Supercoach 2015 – Matt Priddis

Published by Throttlefinger on

Mandusa & the He-Man Brownlow Haters Club

Throttlefinger, our Fantasy Footy New York Correspondent OK community, ol’ Throtts is gonna let off a little steam. And I’m sure it’s gonna ruffle many a boxer brief. So here it goes…I don’t like the Brownlow.

Well, I don’t like awards and award shows in general. The worst of the bunch is easily the Academy Awards. I mean, Dances with Wolves over Good Fellas? That’s like saying you prefer eating tofu in a diaper-infested dumpster over drinking piña coladas on an empty beach with Rose Byrne.

The Charlie is in the same league as the Oscars. OK, maybe not as bad. But the Brownlow is faulty right at its foundation. Having the umps as the judges? You mean putting the decision in the hands of the same guys who can’t make a consistent smothering call? This group’s performance is brilliant in its inconsistency and reliable only in its mediocrity. To have them play judge makes little sense. Plus, the Brownlow has become more about the event’s pageantry and gowns than a celebration of the great sport.

That spewing done (whoooosh), let’s talk about the surprise winner of this year’s Brownlow, Matthew “Mandusa” Priddis. (Get it? “Man” + “Medusa” = tasty nicky)

In a nutshell, Mandusa deserves high praise for this season. It was stellar. Was it better than Fyfe, Selwood or Ablett? Well, that’s debatable — and one which I’d love to have with the community (minus the Brownlow backdrop).

Interesting though, his efforts were not that much greater than what he’s done in the past. So let’s grab a can of Jeri curl activator and go through Mandusa’s footy locks…

2015 Price: $606,200
2015 Position: MID
Games last season: 22
Average last season: 112.7
100+ games last season: 16
Sub 80 games last season: 2 (R4 v Cats: 61, R22 v. Dees: 77)
Price range last season: $507K – $632
Missed games last season: 0
Significant history:

109 SC average over last 5 years

Missed 2 games in 2012 with quad injury

Highest SC average (114) in 2011

10 goals in 2014 is his 2nd highest (11 in 2007)


Priddis put up some rock solid SuperCoach numbers this season. Went 130+ 5 times with a season high of 155 against the Pies. Was 3rd in tackles and contested possessions as well as 5th in both clearances and total disposals. One of the knocks is Mandusa’s love of the handball. And this year he didn’t try to shake that rep, ranking 2nd in the league in the hand disposal.

All yummy, right? But get this, while his SC average went from 101 to 112, there weren’t any noticeable upticks in Mandusa’s career numbers. The biggest were disposals going from 26.9 to 28.5 a game, tackles 6.1 to 7.3 and inside 50s up to 3.2 from 2.7. No spikes south. Just put together more big games and less craptacular ones.


Priddis will be 30 years old in March. I admit, I’m not the best at figuring out when a player is too long in the tooth to be effective on the grounds. But Mandusa’s hard nose, high activity style mixed with marathon on-field time (85% average TOG over the last 5 years), it’s not to hard to imagine that his aging body is probably going to go “No Más!” soon.


Mandusa definitely benefitted with new coach Adam Simpson’s more attack oriented style. A more skeptical person would counter that the scores went higher as he had to shoulder more of the load given the Eagles’ injury-prone midfield and Selwood taking more of a tagging role.

Regardless, the guy is a ball magnet and a flat out badass premium. And while his locks flail wildly like a 70s porn star getting his first reach around on a speedboat, Mandusa plays with a calm fierceness that makes him pure silk when handling the pill. But is he worth slotting in?


  • Pretty damn steady SC scores. 22.4 SDeevie proves that.

  • Unlike most notable mids, SC numbers don’t start off hot then cool down. Bulk of big scores were racked up post round 17.

  • A reliable sight each round. Only 3 times not on field in the last 4 years.


  • As mentioned, getting older.

  • If Rosa, Shuey and Wellingham stay healthy, Gaff’s game (finally) picks up and Selwood does less tagging, Priddis won’t have to carry as much of the load. This could be a good or bad thing. Something to watch for.

  • Rarely starts hot so his initial price may be difficult to justify.


Priddis is a no brainer…to NOT slot in. At least at the start. He will begin with a bloated price and for the first 5 rounds will put up premium but not elite scores. And that will drive his price down to tastier levels.

I’d say when his price tag sinks around $60-$80K, time to bring in. In fact, Mandusa could be that perfect post bye pick-up, his strong end-year play giving you a nice spat of tons to help your team dance to the finals.


Spot on or off the mark on Mandusa, community? Shoot me your take!


Twitter: @throttlefinger



THE 2015 SUPERCOACH OFF SEASON SERIESAFL Supercoach Legend Jock Reynolds
This article has been penned by an elite Supercoach analyst hand picked from the talent pool of the Jock Reynolds Fantasy Footy Community. He has stood up within our community as a man of fantasy substance, and has displayed the spirit of togetherness, positivity and community that we value significantly.


Itchy Nuts Pieman · 07/10/2014 at 06:46

Spot on throttle. Not a starting player. But one to look at if the price is right. He seems to hit a tasty price at some point of the season. Quality article

    throttlefinger · 07/10/2014 at 08:31

    Thanks Pieman. Yeah, I like him but never ever considered him from the start. Usually around byes his name starts coming into the conversation more. Think it will be more of the same this season. The classic wait'n'see prem.

@TG_Footy_Tragic · 07/10/2014 at 09:46

I had to laugh reading this article Throtts! Bloody Gold!

I agree 100% on "Mandusa"… Wait-and-see.

Top shelf product mate!

    throttlefinger · 07/10/2014 at 10:08

    Appreciate it, Dex! He's got interesting numbers yet his price is gonna be mega bloated to start the season.

General Soreness · 07/10/2014 at 10:12

Nice work again throtts. A little rascals fan I take it from the heading? Spot on regarding bye round upgrade, his consistency cannot be ignored. I will be very interested to see how he goes at the feet of Nic Nat 100% of the time without the Big Cox.

    throttlefinger · 07/10/2014 at 10:22

    Fargin' fantastic point about Cox! A bit embarrassed I left that out, to be honest. That's why your the General and I only a Sergeant. Think that may mean better things for NicNat. But that's definitely a dynamic to watch in the first half of the season.

    And equally impressive you nailed the Little Rascals reference, General. Thought I was going to be out on my old man island for that one.

David · 07/10/2014 at 11:06

People were telling me not to start with him this year and I did a little article proving he is a 110 player but……

Good read my man

    throttlefinger · 07/10/2014 at 20:48

    Thanks David!

xMASOx · 07/10/2014 at 12:18

Great work Throtts, if you want a guy to be in your side and not have to worry about his your man for sure. deserved his brownlow as he played more games then Ablett, more consistent games then Selwood and was fairer then Fyfe 🙂 yes Ablett would have won it had he not got injured but that's the run of green i guess, its judged on 23 rounds and not 15 😉

    throttlefinger · 07/10/2014 at 20:51

    Agree with your logic, Maso. For me though, Selwood would've been the pick. Some games he was just majestic. Yeah, he ducks and all. But the man is true grit. Fyfe a close second.

Donavan · 07/10/2014 at 21:10

Great article Throttle.

I picked Priddis up around round 10 this year, at around the $550k mark. I also picked up NicNat around the same time.

From that point Priddis, Nic Nat and the WCE team all picked-up.

I think that Priddis & NicNat are higher scoring players when the entire team is up and about, or perhaps their influence on the WCE performance is that great. Anyhow I will be looking at the Eagles draw very closely to see when they are likely to gain momentum, and reckon these 2 guys will be a certainty to play a big role.

    throttlefinger · 07/10/2014 at 21:26

    Thanks Big D!

    Excellent point about Priddis and NicNat. As they go, so do the Eagles. The Eagles should a touch better this season at worst, having another year under Simpson system.

    That combo could be lethal for sure. Will be watching NicNat especially close preseason. Big Ben will be doing a review on NicNat on the 10th. Rapt to see what he has to say.

Mozz · 07/10/2014 at 21:59

Goof article Throttlefinger. Love to see you writing your own articles for this great community 😀 I nearly shed a tear myself when hearing that podcast where Jock offered you the job. Can't wait to read the rest of the articles throughout the year and i'll be behind every single one!!

Great thoughts on Priddis, i don't think i'll be starting with him next year just because he is getting older and the WCE midfield should be bolstered up, meaning that he will most likely get less of the ball. I'll take your word and not start with him next year

    jockreynolds · 07/10/2014 at 22:03

    I'll tell you one thing Mozz – the old chinos are getting a frontal testing of the highest order reading this mothers milk. Hope all's well mate

    throttlefinger · 07/10/2014 at 23:06

    Hey Mozz, how ya been? Appreciate the kind words. Starting my day off here in the Apple and nothing better than a compliment from the likes of you to keep my mood on the positive. Thanks.

    While Priddis won't likely be in the TF starting lineup 2015, will be keeping a close tab on him. Curious to see with a healthy midfield and more NicNat will do for him. Eagles ended the season strong so see if they pick up where they left off.

      Mozz · 08/10/2014 at 14:36

      good to hear from you both. All is going well on my front! Have spent a few weeks away from supercoach to gather my thoughts and now back and ready to go!

jockreynolds · 07/10/2014 at 22:01

Fair dinkum spilled my morning cuppa over the old Tai Chi outfit this morning Throtts – Mandusa. That's a belter. Agree with you on the no brainer as a not slotter-in-errer early mate, but I tend to think there will be some who lock him in as a conservative consistent option. I won't be into his at this stage.

Outstanding contribution Throttlefinger. It's an absolute pleasure to have you

    throttlefinger · 07/10/2014 at 23:08

    The pleasure is all mine, Jocko. Love being a part of this community and honored that I can help provide preseason articles with such an esteemed group of SC coaches.

THE SALTSHAKER · 09/10/2014 at 10:49

Priddis is an amazing contested ball player. His work at stoppages is probably the best in the league, he is a freak at getting his hands on the pill. Historically (twice i think 2012 and 2013 he got inj early in games) like a 4sc and 30sc i think putting his avg above 110 if taken out. When you consider he has also been handball happy those results are extroidinary. He is a great distributor in the WCE midfield, you just wish he kicked it more often. Tackling, clearance, cont poss is where he gets his points from every year as regularly in the top 5-10 players but as mentioned he is top 5 for handball as well. I think youre either paying overs or paying for consistency. He doesnt have a lot of pace to lose so age wont weary him. He will be around 110-115 again im sure. I think def wait and see ive had him in 2yrs of sc after bottoming out and he has been great value. His scores were low hundys most often than not. 130 is a big score for Priddis. I think in 2013 i felt i coulda got a mid with higher ceilings, he is a great bye rnd trade target but come last few rounds your really thinking i could get a higher ceiling M8, one that kicks the ball more than handpass

Peter · 09/10/2014 at 20:36

Priddis is a fantastic player and has been for a few years. I had him from the first game and he never disappointed. He gets his share of freekicks and obviously the umpires love him. Because I followed him closely I had a small wager on him for thr Brownlow ($20 @ 44 to one thanks very much). He had two very good rucks banging it down his throat so to lucky me he was a no brainer, but, prpbably not for me next year.

    throttlefinger · 09/10/2014 at 21:59

    Well done, Peter! Yeah, he's the poster boy for wait and see players. Nod to those who bring him in from the start. Just don't have the plums/patience.

lostlarrikin · 12/10/2014 at 23:24

Crackin stuff Throtts!

Expect main points competition to come from Shuey, Masten and ….Scooter!

Call me crazy but I get the feeling that Scooter will hand over the "perennial tagger" mantle to someone else next yr.
Hutchings is my bet to pick up this job. That said, even as a tagger, Scooter was a 100+ player. Given the opportunity (and staying fit), the forgotten Selwood has the makings of Elite-dom.

The role and amount of game time they put into Sheed will also be something to watch.

Gaff still treading water and appears to have had kiddy floaties surgically implanted into his biceps to facilitate his mediocrity.

    throttlefinger · 13/10/2014 at 00:11

    Haha! Gaff was big on Jock's list. Don't really see it. At least doing much with the Eagles.

    I really like Scooter. In fact, 2014 preseason he was in almost all of my mocks. Until I saw NAB. And his injury. But agree he still did well and his price may be a juicy one.

    Yeah, Sheed is definitely the wild card. He and NicNat I'll be watching closely to see how they come out of the gate.

    Thanks for kind comments, Lost!

Comments are closed.