West Coast vs Geelong: JLT Review

Before I begin, big shout out to the Kayo sports app for streaming the game on a full sized screen. Unlike the bloody AFL app which refuses to enlarge beyond postage stamp size. I fear I have irreversible eye damage from squinting at that thing. But I digress, onwards we go!

Game two of the JLT Series heads out west to na-na-na-na-na-na-na-na-na Leeder(ville) Oval that played host to a more or less full-strength West Coast outfit against a Geelong side chock full of fantasy relevance. Let’s dive in.

…Batman! I mean, Leader

West Coast 15.9.99 def Geelong 8.17.65

Notable absentees

West Coast: Josh Kennedy, Nic Nat (LTI), Jamie Cripps

Geelong: Zach Tuohy, Nakia Cockatoo, Zach Smith, Scooter Selwood, Jed Bews, Tom Hawkins (late out) 

Rule change impacts  

Maybe I’m looking for it but this 6-6-6 stuff is definitely making more space at centre bounces. Teams that can shift gears quickly and build momentum will do quite a lot of damage. Neither team had great ruck divisions tonight, so I’m looking forward to seeing the premier ruckman of our comp really take the space afforded to them head on.

As for kick outs, are West Coast just playing with us? Baz seems to think so

But still, the pacy Jetta was preferred to Hurn. Something to watch.

The rookies – West Coast

Jack Petruccelle – FWD – $123,9k

Would love to tell you more about Jack but I hardly saw the kid. Picked it up after half time but ‘fast running’ is not a measurable SuperCoach stat (at least not yet, anyway…)

Francis Watson – DEF – $123.9k

He’s got some serious hustle does young Francis, but it’s a hard backline to break into. Few injuries fall his way and I’d be happy to have him as a defensive rookie option later in the year.

Jarrod Brander – FWD – $135.7k

Don’t think he gets a permanent gig with a fit JK, Darling, and Vardy on the field. Only pulled down two marks. If the Eagles want another tall forward Oscar Allen looked much more threatening, but you don’t want a 236k defender in your side. Do you?

Jarrod Cameron – MID/FWD – $117.3k

Wisp of a lad. While the Eagles have Ryan and Rioli doing their thing Cameron won’t get much of a look in.

The rest – West Coast

Shannon Hurn – DEF – $523,400

The hairline has receded another centimetre or two but he’s still sharp as ever. Entering his 14th season he did what he needed to do. Keep him in your thoughts. 

Jeremy “Mitch” McGovern – DEF – $483,100

A look at the stat sheet would have you concerned but he’s in same boat as Hurn, just going through the motions and will save himself for season proper. Won’t get a lot of love this year I reckon, so if you really want a backline POD have a look at JGov.   

Jack Darling – FWD – $471,700

Kicked 5 (3 in the last term when Eagles pulled away). Classic huge ceiling player, An option at F7 when loopholing comes into play but for the love of God don’t start the guy.

Jack Redden – MID – $517,400

21 possies and 8 cuddles for Jack. Bit too hot and cold for me as a SuperCoach option but I wouldn’t be disappointed if you landed on him in the draft comp.

Dom Sheed – MID – $394,100

Is this finally Dom Sheed’s year? Has teased us the past two without quite breaking out. Was dominant with 39 touches and a goal. I’m a little shy on him, consistency has always been an issue for Dom. If you’re running a Libba/Miles type this year and they don’t deliver over these next few weeks, consider this guy.

Luke Shuey – MID – $492,700

Pranced around Leederville Oval and did whatever the hell he wanted to. Had 17 touches to half time before putting the tracksuit on. 

Elliot Yeo – MID – $585,500

Didn’t look at all troubled by his toe complaint earlier in the preseason. Played mostly through the middle and you should have him high on your midfield watch list.

Andrew Gaff – MID – $587,400

If there’s an uncontested footy you can count on Gaff not being far away from it. This isn’t a knock, just his game isn’t suited to SuperCoach. He is still serving his suspension for a dog and won’t be seen until round 3.

Nathan Vardy – RUC/FWD – $306,400 and Tom Hickey – RUC – $485,600

Different colours, same useless Tom Hickey. Vardy looked threatening at times up forward and provided a tall target. I’d avoid the West Coast ruck division this year, not SuperCoach gold as we had hoped. 

The rookies – Geelong

Gryan Miers – FWD – $123.9k

Put him on your watch list for JLT2. Forward only but floated into the midfield where his closing speed and pressure really stood out. Won’t get a stack of it every week but one high score is enough to see the cash roll in for a few weeks.  

Tom Atkins – MID – $112.9k

Played the forward pressure role with Miers. If there was only room for one I’d take Miers. Had 7 tackles though to Miers’ 1. Also has a fantastic moustache, but sadly that type of thing doesn’t get you SuperCoach points.

Darcy Fort – RUC – $117.3k

I’m close to putting a line through him folks. Didn’t do much for me tonight and with the news dropping today that Stanley is the preferred number 1 I don’t see where Fort fits into this team. Esava will be the second tall target behind Tomahawk.

Charlie Constable – MID – $123.9k

Bench lock. If he’s there round 1 (and he should be) he’ll be in my team. Had it 26 times in a solid 4 quarter effort. 

Jordan Clark – DEF – $144.3k

We’ve got a goer here, community. Perhaps got a bit more opportunity after Vardy’s fat knee smacked into the back of Harry Taylor’s head, but had the confidence to take the game on in a backline that was pretty under siege. 5 intercept marks and 572 metres gained is absolutely elite

The rest – Geelong

Mitch Duncan – MID – $576,500

For mine, was far and away Geelong’s best mid. Had 29 touches and 10 marks. A real chance to break through the 110+ average barrier this year. 

Tom Stewart – DEF – $463,000

Wouldn’t mind seeing him with Tuohy back in the side. Was very good but I seem to recall him doing this last JLT series. Not a terrible option at $460k  

Brendan Parfitt – FWD – $434,300

Would take a hefty amount of stones to pick him but if Parfitt breaks out this year I won’t be shocked. Was a constant threat when he drifted forward. Kicked 3 goals and had 21 touches

Patrick Dangerfield – MID/FWD – $660,500

Did Dangerfield things. Like many of the senior guys out there didn’t go out of his way to hit that next gear. You can keep him at F1

Sam Menegola – MID/FWD – $543,100

Came on during second quarter and had overtaken Kelly, possession wise, shortly after. Had 18 touches in a half of footy. Showed no sign of his injury problems. Wouldn’t talk you out of him.

Luke Dahlhaus – MID/FWD – $418,300

Picked it up a bit after half time but as we know from his time at the Dogs, his best position is in the guts. Played more high half forward tonight. If you had him on your list, first of all, why? And second of all, cross him off it.

Jelwood – MID – $570,500

Another to add to the ‘it’s only preseason, why go at 100%’ list. Played just over half the game and had 15 touches and a goal. Being overlooked at the moment and he’s consistent as they come. Consider. 

Tim Kelly – MID/FWD – $505,800

I know I’ve been banging on about senior guys taking it easy but 13 touches from 83% game time has me slightly concerned. Is his head in it? Don’t go ripping up your team after one JLT game but watch him again next week. 

Gary Rohan – FWD – $261,600

Still very red and Nearly took Dahlhaus’ head off in the third. Will probably miss the next few weeks with some serious sunburn. Avoid.

What you think, community? Did you watch the game? What did you takeaway from it?

Comments (25)

Trackback URL | Comments RSS Feed

  1. Nice_Person says:

    Any scorrs?

  2. Maverick_ says:

    WEST COAST EAGLES
    Dom Sheed 144
    Shannon Hurn 111
    Jack Darling 101
    Thomas Cole 99
    Elliot Yeo 91
    Oscar Allen 86
    Jack Redden 85
    Daniel Venables 80
    Brad Sheppard 80
    Liam Ryan 77
    Liam Duggan 76
    Francis Watson76
    Chris Masten 75
    Mark Hutchings 74
    Andrew Gaff 67
    Tom Hickey 59
    Tom Barrass 59
    Lewis Jetta 58
    Luke Shuey 44
    Jack Petruccelle 43
    Jarrod Brander 42
    Nathan Vardy 41
    Willie Rioli 40
    Jarrod Cameron 38
    Jeremy McGovern 35
    Jake Waterman 29

    GEELONG
    Patrick Dangerfield 129
    Mitch Duncan 107
    Charlie Constable 92
    Brandan Parfitt 89
    Jordan Clark 87
    Cameron Guthrie 83
    Tom Stewart 81
    Joel Selwood 78
    Sam Menegola 76
    Zach Guthrie 71
    Rhys Stanley 70
    Tom Atkins 69
    Mark Blicavs 59
    Luke Dahlhaus 58
    Gryan Miers 54
    Quinton Narkle 46
    Tim Kelly 43
    Esava Ratugolea 38
    Gary Rohan 33
    Lachie Henderson 32
    Jack Henry 28
    Mark O’Connor 28
    Darcy Fort 21
    Jake Kolodjashnij 11
    Harry Taylor 9

    • SC_Kev7 says:

      Cheers, Maverick!

      • Maverick_ says:

        No worries Kev!
        Great write up too mate very insightful..
        People without foxfooty love these threads keep up the great work all very appreciated!

        Couple of rookies popping up tonight which is handy and I have put a line through fort I’d prefer a VC donut at R3 than what he produced tonight.

  3. Patch says:

    Some scores!

    Dom Sheed 144
    Shannon Hurn 111
    Jack Darling 101
    Thomas Cole 99
    Elliot Yeo 91
    Oscar Allen 86
    Jack Redden 85
    Daniel Venables 80
    Brad Sheppard 80
    Liam Ryan 77
    Liam Duggan 76
    Francis Watson76
    Chris Masten 75
    Mark Hutchings 74
    Andrew Gaff 67
    Tom Hickey 59
    Tom Barrass 59
    Lewis Jetta 58
    Luke Shuey 44
    Jack Petruccelle 43
    Jarrod Brander 42
    Nathan Vardy 41
    Willie Rioli 40
    Jarrod Cameron 38
    Jeremy McGovern 35
    Jake Waterman 29

    GEELONG
    Patrick Dangerfield 129
    Mitch Duncan 107
    Charlie Constable 92
    Brandan Parfitt 89
    Jordan Clark 87
    Cameron Guthrie 83
    Tom Stewart 81
    Joel Selwood 78
    Sam Menegola 76
    Zach Guthrie 71
    Rhys Stanley 70
    Tom Atkins 69
    Mark Blicavs 59
    Luke Dahlhaus 58
    Gryan Miers 54
    Quinton Narkle 46
    Tim Kelly 43
    Esava Ratugolea 38
    Gary Rohan 33
    Lachie Henderson 32
    Jack Henry 28
    Mark O’Connor 28
    Darcy Fort 21
    Jake Kolodjashnij 11
    Harry Taylor 9

    Dominic Sheed with 39 touches and 144 is a HOO BOY for 394k… pity his available as a mid-only. Stellar write-up Kev, we'll get you some blockquotes training ASAP.

  4. Maverick_ says:

    Once Bellchambers is back for Essendon Clarke becomes irrelevant & fort was sh*thouse tonight. A captain loophole R3 with fwd swing is becoming an option with westhoff in the fwd line. Play English/Mummy as my R2.

    Or I just save myself the headache and lock in the Gs.

    Thoughts?

    • Russty_ says:

      I'd lock in the G's Mav, Gr, Ga or Gold

      • Maverick_ says:

        Hm I know you are right russty and definitely the smart thing to do…
        If the Gs kill JLT they’ll be locked and loaded if they look average maybe I’ll risk it. Just a nice saving i I can play English R2. Use that $$ elsewhere.

        • Russty_ says:

          It offers a lot of peace of mind mate…I'd like to go Grunda Gawn but can't quite afford but will be happy with Goldy I think.

      • SC_Kev7 says:

        Back to the drawing board on a rookie ruck at R2. Pay the cash. Set n forget

        • Russty_ says:

          I was even considering Vardy Kev, but not now…Vardy + Hickey = crap, Stanley + Fort = crap lol
          Wouldn't trust English to not be crap either.

          • SC_Kev7 says:

            Not buying his hype at all. He’s what? 20–21? Rucks don’t hit their prime at that age

  5. JohnDJ59 says:

    Constable is my M7 and Clark my D5, I just need them to be picked for round one.

  6. Sharkmove_King says:

    My structure seems to be changing with everyone of these JLT games. Im guilty of having Fort @r2 & I also had Petrucelle @f6 but after last night I don't think these guys are good enough to even make the 30.

    Also, call it cold feet but I would have loved to see my SHARKMOVE pick Michael Hibberd play 2 good JLTs before committing. Very disappointed he is not named. There is a little talk around about Callum Mills on here and I must admit I'm very tempted. He ticks all the boxes if playing mid. I promise I won't take the credit for it if he does kill it.

    • Patch says:

      Mills definitely one of the watchlist, but Hibberd would need a lot to go his way for me to consider him. Hore apparently taking a lot of kick-outs in the practice game against the Pies

    • JohnDJ59 says:

      Mills at D3 for me, going with three mid priced players in def, Witherden, Mills, Roberton.

  7. Inteldesign says:

    Anyone interested in joining a cash league? 10 man comp with a $50 buy in. Contact [email protected]

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *