add_filter('comment_flood_filter', '__return_false');

PODCAST: Round 10 Community Night podcast

Published by Jock on

Supercoach 2014

The Community is UP AND ABOUT in the lead in to this last weekend of the bloody byes!

And the teachings of Ross Lyon have really struck a chord with many of our beloved community and their wisdoms this week.

Enjoy the pre Round 10 Community Night podcast folks – looking forward to reading through the comments below in the lead up to a HUGE round

 


Subscribe
Notify of
guest
269 Comments
Oldest
Newest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Brandon241

Cant wait to listen Jock

Jesse

bloody ripper podcast jock as usual

Rowdy

who out of Hartung Shenton or Cameron (adelaide) would have the better JS. looking at getting 2 out of the 3
Thanks community in advance

Rowdy

you are a legend Sir Jock, now that has a nice ring to it

Tom

absolute ripper jock

Jake

Should I trade out polec or Kelly for selwood? And Is 13 trades with 4 on field rookies (Langdon Langford l Taylor and polec/Kelly) enoufh

Azmataz

Kelly.

Yeah you sould be fine as Langdon and Polec aren't doing too badly.

Captain joc

Time to stick the headphones in and have a listen

Would be awesome if you and the boys posted all your teams would love to see how use are all going ?

And Jock Reynolds do you regret not picking missy Higgins?

Ocker

Captain you can look at their teams in the player search
JR Brumby FC Jock
CrouchingTiger FC
Mathemagic FC Higgo

Cheers.

Captain joc

Oh sweet as might go have a look then

Scano

Is Matty Wright a keeper or do we trade?

Captain joc

No trade him with a high B/E

Azmataz

I am in London Jock and have to wait until after work to listen to the podcast damn it (another 5-6 hours away..)

I am trading ass off this week and getting rid of Dunstan, Acres (as I heard he is gone for 6) and JKH for Hartung, Cameron and the MIGHTY Selwood.

This only leaves me with $8k in the bank and 13 trades remaining, but I still have Polec to upgrade, Sam May in my backline who I am going to downgrade to Bews next week. I might even get me a Bud / Reiwoldt bargain next week.

Langdon is looking more and more like a keeper but will see how he gos now that Fasolo is back (who may also be a keeper).

Nick

G'day community i want to trade out matt suckkling next week who would you suggest I get in for him
I already have Mcveigh bartel swallow Simpson enright
Is Pearce hanly a good idea what are your thoughts

Derek

Birchell is good value

Kris

looking to save money – hanley or jaensch perhaps

Rawkus

I think Brodie Smith is a good option and a nice pod

Damo

need a ruckman and have $500000 to spend, what are your recomendations? thinking either cox, minson, goldstein or macevoy…..

Captain joc

Goldy or Minson

Derek

Zac smith massive POD and way under valued.

Josh

Was talking to Blake acres and he reckons 5 weeks

Adam

Are people going with Pendlebury? I'm really unsure if he is a MUST for league finals, or if we could get by with a POD ie. Goddard, Sloane, NDS?

Donavan

I would go Pendlebury if you can afford him.

He is not a must, the only must is Ablett (I think), but Pendles is a reliable 110-130 scorer, and there arent too many.

Of the 3 you mention I like Sloane, just dont know impact of A.Swallow on NDS.

Captain joc

I beg to differ Donavan pendles season so far has made him a must have with ablett

Kris

NDS has one of the better final runs though

Matt

Goddard won't be much of a POD next week after the bye. Expect him to be the most traded in player next week.

Donavan

Which of the following midfield options do we think are going to average the highest sc score for the rest of the season?

Rockliff, J.Selwood, Dal Santo, Libba, Ward, R.Gray, N.Jones, Harvey or McVeigh

Derek

Seriously look at fyfe and Barlow for next week. Look at Freo up coming games! They play every team ranked below 10th in next 8 weeks

Kris

Rocky or Selwood
followed by either NDS libba or ward

Rodger

Who is NDS please?

Sarah

Nick Dal Santo

The Ranger

Webster and Dunstan are getting the flick this week.
Pendles is coming in but what to do with the other spot?
At the moment I'm torn between swinging Bartel to DEF and bringing in Hartung or swinging L.Taylor to the MID and grabbing Cameron….thoughts community?

Donavan

I'd go for Cameron, Hartung will likey get the sub vest

Captain joc

Cameron

Derek

Pendles too expensive. Paying top dollar, look elsewhere for value, pendles might be cheaper later in year, as long as you get him before finals

Kris

Look at Ward NDS or could even wait a couple weeks for steve Johnsons price to drop

Kris

Not much of a fan on either. JS sounds shaky. Rather wait a week for shenton if your able.

Jezzalenko

Great podcast Jock! I have mostly premos in my team but starting to run low on trades. Do you reckon it's worth holding onto Zorko the magnificent or going the sideways trade to a Buddy or a Roo?

Tom.H

nah just hold him

Donavan

Keep Zorko, he will outscore both of Buddy and Roo for the rest of the season.

Cezz

HUGE issues boys. Won't make the 18 players on field this week due to S.Loydd out and Rioli's nightmare of a hamstring.

What im after is a cheap Mid, already got Hartung and refuse to pay for someone that's popped the bubble. In the communitys proffesional opinion, how likely is Morabito to get a game? Bloody Rossy has been letting him smash in in the resi's "Building fitness".

Rocksta

Freo has a bye this week so Morabito is no good to you, irrespective of if he gets a game soon or not.
Richmond are talking about debuting Miles, but I note he's an emergency this week and thus you'll have to wait.
Shenton is a DPP and looks good, but has a bye this week and is a little more expensive at around $155K even though he's only played 2 games.

Garglesnarf FC

Heres a left field pick for you, Kane Mitchell.

Played last game for 114, picked again this week. His downside is that he is priced awkwardly at about $240k, but a pair of 80’s will see him jump $60k. With more to come he could be a sneaky quick cash cow, or even a very handy M9 come finals time.

Lloyds out is making me consider weird things.

WombatsFC

Thanks for the heads up on Langdon mate. I also had a look at Kane after his first game but I'm worried about JS and think he might be swapped with Newton or similar depending on the opponent. He was flying last year(i think) and then he disappeared.
I'm seriously considering Thomas he was ave 103 from 4 before his round 3 injury compounded in round 5 and he was subbed out. Take out the 2 injury games and his ave is 113.7
He's Only 372k and got GWS Ess,Nth all teams that leak very high midfield points

Kris

Mumford or Jacobs?

wes

players coming back from long lay off tend to score lower… short term, Jacobs is better for mine.
and I have Mummy and cannot trade out.
the above said, I believe Mummy still has a low BE, so he will go up again (something 50-60) provided he stays on field for long enough and doesn't break down at all – God no!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Danny

Hi Guys. Little help please
I have 185 need to get rid of 3 r10 bye players.
OUT………. IN

Cutler……. Jaensch
JKH………. C.Cameron
L.Taylor…. Zac Smith (via dpp thurlow).
(or S.Lloyd now that he’s dropped) (Not keen on Nic Nat)
leaves 47k gives me derickx as future R3
OR
OUT……….. IN
Derickx…… Goldy
Cutler……… Bews
JKH ………..Cameron
leaves 100k,……… No R3…….. probably less output
Or any other ideas

Rocksta

I wouldn't be getting rid of Derickx. Although he only scores in the 60's, he is a valuable R3 and seems to be getting better. Also, there is stuff all else out there in the Ruck Department on the Rookie front.
To be honest, I don't like any of those options detailed above

Captain joc

Yeah either do I I can understand your reasoning for moving derickx on but I wouldn’t move cutler or Taylor as they both have more money to make

Kris

STRUGGLING TO MAKE A DECISION….. Thoughts?

1. Dunstan>Jelwood West>Mumford/Jacobs JKH>Shenton 191-231k bank
2. Dunstan>Jelwood West>Jacobs Kelly>Jaensch 23k bank
3. Dunstan>Jelwood West>Mumford Polec>Jaensch 95k bank

Prior to one of the above trades – need to fill 3 mids 1 def 1-2 fwd 1 ruck

Captain joc

I like number 2 the best what about Minson or goldy or Ryder instead of Jacobs/mummy

The JKH to shenton trade could be done next week

Kris

Minson I like – but am on the edge of too many doggies unfortuantely – libba macrae dahlhaus
Ryder I dont like because of bellchambers
Goldy I love his price – but has struggled this season. The last two tons in a row were against a sick lions with a mediocre west and gcs without Tom Nichols.

So I take it you prefer Mumford more than Jacobs?

Captain joc

No no no no I don’t reckon he will be able to stay on the field/keep up these scores
I really like Jacobs it’s just he is abit dear
But won’t you eventually trade macrae out?
And all the more reason for you to have Minson if you got libba

Kris

Most likely will trade macrae out. But it will take a couple poor games – and hes last on my list…
Next week will either bring in another midfielder or fill a slot on my fwd.

Ive only got Mumford on my radar because I like players with potential to hit BIG scores. One big score can be the difference between a win or loss in my league

Kris

Can do as another alternative
West>Minson Dunstan>Jelwood JKH>Jaensch
But means I will have 4 doggies for 5ish weeks maybe

Captain joc

Yeah I like that option a lot actually
I picked up goldy last week so hoping now that he has signed a new contract that he could completely go bang bang for the remainder of the season

Kris

Cheers captain, been much appreciated – the more I keep thinking and discussing it – I've convinced myself that mummy is fools gold. And the money for an expensive ruck could be better spent elsewhere on someone more reliable

Kris

And yer I hope goldy does pick his game up – it could just be that shoulder injury he got early on in the season that has been hampering him a bit. Hopefully his week off has helped him out

Captain joc

Yeah well who knows how mummy will go coming off an extended lay off
Yeah I’m just going with goldy/sandi combo set and forget and spend more money in the midfield where I can hopefully get jpk as I have already got fyfe Ablett pendlebury beams Watson libba and bringing selwood in this week then jpk about r14-17

Kris

very nice Mid! Would have loved to be able to have grabbed fyfe.
And its too late to get JPK until he has a sod of a game. Ward could be a good cheaper pick that ill be looking at next week.

Captain joc

I also see myself spending less in the Fwds as there isn’t many great Fwds so I’ll spend abit more on defence

Kris

I agree. Thats why im looking at taking a risk on grabbing Nroo from the bargain bin or pay slightly extra for LeCras whilst holding fasolo on the ground in my fwd

Captain joc

Why not buddy or wingard I don’t believe Nroo will do too well unless saints are winning

Kris

Buddy is too sporadic for my liking. Nroo prob as well. Wingard and Lecras would be the safer choice. Will be more consistent. But may miss out on some big +140 scores

Garglesnarf FC

Do we consider Jaensch to be genuine premium? Kudos if you picked him early, but I am not a fan of trading him in now in place of genuine premium like a Bartel/Malceski/Simpson etc.

I know he’s cheap but I dont know if he even keeps his position when Henderson comes back in.

Kris

I think jaensch can avg 95-105. which I am happy with. Would rather spend the big dollars in the mid.

Azmataz

Polec to Jaensch is sideways in my opinion. Option 1 out of those 3. Jacobs over Mummy

Daryl Prasad

Wonderful podcast Jock. A pleasure to listen to and full of great information…thanks heaps!

Kris

Is 6 trades for 8-9ish rounds with a full side cutting it too fine?

Captain joc

Yeah probs but you wouldn’t be the only one

Filthy

Need some advice community.

Ranked 92nd overall – getting to the pointy end of the season, upgrading to premiums ASAP

Current team:

DEF: McVeigh, Hibberd, Swallow, Simpson, Langdon, Langford ( Georgio, Cutler )

MIDS: Gaz, Pendles, Beams, Libba, Cotchin, Watson, Tyson, M Crouch (Acres, O’Rourke)

RUC: Sandi, Jacobs (Derickx, Currie)

FWD: Danger, Parker, Dusty, Breust, Zorko, Higgins (S Lloyd, JKH)

Planned changes R10:

JKH to C Cameron

Tyson to J Selwood

Crouch to S Gray

Cash left over – 133k

Plan for R11 is to switch Gray into forward line for Higgins – upgrade Higgins to Kennedy (swans). Would need one other minor downgrade for the extra cash.

Unfortunately, Lloyd/O’Rourke not playing would mean only 17 players this week.

Alternative would be to upgrade Acres into Gray and play M Crouch this week but would lose me the extra 100k for the proposed Kennedy trade next week and delay the transfer. Is it worth the points Crouch may make?

Currently have 18 trades. Proposed trades would leave me with 15.

Only two defenders to upgrade to premo’s for full premium side – Langdon (not urgent, may keep as D6) and Langford.

May do sideways transfers later for Cotchin and Zorko to better players after full premium team (if I can afford it and have luck with injuries.)

What defenders for the last two? Thinking Bartel and maybe Langdon to SMitchell when he returns.

Thoughts / suggestions most welcome and appreciated.

Regards

Wayne

Coach “The Filth”

Garglesnarf FC

Cant help but think you should be telling us what to do Filthy! Nice work. I assume you mean Robbie Gray is your in, & not Sam Gray?

Robbie into the middle looks sound in light of your planned trades next week.

Goodluck on the $50k!

Filthy

OOPs! … i meant Robbie Gray. haha!
You need luck – I have been fortunate with my rucks. A lot of coaches have had injuries to Mummy, Ryder etc which need wasting trades to rectify. Also selected Parker instead of Mitchell or Franklin – could have gone either way.
i don't see that luck in my initial selections, choice of rookies etc make me an "expert" – far from it.
Players such as yourself Wombat, Jimbo from Traralgon etc have been of assistance through their comments and advice to others. I have played SC for a few years so I have some understanding of the "rookie ramp" to generate cash.
I am happy to be in my current position but I still appreciate input from others – thanks for your response Gargle. Cheers!

Paige

Thanks Jock – you’ve given us at SCPaige some great material to upload on our site in the next day or so!

Cheers

Captain joc

Isn’t that plagiarism?

Ripper roo

Totally agree, Captain. This community is built on helping each other out, but taking advantage of it by pulling a swifty is poor form. I hope Crouching lands flykick in on your page. Keen to hear your thoughts Jock and company.

G.Ablett 3 Votes

Get lost paige!!!

Cam_H

I'm a bit suspicious that this post from "Paige" *might* be bogus?

SCaddict

You reckon??

Yes definitely someone playing silly buggers. Shame Jock's admin can't block these sorts of recurring posters.

So better off we all just ignore these posts until they are deleted rather than encourage this kind of tomfoolery.

paul

Worst rookies this year so far is impey, acres and georgio. All works in donut king.

Sleepy

hey Paul you forgot Clurey, Boyd and Jack Martin. McCarthy as well. Then there is Michie and ……….. get my point lol

Sarah

Hi Community,

I'm having difficulty making a decision this morning…

Rory Sloane or Nick Dal Santo?

As a massive crows fan I'm trying not to be biased, hence my indecision!
I need unbiased comments!!!
Thanks guys πŸ™‚

Tom.H

NDS

Garglesnarf FC

They are impossible to split I think. Both are scoring well and both have a decent run home in the finals. Go with the bloke you like more!

Sarah

Thanks Gargles! I obviously like Sloane more but wanted to make sure I wasn't being Crows-biased!!!

Dinkum Davo

I like the sloane ranger out of those 2… I rekon his got the higher ceiling

By the way, wat do people see fasolo averaging at yrs end, could he be a keeper?

Sarah

Thanks for your input.
I'm not sure about Fasolo. He's at an awkward price. I was looking at him too but think I might take Zorko in 3 weeks when he's bottomed out.

Kurt

Sloane. Think Swallow in might slow Dal Santo's scoring.

Sarah

Thanks guys!!
I think Sloane's got an unasailable lead here!!
From the site and my own network the ledger is standing at Sloane 6, NDS 1.

rosco_peco

Out of those two alone, add me down for another Sloane vote Sarah, the kid is a jet and consistent scorer.

On a side note, I cant wait to get Goddard in next week. Take out his injury effected 11 and he's averaging a touch under 118 for the year.

rosco_peco

Love your work Jock, and appreciate all your tireless efforts and contributions, words of wisdom, community support, and outstanding leadership!

Am I crazy to make the following trades this week;
JKH > Charlie Cameron
Crouch > Selwood
$56K left

Garglesnarf FC

They look to be excellent trades Rosco

rosco_peco

Thanks mate, I may even drop Tyson a week early and bring in Bews via DPP to generate cash for next week.

Have to remind ourselves we're back to 2 trades per week next week, and ideally I would like to probably do a downgrade and upgrade of Hallahan and Langford. Tyson to Bews leaves me with $390K and with cash generated from the next round of trades, I should be able to go Hallahan > Shenton/rookie & Langford > JPK/Fyfe or pretty much any uber premo. That will all but round out my onfield team of premo's. with 10 trades left for the year.

SCaddict

I'm doing the same exact moves Rosco though I also plan to cash out Flipper with a third trade down to Hartung.

Danny

Desperate for help. My ideas have been canned. Need more players on field this week. $185,100…* denotes R10 bye….(Lloyd dropped)
.
DEF…… McV*…Burg…Langdon…Hanley*…Enright…(Cutler*, Martin)
MID…… GAZ,.. Jobe*…, D.Beam…, Jelwood…, Ward…, Fyfe*…, Cotch…, Polec ………….(M.Crouch,Hartung)
RUC…… Sandi*…Deickx*…(Thurlow*, M.King*)
FWD…. Danger…Pav*…Zork*…Dusty…Fasol…S.Lloyd…(L.Taylor*…JKH*)
.
Going for league win

Garglesnarf FC

As I see it you currently have 14 players this week?

Crouch and JKH are ripe for being down/upgraded, but that wont help you get near 18 players. I think you are simply going to have tank this round, and make sure you help to set up your squad for the run home. Unless someone else has a better idea, here is my offering;

JKH > Lennon/Cameron
Crouch > Gray to open up F/M swing with Danger Zorko and Dusty

I think Lennon may play more than Cameron, but Cameron saves you $40k of outlay. Gray may seem a little left field as a Mid, but by having the swingman in the centre you have three way flexibility to cover any fwd outs as the season progresses without having to burn a trade. If you also trade in Shenton as either F or M next week you can add yet another rotation into the mix.

Hope that at least gives you food for thought.

Danny

Thanks GFC.
I appreciate it

Captain joc

Hey GFC how sure are we on shenton at 155k about his JS?

Garglesnarf FC

I think he’s probably got the best JS of the current rookies on or near the bubble. Certainly while Acres is out anyway, but like all of them they fight for game time against other rookies and older players returning from injury.

Lennon is fighting McDonough and Lloyd for gametime, Cameron is fighting a host of small mid/fwds at the Crows, while Hartung and Hallahan will fight each other plus Suckling and Mitchell for time over the next couple.

To be honest it is a very tough call as to who offers you the best JS. Price wise Shenton is at least cheaper than Lennon but 32k more than Cameron, and 37k more than Hartung.

I am taking Hartung this week, along with Gray and Selwood. Next week I will take Shenton if named and consider Cameron for double downgrade week.

SCdonkey

Many will disagree with me on this Sandi to Minson playing against Suns should score big.
Then Crouch to Cameron via L Taylor and upgrade JKH to R Gray or Harvey.
This should give you 17 players onfield this week.

Garglesnarf FC

As in Jeremy Cameron? Expecting him to get back to last years form again SCD? As a Giants fan, I certainly hope so, but that is THE most left field pick I have seen this week. Still if he kicks 6 against the black & yellow rabble you will be a genius!

SCdonkey

Sorry snarf I should have been more specific. I was refering to charlie cameron.

Garglesnarf FC

Oh yeah. Me being an idiot on a friday afternoon doesnt help. πŸ™‚

Westerner

Hello community , I need some help please ! Would JKH > Matera or JJK be a bad move?

Derek

neither are premiums. Should be looking at only trading in Premos now. Not these pretend premo/mid pricer burn men

Donavan

Not sure which trade to do.

Team is as follows pre this weeks trade.

Def – Bartel, Enright, Kolodjashnij, Schoenmakers, Langford, Tippett, Webster, Firrito
Mid – Ablett, Pendlebury, Beams, Cotchin, Priddis, Goddard, Polec, Dunstan, Langdon, Acres
Ruck – Sandilands, Mumford, Derickx, Lobb
Fwd – Dangerfield, Roughead, Martin, Franklin, Dahlhaus, Ambrose, Taylor, Lloyd

I have $24.4k in the bank.

Looking to trade Webster, Firrito and Dunstan

Seriously considering 2 trade types, by trading in-

1. Jaensch, M.Johnson & Hartung (thinking Jaensch because I can't quite afford D.Swallow)

2. Hartung, Docherty and a premium mid (Liberatore or J.Selwood)

Appreciate your thoughts, leaning towards option 1.

Thanks.

Garglesnarf FC

Not sure about Jaensch, you are the second person suggesting to trade him in this week and I can see how his price is very tempting. The problem as I see it is that you are taking a punt on a non-proven performer who is occupying the role of a more senior player who is injured (Henderson). Whilst his output is solid so far, it would not be any surprise to see his output drop or his role change on Hendersons return to fitness.

If you are flush with trades (16+) then he is worth the gamble as he has points and cash to earn in the short term otherwise I would go with a proven performer instead.

Firrito is back this week as well, and with Nths draw opening up I would consider keeping him for now.

What about Dunstan down to Hartung and Webster up to Simpson, you could do with another genuine premium in that backline.

Donavan

Thanks for the response Gargesnarf.

Is it too late to get D.Swallow, and save some extra cash for the next upgrade, and increase team flexibility with another DPP.

Really appreciate your thoughts.

Garglesnarf FC

Swallow instead of Simpson would work, just watch the team list tonight as Swallow is only on an extended bench at the moment.

Like the DPP with Langdon in the middle.

Donavan

Thanks gain.

I will keep an eye on the teams tonight (whilst at work).

And I have 17 trades before this weeks trades are finalized.

SCdonkey

Heres my thought. Firrito to Hartung via Langdon still give you full team in def. Then upgrade Dunstan to R Gray giving you DPP swing with L Taylor if you need Gray up fwd. Two trades used gained 34K plus 24.4K you already have. Then next week you can trade Webster and Langford to another premo the likes of swallow simpson etc.. and Bews if named.

Donavan

Thanks SCdonkey, hadn't considered that type of move, but i am now.

SCdonkey

No worries Donovan hope that helped. With those two trades you will have full squad in def mids and fwd this week and on top of that your fwd line will be full premiums.

Zaydan

Daniel Currie > Jonathon Ceglar Just as security
Thoughts

Captain joc

Not worth it

Ocker

Wasted trade.

Avzmo

Zorko, Riewoldt or Franklin, all priced around 400k, which on should I have?

Donavan

Franklin, or if you can wait 2-3 weeks for Zorkos price to fall significantly then get him in

Derek

Have a look at who Freo play in next 8 weeks and think about PAV

Azmataz

I would go Reiwoldt

Matt

I agree with Donavan, jump on the Zorkster once his price has dropped

Matt

Is Matty Crouch to Jelwood and Nick Robertson to hartung good trades?

Donavan

Yes, both solid

Matt

If Bews not named as sub is it worth jumping on him early?

Donavan

I don't like Bews, think he will only get 2-3 games this year.

Derek

stay away. won't get enough games to make you any cash or be a good backup DEF

SuperCyril

Thoughts on:
S.Mitchell to Hurn, N.Robertson to Hartung, and J.Kelly to Selwood. Leaves $16k in bank.
or
S.Mitchell to Bews, and N.Robertson to Selwood. Save 1 trade & $75k in bank.
Cheers

Garglesnarf FC

2nd option by a mile

Filthy

Don't touch Hurn.
Option 2 – more cash, save a trade – no brainer.
Hopefully Bews plays enough games to gain value. At least he is not sub tonight which is a good sign.
Right move to get Selwood whilst he is cheap.

Captain joc

As we were discussing POD players in the podcast majority of pods you pick make you just get further away from the pack.
Example a couple of weeks ago I seriously considered brad ebert for a mid pod both his scores since then have been low I didn’t get him I got fyfe instead

BCHawks

Hey guys I need some serious help with my trades this week. This is my team as it stands

Defense:
J.McVeigh, D.Swallow, A.Walker, P.Hanly, S.Hurn, K.Kolodjashnij, W.Langford, J.Laidler
Midfield:
G.Ablett, D.Beams, D.Mundy, T.Liberatore, M.Murphy, J.Bartel, M.Crouch, H.Cunningham, N.Robertson, B.Acres
Ruck:
A.Sandilands. S.Jacobs, T.Derickx, D.Currie
Forward: P.Dangerfield, D.Martin, C.Rioli, J.Roughead, D.Zorko, M.Wright, J.Kennedy-Harris, P.Ambrose

I currently have 16 trades left and $79,100 in my bank.
What I was thinking of doing either
1.Out C.Rioli in C.Wingard
Out JKH in Cameron
Out Cunningham in Selwood

2. Out C.Rioli in C.Wingard
Out Cunningham swing Wright into my Mid and in Cameron
Out Crouch in Selwood

I am just not sure if Wright will be a keeper or if I should trade him I like option 2 a bit better because it means next week I can trade out JKH for Shenton but I really am not sure to do. If anyone has any better trade options for my team please tell me them. Thanks BCHawks

dognino

As a wingard owner I really don't see why any one would want him, and with roughy and zorko in your Fwds it's another risk on an under performing player. I have roo and zorko along with wingard and it does my head in every week . Do you have enough cash for rioli to gray, JKH to Cameron , Cunningham to selwood ?

BCHawks

No sorry I don't have enough cash.

Captain joc

What about rioli to gray wright to selwood Cunningham to Cameron?

BCHawks

That is actually a pretty good idea. I am just a bit concerned as to if he will be able to keep up these scores that he is getting.

dognino

Am I over exciting the arousal curve by thinking JKH -> t.walker for F6 ? Trying to think of some cheap options around the ground and spend all my cash in the mids

Cam_H

I'm exciting the arousal curve myself … I've made that trade his week. Mick the Mad Irishman has Tex at 97-101 points per round (he's done it once before), so I'm rolling the dice and going for it.

dognino

It's a big gamble, I'm either going JKH to dustbin Martin and keeping faith that pyke will come good now swans have a full fwd line, or pyke to goldy/Minson and JKH to walker/fasolo as permanent F6 as a roll o tha dice …….

Jay

Need help on trades

Polec > Selwood

Robertson > Hartung

Kennedy-Harris > Fasolo

Or

Crouch > Selwood

Robertson > Hartung

Kennedy-Harris > Cameron

rosco_peco

Option 2 mate, polec has a few good weeks coming up. Crouch will take a few weeks before he starts building cash again

Sleepy

Crouch dropped this week

Blueprime

2

Tom

Josh Kennedy or fyfe?

James

fyfe will be cheaper but ross lyon rests players so

SCaddict

All the way with JPK! πŸ™‚

Derek

I have gone JPK over Fyfe, very happy.

But I am eyeing Freo's next 8 games against teams ranked between 10th & 18th and thinking Fyfe or barlow might get a run in my team.

Tommykwr

JPK

T-Mac

Thoughts on Suckling to hurn

Azmataz

Burn

Ocker

JOCK and COMMUNITY:
I am giving my view of Point of Difference, Which in Bean-Counter and or Business terms is associated with Price Point as well to maximize a companies profit. It is all about having an advantage over your opposition.
When we look at what a POD is in Super-Coach terms It is not necessarily having a different player but at what
price and at what stage of the season you pick the same player up at to maximise our scores. We are all looking to gain some sort of an advantage over everyone else. This can be done in a number of ways.
Planning your team strategy at the start of the season is a POD as is "who you pick" but also "who you don't pick" for you team.

Example:
Given the bye situation I only wanted 2 players out of round 8 in the midfield so I decided on Ablett and Beams
with the plan of picking up Pendlebury and J Selwood after their byes.
Given their current prices and scores I have made the correct decission. We need to look at value for money. One Hundred Thousand teams had Pendlebury at the start of the year but I chose not to as a POD.

Profit Total Points
Ablett $59,400 1212
Beams $86,700 962
Total $146,100 in financial profit for 2174 Points.

Whereas:
Pendlebury -$50,300 1035
J Selwood -$89,200 959
Total -$139,500 in financial loss for 1994 Points.
Looking at these figures I am 180 points better off and money saved from my initial 10 million starting value
which allowed me to get Dangerfield instead of Wingard at the start of season. Choosing the right team in the first place can be a POD.
It could be argued why I did not start with Pendlebury as well for more points but I had to make a choice regarding byes and my score over the byes has made up for points lost in the first 7 rounds. If I lost any at all.

Short of writing an encyclopedia I liken the phrase POD to the word "if".
When I was a kid we were always told that the word "IF" was the shortest word in the dictionary with the longest meaning. "If only I had picked up that player last week" Are you guilty of saying that? OR If only I left the big C on Ablett?

Cheers Community hope this gives you an understanding of POD.

Ocker

Making the right decision at the right time.

GarglesnarfFC

Nice work Ocker, thanks!

Ocker

Cheers mate.

Filthy

Nice post Ocker.

Ocker

Cheers mate.

Tim

Just a quick question, thinking of reversing my trades this week but there is a warning tha t says Reversing trade cannot be undone, does this mean i cant do three different trades and do i lose those trades if i do reverse, help!!

Rawkus

No! Unlimited reversals till first game

Cam_H

'Yes' … (my understanding is that) you can't reverse trades once the round starts, but you can make trades involving players who have yet to play, or bye players who will not play.

David

Mate, as long as you reverse all of the trades you have made so far BEFORE THE FIRST LOCKOUT, which is 7.5opm AEST tonight, you will be fine

Nik

Need some help, anything would be appreciated.

Option one – out Kelly, jkh and billings, in hartung Cameron and grey + bank some cash

Option two – out Tyson, Kelly and jkh – in hartung bruest and jelwood.

I’m aware Tyson will be going up a decent amount with a be of 17 but I need a league win.

Thoughts??

Ocker

Kelly, Billings and Tyson can all still appreciate a fair bit in value.
3 trades for 2 guns and a rookie is sound thinking and the right way to go in my opinion.
Not a Breust fan but Optiion 2 looks better for a better chance to win your league game this week.
Does Tyson Billings and JKH work for you financially. That gives you Kelly as another player this week although he is named on Interchange this week and someone has to get the vest.

Cheers.

Derek

don't be in a rush. Hold Tyson until you have extracted all the cash you can.

Jack

Should i trade Georgiou out for Bews so that i have 18 playing this week??

Ocker

Bews has only played one game and is a vest candidate along with the fact that Geelong only give rookies limited games as a rule. I would hold for another week on that one..

James

Hey community, which forward player should I get in this week?. Have $482000.

Hugh 'HTK'

Should I go C Cameron or C Shenton? Is it better to cop the donut this week or take the punt on Cameron?

Ocker

I took the risk on putting Charlie in last week and will probably get Shenton next week.
I normally like to have a second look at rookies but went with Charlie because I believe he will get games.
Your Choice.

Hugh 'HTK'

Thanks mate! Decided to go with Shenton, I just think his job security is a lot saer and I have 18 + (Lloyd) playing this week. I think Lloyd may be a late entrant.

Azmataz

Mate Shenton could have a season ending injury during training. I would hold off until next week to get him in.

I definitely like Shenton's JS over Cameron, and will wait and see what Cameron does this weekend to see whether he comes in or not.

Hartung I think will get the vest.

Derek

When will Honeychurch hurry up and get a game

Sully321

Hi community,
What do you think of my trades this week?
1. Dunstan > selwood
2. Zorko > Cameron
This leaves me with $299,000 in the bank.
Thinking of getting out Lloyd, georgiou or aish.
I'm leaning to Lloyd or georgiou because I already have a stacked midfield.

Suggestions for upgrades would be appreciated.
(Already have enright, swallow, Burgoyne, Johnson in my defence. In the midfield I have abblet, pendles, fyfe, beams, Watson. And in my fwd line i have danger, Martin, and bruest. Players with byes are also not an issue)

MightyDonsFC

Don't trade Zorko out

Sully321

Zorko got a break even of 139 and his form has been shocking

SCaddict

Think you would be better off going Lloyd or JKH (if you still have him) down to Ch.Cameron.

Would only consider getting rid of Zorko if you still have a bunch of trades left (at least say 18 heading into this round) which I certainly don't have.

SCaddict

Yes Lions have a decent run of games coming up with Blues, Dogs and Giants so I intend to hold Zorko the Craptastic for now and see if he can turn things around.

Tommykwr

Trade out Lloyd . Not playing this week

Azmataz

Lloyd's a gun – should be back next week and has negative BE. HOLD I say, HOLD

BCHawks

I have ended up trading Rioli to Wingard, Cunninham to Cameron (I swung Wright in to my mids) and Robertson to Selwood. I now have 19 playing this week. Thanks everybody for the help.

Azmataz

Nice trades! I like!

Forbesy

Roughead to dahlhouse? Or hold ?

Tommykwr

Keep roughy and cop the donut. bit up and down but you chose him for a reason