add_filter('comment_flood_filter', '__return_false');

POLL: Vlastuin & Goodes – hang onto them?

Published by Jock on

3 burning Supercoach Dt questions.Plenty around the community are having a real good hard look at their backlines this week – some are looking to bring in a new premium.

There’s a bloody interesting question to be asked here, especially considering the plight of new kids on the block Brett Goodes and Nick Vlastuin.

At the beginning of the season there weren’t many of us who would have swallowed the slightest mention that one of these blokes could be considered as keepers for the whole season. Both have provided gallant service down back, been a bit up and down, but overall have done everything you could have asked of a rookie and more.

But defense has been a BASTARD this season, and besides Goddard, Gibbs, Shaw and Heppell there have been no blokes put their hand up as genuine solid as a rock solid tried and true back options. Seems as soon as one bobs up, he’s tagged to buggery.

Begs the question community.. in light of the inconsistency this year down back.. could it be the way to go to just keep on keeping on with Vlastuin and Goodes until someone puts their hand up with conviction?

And another question many are grappling with… if you have both and want to move one on, which one do you choose?

Who would you prefer as an on field defender?

View Results

Loading ... Loading ...

Subscribe
Notify of
guest
134 Comments
Oldest
Newest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Wayne

Should I go Terlich and Pittard >> Cotchin and Lach Hunter? This means I wont be able to get in Pendlebury as my midfield would be complete.

@TG_Footy_Tragic

I'd get Pendles in over Cotch, but not at a detriment to my team… Go with your gut mate

Remy

Are these good trades?
Vlastuin~Carlisle
A. Black~Roughy
I wanted a POD and I see Carlisle as one, all AUS form I reckon.

Josh

If you want a POD and you are limited on cash i would try hombsch or even brent reilly. Yes Carlisle is in All Australian form but he isn't exactly that good at supercoach. If you do have more money try a mckenzie or malceski for POD's

Josh

Also maybe heath scotland if you want consistency

micki S

good trade

Milos

I would like to notify everyone that Birchall is out for 4-6 weeks with a PCL injury

@TG_Footy_Tragic

Neither for me, I have Hanley, Birch, Shaw, Gibbs, Duff & Goodes… Goodes goes this week to Goddard.
I was "set" but I can't keep Goodes as my D6…

Steve

birchall gone. 4-6 weeks

Samuel

Mr. Crimmins please help me sir.

This is my team (almost finished it)

DEF: Goddard, Hartlett, Heppell, Birchall, Goodes, Vlastuin (Thurlow, Webster)
MID: Ablett, Pendelbury, Swan, Watson, Barlow, Priddis, JPK, T.Mitchell, (B.Hill, Kommer)
RUC: Cox, Pyke (Nicholls, Currie)
FWD: Naitanui, Bartel, Martin, N.Riewoldt, J "Twinkle Toes" Kennedy, Rockliff, (Staker, Daniher)

I wanna make two more trades and then that's it my team is finalised. Who do u think needs to go im leaning towards either vlastuin or rockliff or do you have any other suggestions? what should i do?

Redfin

Barlow is injured for 3-5 weeks, so trade him out. I would go for C.Ward due to the Giants’ easy run home, or maybe C.Sylvia? Up to you but get rid of Barlow

FrontPocket

Freo are saying he's still a chance to play this week, so I doubt it'll be 3-5 weeks out.

There are plenty of premiums in front of Ward and Sylvia. N. Fyfe, T. Cotchin, B. Deledio, P. Dangerfield.

footyinme

Yeah found out Barlow had minor surgery to his face at most a week off so hold hold hold no silly sideways crap

chandanrajdb

OUT: Vlastuin & B Hill / N Kommer
IN: B Gibbs & L Hunter (Buldogs team, has played only one game though)

And in the coming weeks upgrade on of the midfield rookie to a premium for M8 Position…..

Cheers,
Raj……

Maxy

1 slip up, a tad reactionary. Keeping Goodes and Vlaustin for another week. Hanley and Birchall haven't fired either but you wouldn't sack them just yet. Trades too valuable at this stage.

Azza

But Birch is out for 4-6. Gotta go.

vinny mac

OUT: Vlastuin
IN: Heppell.
Terlich and Goodes are the only rookies I have on field. In the next 3 rounds if the popular DEF options are too inconsistent I feel I may need to bring in a lower-scoring but consistent DEF, e.g. Enright and Scotland.

THESALTSHAKERS

Did the Terlich to Birch last week worked for me, this week not so much was bleeding actually.

I traded out Houli before round 3 has smashed it since….and I've been missing that D4 since.

Backs: Goddard, Gibbs, Birchall, Shaw, Ellis, Goodes — Lester, Thurlow

Mid: Ablett, Pendles, Swan, JPK, Selwood, Priddis, Wingard, T.Mitchell — Mayes, Hrovat

Rucks: Minson, Goldstein — Nicholls, Rowe

Fwds: Cox, Bartel, J.Kennedy, Franklin, Rockliff, S.Johnson — Macaffer, Staker

Ranked 905th

Proj 2457 (wouldn't that be nice)
$84,000 cash

What should my next move be? 8 trades left. Daniher presents the best option this week so Caff > Daniher for $200k and then potentially upgrading my backline but who to get? I'm thinking Lester > Hanley this week but then again he's a bit of a rollercoaster…but who isn't in the backline that I haven't already got? Ive looked at Ibbotson, Heppel, Hibberd, and the one who looks the best is Houli but Ive already traded him out…..I'm stubborn….I can't?

Massive dilemna what to do with this trade as only 6 trades left for injuries

Any idea's?

chandanrajdb

OUT: MaCaffer & Lester
IN: Daniher & Heppell

Cheers,
Raj…..

Westy

Ibbotson!

micki S

Birchall has recently got injured (out for 4-6 weeks).

Luke

Hoping for a bit of guidance from the community here, Team is:
DEF: Goddard, Hanley, Hartlett, Heppell, Gibbs, Goodes, (Terlich, J. Clarke)
MID: Pendelbury, Watson, Kennedy, Priddis, Cotchin, Mundy, Fyfe, T.Mitchell, (K.Martin, Hrovat)
RUC: Cox, Kreuzer (Nicholls, Currie)
FWD: Bartel, Kennedy, Rockliff, Franklin, S.Johnson, Staker (Rowe, Daniher)

Ive got 581,000 in the bank – What should be priority

THESALTSHAKERS

Upgrade staker to Andrew Walker (Carl) or Nic Natanui

dooly

you have to get ablett in as soon as possible

FrontPocket

Make this #1 priority. I tried going without Ablett early, and it's taken me until this round to work him in.

As Jock and the boys have said and written in numerous places:
Select Ablett 1st, then build the rest of the team around him.

I'll be taking this advice next year fo' sho'

Mungo Man

walker for terlich (move staker back), and roughead for rowe. trade for gary ablett when t mitchell fires and goes 400k plus.

Dolls_87

Well structured team, but like the others said, get Ablett.

Smittzzy

Goodes > Shaw
Vlastuin > Ibottson

Seems to me like a good trade what do you think community? can we go better? don't trust Duffield, Waters or Hanley

chandanrajdb

1st Trade looks really good……

But not so sure on Ibbotson……as yet….I know he is smashing the scores ATM…..not a proven Premo IMO…..If your gut feel says he will be good for the rest of the season then do it mate……

Cheers,
Raj….

Remy

Hello community I really need some advice, I'm looking at trading out Vlastuin and A. Black this week, I really, REALLY need help deciding who to trade in for them….
Vlastuin to……
Black to……
Please help, I have (If I trade out Vlastuin) 537,000 to spend on a defender and for Black I have 540,000 to spend on a forward.
Your thoughts would be much appreciated:)

chandanrajdb

OUT: Vlastuin & A Black

IN: B Gibbs & D Martin……

Cheers.
Raj…

Jay

Good Choices…..like Gibbs and Dusty!!
Could look at Shaw in DEF as well, if you have Gibbs in the team already – I think those 2 are most trusted instead of likes of Hanley, Duffield, Waters, Ibbotson, Hombsch, Mckenzie etc..

Dabman

Why would you not include Terlich in this list also? Ave 83 last 3……. compared to goodes 75 & vlasty 63. He has potential to score 100+ also.

@WattZ_TheCouch

Potentially yes, more a consistent 70-80, a lot more consistent then vlastuin for sure. His scores might drop though as Melbourne have a easier second half. Less time in defense and thus less rebounding. But it could go the other way as well I guess.

Personally I'd keep Goodes, consistency is key and I hate 30's.

Jay

Goodes seems to be producing more consistent scores – hasn't gone big like Vlastuin did with a 140 and 130 but hasn't gone too low either, so as a D6 – I'm choosing Goodes and Vlastuin is out for H. Shaw

Homeless Heroes

Team is set, just having a little dilemma.

D: Goddard, Heppell, Birchall, Shaw, Gibbs, Goodes (Clarke, Staker)

M: Ablett, Pendlebury, Dangerfield, Selwood, Cotchin, Hannebery, Priddis, Fyfe (MItchell, Martin)

R: Maric, Natinui (Nicholls, Currie)

F: Martin, Roughead, J.Kennedy, Frankiln, Rockliff, Stevie J (Daniher, Lee)

Enough in the bank to trade Goodes to the Duff Man but only 5 trades in the bank? Feel trades are more important than the upgrade at this stage? Thoughts?

@WattZ_TheCouch

I'd stay your hand. 5 trades, considering you want 3-4 for finals you still have 6 weeks (I think lol) for injuries, and as past seasons show players get tired bodies in the second half of the year.

vinny mac

Leave your 5 trades for injuries in the later rounds.

Dolls_87

Hold fire Heroes, beware the long term injury.. and you'll need your trades come finals.

Favalinko

Make that 4 trades Birchall out for 4-6 weeks

Boozer

I still have 13 trades and I was getting worried… Good luck in the finals dude

Max

And a top of the Monday to you all fellow Jock Reynolds punters. Having been a part of this community and giving feedback where necessary, I keenly seek your advice on my fair old team. Be brutal 'cos that's the only way I'll get better!

DEF: goddard, hanley, birchall, gibbs, goodes, pittard (thurlow,webster)
MID: ablett, swan, watson, barlow, kennedy, deledio, selwood, hodge (hill, t mitchell)
RUC: cox, roughead (rowe, nicholls)
FWD: bartel, martin, kennedy, rockliff, naitanui, staker (daniher, lee)

Simon

Barlow may have a cloud over him…

Dolls_87

Seriously have to consider Pittard's value in your team at this stage of the game.

Jason

Speaking of getting rid of players, are there any good downgrade options this round, apart from Daniher?

I'm trading out Maccaffer for him, but I'm tempted to just wait until guys like Mitchell, Nichols, Terlich and Staker plateau before slaughtering any more cash cows.

The plan is then to make one or two big downgrades before bringing in a couple of final premiums. Another option is to get rid of Zorko or even a Shuey over the next couple of weeks.

FrontPocket

I'm tempted to oust Zorko as well, I just don't have the trades up my sleeve to do it. If you've got enough trades to go from now through finals then I'd thumbs up getting rid of Zorko, but otherwise, stick fat.

The generally agreed strategies are such that we should have a full premium team (22, on the park) going into the next round, so we should be able to sit on whatever remaining trades we have unless we really need them.

chandanrajdb

Agreed with respect to Zorko mate……I am in the same boat……and getting really frustrated with ZORKO the DUD……and I am very thin on trades left so I will have to stick fat with him ATM…..

Cheers,
Raj….

Eugene

Vlastuin has to go for me coz his B/E is too high now.
However I'm not upgrading him to another defender coz they all suck and I already have Gibbs/Goddard/Heppell/Shaw.
Will swing Staker back and get myself Nic Nat!

Tim

trades for this week
vlastuin=> Lachie hunter
Macaffer (switch with staker) => Shaw

FrontPocket

I traded out Vlastuin over Goodes. A bit of a coin-toss. Vlastuin gave me an extra $5k to play with. Goodes is still on the field in my backline (he'll be bench cover come finals time, barring other injuries) but I reckon he'll play out the year more consistently than Vlastuin since he's a mature-age recruit, plus he's got the kind of heritage that makes you confident of his putting in every week.

Vlastuin has had some tasty scores early in his career though.

jonathan

My backline is as follows Goddard, Heppel, Gibbs and Birchall – I need advice from the community – Should I keep Charlie the Dixon and trade out justin clarke or do the trade and trade clarke out next week – i have webster and Frosty on the bench with $474,400 to spend.

chandanrajdb

If Charlie Dixon isn't playing this week then you got to get rid of him…….no point having that much of cash sitting on the bench doing nothing….

OUT: Dixon & Clarke
IN: Shaw & Trent MaCkenzie (GCS) as mentioned in this weeks podcast by higgo….or any premo of your like……..

Cheers,
Raj….

jonathan

I looked into that mate and I was short by $2000 getting mackenzie next week, but if dixons in im keeping him in

jonathan

The trade im doing is bringing Shaw in.

Danny

is it worth upgrading Mundy to Selwood or Watson…
Selwood one trade
Watson two trades
7 trades left prior to the trade

Midfield – Ablett, Swan, Pendilbury, J Kennedy, Priddis, Mundy, Dangerfield, Fyfe (Mitchell, Horvatt)
I still have to upgrade Lester in defence and Jacobs in the ruck but only have 6K in the chest?

dustin

Dont worry about sideways trading mundy at the moment, worry about that in the finals. at the moment you should focus on upgrading rookies.

Jack

My back line is:
Goddard, Gibbs, Hartlett, Shaw, Birchall, Goodes (Vlastuin, Thurlow)
With an aim of getting Hanley in a couple of weeks for Thurlow, should I go Hartlett to Heppel? Or with only 8 trades stick with Hartlett?

dustin

If you still have other rookies to upgrade then i suggest you focus on them first, leave the side trading till later in the season or finals time therefore you wont regret it

rob

griffen or barlow?

dustin

Barlow at this stage, Griffen is just too damn expensive at 660k so you could wait for him to go down like i am

Scott

melbourne and GWS in next two weeks…. averaging 130 against top 8 sides…next best is GAJ on 132…. tough not to consider Griffen

dustin

Surely Bachar Houli is now a must in the D6 and could be the last piece to the defense puzzle because Hanley/Duffield are too inconsistent. What do you guys think?

footyinme

Agree I am even considering him along with Murphy but don't know?

matt

Hey guys this is my team thus far, only 128k in the bank and 10 trades left. Any advice would be greatly appreciated, really stuck on what to do this round ;/

Defence:
Shaw, Goddard, Ellis, birchall, goodes, vlastuin EMG: terlich, thurlow

Midfield:
Ablett, Watson, dangerfield, deledio, shuey, priddis, omeara, Tom Mitchell EMG: viney, crouch

Rucks:
Minson, natanui EMG: daw, nicholls

Forwards: bartel, cox, rockliff, socko, franklin, Harvey EMG: staker, daniher

Only 128k in the bank and 10 trades left. Any advice would be greatly appreciated

throttlefinger

Cash in for Vlastuin, for sure. Houli is playing very strong. Maybe spend a little more and upgrade to Gibbs.

Dolls_87

I wouldn't be comfortable playing both O'Meara & Mitchell in the mid, your priority should be there.

Er, Significant Jock

I would go Daw > McBean. This gives you RUC/FWD swing to use with Cox, and an extra $155k in the bank.

Then consider your other trade up options.

matt

thanks for the help guys

Riley

Birchall out for 4-6 weeks knee injury

Sleepy

Hey Jock, think there are a few other good reliable backmen. Ibbotson and Mckenzie although not household names are at least playing consistent footy. Averaging 103 and 97 respectively. Also old timers (mister consistents and hardly ever injured) Enright 90 and Murphy 94 are plugging along pretty OK. Houli up there on 96. Malceski on 93.

Josh

I agree sleepy, another good defender is Michael Hibberd, he has a high break even of 129 so he should drop down to around 470,000 next week making him a good pickup, he has only two scores under 85 and he is not likely to get the odd 30-60 points like some of the other high priced defenders.

cam

have staker in the forward and have enough cash to trade to anyone. who are the best options?

jack

franklin, stevie j , natanui, bartel, rockliff, cloke, stokes, cox, martin, walker, riewoldt.

footyinme

Bang for ya buck Stokes and Franklin

cam

thanks

Jonas

Thoughts on my team, who to trade and who to get in?

Def: Goddard, Hanley, duffield, birchall, Gibbs, staker. Emg. Thurlow, colquhon
Mid: ablett, pendles, Watson, swan, Selwood, swallow, hanneberry, pridis. Emg. Mitchell, Martin
Ruck: cox, Jacobs, Nichols,currie
Fwd: walker,Martin, Kennedy, Franklin, cloke, rockliff. Emg. Daniher, lee

7 trades left, 94k in the kitty.

What moves old you make?

brianp

jacobs out probably, but you've stuck with him for this long, so i guess hold

Davo09

Hi guys,

Suggestions on inclusions / trade outs on my team?

Def: Goodard, Heppell, Birchall, H Shaw, Gibbs, Goodes (Vlastuin, Sierakowski)

Mid: Ablett, Swan, Cotchin, Barlow, Fyfe, J Kennedy, Priddis, T Mitchell (Hrovat, Kent)

Rucks: Cox, Kreuzer (Nicholls, Currie)

Forwards: Franklin, Cloke, Rockliff, S Johnson, J Kennedy, LeCras (Staker, T Lee)

11 trades remaining and $275K

Thinking about trading out LeCras for Nic Nat or Roughy? Also, thinking about brining in another premium into my midfield.

Rick Grimes

Nice looking team. LeCras would be the first out for mine. Couldn't go wrong with Roughy or NicNat. Though I really like Bartel – super consistent. If Vlastuin is going to sit on your bench, you could consider downgrading him now and then look to upgrade Mitchell in a few weeks time.

Riley

Brichall out for 4-6 weeks knee injury

brad

i've got drew petrie in my team, and his BE is near on 200 hundered this week. thus he will start leaking serious cash.
for a premium keeper i can ride the rollercoaster of the ups and downs, but is petrie a premium keeper???? dont know whether to take the cash and spend it on a better forward option. ( i have nicnat, bartel, buddy, petrie, monfries, staker, b kennedy, rowe)

Davo09

Hi guys,

Suggestions on inclusions / trade outs on my team?

Def: Goodard, Heppell, Birchall, H Shaw, Gibbs, Goodes (Vlastuin, Sierakowski)

Mid: Ablett, Swan, Cotchin, Barlow, Fyfe, J Kennedy, Priddis, T Mitchell (Hrovat, Kent)

Rucks: Cox, Kreuzer (Nicholls, Currie)

Forwards: Franklin, Cloke, Rockliff, S Johnson, J Kennedy, LeCras (Staker, T Lee)

11 trades remaining and $275K

Thinking about trading out LeCras for Nic Nat or Roughy? Also, tossing up bringing another premium into my midfield.

Balls

Trade out Vlast , sub Staker, trade in Nic Nat or Roughie.
Kills 2 birds with one stone.

alex

what to do over the next couple of weeks?

def: goddard,heppell,shaw,hanley,gibbs,goodes (thurlow,frost)
mid:ablett,pedlebury,watson, dangerfield,kennedy,barlow,mundy,priddis (T.mitchell,hrovat)
ruc: natanui,jacobs (nicholls,currie)
fwd: roughead,cox,franklin,zorko,lecras,staker (daniher, B.kennedy)

9 trades left, roughly 100k

alex

8 trades***

footyinme

You need bench cover down back get West coast rookie defender B.Wilson in for Thurlow that should add another 90k. That's all I would do this week.

So then I would say your DEF is complete, a lot of people finishing their DEF 6
with either Vlastuin or Goodes.
Your MID looks awesome, complete.
Hold Jacobs in the RUCK until you reach finals – that way you my see him improve?
Trade out Staker next round he will be worth around 280k – 285k by then plus the 190k in the bank should total 470k. Trade him for a premium FWD next week e.g. Stokes or JJK Twinkle Toes.

alex

i already traded vlastuin to shaw, and maccaffer to daniher this week, so hopefully there are some rookies on the bubble in the coming weeks in which i can downgrade thurlow, staker and B.kennedy

Riley

What about Cyril coming back this week v lions could be a good pick averaging 111 good pick say about 1-2 weeks away could be the difference between winning or losing . My trades are Seedsman out …….
N.Vlaustin out Goddard In

Need help with Mid can afford any one up to $ 568,500 Jock ??? Anyone

Zimmer

Would steer clear of Rioli. Great player, but is up and down and often injured. Too big a risk.

Jay

Quite a few choices: Fyfe, Watson, JP Kennedy, Deledio, Cotchin, J. Selwood, S. Selwood…..or if you want a PoD, you could consider someone like Montagna (Ave 111) or a Douglas (Av 107) – or if you can muster up another 10k, I'd go for Dane Swan…

Josh

scott selwood out for up to a month but all the other options asre good

Dylan

What to do with 9 Trades

DEF:B.Goddard, D.Heppell, P.Hanley, N.Vlastuin, B.Goodes, D.Terlich (Stevenson & Thurlow)

MID: G.Ablett, S.Pendlebury, JP Kennedy, B.Deleidio, J.Selwood, N.Fyfe, D.Mundy, T.Mitchell (Viney & Crouch

RUCKS: D.Cox, J.Roughead (Nicholls & Rowe)

FWDS: JJ.Kennedy, N.Natinui, L.Franklin, D.Martin, A.Walker, B.Staker (Daniher & Neade

liam

good midfield but Mundy out this round. i think your backline is the biggest problem area. Goodes out this round and vlastuin about to bleed money like a stuck pig. bring in gibbs or similar premium in defence not sure what terlich is worth but maybe downgrade him or vlastuin and upgrade the other?

Dylan

And $17,500*

raymond hill

is luke breust a value for money pick up or not

Jack

At this stage, you should be looking to fill your team with proven premiums, not mid price bargains. While Breust is $57,900 than he was at the start of the year, I would not consider bringing him in, due to his inability to consistently score high. He has a low score of 42, and only a high score of 116.

JD_Cereal

I've got B. Goodes, Jack Steven and Zorko, all boys that could be upgraded to score me a bit higher. I've got $40,600 in the bank and 5 trades left. What to do?

vinny mac

save the trades for finals. but if you must, grab an ultra premium.

SCL

ok guys, need your opinion, I have the option of a combination of

ROUGHEAD & HANLEY or

N.RIEWOLDT/D.MARTIN & MICHAEL JOHNSON/HANLEY

which do you think is the best in terms of consistency?

micki S

Roughy and Hanley

footyinme

Riewoldt and Martin

SCL

a forward out of Riewoldt & Martin and a defender out of M.Johnson & Hanley

footyinme

Sorry mate
Martin and Hanley

Wait 1 more week on Hanley though

SCL

interesting, so you would take martin over roughhead?

hmmm

micki S

If you wanna see my Supercoach team. My team name is Turn It UP (Michael). Approximate ranking of 109,000th

footyinme

Can't believe it Birchall out 4-6 weeks after getting him for Dixon rd 11
Back lines a bitch this year.

SCaddict

Yes folks we now have the undisputed front runner for BotY (Burnman of the Year) honours!

Surely it's going to take quite an effort to top this so reckon Crouching can start preparing his Youtube video now!

cal

as my main man Brian Taylor would say. BOY OH BOY!! grant birchall out for 4-6 weeks with a torn PCL!! who would be a good person to replace him with 510K?

The questions I want to ask.
is it worth having heath shaw despite also having cloke, swan and pendlebury?
is blayne Wilson's job security good?
any defender rookies out there?
who else is a good premium defender? heppell (already have goddard and Watson)

Favalinko

HOULI

Dan

shaw or gibbs?

Scott

gibbs is lower in price and dual position, although shaw is doing great recently.

if you dont care about cost then go shaw, but with murphy out gibbs could get more midfield time.

Dan

hombsch or hartlett?

dannyboy

i was going to trade mcaffer to daniher and vlausten to shaw this week. made my mind up on sun night. now birchall (bloody BURN MAN) goes down from 4-6 and now i dont know what to do. im thinkin birch to hanley and vlausten to hibberd. but i really want to get shaw. do u guys think they are good trades or should i do my first option, bench birchall for a week and get hanley (or gibbs) next week. i was plannin to go omera to watson next week, boy birchall has really done a number on a lot of coaches this year. i bought him when he was at $560k which just makes it more painful. he is NEVER going into my sc team ever again.

Dave2008

Yep Birchall has been my burn man too had him from the start. I am thinking him to Shaw and then Vlastutin to Ibbotson but don’t quite have the money. Looking ok for top 4 only in running for league with 11 trades left it would be better to finish defence with as few trades as possible. So question is is H shaw a must have? Ibbotson/any other def under 548 100 or H Shaw and any other def under 486 600. Then Stevie J and another def before finals or keep Goodes as D6?

Backs: Goddard Gibbs Heppel Goodes Terlich Vlastutin Therlow

Mids: Ablett Pendlebury Kennedy Dangerfield Watson Fyfe Bsrlow Priddis Mitchell Saunders

Rucks: Jacobs Natanui Rowe Nicholls

Forwards: Cox Rockcliff Franklin Martin Kennedy McCaffer Staker Kennedy

218k in the bank

Any thoughts greatly appreciated

Birch's Buddy

If you can somehow create an extra $800, I'd go with Heath Shaw and Bachar Houli. If not, at 480k Malceski has been impressive in recent weeks.

Dave2008

Very good option you suggest in Houli but can’t find the extra 800. I don’t think he’s worth an extra downgrade trade to get him though so its either just the one trade Birchall – Shaw and either Vlad to Hibberd/eski/ or downgrade to Wilson/clisby then next week Terlich to Ibottson. Problem is at this time of year I don’t want to have to downgrade again in the backs as Thurlow looks like a white elephant so unless Goodes is d7 I need 3 more premium backs in total and one forward (Stevie j) so 4 upgrades needing up to 6/7 trades leaves only 4 for finals when usually I go in with 6. So I need to pick the bargain. If only Shaw wasn’t the expensive standout back I don’t have…hmmmm

Scott

Jobe or Swan?

Feel like with all this talk about Watson and drugs he might not play in near future or his form could be affected. I already have Pendlebury and sometimes i feel swan is inconsistent. i would keep the player for the rest of the year. Thoughts?

thanks

Rick Grimes

Swan is very solid. Had him from the start and cannot recall him letting me down. I don't have Pendles yet, but I'm very tempted by Griffen. If things go my way over the next couple of weeks, I should be able to get both, giving me a mid of Ablett, Kennedy, Bartel, Swan, Pendles, Griffen, Barlow. BOOM!

Dylan

Who do I get in for Birchall with just 430,000

jimmy

scotland, hombsch or hartlett if you want to take a risk

Smittzzy

Even ibootson mate, give him a look. good run home for a sweeping defender

T-Bone

I have $831,700 to spend on 2 Backman look at either-
H, Scotland and H, Hartlett — left $ 6,200
H, Scotland and D,Pearce — left $ 35,600
B, Godard and D, Glass — left $ 11,400

I also have steaker in my forward line so i could swing him back to buy a forward
H, Scotland and J, Riewoldt — left $ 17,700
B, Godard and J,King — left $ 4,800
H, Scotland and J, Garlett — left $ 15,400
A, Christen and H, Scotland — left $ 1,700
Not look for a major forward my back line needs more help
Open to any ideas?!?!

Stis

Don't forget about HIBBERD! I've had him since the start of the year and has been my best pick for 2013……best part is no1 else has him and he gets 95+ every week! Unlike birchall and hartlett who cause me heart problems every week!

torza

same here champ

doggies14

Looking to trade out Goodes,Clarke and Staker. Any help with who i should get. I'm planning on getting premium defender and Nick Riewoldt up forward. I have $170,000 left.

B.Goddard,D.Heppell,P.DuffieldH.Shaw, B.Gibbs, B.Goodes (J.Clarke,T.Smith)

D.Swan,J.Watson,P.Dangerfield,B.Deledio,J.Selwood,L.Ball,T.Mitchell,G.Ablett (K.Martin,N.Hrovat)

W.Minson, D.Cox (T.NIcholls,D.Currie)

A.Walker,J.Bartel,D.Martin,J.Kennedy,L.Franklin,B.Staker (S.Rowe,T.Lee)

liam

get rid of rowe instead of staker and consider bringing in in roughhead instead of riewoldt.