add_filter('comment_flood_filter', '__return_false');

2015 Supercoach Rookie Watch List – FORWARDS V3

Published by Barron Von Crow on

Barron Von Crow - inner sanctum


Forwards are probably the second easiest line for us to pick this year and thankfully we’ve had more than a few of the rookie priced options hold up their end and continue to look like good selections.

The following changes have been made from v2 to v3, so if you don’t feel like scrolling through the whole thing again, just CTRL+F the following names and see what we’ve added/updated.

V3 Changes:

  • Removed Christian Petracca (ACL injury)
  • Removed Daniel Markworth (Shoulder injury)
  • Upgraded Jack Lonie to “Potential Watchlist”
  • Upgraded Robbie Tarrant to “Potential Watchlist”
  • Updated info on Caleb Daniel
  • Updated info on Jesse Hogan
  • Updated info on Mitch Clark
  • Updated info on Sam Blease
  • Updated info on Christian Salem
  • Updated info on Eli Templeton
  • Updated info on Kane Lambert
  • Updated info on Nathan Krakouer
  • Updated info on Tom Lamb
  • Updated info on Jack Steele
  • Updated info on Liam McBean
  • Updated info on James Sicily
  • Updated info on Jayden Laverde
  • Updated info on Patrick Karnezis
  • Updated info on Kyle Langford
  • Updated info on Brandon Jack
  • Updated info on Ahmed Saad
  • Updated info on Tim Membrey
  • Updated info on Blaine Johnson
  • Updated info on Ben Lennon
  • Updated info on Michael Apeness
  • Updated info on John Butcher
  • Updated info on Cameron McCarthy
  • Updated info on James Stewart
  • Updated info on Paddy McCartin
  • Updated info on Jack Lonie
  • Updated info on Jaden McGrath
  • Updated info on Reece McKenzie
  • Updated info on Todd Elton
  • Updated info on Josh Hall
  • Updated info on Louis Herbert
  • Updated info on Malcolm Karnapy
  • Updated info on Fraser McInnes
  • Updated info on Dallas Willsmore
  • Updated info on Simon Tunbridge
  • Updated info on Robbie Tarrant
  • Updated info on Sam Grimley
  • Updated info on Jack Redpath



Note: All players are sorted by price (lowest to highest) and then alphabetically by last name.




Caleb Daniel – $117,300

  • Has been compared to Boomer Harvey and Tony Liberatore due to his diminutive size. Is physically ready to play AFL football, but has questions over his size. Tony Liberatore says “I’ve seen Caleb play in a couple of matches and I was very, very impressed with the way he played. I love hearing little guys getting up there and I’m very excited for Caleb. I want to see more small players come back and play AFL footy again, it’s wonderful. I can see him being a cult hero actually. He should be a really exciting prospect.”
  • UPDATED 15/01 – It has been reported that Caleb Daniel has been impressive during the Bulldogs match simulation training, with Bulldogs Assistant Coach Steven King stating “Declan Hamilton is going really well and Caleb Daniel, I think, is ready to go, he’s played senior SANFL footy.”
  • UPDATED 20/01 – Western Bulldogs Recruiting Manager Simon Dalrymple says “We felt that his (Daniel) uncontested possessions, his kicking efficiency, was something that was a priority. We see that even though he’s small he’s got that huge running capacity. He can win his own footy and makes really good decisions, and we think as a 16 beeper, that he can play that high half forward role, and can help us bring the ball out of defensive 50, inside forward 50 and hopefully score, because when he gets the ball, we retain the ball.”
  • UPDATED 28/02 – Daniel didn’t take part in the Bulldogs first NAB game against the Tigers. Still plenty of time for him to play over the next two games, so hopefully he makes an appearance.
  • UPDATED 12/03 – Daniel has been named to take on the Tigers in the Demons in the Bulldogs 2nd NAB game.

Jesse Hogan – Melbourne – $130,400

  • Was always more of a Hollywood Hogan fan myself, but Jesse ain’t bad either. Missed most of 2014 with a back injury, but kicked 39 goals for the Casey Scorpions VFL side as an under-age player.
  • UPDATED – 19/01 – Asked about his back injury and how he is progressing in pre-season, Hogan said “I’m just trying to make sure I can do everything right with my body now and I’ve just got to keep ticking off weeks and then before you know it, the games will come. The body’s still feeling good … so I’m trying to get the best base possible and give myself maximum opportunity to play AFL football. I’ve been pretty monitored still, but I’m very excited because I did the whole ‘four quarter’ training [program last week]. I’ve been pretty monitored with my back and they’ve been cautious, but it’s going really well. I’ve run some good times and some PBs (personal bests), and I’m putting together back to back weeks and I haven’t been too restricted. Hopefully I can continue this into the season.”
  • UPDATED 04/02 – In a recent interview, new Melbourne Demons skipper Nathan Jones said about Hogan “He’s fit and healthy, which is the main thing. I’d love to say that he’s going to kick 60-80 goals and he’s going to dominate, but at this stage we’re trying to take the pressure off him, I guess. In all honesty, he’s only really young but he is one of the most exciting talents I’ve seen and the thing I really love about him — as I said, he’s super talented — but, he’s got the work rate and competitive hunger that goes with it. I know he’s going to carve out a really terrific career and all the media speculation will continue, it comes with Jesse, but for us, as long as he plays his role — which, I’m sure he will — he’s going to be a really exciting player for us. I really can’t wait to run out and have him beside me.”
  • UPDATED 05/03 – Hogan played in the Dees first NAB game against Freo and did well for a rookie. He had 11 disposals, 6 marks and a goal for 65 Supercoach Points
  • UPDATED 09/03 – Hogan was unable to train after the Demons NAB game against Freo after having his foot stepped on during the game. He had been cleared of any injury, however the Demons have said they will be careful with him, and he may not play any further NAB games, or miss the match against the Bulldogs at best.
  • UPDATED 12/03 – Hogan has been named in the 29 man squad for the Demons game against the Bulldogs. Remains to be seen if he plays or not though.

Mitch Clark – Geelong – $155,200

  • Joined the Cats after originally retiring from AFL football. Geelong Head Coach Chris Scott says “Yeah we do (think he will be ready to play Round 1). But I say it with some hesitation, but it’s so far away. NAB (Cup) is March 1. AFL Round 1 is April 6 for us so it’s a long way away, which is good for Mitch because he is coming from a long way back. He has had a number of issues he has needed to overcome but all of the indications are that Round 1 is a pretty good target for Mitch.”
  • UPDATED 15/01 – Clark hurt his calf at training with Geelong Football Manager Steve Hocking saying “Mitch has been training incredibly well so far and whilst this injury is unfortunate we don’t believe it will be something that will hamper his build up to the start of the season.”
  • UPDATED 04/02 – It has been reported that Clark will be missing 2 more weeks of training after suffering a minor calf tear. Geelong Football Manager Steve Hocking said ““Mitch Clark is a bit like Johnson but more advanced. He hadn’t missed any sessions up to January and then got that nick in his calf. He is back running and in the next two weeks will be in the main group.”
  • UPDATED 01/03 – Clark played his first game for the Cats against Gold Coast in the NAB games and had 9 disposals, 2 marks and 2 goals for 66 Supercoach Points. A nice start for his season.
  • UPDATED 12/03 – BANG! What a bloody game from Mitch Clark who destroyed the Crows for 17 disposals, 6 marks and kicked a massive bag of 6 goals for 160 points. This is exactly what Geelong would want to see, Talia, the best KPD goes to Hawkins, leaving Clark to take advantage of the others, with Clark matching up on the likes of Hartigan, Cheney or Pods, all 3 who had troubles stopping him. This is a great sign for us in Supercoach. Can’t expect this every game, but it shows he’s still got something to offer.

Sam Blease – Geelong – $177,400

  • Signed by the Cats as a de-listed free agent, former football manager Neil Balme says “We see Sam as a player who can bring pace as well as a great ability in front of goal,” Balme told the club website. We hope Sam can find more consistency in his game and become a regular face in our side next year.”
  • UPDATED 12/03 – Blease’s first game for Geelong was OK. He showed his speed off on a few occasions and had 10 disposals and 2 marks for 48 Supercoach Points in 60% TOG. Probably better and cheaper options available.

Christian Salem – Melbourne – $185,000

  • Spent most of his AFL time being subbed, so he didn’t rise too much in price. Melbourne Midfield Coach Ben Matthews says “It does take time for them to gel, but there’s no doubt we want the likes of Dom Tyson, who had a great season in 2014, to keep improving. Jack Viney is another we’re looking to keep improving along with our draftees from the previous couple of years, like Christian Salem and Dean Kent.”
  • UPDATED 09/02 – In an interview with, Salem says ““It’s been awesome, the change is just ridiculous (He missed most of the 2014 pre-season and the NAB Cup with a thyroid issue) This time last year I was in rehab and now I’ve pretty much completed every main session, so I’m loving it. Hopefully I can finish off the last month and get cracking into games. For me, getting through pre-season was the biggest thing and I think if I get through this month, [I want to] just try and really crack into the team and try and cement a spot. I’ve been trying out a few different positions, so we’ll see where it takes us. To be honest I don’t mind [what position I play] at all … for me, the team comes first so wherever that leads me, I’m happy to play.”
  • UPDATED 05/03 – Salem played in the Dees NAB game against Freo and had 9 disposals, 1 mark and 1 tackle for 40 Supercoach Points. Not the greatest result from 92% TOG.

Eli Templeton – St Kilda $221,300

  • Fully recovered from his broken arm, Eli Templeton says about St Kilda Alan Richardson’s expectations on him “He wants to get me up the field a bit more where I have sort of been playing as a wingman, half-forward, but he wants me to play half-forward and pinch-hitting in the middle, which will be good so I can use my run on the outside.’’
  • UPDATED 10/02 – In a recent “Ask the Coach” on, St Kilda head coach Alan Richardson said about Eli “Eli played predominantly as a small/negating forward in his six games last year, and was very impressive. Our plan is for Eli to play much more on the wing in 2015, going really well after what was a very bad broken arm.”
  • UPDATED 28/02 – Templeton played in the NAB game VS Brisbane and had the lone 8 disposals and 2 rebound 50’s for 51 Supercoach Points.
  • UPDATED 07/03 – Against the Bombers B Team, Templeton had 11 disposals, 3 marks and 3 tackles for 46 Supercoach Points.



watchlost 2

Kane Lambert – Richmond – $102,400

  • Mature age pick taken by Richmond in the Rookie Draft. Won the B&F for the Northern Blues in 2013 and also won the VFL’s Fothergill–Round Medal (Essentially the VFL’s version of the Rising Star award)
  • UPDATED 11/02 – Asked about Lambert potentially being brought off the rookie list, as Anthony Miles was in 2014, Richmond coach Damien Hardwick said “Kane Lambert is a similar story. He is a rookie so it’s going to be a challenging decision as a match committee as to who can be elevated. It was a really strong draft and we are pleased with the talent we brought in.”
  • UPDATED 28/02 – A nice first up effort from Lambert against the Bulldogs with 15 disposals, 4 marks and 5 tackles for 85 Supercoach Points.

Nathan Krakouer – Port Adelaide – $106,900

  • Drafted back to the Power on the rookie list after he left for the Gold Coast. Played for the Magpies in the SANFL last year and was impressive.
  • UPDATED 08/03 – Against the Eagles Krak had 7 disposals and 1 mark for 42 Supercoach Points. Only had 38% TOG, which could be the sort of thing he gets in the real thing. Looking like the sort of guy that the Power would love to use off the bench.

Tom Lamb – West Coast – $117,300

  • Pick #32 for the Eagles, West Coast Head Coach Adam Simpson says about new recruits Duggan and Lamb “I think they’ve all got the ability to play senior football this year, which is really pleasing. I think you can tell a lot within the first few weeks about how they go about it and their maturity and I’m pleased with all of them. What I’m seeing is the ability to handle situations already that perhaps first-year players don’t normally handle, but it is a longer-term approach so I won’t be throwing them in the deep end. But at the same time if they’re ready to play we’ll play them.”
  • UPDATED 19/01 – It was reported on the West Coast Eagles site that Tom Lamb had been completing “light duties” recently in pre-season training.
  • UPDATED 07/02 – Like his teammate Liam Duggan, it is believed that Lamb will be lining up for West Coast against the indigenous All-Stars that will be happening on Feb 20th at Medibank Stadium in Leederville. Another West Coast player we’ll get an early preview of before the NAB Cup starts.
  • UPDATED 28/02 – Came off the bench against the Bullies and had 4 disposals and a tackle for 13 Supercoach Points.
  • UPDATED 08/03 – A better performance from Lamb who spent most of the game up forward. Against the Power he had 14 disposals, 6 marks and a goal for 82 Supercoach Points.

Jack Lonie – St Kilda – $117,300

  • Exciting prospect for the Saints, has lots of x-factor about him.
  • UPDATED 28/02 – In his first game for the Saints Lonie had 7 disposals and a goal for 54 Supercoach Points. Came on before the 1st half was over as the starting sub.
  • UPDATED 07/03 – Very impressive game for the small forward, grabbing 17 disposals, 3 marks, 2 tackles and a goal for 105 Supercoach Points.

Jack Steele – GWS – $117,300

  • Has a month head start on the rest of the AFL draftees on pre-season training due to being an academy selection. GWS have never been afraid to throw a kid into the deep end of the pool straight away.
  • UPDATED 30/01 – In a recent interview, GWS teammate Stephen Coniglio said “Steeley’s going really well. He’s training exceptionally at the moment in our game scenario stuff … he’s been great. He’s been playing in the midfield and up forward and he has done some exciting things at training that maybe a few of the boys hadn’t seen last year. He’s very much a player of the future … and definitely big things to come.”
  • UPDATED 07/03 – “Superhero” Jack Steele started on the bench for the Giants against the Suns and had 3 disposals, 1 mark and 1 tackle for 19 Supercoach Points.
  • UPDATED 13/03 – Steele got to start on-field for the Giants in their 2nd NAB game against Essendon and looked decent, having 11 disposals, 6 tackles and 2 goals for 88 Supercoach Points

Liam McBean – Richmond – $123,900

  • Showed good form in the VFL again last year, but has yet to make his AFL debut. Richmond Tigers VFL head Coach Tim Clarke says ““Liam is one of the most talked about players people bring up when you’re talking about Richmond and the VFL program. He’s a good kid, Liam. He tries his hardest, but he didn’t have the year that was going to push him into senior level this year. We’re hoping that, over summer, he can do that, and if he can bring that expectation of that key forward to his game, he’s going to be pretty dangerous to match up on.”
  • UPDATED 07/02 – Richmond Tigers coach Damian Hardwick has said “We certainly can [play together]. We’ve got some selection headaches down there with young Liam McBean training very well at the moment as well. Training and games are a different thing, so I’m really excited to see those guys when the pre-season trials come around and a few of the intra-clubs. it’s going to be great for the Tigers’ faithful to see some young key forwards hopefully showing what they’ve got.”
  • UPDATED 10/02 – Richmond Tigers coach Damian Hardwick has said we will likely see McBean in NAB Cup action, saying “But it’s an opportunity for us to see these young players we have been stockpiling like (Ben) Lennon, (Matt) McDonough, (Liam) McBean so it’s a great opportunity for our fans to see what they have got.”
  • UPDATED 28/02 – McBean was named against the Bulldogs in Richmond’s first NAB game and had 6 disposals, 2 marks and 1 tackle for 35 Supercoach Points.

Mason Shaw – Port Adelaide – $123,900

  • Was close to debuting last year, but obviously the recruitment of Paddy Ryder will put him back down the pecking order again. Could be competing with Butcher for a spot in the Powers forward line, but Butcher has been given his chances before.

James Sicily – Hawthorn – $123,900

  • Tough to break into the Hawks forward line, but he certainly looked impressive in the VFL Grand Final.
  • UPDATED 28/02 – Played in the Hawks NAB 1 game against Collingwood and had 10 disposals, 1 mark and a goal for 52 Supercoach Points.
  • UPDATED 08/03 – Sicily didn’t play for the Hawks in their NAB 2 game against North. As wel said before, it’s quite hard to break into the Hawks forward line at the moment and he could be a depth player only at this stage.

Jayden Laverde – Essendon – $127,300

  • Named as an Under-18 All-Australian. Touted as a potential Top-5 pick before the draft.
  • UPDATED 09/02 – Like a number of young Bombers, we could be seeing plenty of action from Laverde if the Bombers hold out players from playing the NAB Cup. As with Shaun Edwards, if this happens, it does make it a bit difficult to gauge where he’s sitting in the Best 22.
  • UPDATED 07/03 – Has been restricted to light duties because of a groin injury and did not play in the Bombers game against the Saints.

Patrick Karnezis – Collingwood – $133,500

  • Has had some injuries issues, mostly groin and hamstring problems. Kicked 31 goals at VFL level last year. Will need to have another big pre-season to be in the mix.
  • UPDATED 28/02 – True to form, Karnezis is only again being a total tease in pre-season, in the Pies NAB 1 game against the Hawks he had 15 disposals, 5 marks, 5 tackles and kicked 3.1 for 95 Supercoach Points.

Kyle Langford – Essendon – $142,300

  • Drafted at pick #17 by the Bombers. Essendon Recruiting Manager Adrian Dodoro says ““We wanted to get running height into our midfield and we saw two guys who have got the potential to be, without giving them labels, we think Langford has a bit of Nat Fyfe in him. He can mark overhead, we can isolate him forward, play him onball.”
  • UPDATED 09/02 – Langford will find himself in the exact same situation as Laverde above.
  • UPDATED 07/03 – Langford played against the Bulldogs and had 3 disposals, 2 marks and 5 tackles for 37 Supercoach Points.
  • UPDATED 13/03 – A better 2nd effort from Langford against GWS, he had 12 disposals, 4 marks and kicked 2.1 for 78 Supercoach Points.

Max Duffy – Fremantle – $142,400

  • Missed about half of 2014 with a shoulder injury, but debuted in Round 20. Fremantle may bring in some more younger players this year, so he could get a chance again.

Robbie Tarrant – North Melbourne – $144,700

  • Experienced Roo who may be forced out with the addition of Jarrad Waite.
  • UPDATED 01/03 – In the Roos first NAB game against the Crows, Tarrant had 6 disposals and 3 marks for 32 Supercoach Points. Was subbed out of the game at the end of the 3rd quarter.
  • UPDATED 08/03 – Matched up on Jack Gunston and played much better than in his NAB 1 game, finishing with 15 disposals and 7 marks for 83 Supercoach Points.

Spencer White – St Kilda – $146,200

  • Played the final 2 games of 2014 for the Saints. Late season form in the VFL was encouraging, but scoring potential could be iffy.
  • UPDATED 10/02 – In a recent “Ask the Coach” on, St Kilda head coach Alan Richardson said about Spencer White “Tom and Spencer have had good pre-seasons. Tom in particular has finally had some luck with his body and barely missed a session, so I’m really looking forward to seeing how he performs in the NAB Challenge. Spencer still has another level to find with respect to his running capacity, but he also is heading in the right direction.”

Brandon Jack – Sydney – $150,500

  • Hit with the green vest in 7 of his 8 games last year. No point picking him if that happens again. His price this year would show you that.
  • UPDATED 06/03 – Jack played for the Swans against the Lions and had 11 disposals, 2 marks, 2 tackles and kicked 1.1 for 62 Supercoach Points.

Ahmed Saad – St Kilda – $151,100

  • Back with the Saints after serving an 18 month suspension. Will likely be in the mix for Round 1, but might be given time in the VFL to get back to speed first.
  • UPDATED 10/02 – In a recent “Ask the Coach” on, St Kilda head coach Alan Richardson was asked about Saad playing Round 1 and said “Yes. Depending on their physical preparation, their form and their understanding of their role. There is a chance that our front half will have a significantly different look with those players, plus Membrey, possibly one of the rucks putting their hand up to play forward, Jack Lonie is another that has been impressive as a small, crumbing forward at this early stage.”
  • UDPATED 28/02 – Saad played his first game back with the Saints against the Lions and had 7 disposals, 2 tackles and kicked a goal for 41 Supercoach Points.
  • UPDATED 07/03 – In his 2nd game back against the Bombers, Saad fared much better, with 10 disposals, 4 tackles and kicked 1.2 for 72 Supercoach Points. Reckon the swing between 40-70 is the type of stuff you could expect from him if he does play in 2015.

Orazio Fantasia – Essendon – $168,400

  • Debuted late last year, but hit with the sub vest in all 3 of his games.
  • UPDATED 09/02 – Fantastia will find himself in the exact same situation as Laverde above.
  • UPDATED 13/03 – Only played a half of football in his first game for the Bombers in 2015 and had 6 disposals and 3 marks for 28 Supercoach Points.

Nick Kommer – Essendon – $168,800

  • Played a fair bit in 2013, but missed all of 2014 with a knee injury. Essendon GM of Performance Neil Craig says “”It’s been a long road for Nick, but in the last fortnight he’s made real progress in that he’s now running, which is significant progress for him. It means now that we can start to get some better conditioning into him because he’s missed a lot of footy and a lot of training. He’s still got a way to go but at least everything is in a positive direction at the moment, and having been out for so long, it’s good for him to be able to get out there and sweat and push himself and start to test himself at training.”
  • UPDATED 09/02 – Another young Bomber who could play plenty in the NAB Cup if senior players sit out.

Tim Membrey – St Kilda – $172,000

  • Picked up by the Saints as a delisted free agent. Came for the opportunity that the Saints can provide, question is will he do enough to beat out some other competition.
  • UPDATED 28/02 – Membry played his first game for the Saints against Brisbane and had 6 disposals, 2 marks and kicked 1.1 for 28 Supercoach Points.
  • UPDATED 07/03 – A better hitout for Membrey in his 2nd Saints game, against Essendon he had 10 disposals, 4 marks and kicked 1.2 for 72 Supercoach Points. You’d expect that against the Bombers reserves side however.

Jonathan Freeman – Brisbane – $173,300

  • Played the last 4 games of 2014 and showed some ability as a goal kicker against Collingwood.

Blaine Johnson – Carlton – $176,300

  • Debuted in 2014 playing 5 games. Carlton Football Operations Manager Andrew McKay says “Blaine is a diligent young man who trains hard and obviously got his opportunity through long-term injuries to other players. Now that he has had a taste of senior football we’re confident he will be hungry for more and will continue to press his case for senior selection.”
  • UPDATED 27/02 – Johnson was one of the starting subs for the Blues against the Eagles and had 2 disposals, 1 mark and a tackle for 5 Supercoach Points.

Ben Lennon – Richmond – $180,400

  • Was given a few chances in the middle and end of 2014, but was usually started as the sub. Potential for more game time is definitely there for him this year.
  • UPDATED 01/02 – Richmond coach Damien Hardwick says about Lennon “He’s probably one of those guys who’s capable of playing forward and back, depending on where we see a need at this stage – whether it’s back or forward, he’ll play there. He’s got some things we really like in his game that can help us and make us better. He was an important player for us last year; he’s incredibly talented and we’ve just got to make sure we transfer that to on-field. He’s a player we think has got a big future in the game. He’s just got to continue to work hard and he’ll get his opportunity come NAB Challenge. Hopefully there’s a position there for him come round one. He’s a great kick, he’s a beautiful mark, he’s working very hard on some facets of his game he knows he has to improve and if he continues to do that, he’ll certainly put his hand up to solidify a position in the side.”
  • UPDATED 28/02 – Against the Bulldogs, Lennon had 16 disposals, 2 marks and 2 tackles for 73 Supercoach Points.

Michael Apeness – Fremantle – $189,200

  • With Pav’s time coming to an end you’d think they’d make it a priority to get some game time into Apeness.
  • UPDATED 05/03 – Apeness didn’t do a lot in his 72% TOG, finishing the game with 4 handballs, 1 mark and 1 tackle for 13 Supercoach Points.

Timmy Sumner – Gold Coast – $191,700

  • Continued to be given a few games, but was subbed often. Still needs to find some more consistency to his game if he wants to be a constant threat to the 22.

Paul Ahern – GWS – $192,300

  • GWS never shy away from playing youngsters, but they have so many of them will they be able to play them all?

Jarrod Pickett – GWS – $207,300

  • Same as Ahern.

John Butcher – Port Adelaide – $209,300

  • Has had a few chances at AFL level and while he is a good mark his kicking can be downright deplorable at times.
  • UPDATED 09/02 – In a recent interview, Brad Ebert said about Butcher ““Johnny’s looking good, he’s been training really well. He’s as fit as I’ve seen him, he’s moving freely and has been able to pluck a few grabs and take a few speccies at training. His fitness is the big thing for him because he’s always had those niggly little injuries which have held him back. This season he’s been able to train for the majority of the pre-season, he’s looking really fit and he’s improving. It’s a good forward line to break into but I think there’s a spot for him. He just needs to believe in himself and go for it. It’s tough for me to say exactly where he’ll play but Butch might just be the in-form forward over the pre-season and be able to slide straight in.’’
  • UPDATED 08/03 – Played against the Eagles and had 11 disposals, 3 marks and kicked 1.1 for 46 Supercoach Points.

Cameron McCarthy – GWS – $210,700

  • Will be in the mix with guys like Adam Tomlinson and James Stewart to take over from Patton and Boyd.
  • UPDATED 07/03 – Played against the Suns and had 4 disposals, 3 marks and 3 goals for 47 Supercoach Points. Was the sub that only came into the game for the 4th quarter, so a very nice effort from McCarthy.
  • UPDATED 13/03- Another great game for McCarthy who played almost 3 quarters of the game and had 11 disposals, 6 marks, 2 Inside 50’s and kicked 3.1 for 121 Supercoach Points. Might have the 2nd forward spot sown up after his good pre-season form.

James Stewart – GWS – $216,800

  • See Cameron McCarthy
  • UPDATED 13/03 – Played his first pre-season game against the Bombers and had 7 disposals, 3 marks and kicked 1.1 for 43 Supercoach Points. Seemed to be trying to do a bit too much by himself at times and got caught with it when he could have dished it off.

Paddy McCartin – St Kilda – $222,300

  • The #1 pick in the draft, St Kilda Coach Alan Richardson says “Paddy is no certainty to play a lot of footy (in 2015). We will wait and see how he goes physically. If he trains well and performs strongly in the trial games he is a chance but if not that’s OK. He is here for the long term, not to win the Rising Star.”
  • UPDATED 10/02 – In a recent “Ask the Coach” on, St Kilda head coach Alan Richardson said about Paddy playing Round 1 and said “Yes. Depending on their physical preparation, their form and their understanding of their role. There is a chance that our front half will have a significantly different look with those players, plus Membrey, possibly one of the rucks putting their hand up to play forward, Jack Lonie is another that has been impressive as a small, crumbing forward at this early stage.”
  • Looking like there might be potential for an upgrade to the Priority Watchlist
  • UPDATED 28/02 – In his very first AFL game, McCartin had 10 disposals, 5 marks,1 tackle and kicked 1.1 for 62 Supercoach Points.
  • UPDATED 07/03 – Very quiet game this week for McCartin, finishing with 4 disposals, 2 marks and a goal for 25 Supercoach Points. Bigs always take longer to develop.




Josh Clayton – Brisbane – $117,300

Jayden Foster – Carlton – $117,300

Mitchell McGovern – Adelaide – $117,300

Jaden McGrath – Brisbane – $117,300

  • UPDATED 28/02 – Had 8 disposals and 2 tackles for 46 Supercoach Points against the Saints. 6 of his 8 disposals were of the contested variety.
  • UPDATED 06/03 – Came on as the sub in the 2nd quarter against the Swains, had 6 disposals and kicked a goal for 28 Supercoach Points.

Reece McKenzie – Richmond – $117,300

  • UPDATED 28/02 – First game for the Tigers was OK, had 5 disposals, 1 mark and a tackle for 42 Supercoach Points. Only played 36% TOG. Reckon the Tigers got a steal getting this kid in the 5th round of the draft.

Toby McLean – Western Bulldogs – $117,300

R̶i̶l̶e̶y̶ ̶K̶n̶i̶g̶h̶t̶ ̶-̶ ̶A̶d̶e̶l̶a̶i̶d̶e̶ ̶-̶ ̶$̶1̶2̶3̶,̶9̶0̶0̶

  • Elite endurance and work rate, Knight finished equal 2nd in the Crows SANFL Best & Fairest count. Named in the Crows best in 7 of 18 games.
  • UPDATED 20/01 – Adelaide Head Coach Phil Walsh indicated in a radio interview that the Round 1 side for the Crows would likely have a few players in the side. Could Riley Knight, a player who has a very good tank on him, take over VB’s role as the Crows designated “cooler”? Walsh has also said that Round 1 of the NAB Cup will have plenty of fresh faces in the side such as Reilly O’Brien and Keenan Ramsey, but the next 2 NAB Cup games will likely be their “strongest” team. If Knight is there in Round 2 of the NAB Cup, consider him a good chance for Round 1.
  • UPDATED 06/02 – After suffering damage to ligaments in his ankle during pre-season training, Knight has had ankle surgery and will now miss 3 months of football. Will certainly make it difficult for him to catch up to the rest of his teammates and make a debut in early 2015. Cross him off your list if you were considering him and look for him to be downgraded to the “Maybe Later On” category.

Todd Elton – Richmond – $123,900

  • UPDATED 28/02 – Did the job on Tom Boyd against the Bullies in Richmond’s first NAB game. had 5 disposals, 1 mark and a tackle for 54 Supercoach Points

Taylor Garner- North Melbourne – $123,900

Josh Hall – Gold Coast – $123,900

  • UPDATED 01/03 – OK game against the Cats though he did get hurt in the 3rd, but played through. Had 6 disposals, 3 marks and kicked 1.1 for 40 Supercoach Points.
  • UPDATED 07/03 – Only had 29% TOG against the Giants, but finished with 2 disposals and 2 marks for 7 Supercoach Points.

Kieran Harper – North Melbourne – $123,900

Mitch Harvey – Port Adelaide – $123,900

Louis Herbert – Gold Coast – $123,900

  • UPDATED 01/03 – Played half the game against the Cats and only had the 3 disposals for 23 Supercoach Points.

Malcolm Karnapy – West Coast – $123,900

  • UPDATED 27/02 – Played 3 quarters of the game and only had the 2 touches and 3 tackles for 6 Supercoach Points in the Eagles first NAB game against the Blues.
  • UPDATED 08/03 – Started on the bench and had 42% TOG. Finished the game against the Power with 4 disposals, 2 marks and 2 tackles for 36 Supercoach Points.

Fraser McInnes – West Coast – $123,900

  • UPDATED 08/03 – Spent time forward and in the ruck for the Eagles against the Power. Finished with 10 disposals, 1 mark, 7 tackles and 12 hitouts for 88 Supercoach Points. Score was slightly elevated due to 3 frees for. Still, a very nice effort from him. Could we see him get time if Nic Nat misses?

Dallas Willsmore – Hawthorn – $123,900

  • UPDATED 26/02 – Had 13 disposals, 3 marks and kicked a behind for 51 Supercoach Points.

Simon Tunbridge – West Coast – $131,700

  • UPDATED 27/02 – In the Eagles first NAB game against Carlton, Tunbridge had 12 disposals, 3 marks and 3 tackles and kicked 1.1 for 75 Supercoach Points.
  • UPDATED 08/03 – A quieter game for Tunbridge against the Power, finishing the game with 6 disposals, 2 marks and 2 tackles for 34 Supercoach Points.

Liam Sumner – GWS – $155,900

Sam Grimley – Hawthorn – $176,500

  • UPDATED 26/02 – Played the Hawks first NAB game against the Pies. Rotated back and forward and finished with 4 disposals, 4 tackles and 6 hitouts for 56 Supercoach Points.

Peter Wright – Gold Coast – $187,300

Brad Hartman – Geelong – $188,100

Jack Hannath – Fremantle – $191,700

Jack Redpath – Western Bulldogs – $204,300

  • UPDATED 28/02 – Strong game from Redpath against the Tigers, finishing up with 10 disposals, 7 marks and 2 goals for 82 Supercoach Points.

C̶o̶l̶i̶n̶ ̶S̶y̶l̶v̶i̶a̶ ̶-̶ ̶F̶r̶e̶m̶a̶n̶t̶l̶e̶ ̶-̶ ̶$̶2̶0̶6̶,̶0̶0̶0̶

  • Poor first year for Sylvia at Freo, but he’s a senior player who may have just taken some time to adjust to the standards that are required out West.
  • UPDATED 20/01- Sylvia still hasn’t returned to full-time training after off-season ankle surgery. Fremantle general manager of football operations Chris Bond says “Colin has had an interrupted pre-season and has been training in the rehabilitation group. We expect Colin to be able to rejoin the main playing group in the not too distant future.”
  • UPDATED 06/02 – Colin Sylvia has been “banished” to the Peel Thunder after repeatedly failing to reach the fitness standards set by the Dockers with Dockers coach Ross Lyon saying “”All I can do is coach action and behaviour. I don’t assume anything. But there’s some actions and behaviour you’ve got to deliver on consistently to be a good AFL player. Over a long period of time, Col hasn’t been able to deliver on those. From the first day Col arrived at the club, he arrived in poor condition. He couldn’t complete a three-kilometre time trial, and it’s continued on pretty much in the same vein on and off till this point. There’s been an enormous amount of resources, time and support and guidance [for Sylvia]. No-one goes out our door wondering why they’ve been delisted or why they’re training at Peel. This has been a 14-month build.”

Tim O’Brien – Hawthorn – $209,600

As always, if you see any names you think should be added or removed or have any news /information you’d think the community should know about, please let us know in the comments below.


Notify of
Newest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments

Thanks Mr Crow! Gives those of us who can't watch the NAB a hope of going in with the 'right' rookies… much appreciated.

seaford scouse

Awesome write-up again Baron, cheers.

References Hogan in Clarks update on 01/03 but I think we all get it, and what a second-up effort, has to be a lock surely!

McCarthy looks very impressive and with Patton out deserves an upgrade to priority I reckon, think the Giants may even rest him for the last NAB to try out different structures, give others a look like Ahern and have him cherry-ripe for round 1, seriously considering him now.

Thanks mate incredible stuff from you with all these updates and you still find time to review the Giants game in-between!


I think that GWS knew what they were doing when they traded Boyd, to have McCarthy come out and go bang is massive.

seaford scouse

Indeed, hats off to their list management team on that one, Griffin and a ready made potentially better replacement for big Tom is a huge win. They've certainly added some decent experience over the last 2 trade windows, starting to all come together for them. Not sure about finals this year but next year they should be challenging.


Also updated that name thanks mate


Rip into my team boys. I would love feedback. Help a fellow supercoacher out, please give me Feedback

DEF: Smith, Shaw, Newnes, Pearce, Edwards, Goddard, Saad, Newman
MID: Ablett, Pendlebury, Selwood, Sloane, Griffin, Boekhorst, Freeman, Vandenberg, Laverde, Steele, Krakouer
RUC: Mumford, Nic Nat, Read
FWD: Gray, Goddard, Deledio, Swan, Clark, Lambert, Lonie, Daniel

Not sure wether to trade Delidio, get Hogan and upgrade a rookie mid and get another premo midfielder.


sam siddall

Good team very similar to mine except think u mit be 1 prem short in bk line as I think u would be lucky 4 2 of ur 4 def rooks to play


Thanks Sam, how do you i suggest i fix that?

sam siddall

If it was me id drop goddard for hogan as I think goddard may struggle abit with bombers worries even tho he isnt going to be banned then upgrade newman to simpson cause will probably play 22 games and be top 6 def plus I think hogan will make more money and score more points than newman even if he plays which I dont think he will so ur making money still and hogan will make up the 5 to 10 points u may loss from goddard to simpson


Hye guys, I would love some feedback on how my team is progressing so far. Still not completely happy with it.

DEF: Burgoyne, Johnson, Newnes, Edwards, McIntosh, Hamling, Goddard, Saad
MID: Ablett, Priddis, Martin, Griffen, Montagna, Cockatoo, Anderson, Heeney, Vandenburg, Steele, Lambert
RUC: Jacobs, Mumford, Read
FWD: Gray, Bartel, Zorko, Swan, Lennon, Clark, Karnezis, Hogan

King Menace

Backline is weak. Far too much spent on rucks. Keep Mumford, downgrade Jacobs to someone like Nic Nat. Martin, get rid of him. Better money spent on another big premo rather than him. Like Priddis selection. Montagna, not sold.



sam siddall

Id forget the 450 to 500k midfielder drop to a rook and pick a another top def for rook def after doing what u said in last comnent too


What ya think about my team community? Don't hold back!

DEF: Shaw, Newnes, Higgins, Geary, C Pearce, Brown (Goddard, Saad)
MID:Gaz, Pendles, Fyfe, Beams, Griffo, Newton, Cockatoo, Anderson (Heeney, vandenburg, Krakouer)
RUC: Mummy, Goldy (Lucey)
FWD: Grey, Swan, Bartel, Clark, Hogan, Steele (Daniel, Lambert)

All criticism welcome!

sam siddall

Good teqm would get rid burger on bench to read then use money to upgrade great to prem def

sam siddall

Sorry thought u had burger on ruck bench read it wrong


Hi guys.

Would like some feedback on my team.

DEF: Simpson, Burgoyne, Shaw, Newnes, Langdon, Goddard, (Saad, Adamson)
MID: Ablett, Pendlebury, Selwood, Ward, Rich, van Berlo, Freeman, Vandenberg, (Heeney, Boekhorst, Ellis-Yolmen)
RUC: Goldstein, Naitanui, (O'Brien)
FWD: Deledio, Bartel, Martin, Clark, Hogan, Laverde, (Steele, Lambert)



Not too bad. maybe Martin down to Swan, potentially similar output but Swan 70k cheaper

sam siddall

AgreeSimpson not shaw I meant


Draft at 8pm tonight if anyone is interested league code 589234


Dustin Martin or Ivan Maric?

seaford scouse

dusty for sure Tyler unless your looking for value which Maric offers a bit of being under-priced.


Thoughts on Dangerfield?


Thoughts on who should fill these gaps?

H.Shaw Newnes _________ __________ Pearce H.Goddard
Ablett Pendlebury Fyfe Beams Griffen __________ Heeney Freeman
Naitanui Bellchambers
Deledio ___________ Swan Bontempelli Clark Hogan

I have 1,763,300 left. And was thinking def gaps should be filled by mid pricers, mid gap by a swallow or a steven and fwd gap by a premium. Please help!!!


Choose your own side


Maybe Langdon, Savage, Steven and Martin. Great team btw.

sam siddall

Shaw kelly newton gray

sam siddall

Simpson not shaw I meant

seaford scouse

Crouch b


Is anyone considering Tom Hickey?

Has played injured for last 3 years, knee all fixed now, bulked up and ready to be the lone wolf at Saint kilda


imo there is better value out there. He's never been a big hitout to advantage ruckman which is important this year, and average in possessions. I will be passing this year.