St Kilda v Western Bulldogs NAB School worksheet

Filed in NAB Cup Analysis, St Kilda, Supercoach, Supercoach 2014, Western Bulldogs by on February 20, 2014 • views: 1262

Analysis of the St Kilda v Western Bulldogs game:

Reasonable first hit out by my beloved Saints community. Proud of the boys.

However it wasn’t a great night to get some solid predictable fantasy footy formlines:

  • Was wet as buggery, game almost washed out. Tough to get a grip on any solid preseason form and structure.
  • Very disappointed not to see Fuller, Honeychurch, Markworth get a game. Both teams has significant OUTS on all lines.
  • Saw enough in Luke Dunstan to keep him up around my first rookie selected this season. $132,000 and will play plenty. Ran with the Dogs big boys, got plenty of contested ball in his limited game time. Jack Billings – no at his price at this stage. Didn’t see much game time but didn’t show much when he had a gallop.
  • Jack Steven, Libba, Armitage, Dahlhaus – any of these blokes could go the next level. Not sure enough at this stage to lock any of them in though at this stahe.
  • Savage will be a very solid pickup for the Saints and will make you some cash. Question is will he make enough to make his selection worthwhile? No for me at this stage.
  • Tom Hickey will toil in the ruck serviceably and warrants some thought as your R2 or R3.

How did you see the game community?

Jock Reynolds

Download Jock Reynolds completed STK v WBD NAB School Worksheet

Comments (36)

Trackback URL | Comments RSS Feed

  1. Sarah says:

    Didn't realise Dunstan only played 50% game time. Makes his score look even better!

  2. Kev says:

    Just on templeton, still on the rookie list atm. Not sure if saints have a spot on senior list?
    Liked Libba – wet weather or not he has runs on the board from last year

  3. twindbag86 says:

    Toot toot… all aboard the Libba bandwagon… there goes my POD!!!

    Quick poll community –

    Jack Steven or Nat Teenwolf Fyfe???

    • PJ8 says:

      Tough one Twindbag. Probably couldn't go wrong with either, but Fyfe for me. Only reason being Freo will win a lot more games than the Saints (and I'm a Saints man)

      • twindbag86 says:

        Thanks for the input PJ8. That being said though, it's not as though the Saints won a stack of games last year compared to Freo and their numbers still stacked up pretty well against one another.

        I notice Steven hasn't really been discussed a lot when people are stacking up their midfields… what is the feeling – overpriced?

        One of the big factors to consider is who will attract the tag at both respective clubs?
        I would think maybe Montagna would attract the tag before Steven.
        At Freo, possibly Barlow before Fyfe?

        What do you reckon?

        • PJ8 says:

          I'm not saying at all that Steven will drop off or over-priced. Think he defiantly will Average 105-110. As I said I don't think you can go wrong with this selection. Just my opinion that Fyfe has been coming on for a couple of years now and think he can breakout to a 115 average.

          Also on the tagging, I would think that Steven would now be one of only 2 players other teams would tag (along with Joey Montagna) now that Dal as gone.

          Freo have Munday and Barlow as well as Fyfe as possible tagged players. An extra player for other teams to go for. Plus, Fyfe won't have Crowley tagging him haha.

        • Grufflez says:

          Steven WILL get the tag.

    • Fourbells says:

      Still think Teenwolf has it over both Steven and Liberatore at this stage, although the bulldogs seem to have the easier draw

      • twindbag86 says:

        There's a few players who are in similar categories I reckon that are tough to make calls on (Kieran Jack, Rory Sloane, Scott Selwood)… they are at an awkward price where they HAVE to perform otherwise they are going to burn you real fast… but all potential PODs

        • PJ8 says:

          Sloane, Jack, Selwood in that order

        • twindbag86 says:

          The winners though are those who are going to be prepared to take a punt – if you play conservative and pick the same blokes that everyone else chooses, you will be do alright but won't go anywhere near winning the thing.

          It is that reasoning that I am starting to have doubts over blokes like Jack Martin – very high price for a rookie that every man and his dog is picking and is potentially going to earn the same coin as someone significantly cheaper, like Ellis, Crouch, etc… Unless Martin is going to get that extra 50 points in output than those guys, I don't reckon it is worth the extra coin.

    • Blueblood says:

      with Montagna out round 1, i think Steven will get the tag..you can bet Roosy will be trying to shut him down but Macaffer might also go to Fyfe; tough one for round 1 Twindbag; honestly flip a coin

  4. PJ8 says:

    Big Will looks like he will be the dominant ruckman again this year. 30 hit outs from 47% game time.

  5. PJ8 says:

    Also have to agree with you Jock. Very happy as a Saints fan last night. It wasn't looking good in the first quarter but was a good fight back in the second and played well for the rest of the game.

    Lot of youngsters to get excited about.

  6. Bob says:

    Some of the dogs second year players will never be this cheap. Macrae, Hunter and Talia all look like playing a lot more this year. What about Koby Stevens, must be ready for a break out year.

    • The Drama Llama says:

      Koby still too much of a risk for mine, Looked a shining light in a few games last year then an absolute spud the next. Will watch with interest and consider with corrective trades but still expect him to be inconsistent against the better midfields.

      • Bob says:

        Was thinking as a mid priced upgrade. Will play Rd 1 and is one of BM's favourites. Otehr options are Daisy and Carazzo but need to see them actually on the park.

  7. Pete says:

    Didn't take a lot from last nights game, obvious comments above and in jock's review.

    Anyone going to take a real POD and lock in Lin Jong?

  8. Brett says:

    Lin Jong is a rookie – will need a LTI before he gets a run

  9. tomo says:

    Why is there a pube on your paperwork?

  10. SCaddict says:

    Liked what I saw from the Hickmonster last night. Only had to battle with Big Will for a half of course, so that needs to be factored in.

    Very much within my ruck calculations at this stage but will have to await NAB 2 and 3 before any decision there.

    I see Ralphy from the Herald Sun is planning to run with an ultra ballsy Hickey/Sandi ruck tandem. If it comes off it will definitely help him get a leg up in their office league against Clarky, Sammy, Robbo and the boys.

    http://www.heraldsun.com.au/sport/afl/jon-ralph-r

    • Grufflez says:

      That is one of the worst teams i have ever seen.
      I am not doing this to be rude but that team of Raphy's is absolute garbage,auto team pick would do a better job…better luck next year if he starts with that.

      Jays team is average.

  11. David says:

    Why not Dulhouse Jock?

  12. vinnymac says:

    Dahlhaus, pavlich or zorko? These mid-priced FWDs are giving me migraines, and at this stage I'm not convinced that any of the premiums are worth their weight in $. Dangerfield aside, which FWD premiums would be the safest to select?

    • Grufflez says:

      N.Riewoldt is expensive and may drop his 105 average a little, but he should be good for 100 ish again if you have a cash.
      Saints only won 5 games last year so another bad year shouldn't worry riewoldt to much.
      Of those 3 options you mentioned mate i like Pav.

    • PJ8 says:

      I like Roughead Vinny, rolls around the ground doing what he wants. Goes forward kicks goals, goes in the midfield and racks up touches and hitouts.

      Maybe T. Mitchell after last nights performance. See how he goes in NAB2.

  13. THE SALTSHAKERS says:

    Fyfe could avg 115+ if he uses ball better, wins plenty of contested footy, freakish ability but has tendency to kick forward without spotting up a target appears to be the trade off, causing plenty of clangers. It cost him going large many times, some of his low 100s he still scored well due to high % of contested football. If he can improve this area in 2014 he should bang out big scores more consistently.

    Jack Stevens went up a gear and now knows can take on the best in comp. Think Ryan Griffin-esque explosiveness from clearances when taking on opposition. Shown ability to accumulate the football consistently, hard worker all over ground, and backs his leg speed. Runs all day, uncanny ability to find space like Boomer but further advanced at same age. Will attract more attention, bigger workload in 2014. Only thing hurting him is Saints will struggle in the guts, not enough support.

    Kieren Jack – part of great midfield. Pts shared too much.

    Libba will continue to improve with Griff, Murphy out meaning his share of ball should increase.

    Toss up between him and Fyfe

    • Dee says:

      Griffen will be good for round 1 won't he?

      • Brett says:

        Griff should be ok – expecting him in next nab

        Murphy doesnt impact Libba's possessions – actually its Big Will who has a big impact on Libba's numbers, If Big Wills on song Libba is getting plenty of it.

  14. Bandit says:

    What's with the pubic hair on the scan Jock?

  15. If or when your favorite game in your youth was creating clothes for your toys as well as
    creating creative changes in your very own apparel, then I think people such as you are absolutely those which are destined to become a fashion designer.
    This fabric is intended to be loose fitting, but wear
    it too loose and you’ll look fat. Perhaps you are a model who wants to expand your
    portfolio with a range of startling shots that show off your versatility and individual flair.

    Here is my page :: herve leger bandage dress xl

  16. It’s awesome to pay a visit this web site and reading the views
    of all mates about this piece of writing, while
    I am also keen of getting familiarity.

    For an incredible solution please check-out this page handbag store online

  17. hi!,I love your writing very a lot! percentage we be in contact extra approximately your post on AOL?

    I need an expert in this space to solve my problem.

    Maybe that is you! Taking a look ahead to see you.

    Here is my webpage – super fast weight loss