyboyy

danger on top but cant go wrong

SCOTLAND THE BRAVE

think lycett could be the one but hard to ignore tbc at $300k only needs to score 57 or more pw to go up – surely a first choice ruck could go 80 plus.

chevvy

I had lycett locked in then put bellchambers in, dunno tho…

Jacob

I reckon its worth the risk especially with Kruezer to fall back on in TBC goes down early.

cow roll

It depends on whether that $100k extra is better spent elsewhere.

in short, choose Lycett for stability. TBC for risk and reward.
Lycett is a $450K-500k player
TBC is $400-450K

schmit

anyone have league codes they will give to me :)?

Luviboy1

524635

Jez

Need peoples opinions on this for my M5 and M6 spots:

A Swallow + Judd
or
Griffen + Steven?

Steve

A

Bloke

Swallow, Judd

Monkey_Magic

100% Griffen and Steven, higher ceilings and potential keeper in Stevens

@TheNoLanguage

Is anyone considering Burgoyne in DEF? Haven't heard a peep about him but I feel he could be a top 5 DEF with his dual status..

Donavan

Back your gut feeling.

For me he scores well in big matches because when the Hawks are under pressure Burgoyne gets a run in the centre bounces. But in matches where the Hawks are coasting Burgoyne is used sparing in the middle, and along with many of the other senior Hawks players is managed. For this reason he is not in my team.

Caz

Thoughts on Hurn in defence. Thnx

marty

Has a big role this year not only as captain but with so many defenders injured and retired. He could embrace it or crumble with that workload. I’d save coin and go Sheppard if you want an eagle that will rise in value. He’ll play every game.

The Ranger

Any sign of a Mad Mick team reveal?

SCaddict

<crickets chirping>

Phil

<random cough in the audience>

Spifflicator

Always keen to see the Madmans work!

CJay

First 3 articles were very interesting. Would be nice to see what would be the 4th and final before lockout.

Flanno24

Anybody have super coach leagues with spots to fill? Hoping to join some with serious players rather then mates, cheers

vinnymac

Join my league! 6627277

vinnymac

627277 I mean

cognitohawk

Jester Fc (Fantasy Legends) 627814. Would love to take you on Flanno, and anyone else in the community. Would love to contest some serious players this year

Luviboy1

Plenty of spots in these league that need to be filled.
524635

Basil

Anyone rate Ricky Henderson??

Tossing up between him and geary as D5

Rocksta

I'd go Hendo

cow roll

hendo

Liam

Thoughts on my team community? any advice would be great!
Backline: Shaw, Gibson, Taylor, Newnes, Goodes, Saad (Mcintonsh, Goddard)
Middle: Fyfe, Selwood, Beams, Parker, Griffin, Cripps, Cockatoo, Ellis-Yolmen (Heeney, Freeman, Miller)
Rucks: Mummy, Maric (Nakervis)
Forwards: Gray, Dusty, Swan, Salem, Clark, Hogan (Lonnie, Lambert)

Rocksta

Looks good!
You have 14 keepers from what I can see……………same amount as my team.
I do however have GAJ as one of my 14. I'm assuming you don't have much coin left if you have 14 keepers and thus you just need to be mindful of how difficult it will be to get GAJ in with limited funds.

Liam

Yeah i only have 34k left over, im just a bit worried to start with Gaz as he could be eased into match fitness and may leak some money but yeah big risk not going in with him.
Thanks for your reply though!

liam

any chance of you showing us your team Rocksta

Danny

I think my team is ready. Tell me if you agree.
First up grade will be best defender by no later than round 4 or 5
Wish I could have Gibson, and Buddy. Think they will be early targets for my team. $30 left. Not that it matters to much yet but bye structure is 10, 9, 11, but with 3 perm mids out R12.

DEF. Simpson, Newnes, Higgins, KK, Goodes, McIntosh, (Saad, Hamling)

MIDS. GAJ, Pendle, Fyfe, Jelwood, A.Swallow, Sheed, Cripps, Cocka2, (Heeney, CEY, Miller)

RUCKS. Goldy, Nic Nat, (O'Brien)

FWD. Gray, Dusty, Swan, Salem, Clarke, Daniel, (T.Lamb, Lambert)

Danny

it"s $30K left.
I can swap KK for Gibson if i swap Goldy for Maric and still have $25K left

Bloke

Ready

vinnymac

Hey guys please join my supercoach league: 627277
This is the first time I’ve created a league and I wish to fill it with people obsessed with fantasy football!

Matthew

I'm having a real dilemma over my R1. Who do you think is a better option; Jacobs or Mumford? I know Mummy has an easy start and can go huge, but is injury prone and the new system doesnt favour his scoring as much. Help would be nice

marty

99pts in a half of footy says to me Mumford isn’t worries about new scoring system.

Marco_Polo94

I have Robbie Tarrant over Hogan atm, surprised he didn't make the list Jock.

WebSpyda

Jock is hiding a few gems for the paying member sme thinks

Kim

He will not get much game time at North, their team is hard to break into without many injuries, melb is much weaker team hogan will play plenty

Steve

Good evening all, please help…

A} Maric and Ibbo

or

B} Bellchambers and Hibberd.

cow roll

B

throttlefinger

Wow. Jeez. The scoring potential is far greater in A.

Looking at the B-sides in these comparisons: Ibbo and Belly probably will have comparable highs and lows. Who more consistent highs? NO IDEA. Injury-proneness is a push.

On the A side, Maric will most definitely have a higher scoring average than Hibberd. SD leans towards Hibberd.

I don't like TBC but like to avoid Freo defenders.

Hate to say Steve, this is a gut call. Think if pushed I would go B.

SCaddict

Yeah I'm pretty surprised Tarrant has barely rated a mention at all this preseason.

Has played every NAB game with decent output and his captain is calling him a near certainty for round 1. Could be rejuvenated with a new role in defence.

I don't expect him to set the world on fire but if he makes the Roos final 22 this weekend he's a lock on my forward bench.

throttlefinger

Bench lock makes sense, SCaddict, although would you be looping him with Hogan. Seems you would have 2 folks who may be more underwhelming than you like. Or would you consider him over Hogan? What you figure his average would be (or like it to be)?

SCaddict

I don't think a 50-60pt average for Tarrant down back would be an unrealistic expectation. While you obviously can't place much too much stock in preseason output he did average 59 from the 3 games from just 50% TOG.

As a key back I don't see him as much of vest risk either at least compared to other options like Krakoeur, Lamb, Lambert or in the midfield Miller, Anderson, Cockatoo or Heeney.

As such I believe his JS if he can stay healthy is better too so you have to weigh all this stuff up and not just go purely on potential upper ceiling averages when picking your rookies. You could mount a similar argument for picking Brown on your defensive bench over other options like McIntosh or Hamling who could end up being in and out of their team's best 22.

Dee

Well said mate…

throttlefinger

Spot on, my man!

And with Lambert being listed as an EMG, think he makes more sense. Lambert will get time soon (may even be a late sub) so not the worse to pick and wait. But may go for the JS from the get go…may have to do the same with Brown in the back line (although KMac makes that less necessary).

Nolz

Hey guys, have finally got my team to a point of comfort. Would love the community to tear it to shreds..

Shaw, Gibson, Newnes, Higgins, Goodes, Saad (McIntosh, Hamling)

GAJ, Fyfe, Beams, Griffin, Swallow, Rich, Cripps, Heeney (CEY, Miller, Steele)

Goldy, Maric (Cox)

Goddard, Buddy, Swan, Salem, Clark, Hogan (Lamb, Lambert)

Kev

Not my favoured structure but can't argue with the cattle selected, Nolz. Best of luck for 2015

@TheNoLanguage

Cheers Kev!

Motsy

Someone tell me I'm crazy and talk me out of this….years of experience have told me otherwise but I can't help but entertain the idea.

Move a Swan, or Gray to the mids, to take advantage of the surplus rookie forwards who I believe will out-perform the mid rooks this year.

Later in the season move Gray or Swan back in to the forwards and upgrade to mid premiums?

SCaddict

Yeah either that or just place Lambert on your midfield bench which is one of my potential team configurations depending on selections on Thursday.

throttlefinger

Agree with SCaddict. That the easier move. I may MAY put Krak on my mid bench as a swing AND loop for my bench rooks. Think Krak will get some time down the line but if not, I can use him from time to time to get the better score between Heeney and CEY/other rook.

Rocksta

I’m doing the same throttle. I have Lambert on my forward bench with only one onfield rookie in the forward line. Thus, having a DPP Mid/fwd on my mid bench is very important. I was going to use Jack Steele, but doesn’t look like he’ll play and thus best to save the cash…………and give you another emergency/captain loophole avenue as you say.
As you, I also think he will get elevated at some point in the season.

throttlefinger

I think Steele will get a shot, Rocksta. Got a 87 N2. Maybe after R5. We do need some rooks for downgrades and think he'll be a good one.

throttlefinger

Have a league with a couple openings: 192108

Bring it on!

OldOcker

You got me with my last spot.
Cheers Mate.

throttlefinger

Sweet! That makes me very happy that I'll be doing battle with a coach of your caliber, Ocker.

OldOcker

Don't think I will bother you too much mate my team seems to be a bit generic,

Just trying to get on this Twitter thing. OldOckerOO.
Bloody social media is not for me..

throttlefinger

I'm not super big on social media. But what I like about Twitter is that it's an easy way for me to talk with many of my footy friends and receive information about things I'm interested in. I don't do a lot of tweeting just to be tweeting. Mostly passing along an article, funny lines or getting in a discussion with one of the community.

Food for thought, Ocker.

OldOcker

Yeah me too mate, It will get very little use. Just to keep up with footy info from around the place.
Just might find that golden nugget of information that helps.

Gold Rush

Thanks throtts, I'm in – looking forward to the challenge.

throttlefinger

Sweet Gold Rush. Look forward to locking horns with you.

shezza

Anyone putting Brad Sheppard into their team???

throttlefinger

Doesn't seem like many, Shezza. 2% so far. Considered him for a split second but moved on. Hasn't gone 15+ games and usually want that for someone at that price (2nd years being the exception if they came in late).

Speaking of that, what's your thoughts on Nick Haynes. Does well but hasn't gone a full season yet. Very promising scores last season and NAB. Patfull and an emerging Hampton could make it easier on him.

shezza

I haven’t selected him. He looked good in the pre season but rebounding defenders Shaw and Hampton, I’m not sure what his role would be. I guess, like most, we need to watch closely his first two games and if someone such as “The Gift” or KK is not performing, maybe trade?

throttlefinger

Yeah, that's the land of the corrective. Leaning towards KK. But if Sheppard, Langdon, Haynes, Bewick or others go off, then can make the move.

Rick Grimes

Hibberd or Simpson?? The last decision to be made (for today).

Danny

Simpson

Kev

Line ball, Rick. Don't reckon the bombers will be that underdone as many are claiming. They'll come out breathing fire. Simpson for (semi) consistency, but if you're short 10k elsewhere having Hibbo wouldn't be the worst thing

David

Gibson

Dee

I reckon Simpson…

Danny

I think my team is ready. Tell me if you agree.
First up grade will be best defender by no later than round 4 or 5
Wish I could have Gibson, and Buddy. Think they will be early targets for my team. $30K left. Not that it matters to much yet but bye structure is 10, 9, 11, but with 3 perm mids out R12.

DEF. Simpson, Newnes, Higgins, KK, Goodes, McIntosh, (Saad, Hamling)

MIDS. GAJ, Pendle, Fyfe, Jelwood, A.Swallow, Sheed, Cripps, Cocka2, (Heeney, CEY, Miller)

RUCKS. Goldy, Nic Nat, (O'Brien)

FWD. Gray, Dusty, Swan, Salem, Clarke, Daniel, (T.Lamb, Lambert)

I can swap KK for Gibson if i swap Goldy for Maric and still have $25K left

Kev

Man with a plan, Danny. I like it. Can't see a lot wrong with that, maybe Lonie over Daniel (depending on team sheets of course).

Maric lone ruck at the Tiges, swapping him for Goldy is not a bad move.

derek

good looking team.

you could squeeze a few more dollars if you have Cox instead of O'Brien at F3. the extra $15k will give you enough to get Gibson. (I would go Shaw instead of Gibbo)

BAM

Jelwood or Parker

Luviboy1

Both in my team, but if I had to pick, Parker.

Tofor

Parker

mick

where did you come up with Tom Read from Geelong, has not played a game in NAB, they have four other rucks running round, he won't play a game for geelong in afl all year.

shezza

Captains loop hole and has fwd/ruck eligibilty

Norks fc

Any opinions on team thankfully received
Shaw Taylor newnes Goodes saad Macintosh ha bling Goddard
Fyfe Selwood prides wines Griffen swallow Cripps Heaney eyc miller krak
Godly maric cox
Gray Martin swan bonts saad lambert lonie lamb

Kev

Massive risk fielding 4 backline rookies. Saad I like, McIntosh will likely play round 1 but not sold on his js. Goddard seems to be on the outer, and hamling has been impressive but a bit of an unknown.

Bont will have the life tagged out of him, and Ahmed Saad is still on the rookie list.

Tulendeena

Watson or Parker?

Watson may have something to prove round 1

Luviboy1

Parker. Top 8 mids this year.

Tofor

Second that.

Spud

What does the community think is the better combo… I’m torn!

Higgins and J. Selwood

Or

Hibberd and JPK?

Cheers guys!

jim

Hibb and JPK.

joe

selwood and taylor adams vs swan and parker?
thoughts,
thanks in advance community.

Tyler

2

shezza

Swan and parker but with no conviction. I think it is a touch of a “Jennifer Hawkins” or “Megan Gale” pre kid type of question!!

Vince

Haaay legends I'm still pretty new at this caper I was hoping somebody can explain to me the captain loop hole and put it simply because I'm easily confused I tried to do it last year and stuffed it up any help is much appreciated!

Luviboy1

Basically what you have to do is have 1 player who will score 0, put them on your field and make them C. Have a player on your bench as E for this C, as you dont want to be stuck with a 0. Make a player who you think will score well, your VC, making sure they play before the C option.

If the VC scores well, leave it and take the doubled score.
If the VC scores badly or gets injured etc. change your C option (making sure they havent played yet) to a viable option for C who you think will score well.

derek

that is the trick, make sure the 0 scorer hasn't already played, ok if your VC has done well, but bad if you cant do the transfer.

and check and double check you have the E on your good benched player. Made the mistake once last year and it cost me a top 8 spot.

Vince

Thanks guys 🙂 helped a lot I'm going to put the vc on Kennedy and if he fails throw it on griffen cheers and good luck for the season

derek

I'm expecting a lot of Howls from everyone after week one and there are players who we don't have score really well, and we will be saying "I had him in my team and then took him out" at this stage I think I have had everyone in my team at some stage…..we must remain calm

Kev

Happens every year, Derek. Always the select few who vent with "but Jock said do this" or "John Bruyn said lock him in". Take advice on board, but back in your gut feeling

Zilla

Quick question Jock. Why has everyone been avoiding Wells?
Good price and could get back to best?
Cheers

Kev

Wouldn't say that he is being avoided, ZIlla. Rich is the more popular choice in that price bracket. I also don't see him as a top 8 mid, it's a wasted trade having a mid pricer in your mids imo

SCaddict

I'm going to disagree a little with Kev. I see him as a viable stepping stone selection for certain Supercoach teams just like a Judd, Rich or Scooter. Reckon he's at least $100K under-priced and will likely generate both cash and reasonable premium (though not elite) production at the same time.

As Kev more or less said he's in no scenario a season long keeper so the tricky thing will be when to upgrade him although I suspect it would be around the byes.

You would also be assuming a durability risk in picking him just like Judd but bottom line he's very attractively priced for such a quality player and should still be an important part of the Roo's game plan.

Luviboy1

7 spots left. Code: 524635

derek

4 spots left.

Luviboy1

*1

Spiro

Thoughts on my team, any advice would be great. Have $14,500 in the bank

Backs: K Simpson H Shaw J Newnes K Jaksch B Goodes A Saad (K Mcintosh H Goddard)

Mids: S Pendlebury N Fyfe J Selwood D Prestia R Griffen C Judd P Cripps I Heeney (N Cockatoo C Yolmen T Miller)

Rucks: T Goldstein S Lycett (R O'brien)

Forwards: J Bartel D Martin D Swan C Salem M Clark J Hogan (K Lambert T Lamb)

derek

you have a few players I haven't seen in many other teams. Jaksch could be great value. Prestia is also a great pick if Gaz is sitting back taking it easy first few rounds.

Jack

DEF: K.Simpson, H.Shaw, H.Taylor, J.Newnes, B.Goodes, K,Mcintosh (H.Goddard, A.Saad)

MID: G.Ablett, S.Pendlebury, J.Selwood, R.Sloane, C.Ward, P.Cripps, J.Anderson, I.Heeney (A.Vandenberg, C.Ellis-Yolmen, T.Miller)

RUC: I.Maric, N.Naitanui (T.Read)

FWD: D.Martin, D.Zorko, D.Swan, C.Salem, M.Clark, J.Hogan (C.Daniel, K.Lambert)
Money in the Bank: $20,800

Any thoughts would be appreciated!
Cheers

Conor

thoughts on touk miller?

Kev
zeesus

lock

Jesse Levesque

Rich/Wells or Sheed?

shezza

Wells Rich Sheed in that order.

amateurcoach

Hi everyone,
is it too much to have all three of Boak, Wines and Grey? if so than who do i replace?
thanks

derek

I know we shouldn't worry to much about the draw and who they play when it comes to the pemiums, but Port do have a tough start to the year and I think 3 might be a bit heavy.

zeesus

Boak and Gray are good options. I think there are others to choose from around Wines price.. look for someone else i say.

derek

Krakouer not being elevated is a good thing. I've decided to go with Gray, Dusty, swan, Cloke, Salem, Clark, Hogan & krakouer in my Forward line. With lambert in my Mids to offer a MID/FWD swing.

Cloke is my Shark move!

I consider Cloke, Clark & Hogan all risky selections, however by having Krakouer as a loophole on the forward line, offers me some flexibility with the Emergency loophole. For the First 8 weeks, Port play AFTER Melb & Collingwood, giving me the opportunity to switch krakouer on or off the field depending on the scores of Hogan & Cloke (and Clark).

I can also swing him to the midfield (via Lambert) and offer the same loophole to the midfield rookies if I am worried about scoring of my rookies.

Phil

Clarks not risky. Geelong play 3 games at Kardinia Park in the first 4 weeks, he will go nuts in at least 2 of them

Kev

He ain't the most durable guy around, Phil. Clark is a smash and grab rookie imo, first rookie upgrade in my team

derek

Hogan, cloke and clark could score 23SC on a bad day. Cats play the hawks first up, I'm not expecting to much from mitch.

Whoever is playing first I can put as an emergency and have Krakouer on field. If they have a poor score, I can then switch one of the other onto field and hope they score better.

Dee

Do you think Krakouer will get a game before Steele? That's the question…

Cyril is Delicious

Join my league, 338187

Morse

Hi Guys, the Ablett or no Ablett debate is continuing but I have done some analysis based on the assumption he will achieve approx 70% of the same score he did against the same opponent last season (Melb, StK and Geelong).

Let's assume he goes 113,129 and115 in the first 3 weeks, this is realistic considering his lack of pre-season match fitness (not bad for most players but we would expect more from GOD and a $735K spend).

This would mean his first 3 round average is 119 points meaning a significant price drop from $734,600 down to approx. $639,625 ($94,975 decrease) by round 5/6. If he then scores 130 per week for the next 5 weeks against GWS, Brisbane, Crows, West C and Pies this would bring his 8 week average to 125.87 and his price come round 9 to approx $676,575.

I think the question is not whether to start him but more importantly who is the person you will start with in round one that is going to grow in cash by $40-50K to allow a straight swap for little cash reserve and which round will you swap them for GAJ?

For me I won't be starting him but plan to bring him in by round 5.

Thoughts community?

derek

remember his price won't drop until after week 3. Then the week 1 score will only affect his price for 1 week etc. Not as simple as just his average. I don't think he will drop as much as you think.

Kev

Is it worth not starting with him just to save 40-50k? Easy to trade away when you've got 30 in your pocket, but you'll need them in the back half of the season. Not to mention the guy you trade for Ablett has had a strong start to the season

Tony

Hi Guys kk or bewick @d4

Luviboy1

Thumper

zeesus

Everyone is going KK! I like Bewick and it would be a good POD. imagine if he has a cracker?!

jimmydowland

Whats everyone's thoughts on Daniel Rich?

SCaddict

Has promised plenty for many years but so far hasn't really delivered. I got burnt by him back in 2013 so he won't make my team but is undeniable value at his asking price this season.

grove_street

Now that Essendon are in the clear what are peoples thoughts on getting Watson?

Luviboy1

Great POD. Im not willing to pick him up personally tho.

Phil

i wouldn't pick him ahead of Gaz, Pendles, Fyfe or Kennedy and I don't want 5 midfielders missing Round 12. Otherwise good pick, could explode early although Essendon do have tough early fixture.

grove_street

my 2 options are Rich and Selwood… or Watson and Griffen – other midfielders are Gaz Pendles Fyfe and Wines

Pete

Fyfe or Selwood?? Who would you go for?

grove_street

Fyfe – after losing brownlow contention last year surely he'll behave and be going huge.. Whereas Selwood has less midfield support this year

jimmydowland

What’s more important, Daniel rich in the midfield at M6… or Tommy Bellchambers at F4

SCaddict

I wouldn't be busting up my side to get Rich in but TBC could prove very handy in your forward line if one or both of your starting rucks miss a game here or there.

The General

Community. For someone doing a last minute team fill, what's the go with Titchell and Ryder? Worth a look?

Kev

Nope