Flesh for Fantasy – Round 10, Bye 3

Filed in Supercoach, Supercoach 2014, Supercoach Mr Crimmins style by on 22/05/2014 • views: 36223

flesh-for-fantasy-150x150G’day community,

It’s almost over. There is light at the end of the tunnel. We are into the final week of these horrid byes and our sides should start taking shape. Only a handful of SuperCoach relevant players have the week off, so this week creates another opportunity to upgrade those players and move them on to a player who has already had their bye.

Who should you look for? Let’s take a look.


Sam Gibson (NM) MID – $527,500 SC

  • Next 5 Games: GEE (A), WCE (A), RICH (H), ADEL (A), MELB (H)
  • Recent Scores: 123, 103, 85, 122, 102, 149
  • Breakeven: 61

Once flying under the radar, Sam Gibson is starting to get some recognition for his stellar form to date. A mature age recruit, his recent scores speak for itself – dropping under 100 just once in his past 6 games. His outside run and ability to get the footy has been superb. 35 touches and 10 marks against the Lions to back up his 30 touches and 9 marks against Gold Coast shows just prolific he can be.

While his run coming up is awkward, a mixture of tough and easy games, there is no reason to suggest Gibson’s run of form won’t continue, especially if guys like Nicky Dal and Boomer continue to take attention away from him. A good shout.

Todd Goldstein (NM) RUCK – $445,000 SC

  • Next 5 Games: GEE (A), WCE (A), RICH (H), ADEL (A), MELB (H)
  • Recent Scores: 98, 93, 89, 69, 101, 101
  • Breakeven: 77

Todd’s form his season has been scratchy at best, producing good games, but not the great games we expect from him. Whether that shoulder injury he suffered early in the season was still hampering him only Todd will know. However, he has hit triple figures in his last two and is starting to show a bit. 15 touches and 43 HOs against Gold Coast, along with 10 touches and 33 HOs against the Lions signals a player coming into form.

If his breakeven was any higher I’d probably sit on him for one more week, but given those 2 100s will be staying in his rolling lockout and the 69 will be dropping out, I’m expecting Todd to start appreciating in value. If you need a new ruckman, Todd is definitely worth considering.

Tom Libertore (WBD) MID – $563,900 SC

  • Next 5 Games: GCS (A), FRE (H), BRIS (H), COLL (A), PORT (A)
  • Recent Scores: 82, 76, 96, 139, 171
  • Breakeven: 24

Hard to deny his form of late, and if you’re unsure about Sam Gibson, an alternative is Tommy Libba. His performance v Melbourne was outrageous, collecting 27 touches, laying 14 tackles and kicking 2 goals. Against Essendon he had 25 touches, 8 tackles and kicked a goal. He is back to his inside best.

He will cost a bit more than Gibson, and of course, you could at getting Joel Selwood in at that price, but given his last two scores and his breakeven, it is great time to get Libba in.


Luke Dunstan (STK) MID – $326,000 SC

  • Next 5 Games: BYE, COLL (H), PORT (A), GEE (A), WCE (H)
  • Recent Scores: 55, 52, 66, 78, 67
  • Breakeven: 48

Another opportunity presents itself to get rid of Luke Dunstan. He has been poor SuperCoach wise for a little while now and with a bye this week, it is time to dump. His breakeven is still achievable, but I expect him to remain in that $320k-$330k bracket. Best to bank the cash and continue the upgrade.

Pearce Hanley (BRIS) DEF – $420,800 SC

  • Next 5 Games: BYE, CARL (H), WB (A), GWS (H), FRE (A)
  • Recent Scores: 35, 66, 90, 72
  • Breakeven: 87

Pearce has been a shadow of his former self this season, simply unable to get a solid run at it. Battling an injured hamstring, Pearce has struggled to get his season going since. Hanley’s numbers aren’t bad – 17 touches and 7 tackles against North Melbourne, along with 27 touches against Essendon, but he’s just not accumulating the scores. A bye this week may be what he needs to regenerate for the run home, but for those who own him, it’s probably for the best you move him on for a consistent scoring defender. Who knows, given him price and breakeven, if he strings a couple of solid performances together he may be a decent option. But for now, it’s time to say goodbye. To be sure….


Here the key break-even scores to keep in mind heading into round 10:


  • Joel Selwood (GEE) 92 BE
  • Corey Enright (GEE) 71 BE
  • Brent Harvey (NM) 58 BE
  • Dustin Martin (RICH) 55 BE
  • Chad Wingard (PORT) 72 BE
  • Matt Priddis (WCE) 96 BE
  • Tom Liberatore (WBD) 24 BE


  • Brett Deledio (RICH) 145 BE
  • Scott Pendlebury (COLL) 145 BE
  • Dayne Beans (COLL) 157 BE
  • Marc Murphy (CARL) 130 BE
  • Rory Sloane (ADEL) 124


Here are this week’s burning questions.

Image 1

ANSWER: Interesting question Wayno, but I just think given his form there really is no real need to dump Sandi. He is still pumping out 120+ scores and we don’t know how Mummy is going to go coming off an extended layoff. Also, given Freo’s form right now, I reckon they’d be silly to tempt fate and rest Sandi. He’ll play the year out. Hold.

Image 2

ANSWER: Yeah definitely worth dumping Acres. Extended break, plus St Kilda will probably run him through Sandy to get form back, he did have a very late start to the season. So best to cash in whatever you can of Acres and keep an eye on any rookie mids you can downgrade to.
Good luck this weekend community

Mr Crimmins.


Kick Back, Relax And Take In Supercoach Heaven:

PODCAST: One Bye To Go, Ripper!

Tight Arse Tuesday – Round 10

Round 10 Supercoach Scouting Report


Comments (170)

Trackback URL | Comments RSS Feed

  1. Legend123 says:

    Great article as always crimmo! now im in a delamar at the moment i have 12 trades left after this week and i have 1 rookie left on each position but none of my rookies are making any cash. I feel that I will run out of trades come round 16. Any advice. Cheers!

    • Andrew says:

      Who's your rookies?
      If they're new, then just hold the trades and wait for them to peak at their price. If you've got a team that good, you don't need to keep trading.

      • Legend123 says:

        Thanks mate. Probably half the rookies are new like acres and hartung but then im stuck with the duds like impey and georgio which probably end up on my bench. Great advice. The annoying thing is though im ranked 50,000. Cheers

        • Andrew says:

          That's harsh mate. Hartung seems like the one who will make you money quick, but the problem with him is that he was vested last game.
          I think with Acres and Gergiou, you'll just to wait for another mid/def rookie to come up.
          Thought about trading Impey to Cameron from the crows? You'd only make 27k but Cameron looks a better option then Impey.

          • Legend123 says:

            yeah i was thinking that but i still have kennedy harris and taylor as my other foward rookies and i can then go one to cameron and the other to wingard. Just my thoughts but i will probably take on your advice so i have warm bodies on my bench.

  2. Tom says:

    What should we do with Matt Wright?

    • BCHawks says:

      I am swinging him into my midfield this week and then next week I am going to trade him for Pendles.

  3. Patch says:

    Great write up Crimmo. Hadn't considered Gibson in the slightest.

    I continue to have the Dangerfield dilemma: is he worth paying 600'000k for, or will I get the same output cheaper from Selwood, hence saving myself the money now and getting Dangerfield later?

    • Matt says:

      Selwood is 80k cheaper and expect greater output from him for the rest of the year.

  4. crameri says:

    first lick my rim

  5. Andrew says:

    Seeing how Lloyd is out for Richmond (dropped). Is trading him out for Taylor Walker a good idea?

  6. Patrick says:

    hey guys need a sh*tload of help please, my side looks like this:
    B: Mcveigh, Hibberd, Birchall, Langdon, Langford, Suckling (Tippet, Georgiou)
    M: Gaz, Cotch, Dal Santo, Murphy, Beams, Goddard, Polec, Dunstan (Crouch, Lloyd)
    R: Sandi, Goldy (Dericks, King)
    F: Parker, Danger, Dusty, Dalhaus, S.Llyod, JKH (Ambrose, L. Taylor)

    Any and all advice would be greatly welcomed and appreciated!!!
    Cheers guys

    • BCHawks says:

      I would do JKH to Cameron and then Lloyd to Gray and then Dunstan if you have the cash or Polec to Selwood.

      • Patrick says:

        cheers BC, i can just afford to do that with 22k left in the bank.
        Was hoping to upgrade polec > pendles next week but i think my backline needs fixing up!!

        • Deano says:

          I think you backline needs some straightening up, i would look at Hanley next week for suckling and poled to pendles if you have the money

  7. Patrick says:

    Sorry i forgot, 388K and 16 trades !!

  8. Jimbo Jones says:

    Great write up! Any advice on a Boomer vs Dahl trade-in this week?

  9. Owen says:

    Goldstein is a little more than you have got written here Mr Crimmo, he's at 470.5K and not 445K, but still worth it I think.

  10. crabb says:

    I got Goldy in last week as I still had Hickey, and your writeup has given me a boost in confidence from confirming my judgement, thanks Crimmo.

  11. crabb says:

    Oh and, I have acres and Dunstan, given acres injury, would it be reasonable to trade him out this week instead, ad give luke one more week to appreciate?

    • wes says:

      IMO, and I am not crimmo, I like your idea on keeping dunstan 1 more week.
      he should hit target BE, and with it so low, risk of him falling under and dropping$$ is low also.
      depends on whether you want points now or not. he has the bye….

    • Dylan says:

      Dunstan's form isn't fantastic, but he hasn't scored under his BE. in saying that, he will probably only go up by about 10k, while at least Acres isn't going to lose anything. If dunstan's BE was higher I'd say axe him, but it really depends on your priorities. I'm going to axe dunstan next week, I'll sit on acres for a bit i think.

  12. john snow says:

    who is getting rid of these troubling rookies?
    – Lloyd
    – Acres
    – Robertson
    – Clurey

    All in my team and I have one trade left for the week. Are there any decent upgrades. Cameron looks good but not on the bubble and Lloyd still has money to make with a low BE.

    Maybe Acres for Hartung? Or possible shenton next week who is on the bubble after the bye

    • Gilly says:

      Hi John, I have Acres Lloyd and Robertson. At this stage want to move Robertson but unsure who too ( see below). Not sure Hartung is the answer I think he will be green vest material which will obviously limit his scoring ability. Maybe Lloyd to Shenton next week if Lloyd not named. I am going to take the punt on Cameron this week as i am heavy on rd 10 byes. Hopefully Morabito pops up soon. Good luck!

      • Dylan says:

        Robertson's BE is over 100, it's time to go! Lloyd still has cash to make, hopefully he can get back in to the tigers squad. Acrres at least isn't going to lose any money, same for clurey who appears to be unable to get a gig.

        Hartung will make you some money, even if he wears the kermit vest

  13. Gilly says:

    Great write up Crimmo, although I had been patting myself on my back for picking up Gibsons form (sigh) I guess I should have known better than to think I could outsmart the Supercoach community. What are people’s thoughts on Ryan Griffen? Have to consider at his price but not sure that he has shown me enough to suggest that he could avg 110 for the rest of the year.

  14. Mozz says:

    Is it worth holding onto Polec for one more week?

    • BCHawks says:

      He still has a makable break even and if you don't have pendles yet trading Polec next week for him would be a good option.

    • shallots says:

      Depends what your willing to risk. Polec could get 60 or get 120. Do you want dollars or points?

    • john snow says:

      He should make his BE and increase in value. I am holding for now.

  15. Rocksta says:

    Trade Pearce Hanley out?

    I’m goi g to trade him in next weeks after his bye

    • Shinboner says:

      Brought him in last week. With the numbers he's pulling up, he's bound to go massive any day now.

  16. shallots says:

    Great. Sam LLoyd is out. And another thing- Cripps will never play another game for Carlton while Malthouse is around!!!

  17. The_Darwin_Ducks says:

    I have both Sam Lloyd and Jay Kennedy Harris in my forward line, which one of the two should i get rid of for Charlie Cameron and is it a risky trade because Cameron isnt on the bubble yet?

    • john snow says:

      it is a risk if he doesn't get a game or breaks down we don't make any coin on him. I think I'll wait.

      • Sleepy says:

        Neither Lloyd or JKH playing this week so hold them. They wont lose any money and just see how Cameron goes and get him next week on the bubble.

  18. Danners16 says:

    Hey guys sorry I didn't let you know earlier, but you can fire away with your supercoach questions now! I will be online for about 30min depending on how many questions I get. So fire away with your supercoach questions!

    • The_Darwin_Ducks says:

      The above question…

      • Danners16 says:

        Not a risk, he seems an alright player. Sam Lloyd should be priority since he got dropped so trade him to Cameron, I will being doing that trade, JKH has the bye so you could trade him to C.Shenton next week.

    • Brandon2416 says:

      Hi Danners,
      My team is :
      Defender: Swallow, Simpson, Burgoyne, Bartel, Langdon, Enright(Geourgio, Gardiner.
      Midfield: Ablett, Pendles, Beams, Selwood, Mcveigh, Dal Santo, Murphy, Watson (Hartung, Robertson)
      Ruck: Jacobs, Sandi (Derickx, Currie)
      Forward: Dangerfield, Martin, Dalhaus, Wingard, Zorko, Taylor (Llyod, Ambrose)
      91k in the kitty and 14 trades after the 3 trades i did this week which were Higgins to Wingard, JKH to selwood(via taylor DPP) and crouch to hurtung.
      Just wondering if you had any advice about my team or the trades i made

      • Danners16 says:

        All good trades C.Wingard is a bit of risk but it can definitely pay off, other 2 trades are good. Your team looks really good, I like how you have J.McVeigh in the midfield for rotating into the back line.

    • Brandon2416 says:

      what trades do u suggest for next week??

      • Danners16 says:

        Good question, probably upgrade L.Taylor by downgrading either N.Robertson or S.Lloyd probably Lloyd to Cameron for cash then upgrade L.Taylor if you can

    • Michael says:

      Hey Danners, I'm stuck with the wrong Cameron (GCS) atm, was supposed to be right for this week but still saying injured. Thanks to Lloyd being out I now only have 15 confirmed starters this round with D Swallow also not in final 22 for the moment. Should I get rid of him even though only made about $50K? Bews really the only option to trade in, leaves me with about $50K in the bank.

      • Danners16 says:

        Don't get worried about D.Swallow, he has been in great form, the teams will change before the game with positions. J.Bews has kept his spot so Clay Cameron to Bews sounds good

    • Danners16 says:

      Alright guys that's all the time I have, I will probably be online again on Monday sometime, I will let you know when. Thanks

  19. Tom.H says:

    My current FWD line is:

    Danger, Parker, Zorko, Martin, JKH, Lloyd (Ambrose and Taylor)
    Who should I upgrade to? I have $130k to deal with. Want a keeper for the rest of the season

  20. The_Darwin_Ducks says:

    Wingard is cheap and reliable, i think he could start to put up some big scores in the near future
    If you can afford it then Gray is absolutely destroying it and very consistent
    otherwise the likes of Dalhaus is a very good option

  21. Matt says:

    Any trade ins for currie and lloyd? Need the extra numbers this week i have 60k left in the bank.

    • Matt says:

      I also need to move on Harry Cunningham to get 18 on the park this week. Any suggestions?

      • Michael says:

        Cunningham out Hartung in – leaves you with $225K in bank.
        Then Lloyd out Cameron in – leaves you with $324K in bank
        Then Currie out leaves you with $482K to spend on a host of good ruckmen:
        – Cox ($479K)
        – Goldy ($471K)
        – Warnock ($463K)
        – Lobbe ($430K)
        – Hampson ($404K)
        – HMac ($389K)
        who all average over 80.
        Depends who you want to risk and how much $$$ you want to save, rucks have been pretty average apart from Sandy & Sauce this year. You could even risk NicNat at $376K!

        Good luck!

        • Matt says:

          Thanks. Only concern is already have cox and sandilands r1 and r2 and only really needed to sideways trade currie as he hasnt played for a few weeks.

          • Michael says:

            Should've mentioned that, I assumed you wanted a premo ruck. No rookie ruck options that I know of, better off keeping Currie.

            • Matt says:

              Thanks I'll build the war chest this week and trade two of polec dunstan and tyson up next week.

          • Matt says:

            And not sure if worth having 3 premo ruckman

  22. Emmanuel says:

    Too much deadwood in the team.

    Who should I be looking to move on as a priority give that I can only make three trades.






    • Michael says:

      Acres – keep, hasn't made enough money yet.
      Dunstan – trade, has already reached ceiling
      Robertson – see Dunstan
      Zorko – forgive last start, dribbly arse, keeper
      Rioli – if you really need starting players then trade, but he's a premo so try & hold if you can.

      • Emmanuel says:

        Thanks for that. Thinking was definitely Dunstan and Roberston. Wasn’t sure about Rioli. If he’s back soon I would keep but don’t want that much cash on the bench with players like Gray and Boomer performing well

      • Emmanuel says:

        I heard Acres will be out for a while. Still keep?

  23. Josh says:

    I've got a large number of cows to offload and too many choices:
    My questions are:
    I've been sitting on Pyke for a while in the Ruck (looking for league wins and too many other things to do). Should I upgrade to Mumford or is he too risky?
    Alternative could be to get Jelwood in but probably can't do both.
    Team is:
    B: McVeigh Johnson Swallow Burgoyne Langdon Langford Georgiou Cutler
    M Ablett Pendlebury Beams Rockliff Liberatore Cotchin Polec Dunstan Roberston Acres
    R Sandilands Pyke Currie Thurlow
    F Dangerfield Martin Dahlhaus Higgins Wright JKH Lloyd Ambrose
    Thanks for any advice – particularly on whether to take Mummy.

    • Josh says:

      275K in the bank and 16 trades

    • Michael says:

      You've kept Pyke this long, may as well hold as he'll be back next week.
      Give Dunstan the flick straight to Jelwood, get rid of Robertson to Hartung.
      Then Georgiou to Bews.
      Will leave you with about $227K in the bank.

      • Josh says:

        Thanks. bews is an option I hadn't spotted.

        • Michael says:

          not on the bubble yet so slight risk, but is named this weekend so hopefully will have another good game and keep his spot for the bubble round and more.

  24. Dingo says:


    Should I get rid of Polec or Ellis for J Selwood
    Next Three Weeks:

    Port: Hawks, Melb, STK
    Rich: GWS, ESS, NTH

  25. Michael says:

    You've kept Pyke this long, may as well hold as he'll be back next week.
    Give Dunstan the flick straight to Jelwood, get rid of Robertson to Hartung.
    Then Georgiou to Bews.
    Will leave you with about $227K in the bank.

  26. Mozz says:

    Do people think that Pendles will reach his breakeven? (145)

    • Cam_H says:

      It's possible but not probable.

      He's averaged 110 against West Coast, and the last time he played West Coast on the MCG he got 111. He averages 111 on the MCG. He's exceeded 130 points only once this year.

      With that said, it's possible.

    • Nathan says:

      Yep, or very close to it. If u want to trade Pendles in u will just have to accept paying out big coin – I would not be banking on any major price drops. There are plenty of other cheaper options around at the moment though!

  27. henry says:

    aish to slone ranger.
    JKH to shenton.
    cutler to hurn.
    leaves me with 16 trades left 100k in the bank
    only have dunstan,higgins,lloyd to upgrade
    thoughts on keeping fasolo, langdon and tyson for the season?

    • Cam_H says:

      Aish to Sloane seems very good.

      JKH to Shenton won't get you far this week … maybe see what Charlie Cameron, Ben Lennon, or Tex Walker get up to. If you need to get rid of JHK this week because we're all heading back to two-trades-per-week territory and you've got a one-up one-down in mind, then 'yes' … seems like a safe move.

      Tom Cutler can still earn you $60,000 … and Hurn is risky. Your call on that one.

      Best of luck! :O)

      • henry says:

        thanks cam! just worrie because cutler is my d6 but i can wait a weeks i guess. As for the JHK next week i plan to downgrade sammy lloyd if not named for cameron and upgrading dunstan to any mid i like the fancy off seeing as i will have more then enough $$

        thanks again cam

        • Cam_H says:

          Believe me, I'm no expert like others here … just happy to offer my two cents and maybe it's of use, maybe not.

          If you're desperate to unload Cutler because of bye issues, Sam Docherty might be worth a thought.

          Your plan seems sound. I'm a bit worried that Charlie Cameron's a flash-in-the-pan … we'll see on Sunday.

          Again, best of luck with whatever trades you go with!

    • Nathan says:

      Where are u ranked? Or is leagues your strategy? I personally feel Higgins has more to offer, but everyone else on here seems to wanna trade him out ASAP. I’m not sure about Hurn, but I love PODs. I don’t think Fasolo and Langdon will keep scoring 100+ for the season. But you have plenty of trades to swap for a keeper when these two start slowing down (scoring)

      • henry says:

        ill take anybody words of wisdom cam! thanks mate

        nathan i am ranked 10,000 after a horrible start to the season only averaging low 2000's week 6 was the week for me scoring 2499 and being i think around the 200 in the world for the round and it has boosted my average and ranking up.
        so i am going for the league win, am in throttledomes league which is the most challenging ranking in the top 100 for the league average.
        will keep higgins and cutler for a few weeks to see how they go.
        as a saints supporter i think shenton will be able to keep his spot and generate money
        very unsure what to do with cutler as he is my d6 and i dont want to be keep getting 50 point scores!
        as you said ive got a few more trades then what i expected to have. so im allgood on that front just need to get to full premo!

  28. Rowdy says:

    thinking of trading in D Martin for JKH this week only 452k.what are peoples thoughts?

    • Michael says:

      yep good choice, won't be any cheaper this year.

    • Nathan says:

      meh. He is already in so many teams that I feel you gain nothing by trading him in now. I’d get more creative. But above all, go with you’re gut

  29. Paddy says:

    'm going to struggle to field 18 players this week, Lloyd is out who I have and this week I planned on getting Selwood.
    Also, my rucks have been Sandilands, Pyke, Derickx and King (been playing with Derickx the last few weeks).
    Mid rookies are: Tyson, Polec, Acres and Roberton

    I was thinking about getting rid of Pyke, but that would mean that the only way I can get Selwood is to trade Tyson for him. I would also have to take a punt and possibly get 2 rookies who have only played the 1 game (C.Cameron and Lennon).

    Which option is best.

    Option 1:
    JKH to Cameron
    Tyson to Selwood
    Pyke to Jacobs/McIntosh/NicNat (Nic Nat is a big risk, but is cheap and could give me a lot of money for next round)

    Option 2
    JKH to C.Cameron
    LLoyd to Lennon
    Robertson to Selwood

    Option 1 gives me Selwood and a good ruckman to replace Pyke, though may have to cash Tyson early and will be taking on 2 rookies with 1 game

    Option 2 gives me Selwood, but will still be stuck with Pyke but I will still have Tyson to grow some cash.

    • Nathan says:

      What is your strategy? Overall or leagues? You need to have the end game in sight as you may be slaughtering lambs too early (while burning trades) in a feeble attempt to get Selwood this week. Having said this, Selwoods price is a juicy as ever! So nobody can blame you for being desperate to get him in. I’m just saying in the bigger picture, is it crucial to your overall strategy? Maybe there are other options? A working in Crouchings gym I find helps clear the mind and see things form a new perspective

      • Paddy says:

        I still have trades left and have to get a premium in this round. Leaning towards option 2, as I wanna keep Tyson.
        It would just mean I take a big chance on taking Cameron and Lennon who are still 1 week early before being on the bubble.
        The other option to get Selwood would be:
        JKH to Cameron
        Acres to Hartung
        Robertson to Selwood

        and could see if Lloyd can come back in next week. If not, trade Lloyd out next week and upgrade Higgins.

        • Nathan says:

          I like your thinking. Your last option is sound all things considered. Just be mindful that flipper Robinson could make you another $100+ over the next 3/4 weeks if not too sub affected. But with his bye and Selwoods juicy price it’s fair to have Robinsons head on the chopping block

  30. Rowdy says:

    is Rioli worth keeping or should i trade?

    • Nathan says:

      Trade. He will just keep frustrating you.

      • Captain joc says:

        If you’ve kept him this long and are not in it for the 50k then you might aswell keep him have a look at the hawks injury list and see how much longer they think he could be out for

  31. Michael says:

    Option 2, as per other post considering getting rid of Pyke, he'll play next week post bye so hold. You'll make another $50K+ out of Tyson, could even be a keeper at M8. Kicking myself I didn't jump on him, my one big mistake this year so far.

    • shallots says:

      How is Tyson a keeper? Next week SJ will come in and i'll have 8 prem mids. I am wondering how anyone thinks Tyson is a keeper?

  32. The Ranger says:

    Webster and Dunstan are getting the flick this week.
    Pendles is coming in but what to do with the other spot?
    At the moment I'm torn between swinging Bartel to DEF and bringing in Hartung or swinging L.Taylor to the MID and grabbing Cameron….thoughts community?

    • Nathan says:

      Get Hartung. Don’t take the risk on players before they are on the bubble, a week is a long time in footy as they say!

      • The Ranger says:

        I hear what you're saying mate but at this stage of the game job security is a must for me and I'm thinking that Hartung won't be in the Hawks best 22 once they're all fit again whereas Cameron might just keep his place.

        • Nathan says:

          But remember what their primary role is, to make u quick coin so you can upgrade to a premo. With Hawks injuries Hartung found be around for a few more weeks yet. And I personally hate risking a trade on a player after one game. Injury, suspension and being dropped are all possibilities. So just know the risks and above all, go with your gut instincts

  33. Brandon2416 says:

    Hi community,
    My team is :
    Defender: Swallow, Simpson, Burgoyne, Bartel, Langdon, Enright(Geourgio, Gardiner.
    Midfield: Ablett, Pendles, Beams, Selwood, Mcveigh, Dal Santo, Murphy, Watson (Hartung, Robertson)
    Ruck: Jacobs, Sandi (Derickx, Currie)
    Forward: Dangerfield, Martin, Dalhaus, Wingard, Zorko, Taylor (Llyod, Ambrose)
    91k in the kitty and 14 trades after the 3 trades i did this week which were Higgins to Wingard, JKH to selwood(via taylor DPP) and crouch to hurtung.
    Just wondering if anyone had any advice about my team or the trades i made

    • Nathan says:

      Another one jumping off Higgins I see! I feel Higgins will avg 80+ over coming rounds and will make more $ yet. But I seem to be alone on this view around here. But Higgins to Wingard? Risky in my view. Could end up scoring the same. I’d like to see that if u are upgrading Higgins that it’s to a premo. Maybe u think Wingard will be this?? His change in role seems to be affecting his scoring. He is a jet, but Gray would be the one I’d be jumping on from Port as a forward premo lock

    • Brandon2416 says:

      i only have 470k to spend which forward do u suggest

      • Nathan says:

        You have a solid looking team. So why accept spending 470k on a premo lock forward if their are none about for that coin? With 14 trades you are bound to come across another $50-$100k over the coming weeks to afford u a Gray/Parker type player.

        • dognino says:

          +1 to this, so many people jumping on wingard. I've had him all season and wish I never picked him, he's dropped too much coin and doesn't really look like he will score any better in the second half of the year unless gray goes down with an injury . Hold Higgins until you get enough coin to go premium

      • Blueprime says:


  34. KadeKisajet says:

    How long is zorko out for?

  35. Peter says:

    jpk or fyfe?

  36. Danzo says:


    Have 70k and all 3 trades this weekend.

    B – Swallow, Hooker, Burgoyne, Langdon, Langford, Tippet (McVeigh, Gardiner)
    M – Ablett, Beams, Pendles, Fyfe, Selwood, Polec, Dunstan, Thomas, (Robertson, Michie)
    R – Jacobs, Sandy (Currie, Ceglar)
    F – Danger, Parker, Martin, Roughy, Loyd, Ambrose, (Higgins, Impey)

  37. aydan says:

    hartung or hallahan?

  38. Jim says:

    is currie to ceglar worth considering?

  39. James says:

    fyfe, selwood and kennedy. Which two should I pick?

    • Jim says:

      I'd prefer selwood, but kennedy sitting on a breakeven of 77 should be considered.

    • Nathan says:

      I assume money is no issue if u r looking at JPK? selwood is as cheap as he can get this week and will be heavily traded in to many teams. But if u have the $, JPK is gold !!!

      • Nathan says:

        And then Fyfe just slightly over selwood for mine. I have Selwood and JPK but would love to get Fyfe. I just can’t justify the $

    • Michael says:

      Get all 3 if you can, I just got Selwood this week to complete the trifecta.

      • Captain joc says:

        In terms of scoring if put then as:
        3.fyfe (although freo have a real easy next 6)
        In terms of value

  40. Trent says:

    So anyone getting Mumford back in. Or should I go goldy. I know his cheaper but mummy can produce some great scores.

    • Kris says:

      Im in the exact same boat. I need a ruck. But I do disagree with Crimms on Goldy. His last two games which he tonned it up in were against Gold Coast without Tom Nicholls and against a sick lions team going up against trent west. YET he only scored 101 on both. Bit underwhelming to say the least.
      Jacobs looks to be the only other decent ruck option. He doesn't rake in the hit outs but he makes up for it in disposals.
      Mumford, besides any lingering health issues that could affect his game, has only played vs Pyke (in the rain), Jake Spencer (in the rain) and Hickey. Caused Inflated scores? But his scores were that big its hard to ignore.

  41. Kristofor says:

    Jed Bews.
    What do you guys think of his job security? Will he get 4-5 games in?
    Considering these Trades this week.

    Hanley – Bews
    Robertson – Selwood
    Kennedy Harris – Cameron

    Leaves me $170k in the bank and 12 trades left.
    Full midfield, suckling as a D6 and needing 2 upgrades in forward line.

    I've had Hanley since the start.. hurts to have to let him go.. It's either him or Zorko… who has also been painful

    Would appreciate your thoughts and perspective on this 🙂

  42. Michael says:

    Trades I'm considering:

    ClCameron out, Bews in
    JKH out, ChCameron in
    Robertson out, Jelwood in

    Leaves me with $14K in the bank and the following team for this week:

    DEF: Swallow, Bartel, Langdon, Enright, Shoenmakers, Bews (McVeigh, Hibberd)
    MID: GAJ, Pendles, Beams, Jelwood, Murph, Polec, Hallahan (Fyfe. JPK, Acres)
    RUC: Jacobs (Sandy, Derickx, King)
    FWD: Danger, Dusty, Cameron (Pav, Zorko, Lloyd, Taylor, Ambrose)

    Gives me 17 on field unless fingers crossed Lloyd is brought in as emergency, in which case I'll have 18.
    Bad news is I only have 10 trades left.

    My other option was:

    Robertson out, Hartung in
    JKH out, Boomer in
    Leaving 11 trades.


  43. The Mullet says:

    OK…I need a sanity check here….am I crazy or not? My rucks are Sandi, Minson (Currie, King). I'm seriously thinking about upgrading Currie (155k) to Rowe (281k, played all games except Rd1 and appears to have bottomed out with good JS) PURELY as cover for Minson/Sandi in the last half of the season.

    • Michael says:

      Yes you're crazy, do not do this – waste of trade IMO. Get your Mids to full premo first, if R1 or 2 go down deal with it then, you'll have enough cash from them to pick the next best ruck in their place if it's season ending, or even cop the donut if it's only for a couple of weeks.

  44. TigerTuff says:

    Rockliff or Fyfe? Thoughts why.. Thanks!

  45. Josh says:

    Hi do u think I should do these trades
    Jed lamb to Wingard
    And jack billings to Sam Gibson I have 550k to get a mid

  46. Stumped says:

    what to do? ruck needs attention and i'm thinking naitanui based on what i can afford…as pyke is shite.
    Can't pass up the option of Jelwood this week either – maybe for dunstan.
    this leaves me enough to snare live wire C Cameron…

    I have $127k to play with pre trade. I have 14 trades left… 11 after this triple injection of supercoach bye pain.

    def- mcveigh, swallow, langdon, hanley, burgoyne, suckling, georgiou, webster
    mid- rockliff, beams, bartel,tyson, goddard, cotchin, m murphy, dunstan, hartung acres
    ruc- sandi, derrickx, pyke,currie
    fwd- danger, zorko,martin,dahlhaus,fasolo, lloyd, l taylor, ambrose

    thoughts welcome.. nay… NEEDED!!!!

  47. According to incomplete statistics on the global market, market demand is growing at 7% a year, which
    in China, a large market share, is the fastest growing
    demand country, also industry ‘s fastest growing
    country. So the patient can actually see and
    understand what they are looking at. This causes confusion as well as duplicitous expenditures.

  48. Yes! Finally something about weight loss patches.

    Visit my site … garcinia and green coffee

  49. Hi Dear, are you actually visiting this web
    page regularly, if so after that you will definitely get pleasant experience.

    Here is my blog – how to grow lashes

  50. You actually make it seem really easy with your presentation however
    I find this matter to be actually something that I believe I might by no means understand.
    It sort of feels too complex and very wide for me. I’m having a
    look forward on your subsequent post, I’ll attempt to get the cling of

    My homepage; best wrinkle serum

  51. I think everything typed made a lot of sense. However, think about this, what if you added a
    little content? I ain’t saying your content isn’t solid., however suppose you added a title
    that grabbed a person’s attention? I mean Flesh for Fantasy –
    Round 10, Bye 3 | Jock Reynolds is kinda plain. You ought to glance at Yahoo’s
    front page and watch how they create post titles to grab
    people to click. You might add a related video
    or a pic or two to get people interested about everything’ve got
    to say. In my opinion, it would make your posts a little livelier.

    For the best detailed explanation please view this amazing site:
    website design inspiration (http://digilancers.com/profile-11699/info/)

  52. When it comes to human beings also their noticeable appearance is
    very crucial for their position development in their career.
    Also, you might want to consider using original floss instead of mint kind.
    For some these techniques do not make much of a difference
    if the stain and discoloration is in too bad condition.

    My weblog … Teeth Whitening 4 You

  53. http://www.honestymed.com/produ.php?p=christian-l

    “But it’s a bunch of rules advisers and wannabe lawyers sitting around a room arguing over what they think’s going to make them more competitive.”.

  54. werndly.com says:

    Fantastic blog you have here but I was wnting to know if you knew of any user discussion forums that cover the same
    topics talked about here? I’d really love to be a part of online
    community where I can get comments from other knowledgeable individuals that
    share the same interest. If you have any suggestions, please
    let me know. Bless you!

    Feel free to surf to my web-site -smokeless
    cigarette brand review (werndly.com)

  55. Its like you read my thoughts! You seem to understand so
    much approximately this, like you wrote the ebook in it
    or something. I feel that you could do with some p.c.
    to power the message house a bit, however other than that,
    this is fantastic blog. An excellent read. I will certainly be back.

  56. gucci evenings handbags

    Hi there, I discovered your blog by way of Google while searching for a related subject,
    your site came up, it appears to be like great. I have bookmarked it in my google
    Hi there, simply turned into alert to your blog thru Google, and located that it is truly informative.
    I’m going to watch out for brussels. I will appreciate in the event you proceed
    this in future. Numerous other folks can be benefited out of your
    writing. Cheers!

  57. Asking questions are in fact good thing if you are not understanding something fully, except this post gives nice understanding even.

  58. It is not my first time to visit this web page, i am browsing this site dailly and
    take nice information from here every day.

  59. Servers IBM says:

    As an enthusiast of information technology invite any woman interested in IT
    at my blog. Receiving of feeling training describe
    I explore and I practice different type furniture – beginning by with
    mobile phones, on much HP servers, IMB or Cisco.
    Good relations with distributors accesses buy me to many
    equipment lot before the premiere.

  60. Oh my ցoodness! Incredible artіϲle dude! Thank you so much, However I am having troubles with your RSS.

    I don’t understɑnd the reason why I cannot subscribe to it.
    Is there anybody getting similar RSS problems? Anyone that knows the
    solution can you kindly respond? Thanx!!

    My page telecharger driver booster

  61. Appreciation to my father who shared with me on the topic
    of this weblog, this webpage is really remarkable.

    For a wonderful answer please check out this website – modular homes

  62. I’m pretty pleased to discover this page. I need to

    to thank you for your time for this particularly fantastic

    read!! I definitely loved every bit of it and i also have you saved

    as a favorite to look at new information in your website.

  63. Write more, thats all I have to say. Literally, it seems as though you relied on the video to make your point.
    You obviously know what youre talking about, why throw away your intelligence on just posting videos to your blog when you could be giving us something enlightening to read?

  64. When Andre began giving the money to the fans, Bobby Hennan grabbed the bag and took off.

    Something like, Edward looked my way and the soft topaz of his eyes captured my gaze.
    To use this to your advantage, wait until you have a good amount of customers in your store (even better if they come in as

  65. Melanie says:

    Finally, even thousands of people to loose countless millions of dollars; noot to indulge in spending a small sum left over.
    If you wamt the person has to be taken not to drop itt on the watch meanms to you and bwck to
    your mind. Earlpy onn it you should you look for new
    watch repair watch bands for sale. Most will even guarantee their work if you are not just writing papers,
    we’re in there!

  66. Thanks to my father who shared with me about this webpage, this blog is really remarkable.

  67. I really like your blog.. very nice colors & theme. Did you design this website yourself
    or did you hire someone to do it for you? Plz respond as I’m looking
    to construct my own blog and would like to find out where u got
    this from. thanks a lot

    For the best detailed explanation please jump over to this page:
    sleeping tube

  68. I’ve been exploring for a bit for any high quality articles or blog posts on this kind of house .
    Exploring in Yahoo I eventually stumbled upon this web site.
    Reading this information So i’m glad to show that I have an incredibly good
    uncanny feeling I found out exactly what I needed.
    I most for sure will make certain to don?t overlook this site and give it a look regularly.

    For a better answer please click the link to this blog
    :: salman Khan body building

  69. Pull the lever to bring back the torture device and run inside to the right and flip the lever then hurry to the gate to open it.
    After walking across those long chains again do some more wall hanging and make your way inside to the fountain. It does require timing, and not all spells can be absorbed by the shield.

  70. Unbelievably user pleasant site. Great info available on couple of clicks.

  71. edemhotel says:

    Eine unvergessliche Erholung zu den besten Preisen!!!Die Unterkunft EDEM Hotel befindet sich in Utjeha, 40 km von Budva und 49 km von Podgorica entfernt. Das Hotel verfügt über einen Außenpool und Aussicht auf das Meer und Sie können das Restaurant oder die Bar besuchen. Gebührenfreie Privatparkplätze sind an der Unterkunft vorhanden. http://edemhotel.me/ http://www.edemhotel.com/