add_filter('comment_flood_filter', '__return_false');

Jock Reynolds Fantasy Footy Podcast – pre round 7

Published by Jock on

Jock Reynolds Father of Fantasy podcastIs DANGER on your Supercoach or Dreamteam menu this week? Or Daisy Thomas? The time has come to make the most of premiums who have dipped in price as their form turns around.

As per usual we look at all the best trade in options – but also players who are causing the community some pain. Sam Jacobs.. should we keep him? Is Kane Mitchell again a relevant midfield rookie? When should I take my cash cow to the slaughterhouse? Who has the easiest run over the next four weeks or so?

Settle into a comfortable chair, get your pen and paper ready, and let’s rip right into it!

Enjoy the show folks!

 


Subscribe
Notify of
guest
305 Comments
Oldest
Newest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Gillie4

Fantastic Jock!! Waited all weekend for this!

bob

hayden crozier?

Adrian

I want to downgrade Neade/Dwyer to free up some cash so who would be the best person to downgrade to?

@MRB37

How much cash? Brent Staker for 128K could get a game this week. Was looking like a solid choice in the pre-season. Also have Sam Kerridge if you only need to make 100K or so. Not sure on Ben Kennedy's JS, so i'd hold on him for now.

Matteo from Parkdale

Ryan Lester

WHO IS HE

WHERE IS THE BOY FROM

AND DOES HE GET A SPOT?

:O

AFL Guru

i traded Stevenson out for Lester in. Should appreciate $50,000 next week

@matt_bolitho

inside word- job security average as they try mould him in 2013 to a full blown midfielder instead of a utility. will be in and out of the 2s as they run him at 100% game time in the midfield in the 2s. massive risk at his price

JPM

haha matty bolitho. get around him

@matt_bolitho

haha easy when you went to school with him JP 😉

JCC

He played 19 games last year and injured his Abductor in after round 2. He was back last week and I'll be surprised if he isn't named this week with 5 confirmed outs (and maybe a 6th). If Pittard or Stevenson are on your bench either will be a good trade if you never use them.

JCC

Ryan has just been named starting in the forward line. All he has to do is walk on the park to make $$$.

Paul

I'm with Matteo, whats the deal with Lester? Two games and two scores over a hundred, he had a very average year last year. What kind of game is he playing? Is he filling a spot for an injured player or are we likely to seem him week in and week out. Price rise is good, but looking for a consistent 100 point player is this him?

@matt_bolitho

see above

DT_Legend

Another great podcast Jock. This week was a very frustrating week for many but we will all be stronger for the experience.

Marc

Honestly don’t know if I can keep Jacobs anymore. He had a better game against the Hawks, but it didn’t translate into SC points. I really want Dangerfield in my side this week though, so I may need to use trades to grab him instead. He was bloody amazing against the Hawks, got ’em close to the win. Jenkins owners should have cause for excitement. Now that McKernan is the 2nd ruck, Jenkins is spending the entire game up forward. 6 shots on goal, if he can change that 2.4 line to 4.2, you’d be bloody rapt with that.

Mac

Jacobs to Hannath?

Emma

I traded wines to muprhy this week . I also have Jacobs but will keep him not worth trading could look to upgrade hi to nit nat later .

Marc

Same thinking I have. Crows play GWS next week, so hopefully he can use that as a springboard to some better form. Of course they may also use it as a chance to rest him for a week too.

se4no

I dunno about Murphy, I'd be looking at A.Walker if I were you…

Osh

I have 240k in the bank. Who should I get up forward: JJ.Kennedy, Robbie Gray, Lecras or A. Walker? PLS REPLY

Marc

You’d have to go Walker, Osh. Looking like a season keeper, the other 3, not so much.

Osh

Cheers mate!!!

SCaddict

I agree with Jock that you've probably missed the boat on Walker so save that precious cash. I take it you already have Daisy as I reckon he's the best value forward premium pick up this week.

Matt

Even if you can get Dusty? Need to get rid of Hawkins. Going back and forth between Daisy and Martin.

SCaddict

Yikes that's a tough one Matt. I already have Dusty so the decision is a no brainer for me.

But if you have neither I'd still say Daisy as he's a $100K cheaper and likely to deliver similar premium output to Dusty. I'm sure you could always find a use for a spare $100K.

Matt

Thanks SCaddict. I agree. Plus if Zorko lays another egg, I can get Dusty or Rockliff with the savings.

pdid

lol @ similar output to dusty. never happening. where as dusty is a higher cab in a rank @ richmond and will get substantial midfield time, daisy thomas instantly suffers from the return of ball and beams. not to mention he will consistently suffer from pendlebury swan and sidebottom. this guy had a once off 150, why all the hype? he's cheap for a reason guys.

Michael

Walker for sure 1 goal 21 disposals managed 141 gota be doing somthing rite

pdid

yeah he's running around in 20 meters of space kicking the ball straight on to the chest of a carlton player. pretty easy SC points. wait till the pressure comes on and teams start to tag him – BURN.

@MarkVassett

so trade neade or dwyer this week?

Gillie4

Great podcast again! Very inspirational!

harry

Which trade should I make
Neade to Johnson
Neade to dale thomas
Or Stevenson to heppel

SCaddict

Without hesitation Neade to Daisy. That's exactly what I'm doing in both SC and DT this week. Bargain of the week I reckon. Dwyer to Daisy is the other alternative if you still have Dwyer.

@MarkVassett

L.Stevenson (OUT) N.Vlastuin (IN)
J.Neade (OUT) D.Thomas (IN)

Thoughts?

Jeremy

Was thinking the exact same moves. Solid

Billericay

Like it

Jeremy

Although tempted to trade out Dwyer instead

Billericay

Dwyer less likely to make his BE and I prefer Neade’s JS too

Jimmy

Need to get rid of Dwyer and Luke Brown, both with high B/E's. 50k in bank, any suggestions?

@MRB37

Brent Staker? FWD and DEF so you could use him to replace either one. Reckon he could be named this week?

jjdoesmusic

im trading dwyer for bartel and brown for lester… this way you upgrade to a player that has avg over 90 for 6-7 years and only has a break even of 60 while lester will earn you more cash… good luck

Matt

Murphy for Stanton
Dusty for Hawkins
OR
Pendules for Stanton
Daisy for Hawkins.

Thoughts?

Marc

I like the 2nd option, Matt. Pendles is playing awesome this year. Two games 160+, one 130+, two 120+ and no game below 100, guy is killing it. He’s the perfect guy to use the Captains loophole on too since Collingwood get plenty of Friday/Saturday games as well.

Matt

Thanks Marc. Yeah. I've been using Swan as the loop. Pendules is much better option.

Osh

Yep I think 2nd option is better Daisy probably better than Dusty and Pendles is in sublime form.

Matt

Agree Osh. Pendules has been impeccable. Think with shift Daisy will have more games like that. Can get Dusty later…especially if Zorko keeps producing cringers.

Michael

Pendles for sure playing some awsome footy

@MarkVassett

second option looks the better one in my opinion

Matt

Agree Mark. Thanks.

fraaaaser

Great work as always jock strap.

was holding tight on frost from the colliewobbles but rumour has it has done his knee! need to pull the pin.

Any news on Docherty or Laird? or am i better off subbing a mid back and making room for Kanye Mitchelson… now he has played a full game will he keep the trend up?

Marc

Laird should hopefully be back this week. Was only a corkie, so if they're serious about getting games in him this year, he'll be back.

Osh

Got Stevenson in my team so who should I downgrade him for to get extra $ to get Dale Thomas for PLZZZ HELP!!!

SCaddict

Reckon Staker is a chance to play this weekend after a few successful runs in the magoos (NEAFL). So if he gets named in the seniors and not given the kermit costume on Saturday then he's an option to consider for $128K.

Otherwise Vlastuin is probably your next best option if you don't already have him, although he will cost you $159K.

Anyway I thought you had $240K in the bank already so can't you just upgrade one of your forward or midfield rookies directly to Daisy? Either Neade, Dwyer or Rowe would be a perfect choice.

Marc

Look at Rory Laird, should hopefully be back in the side this week.

SCaddict

Really enjoy this website and the weekly podcast so am more than happy to hit that donate button.

I'm sure a lot of time and hard work behind the scenes goes into making this the superb place that it is so I can certainly spare a little bit of loose change to ensure the ship keeps sailing strongly.

Keep up the great work lads!

Judd

Good work Jock, Higgo and crouching..
No talk about winderlich, rested this week and played very good on Anzac day against the pies with an 123, he is ONLY $250,000 with a breakeven of 7, surely to get a significant price rise this week… Those of you who are getting rid of rowe or dwyer this would be a great straight switch if you wanted to spend cash elsewhere.. Whats everyones thoughts?

Mikey mike

A risk seeing he has played little football in the last 3 years. Had a ripper of a game vs Adelaide last year and didn't play again, and kicked 13 goals in the first 2 weeks of the vfl despite not playing a full game either weeks.
Scored well Anzac Day despite at times showing rust. If he can play vest free football for the next month and stay on the park could make a quick 150k.

Judd

Yer i think Hirdy likes him and he was great down forward on anzac day i dont think he will get the vest they have enough young players for that role and he has always been a very fit player. Time will tell i guess. If he is named in the side this week I will most likely pick him up.
Tell me what you think mike
J. Elliot out Winderlich in to free some cash and,
Stevenson out H Shaw in with

Matt

Well said. And completely agree.

Marc

I'm distrusful of CEO's Braxton, I hope you're not friends with Steven Trigg, cause we won't get along if you are. But because Jock, Crouching, Higgo, Crimmo, Vince Gambino, Mick and the entire community are dead set legends and because you've all helped me tremendously i'd love to show my appreciation for all the hard work you do and help you guys out.

Now i'm facing a bit of a trading dilema this week. Do you guys reckon it's worth upgrading Mundy to Dangerfield? I have two options i'm looking at

1st
Rowe to Hannath or Witts (This could be any downgrade trade that nets me 100K though, Dwyer to Kerridge, Goodes to Vlaustin other options)
Wines to Dangerfield

2nd
Jacobs to Daisy Thomas (With Cox moving into my 2nd ruck spot)
Mundy/Maloney to Dangerfield

Jacobs 140 BE is worrying (and that I have Maric with a 160BE too), but Mundy to Danger isn't as big an upgrade as Wines to Danger.

Matt

In fact, Jock and the boys much more valuable than SC Gold.

Birch's Buddy

Hear, hear!

clayton

Fellas, love the podcast as usual!
This week, i'm going against the crowd and NOT taking daisy. The reason for this is simple, so I can afford to bring Buddy Franklin in next week, whilst upgrading stevenson back to Goodes.
The way I see it; Buddy next week > Daisy this week

Dashmasha

LEWIS JETTA, is he worth grabbing, dropped 120,000K, is 300 K now. BE 29.
— Jock or any Sydney supporter, can you let us know what's happening with Jetta. He just got a massive score over 120, is he back and is he worth it………………..

Jetta, dropped 120K, cost 300K, BE 29
Winderlich…. cost 246K, BE 7

Does this sound ok——
VINEY to Jetta – or – Winderlich (with using a swing man)
Wines to Daisy Thomas

Sean

We've got a very tough month ahead – Hawks, Freo, Collingwood and Essendon. He looks fired up again, and is a big game player, but probably won't get 21 possessions and 16 kicks again.

SCaddict

Yeah I'm a Swannies supporter too but wouldn't touch Jets either. Like the idea of Wines to Daisy much more.

James

Any options for grimes

@MRB37

Straight swap for Duffield looks good if you don't have/don't want to spend any cash.

James

Cheers mate

pdid

probably a few 100 options if you actually open your eyes and have a look. pathetic.

James

The give me a player that is in good form (apart from duffield)

Max

Hi guys,

Considering if I should trade down O’meara then upgrading Dwyer to Franklin?!?!

Please help out guys!

Thanks!

Jay

Why consider trading O'Meara!! he's worth $357k with a BE of -18!!! Absolutely hold….i think he will get to $400k soon, but i think he may end up being a keeper for the whole season……Wines is starting to slow down – I would look to trade him out before O'Meara – but not this week….

Jay

Also Franklin has BE of 171, so maybe worth holding till next week – he maybe under $500k next week before he takes on the Giants……

udi

get buddy next week. hang on he will go down in price over the next 2 weeks.

Osh

I think wait until after next week with Buddy because he might not get a good score against Sydney and with a BE of 181 he might even get below 500k. but after Sydney the Hawks have GWS, Melb and GC so probably a couple of 100 plus scores there.

Max

Sweet thanks a lot guys 🙂

Jimmy

westhoff BE of 220. what do i do?

SCaddict

Have a nice cry!

Then get off the Hoff and do the much maligned sideways trade to either A.Walker, Stevie J, Dusty or Rocky whilst you still can. Or better yet downgrade to Daisy and make $100K.

JCC

If you have the cash and don't have Cox yet bring him into the forward line, dual pos player with decent average. Might need to cash out a cow to make up the extra $$$.

SCaddict

Yes that's a great option as well.

Zac

Get rid of him, there is no way he was going to keep up his form. Maybe downgrade to dale Thomas who just came through with a 150 for a but of cash generation

Tina

Big Call but how about getting rid of Buddy!

Osh

No don't get rid of Buddy after Sydney he has GWS, Melbourne and GC he would surely get a couple of 100+ scores.

Jay

Fantastic podcast as usual guys!! Top stuff..

Was only considering 1 trade this week – Neade to Stevie J, but Viney's huge BE got me thinking….so 2 trades this week are:

Neade to Stevie J
Viney to Wano's man J. Hannath (with Blicavs into the MIDs)

Worried about Shuey, so that 2nd trade may change depending on extent of the injury!!

Next week Priddis is the man!!

SCaddict

I'm actually hanging on to Viney for the time being. Once that 9 gets out of his rolling price average he should start making cash again.

But yes Neade to Stevie J looks like a winning trade to me.

Jay

I like those options, but you may look to do one and one….i.e a Premium Upgrade + Rookie Downgrade, otherwise the premiums may become unreachable in the next few weeks….

Liam

What do with Jacobs? Swing Rowe into the ruck and make an upgrade in the forward to a Daisy Thomas? Or stick with Jacobs and hope he comes good?

theazzyg

Playing gws this week, i'm gonna give him 1 more week

Brian

Setanta O'Help-me due back this week (on the bubble, breakeven – 25) and has got to be a quality exchange in the ruck and maybe a good point of difference too.

David

Is dale Thomas really worth it ?
He's never been a huge scorer in this game and fri night was a fluke he won't get that away with that against good sides and with ball and beams returning soon I don't like his chances think ill be looking else were.

Adam V

If he continues to play at half back, like he did on Friday night then absolutely but if he goes onto the wing/ half forward flank then its a no.

ABC

Thinking exactly the same thing. Would rather get NicNat.
Not sure why everyone is going on about Priddis too. Same thing happened to him last year. I picked him up but he was average in terms of a premium mid.

Birch's Buddy

Last year he dropped because he was in bad form, and just slowly dropped. This year, he's looking good, pumping out 105+ scores (bar his first game), but has been affected by an injury-induced 5.

Dean

Daisy actually scored real well last year hence why his price was so high this year. However in saying that, I tend to agree with you, I wont bother getting him as he isn't playing that well.

Osh

Who's a better option to downgrade Stevenson to: Laird, Staker, Corr or Sierowkoski

Genco

Aidan Corr

mcareec

rookie mid option please somone to downgrade to
thanks

mcareec

Charlie you flog

Birch's Buddy

Lonergan?

Adam V

Which is a better option?
Out: Wines and Stevenson
In: Laird and D Thomas it leaves me with $169k
or
Out: Stevenson and Rowe
In: Laird and D Thomas leaves me with only $7k but i keep Wines who i can cut next week for Priddis or Franklin

Daniel

Why not Stevenson to vlastuin and rowe to daisy?

Brad

Hannebery… Thoughts? worth getting in averageing pretty good 98 in DT

Judd

Ive had him since the start and he has been gold, the best mid pricer on my side.. He averages 110 in SC and he was the only reason I persisted with dangerfield because i could afford to with him scoring so well and thank god i did…
However you may have missed the boat he has crept up to 530,000 (In SC) however he has been so consistent and im a real fan tough choice, he should still rise in price a bit more…

Paddy 'O' Furniture

Help me out jock Me Old Mate,

Not happy with Lake, he's about to bleed the coffers dry.

Worth trading for Shaw ?? or too Sideways for your liking

Need your wisdom

Ryan

I'm 20th in Supercoach,

Jacobs is killing me, can't afford to keep him.
I have 132k in the bank. Thinking:
Goldstein for Jacobs
Wines for Dale Thomas

Thoughts?

SCaddict

Yes looks like solid moves to me.

But ranked 20th overall you should be giving us advice. 'Dusting Martin' is a killer team mate. Glad you're not in any of my leagues ha ha!

vinny mac

I personally would hold Jacobs!

pdid

lol, 20th and looking for advice. Luck out much?

pdid

pathetic.

Daniel

Pretty good team you got, but do Jacobs to Leunberger and walters to a.walker, wait a week for wines

Kevin

Great podcast Jock! Was thinking of bringing in Dale Thomas but am considering getting Petrie because I already have Cloke and Pendles, thoughts?

Birch's Buddy

Petrie is a KPP. Very up and down.

THESALTSHAKERS

Grimes > Lester

Dwyer > Thomas

James

That are the exactly same trades i did
Great Job

would suck jock off!

who would you pick marc murphy patrick dangerfield trent cotchin or joel selwood??
and dale thomas or luke hodge please need some help any feedback would be great from would suck jocks cock! 🙂

Sammy

luke hodge over daisy and selwood or the others

Sammy

selwood over the others*

Lewis

dangerfield & daisy

Sam

Cotchin and Hodge

Sam

And seriously change your name

would suck jock off!

no it shows my appreciation to the great man himself

john

i bet Jock would be hoping that your a female.Thats a shocker if your not.

would suck jock off!

your mums sucking jock off

Robert

Really need some help

Getting rid of mummy and mundy and that comes to 900k

Sholud i get Robbie gray and dale thomas

Or

Gray and Walker ( Carlton )

please write down any other combo down need forward and mid

Cheers

Sunka

Nice work Jock and crew! I'll be chipping in to the donation kitty for sure. A lot of hard work and pure comedy from you guys! Respect.

A couple of questions… Should I hang on to Chris Mayne as F5? He was my hopeful breakout contender and while he's been solid, I can't see an average of 100 coming. $426,000 and has barely dropped in price. A sideways trade to Thomas? or upgrade Neade to Thomas leaving Mayne at F6?

Cheers

mattywheelahan

Either Walker or Danger!! which one omg

Birch's Buddy

Walker, easily. Danger can't cope with a tag, and he's not going to get the same freedom next week.

Sam

Danger all the way!!!

Anandu

You guys think Docherty will play this round?

SamBoy

Could I please have some help with my team for this week:

DEF: Goddard, Harlett, D.Pearce, Heath, Stevenson, L.Brown (Gibbs, B.Goodes)
MID: Pendelbury, Swan, Watson, J. Kennedy (SYD), Rockliff, Barlow, Wines, O'Meara (Bradley Hill, Kommer)
RUC: Cox, Gawn (Daw, Currie)
FWD: Bartel, D. Martin, J. "Twinkle Toes" Kennedy, Chapman, S. Day, Macaffer (Dwyer, Rowe)

I brought in PEARCE for pittard i dont know why, I thought he was a good option.

So with 2 trades to use for the week and $35,900 in sal.cap who goes and stays?
Please help me guys

jimbotraralgon

hey Sam

Would probably move out Stevenson for vlads or docherty.

The maybe its time for Dwyer to move on as well.perhaps to Kane Mitchell (if you think he will avoid the vest) by moving rocky forward.

Will give you some cash to chase buddy or priddis next week.

Cheers

SammyC

oh thanks good idea mate

jonathan

Just traded Wines out for Mitchelson and Neade out for Daisy.

Tim

Hi community

How are these trades looking for this round?

Trade 1- Out Bennell In Kane Mitchell

Trade2 Out Dwyer In Walker

If any other opinions please say

jimbotraralgon

hey Tim.

Like the first trade. Think we might have missed the boat on walker. Plus I still wonder if he can sustain it all year. Could put in 60 score still.

Daisy is the obvious one however if you have the coin I would grab Stevie j. Or even hold the second trade for next week and go for buddy or priddis.

James

Should I trade out Koby Stevens for Patrick Dangerfield or Macaffer for Dale Thomas?

Sammy

Danger all the way

jimbotraralgon

Case number two please andrew.

Chris

i'm getting ablett. Should i get rid of watson or cotchin?
All advice will be greatly appreciated.

Daniel

Watson

Lewis

cotchin

Sam

None, save up to get Ablett from a rookie. Your gonna want to end the season with both Watson and Cotchin.

Birch's Buddy

Neither. As Sam says, use a rookie to get Ablett somehow. You're going to need Cotch and Jobe in your final team anyway. Imagine having Gaz, Watson and Cotchin!

jimbotraralgon

find another way. Both have bottomed out meaning maximum loss.

Next week if you slaughter wines and omeara it should get you close. Just my opinion.

Jimmy

Im thinking JJ Kennedy to Dale Thomas and Dwyer to Staker this round, which will leave me 200k in the bank and hopefully enough to upgrade Neade to Franklin next round. Thoughts?

jel

JJK to Daisy – risk of hoping on the bandwagon that goes nowhere.
A sideways trade of a 100+ avg player…. I'm keeping JJK a bit longer.
I managed to do the Wines to Daisy swap instead.

ABC

Raj, there's no point constantly bombarding us for advice otherwise you're not really playing.
Is it your team or the websites?

Rob

Yep… Totally agreeABC. Raj you need to have a crack yourself at some stage.

chandanrajdb

Hi ABC,

Thanks for your comment mate…..much appreciated…..for the above reason you have mentioned i have deleted my post…..

But at the same i would like to ask you a simple question,

"WHAT IS THE POINT OF HAVING A COMMUNITY LIKE THIS?"…..Please answer your opinion…..

I will tell you mine, in my opinion if you have any sort of confusion or not sure of something post it on the forums and get some opinions or suggestions…..and make the call based on the comments received and also your gut feeling and research……that's what most of them are doing….

As you can see most of them are asking for some opinions / suggestions from the experienced SC players in the community……you may be getting some of your questions answered by someone already……if this not the case why are you even considering to read the people's comment in any article…..

i know that i need to be making the call….since i am only a 2nd year player in SC i have some doubts which i need to clarify by throwing a question in this community……i am still learning mate…..

I would like to let you know what happened before rd 6….i asked a questions regarding the OUT Gibbs, IN Dixon…..most of them said HOLD Gibbs…..but i just went with my gut feel and traded off Gibbs for Dixon….may be a bad trade?..if yes its a mistake i did…but you learn from your mistakes…..

If you got a problem with people asking the questions, then you shouldn't be reading any comments which are posted in any article in JR website…..because most of the comments are actually someone asking some sort of advice from the community…….

And please, if you are not interested in giving any advice then please don't…..and also please make sure you are not posting some negative things about someone's post……

This forum is up for discussion, people ask for advice and give some advice mate…..ultimately its you who will be making the call…….IT'S YOUR TEAM NOT WEBSITES…….

Thanks,
Raj…….

Sam

Well said raj and your right..ppl if you don’t like to help anyone then please ignore the comments they make..

ABC

I don't think that anyone takes it as far as you and writes an absolute essay on what is troubling you in the supercoach world. Every single time you put your whole team and all these options.
Mate, no-one has the time to go through it just for you and think about all these things. Just ask a question or two and don't get aggressive by constantly using capitals and begging for help.
You clearly have way too much time on your hands.

chandanrajdb

Thanks again mate for your advice above i will take it…..would not want to drag it on and on…..

Birch's Buddy

See this is why I love this community. No hostilities, friendly advice and open ears. Good on ya Raj!

Liam

What about Aaron black? Might trade Dwyer down to black, (averaging around 85) priced around 210k? Good trade?

Chris

What do you think about these trades?
Tex to Stevie J and M.Murphy to Daisy

Sam

1st one yes, 2nd one no.

Chris

why no for the second one?

SCaddict

Unless Murphy has an injury I haven't heard about I'd absolutely hang on to him with the draw the Blues have from now til the byes.

I'm huge on getting Daisy in this week but definitely not at the expense of Smurf. Reckon he has some big scores coming up.

jimbotraralgon

Like both trades. Still think Murphy is growing into the captains role and is affecting him. Plus I like daisy.

Daniel

Daisy for Tex?

Lewis

what do you guys think.
Jetta IN Wines OUT
Daisy IN Dwyer OUT

ABC

Jetta has had one good game.
Never go off that. Just look at Nick Suban, Danyle Pearce, David Armitage etc etc

jimbotraralgon

jetta no! Please god no. Oh the humanity!

Even though he is a vest risk, wines to Mitchell might be better. Or even crouch next week?

Daniel

Which trades should I do
Monfries to d.thomas
Viney to Evans
OR
Monfries to gray/a.black/h.crozier
Wingard to k.jack

Sam

None, but if you had to do one I'd go Monfries to Daisy.

Callum

You must get rid of viney! You would look to upgrade to a thomas or downgrade to a vlastuin.

jimbotraralgon

keep monfries. Averaging 99 as a forward makes him a potential keeper. Or a mid season upgrade around the byes?

Daniel

What about jj Kennedy to daisy and wines to l.Parker

BBE

Another great Podcast fellas
I'm surprised however though you didn't mention the likes of JJK. He now has a breakeven in the 60s and with the delicious likes of Stevie, Daisy and Walker surely he's a valuable upgrade option.
Cheers

James

How does Heath to Docherty and Wines to Dangerfield sound?

James

Is dwyer to thomas the order of the day?

Chris

Sam…why do you say no to murphy to daisy?

Matt

Well Murphy hasn't been that bad! No reason to get rid of him

Brocky

Murphy doesn't look good, doesn't even want to sing the song at the end of a game. I say he's struggling and will get cheaper yet.

Callum

G'day there, Great podcast as always. This week i will be getting in thomas, but not sure how to do that just yet. Here are the possible options:

OPTION 1:
Out: Wines
In: Vlastuin ( This will provide a dpp going mid to back, very handy in the long term.)
AND
Out: Dwyer
In: Thomas

OPTION 2:
IN:Thomas
Out: Jacobs ( Swith roughy to ruck)
AND
In: Hannath
OUT: Rowe
This option is the cash generation, which would leave me enough money to bring in cotch or watson in next week.

Option 3:
In: Thomas
Out: Dwyer
AND
OUT: Heath
IN: Vlastuin

Help would be great. Cheers!

SCaddict

Reckon either option 1 or 3 would be fine. Perhaps prefer option 3 the most as Ollie is probably worth keeping around one more week where as I think Heath has already reached his used by date.

vinny mac

Option 3 looks very good! I actually seem to like Option 2 as well, but only if you're sure Jacobs will perform poorly for the rest of the season, which I highly doubt.

JimBob

Can someone tell me when Kreuzer is back really want jump on him especially when i have jacobs? Great Podcast! Very well done!

Mitch

What do you think of robbie gray

G unit

Just signed him up for Dwyer

CHRIS

gun

Jacko

going leuenburger to gawn to get cash for wines to danger.

Thoughts?

Callum

Keep leunberger for now, he still got money to make. And if you want gawn, get rid of a rookie by downgrading.

Birch's Buddy

Love ya, Jock!

Tim

Hi community thoughts on this weeks trades
How are these trades looking for this round?

Trade 1- Out Bennell In Kane Mitchell

Trade2 Out Dwyer In Walker

Rob

Hi fellas
Want to get Evans before his price goes up any further. Should i trade him for mullet or moloney?

Bill

A bit late to get him now I think

Birch's Buddy

Try Jesse Lonergan.

Chris

Whats are better trades
Neade down to ben kennedy and dwyer up to jobe watson/josh kennedy
OR
Neade to Jetta and stevenson to duffield
Help please 🙂

jimbotraralgon

Stating the obvious but Dwyer to Mitchell and neade to diasy might be best

would suck jock off!

who should i get joel selwood or trent cotchin???? please help cheers guys need feedback here!

THE SALTSHAKERS

selwood – cotch needs help in midfield

jimbotraralgon

if you can dpp into the fwd line then try to get Stevie j

udi

if both cloke and walker were same price not considering walkers DPP status who would u pick. i need a fwd who has a bye on round 13. fwd thinking about the bye rounds. next week i m going to get Priddris and cloke / walker

Dolls

Walker. Cloke has a higher ceiling but walker more consistent.

would suck jock off!

luke hodge or dale thomas???? need help please help!

sam

hey guys what is the job security for hayden crozier and aaron black..can anyone help

would suck jock off!

job security is looking great i would get both if i could but cant! get if you can!

Birch's Buddy

Harvey is back this week, so he goes onto one of the forward flanks. So it's Black, Sierakowski, and eventually Garner for that other flank. I'd say no.

Dan

Two questions guys. Firstly, is Ablett’s price going to drop any further? And who should i pick out of Stevie J and Daisy this week?

udi

stevie J

Birch's Buddy

Daisy this week. SJ is priced at about 25 PPG above Daisy. Will he do that across the season? I don't think so. Daisy is good value, but you're going to need SJ at some point in the season anyway.

jimbotraralgon

love Stevie j. After this week they play low teams and he luvs to beat up on the weak.

Dee

Hayden Crozier… Thought on him Jock? Has scored 85 and 92 in he's 2 games this year with a price of $219K…. Looking to get him in for Dwyer, he's job security at the moment looks good is he worth the punt mate?

Dolls

If he can stay in the side.. He's a good sort but Lyon's been trying a few of the youngsters so far this year.

Dash

Is it worth trading Daisy in for JJK? Thomas probably has greater short term cash generation ability, but will he be a keeper? Anyone think JJK could be a keeper?

Sunka

I'd look elsewhere for that trade if you really want daisy. JJK dominates when he plays a full game. Seems to go missing for a while in a few games this season, but I'd hang on. I am. Is he your worst forward other than rookies? I'll either be ditching Mayne or upgrading Neade if I want Daisy

Dave

Grimes going down meant I used my cash to bring in Shaw. Didn't want to take the risk on Lester. Perhaps I might have to miss the boat on Daisy and bring in some cash ready for Buddy or Priddis next week.

And yeah, he's sitting at F4 at the moment with only rookies below him. I suppose it comes down to whether he keeps averaging 90+ or heads back towards his previous years of 60s and 70s.

SCaddict

Yeah I agree with Sunka. Both are worthy of a long term spot in your forward line. Are you able to upgrade one of your rookies to Daisy by cashing out another rookie?

Charlie

At the moment I have 7 Brisbane players in my side, I plan on keeping 3, maybe 4. I have Maloney, Rockliff, Zorko, Leuendburger, Hanley, Mayes and Docherty. Mayes and Docherty are just there as cash cows, I’m going to upgrade Maloney whether it be this week or next. I don’t know if the amount of Brisbane players I have should influence my trading? They have a tough draw the next few weeks, and I’m not sure if I should cut some of them now?

1-This weeks trades I was thinking of trading Dwyer out for a rookie, and then upgrading Neade to a Dale Thomas? But then that didn’t do anything with my Brisbane players..

2-My other option is to trade Dwyer or Neade to a rookie and then I can upgrade Moloney (who’s brake even is starting to get up a bit higher) to any midfielder, I was thinking Jobe or even a mark Murphy who’s form is just starting to turn around.

3-Another one was to trade Dwyer or Neade to a rookie and Moloney straight to Thomas?

4-Or I could not worry about my Brisbane players or upgrading this week and I could just trade Neade and Dwyer for rookies?

Help would be greatly appreciated!

vinny mac

In my opinion I'd trade out Zorko before Moloney, who has been more consistent this season. Upgrading to Murphy or Daisy sounds like a great idea!

jocks willy is great

will bryce gibbs be back this week??

marty patton

is it worth putting my VC loophole on joel selwood against the bombers in the friday night clash or not and if he scores bad ill put the captain on ablett against melbourne please guys need some help here any feedback will be great!!!!

Sunka

Go for it.

Birch's Buddy

Good idea.

jimbotraralgon

unfortunately for me I don't think so. Mick doesn't have a history of rushing back the injured.

@PaulCarnovale

Thinking of trading down Josh Jenkins for Gawn.

What is his job security like?
Is Jamar injured because I cant see his name on the injury report?

Jarod

Hey guys and girls I am Richmond supporter and The Tiges are like
Y to bring in Tuck and Foley. Vlastuin came in for Tuck. So is Vlastuin going to play this week. And Lester from Brisbane, any thoughts?

jimbotraralgon

with goodes and maybe Gibbs out he better be.

jonty

best downgrade for viney?
and do you reckon, upgrade or downgrade for daisy?

Birch's Buddy

Keep Viney.

tom

is it worth trading moloney

@Jacko2128

what is most important:
1. Getting Viney out?

2. Getting Rowe out?

3. Getting Sinclair out?

Cheers.

@Jacko2128

And i can provide cover for each of them..

Dash

Is trading Daisy in for JJK a worthwhile investment? had to use my first trade to bring in Shaw for Grimes so I don’t have the cash to upgrade a Dwyer etc.

I think Kennedy has peaked, but is it too sideways? Should I be looking to downgrade a rookie to win back some cash?

Dave

Sorry about the double post. Was using my phone and it looked like it didn't submit

Birch's Buddy

JJK is a KPP. I generally stay away from them. Daisy will rocket in price, so if this is the only way you're going to get him in, then by all means do so.

pdid

ANYBODY PLS HELP ME

GOING TO TRADE GARY ABLETT FOR BRAD SEWELL,

AND WINES FOR MATT PRIDDIS

PLSS HELP SOMEBODY??????????????????

pdid

I'LL DO IT, I DONT GIVE A FK

pdid

QUICK SOMEBODY PLSSSS HELP ME BEFORE I DO IT PLSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSS

Liam

mate If u have Ablett I wouldn't be getting rid of him. He is a champ.

Birch's Buddy

A massive no to the Ablett trade. Do Wines -> Priddis next week (you'll save about 30-40k).

Birch's Buddy

Oh and next time, no capitalising everything. Looks like you're shouting at us.

@Jacko2128

what is most important:
1. Getting Viney out?

2. Getting Rowe out?

3. Getting Sinclair out?

PS. I can provide cover for all of them too.

Birch's Buddy

Keep Viney. Once that shocker is out of system (after this week), he'll start making cash again. Should get to 250-300k before maxing out.

Probably Sinclair out, with Nic Nat back. Rowe is a chance to play this week after Waite's suspension.